User talk:Buster7/Wikiknights
Add topicEarly A.M. work
[edit]- A long discussion that supports the need.
- Another long discussion of a particularly bad one that stands out in my mind.
Second Mover Advantage
[edit]- Assertion of an oft-repeated but never policy-recognized first mover advantage for noticeboard respondents. If the first administrator who responds to a noticeboard request declines to do something, that has not in any meaningful sense prohibited others from acting after seeing the discussion. Indeed, it cannot; it would punish administrators who were in the process of responding elsewhere, or were unaware of the filing of a noticeboard report. It establishes an unreasonable first mover advantage in administrator disputes, which Arbcom has repeatedly stressed it does not want to see happen on the project, with considerable community support. Hans at ARC
Basic questions
[edit]- Should the general public (i.e. the english speaking humans of the world) have an expectation of being treated with basic courtesy and respect when joining, editing and working with others on the English Wikipedia?
- If yes, how do we ensure this?
- If a basic tenet of editing at WP is to assume that every talk page is an area of mixed company (ie, women are present) would that prevent using social mores and prevailing customs as the excuse to be rude and vulgar?
- If so, where do we begin that conversation so that it works its way into possible life.
- Is it safe to say that WP is a society, in the broad sense of the world. Haven't societies thruout history created their own standards of what civility is?
I'm reminded of...
[edit]From the JAN2017 archives...
[edit]A 7 year old idea. When I first started to edit WP and I was roaming around various article and editor talk pages, getting my feet wet, it struck me how often I found editors singlehandedly trying to fend off attacks from other editors. Many times the individual was new and the "others" were veterans. I thought how good it would be if there was a group of editors (I planned to call them WikiKnights) that could provide assistance and a friendly voice so, at the very least, the lone editor didn't feel isolated and forgotten...so that there was a group that could get them past this moment of stress and strife and help them move on to bigger and better things. I was a young and inexperienced editor and never got it passed the draft stage. Maybe it now has possibilities. Buster Seven Talk 05:16, 12 January 2017 (UTC)
- Isaacl. The WikiKnight idea fits with your "small groups". Kind of like cadres whose mission is to retain the troubled editor. I'm not talking about troublesome editors; I'm talking more about editors that have gotten into trouble basically because of their inexperience. Buster Seven Talk 06:05, 12 January 2017 (UTC)
- I'm reminded of a village pump discussion on an anti-bullying task force, which I tried to recast in terms of dealing clique behaviour and setting expectations, both for experienced editors and newcomers. As discussed later in the thread, there are lots of challenges in making this operational, not the least of which is managing the helpers themselves: how can their interactions be guided towards helpful intervention, as opposed to making the situation worse? Unfortunately it is the textbook definition of a difficult-to-staff initiative in a volunteer group: lots of investment in time required in stressful situations, with likely a low number of successes. The Teahouse might provide a function similar to what you are thinking of. Last time I checked, involvement there was drying up, so maybe trying to reinvigorate it would be a good step forward? I encourage anyone to think of tasks you can do yourself or with a small core group, and try them out—if you succeed, great; if not, re-evaluate, and try something else.
- On a side note, I think the thankless task of mediating disputes or even just providing some gentle intervention to get everyone talking constructively is an area where it would be useful to have paid staff, simply to ensure there is someone dedicated to the task. As far as I can tell, though, there isn't much support for this amongst those most likely to participate in a Request for Comments on the matter. isaacl (talk) 16:05, 12 January 2017 (UTC)
- In terms of dealing with the helpers as a group, maybe the first step might be for them to leave polite notes on the bullies' talk pages, indicating that they are coming in as, well, observers, in a discussion. They could also then use the same user talk page to address concerns over problematic behavior, while using the article talk page or bullied editor's talk page to discuss the broader issues. Should an individual become too familiar to the anti-bullying task force, they could obviously seek administrative or arbcom attention. To my eyes, part of the problem might be where to have the anti-bullies discuss things in a way which doesn't maybe contribute to the problem in some way. John Carter (talk) 16:02, 16 January 2017 (UTC)
- In my experience, bullies don't take kindly to notes about their bullying, no matter how polite it is phrased. I think the "helpers" should just show up in the arena and show concern for the editing future of the bullied editor (who is most likely a newbie). Whatever "the issue is" is of secondary importance to retaining the editor. "The issue" will be handled by the machinery of WP. What WER members should be most concerned with is the possibility that the new editor will be chewed up in the machinery process and spit out. I'm advocating that we don't need one more voice to handle the issue. The voices handling the issue are abundant and loud and not rare. What is rare is a voice that speaks to the "bullied" editor with support and understanding.Buster Seven Talk 18:29, 16 January 2017 (UTC)
- In terms of dealing with the helpers as a group, maybe the first step might be for them to leave polite notes on the bullies' talk pages, indicating that they are coming in as, well, observers, in a discussion. They could also then use the same user talk page to address concerns over problematic behavior, while using the article talk page or bullied editor's talk page to discuss the broader issues. Should an individual become too familiar to the anti-bullying task force, they could obviously seek administrative or arbcom attention. To my eyes, part of the problem might be where to have the anti-bullies discuss things in a way which doesn't maybe contribute to the problem in some way. John Carter (talk) 16:02, 16 January 2017 (UTC)