Jump to content

User:User97104/Very Helpful

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

A compilation of policies and guidelines.

Civility is part of Wikipedia's code of conduct and one of its five pillars. Stated simply, editors should always treat each other with consideration and respect.

Wikipedia's civility expectations apply to all editors during all interactions on Wikipedia, including discussions at user and article talk pages, in edit summaries, and in any other discussion with or about fellow Wikipedians.

Cooperation and civility

[edit]
Civil, respectful interactions are important.

Editors are expected to be reasonably cooperative, to refrain from making personal attacks, to work within the scope of policies, and to be responsive to good-faith questions. They should focus on improving the encyclopedia while maintaining a pleasant editing environment by behaving politely, calmly, and reasonably, even during heated discussions.

Differences of opinion are inevitable in a collaborative project. When discussing these differences, some editors can seem unnecessarily harsh, while simply trying to be forthright. Other editors may seem oversensitive when their views are challenged. Resolve differences of opinion through civil discussion; disagree without being disagreeable.

Be professional. Try to treat your fellow editors as respected colleagues with whom you are working on an important project. Be especially welcoming and patient towards new users who contribute constructively, but politely discourage non-constructive newcomers.

Assume good faith

[edit]

The assume good faith guideline states that unless there is strong evidence to the contrary, editors should assume that others are trying to help, not hurt the project.

The guideline does not require that editors continue to assume good faith in the presence of obvious evidence of intentional wrongdoing. However, do not assume there is more misconduct than evidence supports. Given equally plausible interpretations of the evidence, choose the most positive one.

And bear in mind that the editor may not have thought they were being uncivil; Wikipedia is edited by people from many different backgrounds, and standards vary. And in addition, faceless written words on talk pages and in edit summaries do not fully transmit the nuances of verbal conversation, and can sometimes lead to misinterpretation of an editor's comments.

Apologising: It's OK to say sorry

[edit]

Disputes, and even misunderstandings, can lead to situations in which one party feels injured by the other. We all make mistakes, we all say the odd hurtful thing, we all have bad days and bad moments. If you have a sneaky feeling you owe someone an apology, offer the apology.

An apology provides the opportunity for a fresh start, and can clear the air when one person's perceived incivility has offended another.

Don't be too proud to make the first move when it comes to saying sorry. That kind of "pride" is destructive. There's no loss of face in apologising. Apologising does not hurt you.

Remember, though, that you cannot demand an apology from anyone. It will only get their back up and make it either less likely to happen, or to be totally insincere if you do get an apology.

Different places, different atmospheres

[edit]

Article talk pages should be, on the whole, considered to be professional workspaces. They are places to collaborate on how to improve the article, and to discuss the article (though it's OK for conversations to wander into related areas, or go more into depth than the article does, as that helps with research and gives ideas on improvement).

While an editor's talk page may have a more informal atmosphere than article talk pages, civility policy still applies everywhere, including there. Note that, in general, the editor may remove comments there at their discretion.

Edit summary dos and don'ts

[edit]

Be careful with edit summaries - They are relatively short comments, often written in haste, and thus potentially subject to misinterpretation or oversimplification.

  • Explain your edit. - Be clear about what you did, so that other editors can assess your changes accurately. And be prepared to use the talk page to more fully explain, or to engage in more substantive discussion.
  • Review your edit summaries before saving your edits. - Remember, after pressing "Save", you cannot go back and change the wording of your edit summary.

Here is a list of tips about edit summaries:

  • Use neutral language.
  • Remain calm.
  • Don't be aggressive.
  • Don't make snide comments.
  • Don't make personal remarks about editors.

No personal attacks or harassment

[edit]

Editors are expected to not personally attack or harass other editors. This applies equally to all: it is as unacceptable to attack an editor who has a history of foolish or boorish behaviour, or even one who has been subject to disciplinary action by the Arbitration Committee, as it is to attack any other. Wikipedia encourages a positive online community: people make mistakes, but they are encouraged to learn from them and change their ways. Personal attacks and harassment are contrary to this spirit, disruptive to the work of building an encyclopedia, and editors engaging in such behaviour, may be sanctioned, including, but not limited to being blocked.

Incivility

[edit]

Civility is to human nature what warmth is to wax.

Incivility consists of personal attacks, rudeness and disrespectful comments.

An uncivil remark can escalate spirited discussion into a personal argument that no longer focuses objectively on the problem at hand. Especially when done in an aggressive manner, these often alienate editors and disrupt the project through unproductive stressors and conflict. Such exchanges waste our efforts and undermine a positive, productive working environment.

While a few minor incidents of incivility that no one complains about are not necessarily a concern, an act of severe incivility, such as a single episode of extreme verbal abuse, profanity directed at another contributor, or a threat against another person, is unacceptable, and the offender may be blocked from editing. And a continuing pattern of incivility may result in the editor being banned from the community.

This policy is not a weapon to use against other contributors. To insist that an editor be sanctioned for an isolated, minor incident, to repeatedly bring up past incivility after an individual has changed their approach, or to treat constructive criticism as an attack, is in itself potentially disruptive, and may result in warnings or even blocks if repeated.

Identifying incivility

[edit]

It is sometimes difficult to make a hard-and-fast judgement of what is uncivil and what is not. Editors should take into account factors such as:

  • the intensity and context of the language/behaviour;
  • whether the behaviour has occurred on a single occasion, or is occasional or regular;
  • whether a request has already been made to stop the behaviour, and whether that request is recent;
  • whether the behaviour has been provoked; and
  • the extent to which the behaviour of others needs to be treated at the same time.

The following behaviours can contribute to an uncivil environment:

  1. Direct rudeness
    1. rudeness, insults, name-calling, gross profanity or indecent suggestions
    2. personal attacks, including racial, ethnic, sexual, disability-related, gender-related and religious slurs, and derogatory references to groups such as social classes or nationalities
    3.  Shortcut:  WP:ICA 
      ill-considered accusations of impropriety
    4. belittling a fellow editor, including the use of judgemental edit summaries or talk-page posts (e.g. "that is the stupidest thing I have ever seen", "snipped crap")
  2. Other uncivil behaviours
    1. taunting or baiting: deliberately pushing others to the point of breaching civility even if not seeming to commit such a breach themselves. All editors are responsible for their own actions in cases of baiting; a user who is baited is not excused by that if they attack in response, and a user who baits is not excused from their actions by the fact that the bait may be taken.
    2. harassment, including Wikihounding, bullying, personal or legal threats, posting of personal information, repeated email or user space postings
    3. sexual harassment
    4. lying
    5. quoting another editor out of context to give the impression they meant something they did not.

In addition, lack of care when applying other policies can lead to conflict and stress. For instance, referring to a user's good-faith edits as vandalism may lead to them feeling unfairly attacked. Use your best judgement, and be ready to apologize if you turn out to be wrong.

Avoiding incivility

[edit]

Incivility – or the appearance of incivility – typically arises from heated content disputes.

  • Take a real-life check. Disengage by two steps to assess what you're about to say (or have just said). Asking yourself "How would I feel if someone said that to me?" is often not enough; many people can just brush things off. To get a better perspective, ask yourself: "How would I feel if someone said that to someone I love who cannot just 'brush it off'?" If you would find that unacceptable, then do not say it. And, if you have already said it, strike the text and apologise.
  • Try not to get too intense. In the heat of a lively discussion, passion could be misread as aggression.
  • Avoid the appearance of being "bossy" or oppressive in tone. Nobody likes to feel like they are being bossed about, or bullied.
  • Avoid condescension. Even if you see another editor's comments as ridiculous, the editor very probably doesn't, and expressing ridicule is likely only to offend and antagonise, rather than helping. Do not tell people to "grow up", or negatively compare the situation to kindergarten.
  • Avoid name-calling. You may feel that someone may very well be an idiot, but telling them so is neither likely to increase your perception of their intelligence, nor improve your ability to positively communicate with them.
  • Avoid personal attacks when discussing other editors. Discussion should be limited to polite discourse about their actions.
  • Avoid editing while you're in a bad mood. It does spill over. (See Wikipedia:Editing Under the Influence and Wikipedia:No angry mastodons)
  • Be careful with user warning templates. Be careful about issuing templated messages to editors you're currently involved in a dispute with, and exercise caution when using templated messages for newcomers (see Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers). Consider using a personal message instead of, or in addition to, the templated message.

Being right is not enough

[edit]

Incivility is not excused on the grounds that an editor has the "correct" position on an underlying substantive dispute or the interpretation of policies and guidelines within those disputes. Civility is expected of all editors; incivility is harmful to the functioning of the project irrespective of the merits of an underlying dispute.[2]

Dealing with incivility

[edit]

When faced with an isolated example of incivility, consider ignoring it and simply moving forward with the content issue. And if necessary, point out gently that you think the comment might be considered uncivil and make it clear that you want to move on and focus on the content issue.

If you don't feel that is an option in the current situation, then consider the following:

  • First of all, consider whether you and the other editor may simply have misunderstood each other. Clarify, and ask for clarification.
  • Consider the possibility that something you said or did wrongly provoked a defensive, irritated or fed-up response. Be prepared to apologize for anything which you could/should have done better. (If an awful lot of people seem to be getting frustrated with you, the problem may be with you.)
    • However, this does not excuse incivility.
  • In general, be understanding and non-retaliatory in dealing with incivility. If others are uncivil, do not respond the same way. Even if you're offended, be as calm and reasonable as possible in your response. Until there is clear evidence to the contrary, assume that the offense was unintended.
  • Explain, clearly but kindly, exactly what you felt was uncivil. Sometimes it helps to let the other editor know how their edit made you feel. Editors are not mind-readers. ("That made me feel..." is much less likely to incite more anger or resentment than "Your post was...")
  • Ask the editor to strike through an uncivil comment, or to re-word it calmly and neutrally.
  • No matter how much you're being provoked, resist the temptation to snap back. It never works; it just makes things worse. Strive to become the editor who can't be baited.
  • If none of this is working, and the other person is not damaging the project or being uncivil or unkind to other editors, either walk away or request dispute resolution from uninvolved editors. Take things to dispute resolution (see below) only if there is an ongoing problem that you feel that you cannot resolve.
  • When the other editor needs to be stopped in their tracks to avoid causing serious disruption or needs a fast and strong wake-up call, file a report at the administrators' "Incidents" noticeboard. Bear in mind the risk of shooting yourself in the foot if you yourself are guilty of policy violations. Please also read the ANI advice first.

Removing uncivil comments

[edit]

Where the uncivil comment is yours, any of these options will help reduce the impact:

  • Where someone is unintentionally offended at your comment, calmly explain what you meant.
  • Strike it out (using <s>HTML strikeout tags</s>), to show, publicly, that you withdraw the comment.
  • Quietly remove it, or rewrite the comment to be more civil – Usually only a good idea if you think better of it before anyone objected to it. If someone has already reacted, you should acknowledge the change in a quick comment after the changed text, for instance, Comment removed by author.
  • Simply apologise. This option never hurts, and can be combined well with any of the others. Even if you feel the thrust of your words is true, or that they are misunderstanding what you meant, you can still apologise.

In the event of rudeness or incivility on the part of another editor, it may be appropriate to discuss the offending words with that editor, and to request that editor to change that specific wording. Some care is necessary, however, so as not to further inflame the situation. It is not normally appropriate to edit or remove another editor's comment. Exceptions include to remove obvious trolling or vandalism, or if the comment is on your own user talk page. Derogatory comments about another contributor may be removed by any editor.

Dispute resolution

[edit]

In a case of ongoing incivility, first decide if anything needs to be done. Confronting someone over a minor incident – particularly if it turns out that you misinterpreted what they meant – may produce more stress and drama than the incident itself. Consider your own behaviour, and, if you find you have been uncivil, apologise to them instead.

In escalating order of seriousness, here are the venues you may use for dispute resolution if the relevant page's talk page is insufficient:

  1. User talk page. If some action is necessary, first consider discussing it on that user's talk page. Be careful not to escalate the situation, and politely explain your objection. You may also wish to include a diff of the specific uncivil statement. If you are in active dispute with the user, consider offering an olive branch to them instead.
  2. WP:Third opinion. The forum itself is in general rather used to request input from an uninvolved editor regarding content disputes. For conduct disputes, you may try advertising the issue with the relevant link in its talk page but without discussing it there.
  3. Dispute resolution noticeboard talk page (DRN). Similar to Third Opinion, it deals only with content disputes but in a highly moderated format. For conduct disputes, you may try advertising the issue with the relevant link in its talk page but without discussing it there.
  4. Administrator. If discussions with the editor fail to resolve the issue, you may ask an administrator to evaluate the conduct of the user, specially if the conduct damages Wikipedia unduly, is against policy and affects you or others very much. But be aware that your conduct will also be scrutinized.
  5. Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents. The Administrators' noticeboard is intended to report and discuss severe incidents of misconduct that require intervention by administrators and experienced editors.
  6. The last step—only when other avenues have been tried and failed—is the Arbitration Committee. It is the final binding decision-maker primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. It scrutinises all sides involved in the dispute and creates binding resolutions. But it may accept or decline any matter at its sole discretion.

Blocking for incivility

[edit]

Blocking for incivility is possible when incivility causes serious disruption. However, the civility policy is not intended to be used as a weapon and blocking should not be the first option in most cases.

  1. Be sure to take into account all the relevant history. Avoid snap judgments without acquainting yourself with the background to any situation.
  2. Think very hard of the possible merits of all other avenues of approach before you take action. Sanctions for civility violations should only happen when nothing else would do. Poorly considered civility blocks have at times worsened disputes and increased disruption. Remember that sanctions may be more applicable under another heading (disruption, personal attack, tendentious editing, or harassment)
  3. Civility blocks should be for obvious and uncontentious reasons, because an editor has stepped over the line in a manner nearly all editors can see. In cases where you believe that taking admin action against someone who was uncivil might be contentious, it is expected that discussion will be opened on the matter, via WP:ANI, before any admin action is taken. Benefits derived from long or controversial civility blocks should be weighed against the potential for disruption caused by block reviews, and unblock requests.[3]
  4. Users should be clearly warned, in most circumstances, before being blocked for incivility, and should be allowed sufficient time to retract, reword or explain uncivil comments. Even experienced contributors should not be blocked without warning. Exceptions to this may include users who make egregious violations or threats, or who have received multiple warnings or blocks.

Immediate blocking is generally reserved for cases of major incivility, where incivility rises to the level of clear disruption, personal attacks, harassment or outing. As with other blocks, civility blocks should be preventive and not punitive.[4]

Emergency situations

[edit]

Hateful speech, legal threats, and other urgent incidents should be reported at the Administrator's Noticeboard Incidents page.

A special case is outing, that is, revealing personally identifiable information about another editor that they have not revealed themselves and probably do not want known, such as their name, phone number or address. These should be immediately reverted, then an oversighter should be contacted to remove the information from the edit history, so that it cannot be found by anyone else later. This applies whether or not the information is correct, as to confirm the information is incorrect by treating it any differently gives the outer useful information. Wikipedia:Outing has full information.

Threats of violence or suicide should be reported immediately. See WP:EMERGENCY.

See also

[edit]
Civility barnstar

Notes

[edit]
  1. ↑ Grayling, A.C. (2001). The Meaning of Things. Weidenfeld & Nicolson. p. 13.
  2. ↑ Originally formulated by the Arbitration Committee at Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/SmallCat dispute § Being right isn't enough.
  3. ↑ Administrators should try to follow The Principle of Least Drama: when given a choice between several ways of dealing with a problem, pick the one that generates the least drama.
  4. ↑ "[The] law and its fulfilment, namely punishment, are essentially directed to the future, not to the past. This distinguishes punishment from revenge; for the motives which instigate the latter are solely concerned with what has happened, and thus with the past as such. All requital of wrong by the infliction of pain, without any aim for the future, is revenge, and can have no other end than consolation for the suffering one has borne by the sight of the suffering one has inflicted upon another. This is wickedness and cruelty, and cannot be morally justified." —Arthur Schopenhauer (1883). The World as Will and Representation, Vol. I, § 62.

Further reading

[edit]

A clean start or fresh start is when a user stops using an old account to start fresh with a new account. The two most common reasons for wanting a clean start are recognizing past mistakes and avoiding harassment. The old account must be clearly discontinued and the new account must avoid editing patterns or behaviors that would allow other users to recognize and identify the user. It is expected that the new account will be a true "fresh start": they will edit in new areas, avoid old disputes, and follow community norms of behavior.

A genuine clean start is not considered improper. However, if an editor uses their new account to resume editing articles or topics in the same manner that resulted in a negative reputation in the first place (becoming involved in disputes, edit warring, or other forms of disruptive editing), the editor will probably be recognized (as a "sockpuppet") and connected to the old account, and will be sanctioned accordingly. Changing accounts to avoid the consequences of past bad behaviors is usually seen as evading scrutiny and may also lead to additional sanctions. The behavior of the new account determines whether it is a legitimate fresh start or a prohibited attempt to evade scrutiny. A clean start is not permitted if there are active bans, blocks, or sanctions (including but not limited to those listed here) in place against the old account.

Criteria

[edit]
Users who may have a clean start
Any user in good standing who has no active or unexpired sanctions and who is not being, or about to be, formally discussed for their conduct may have a clean start.
Users who may not have a clean start
Any user who has currently active bans, blocks or other sanctions imposed (including, but not limited to, those listed here); or is currently or about to be formally discussed for their conduct (such as at an administrative noticeboard or in an open case with the Arbitration Committee); or is attempting to evade scrutiny, may not have a clean start.

How to "clean start"

[edit]

If you decide to make a fresh start and do not wish to be connected to a previous account, simply stop using the old account and create a new one that becomes the only account you use. As any editor in good standing may request a rename, you could consider renaming your old account before abandoning it, but this rename will be publicly logged and could draw more attention to you (see Streisand effect). To reduce the chance of misunderstandings, you should note on the user page of the old account (while logged in under that account) that it is inactive, by using the {{retired}} tag or leaving some other message. You may not use more than one account at a time in most circumstances.

Notification and permission

[edit]

If you are not under Arbitration Committee sanctions, you are not required to notify anyone of your clean start. However, you may find it helpful to notify the Committee or a member of the checkuser team, and get confirmation that there are no obvious problems with you following the clean start procedure. This may reduce the risk of misunderstandings that might result from "behind-the-scenes" discussions and investigations, and may assist you in an appeal of a mistaken block or sanction for creating an alternative account.

Be aware that no one can grant permission for a clean start. The term "permission" carries with it the sense that you will not be held at fault for your actions. If you attempt a clean start but are recognized, you will be held accountable for your actions under both the old and new accounts. The fact that you notified someone of the change will not excuse you from the consequences of your actions or protect you from recognition.

Editing after a clean start

[edit]

It is assumed that editors who change accounts under the terms of a fresh start are seeking exactly that, a fresh start. You are responsible for editing in a manner that respects community norms of behavior and avoids association with disputes or poor behaviors that you might have been involved with under your former account. It is best that you completely avoid articles or topics that you previously edited, especially if you were involved in a dispute with other editor(s). If you do not make positive changes in your behavior, you may be recognized and held accountable for the actions of your past account(s). Likewise, if you want to make a clean start because of harassment from other editors, you should avoid editing articles that may place you in conflict with the same editors, because they will probably recognize you.

Returning to previous articles and topics

[edit]

It is only natural that editors will want to edit the same topics that drew them to Wikipedia in the first place. However, returning to a favorite topic after a clean start carries a substantial risk that other editors will recognize and connect the old and new accounts. This can result in arguments, further loss of reputation, and blocks or bans, even if your behavior while using the new account was entirely proper. For this reason, it is best to completely avoid old topic areas after a clean start. If you have a favorite topic that you wish to edit, it may be better to continue using the old account, clean up your behavior, and rebuild your reputation the hard way. Alternatively, spend some time editing other areas and building a reputation as a "good" contributor before returning to former topics of interest. Remember that the goal of "clean start" is to make a positive change in your behavior so that you are not recognizable as your former account; returning immediately to areas of editing that were previously contentious makes it more probable that your previous account will be identified.

Contentious and scrutinized topics

[edit]

Certain articles and topics are particularly contentious and have attracted additional community scrutiny in the form of requests for comment, community sanctions, or arbitration cases. These areas should be completely avoided by the editor attempting a clean start. Even if the original account is not under a formal editing restriction, changing accounts hides the editor's past relationship to the disputing parties and interferes with the community's ability to monitor the dispute. It is not an appropriate use of a clean start to resume editing contentious or scrutinized topics with a new account. Changing accounts and then resuming to edit in a contentious area carries a substantial risk that other editors will recognize you and connect your old and new accounts. You may be viewed as evading scrutiny, which carries a risk of long-term blocks and bans. If you are unsure in a particular situation, you can ask a member of the Arbitration Committee or the functionaries team for advice.

The guiding principle is that a clean start is not a license to resume editing in areas under heightened scrutiny. It is intended for users who wish to move on to new areas having learned from the past, or who wish to set aside old disputes and poor conduct.

Requests for adminship

[edit]

You are not obliged to reveal previous accounts; however, it is strongly recommended that you inform the Arbitration Committee (in strictest confidence if you wish) of the existence of a previous account or accounts prior to seeking adminship or similar functionary positions. Failure to do so may be considered deceptive and poorly received by the Wikipedia community.

Seeking or accepting a nomination for administrator after a clean start often results in controversy. If the reasons for your clean start no longer apply, then your best option is to simply link the two accounts before your RFA and resolve any outstanding issues relating to the account that ceased editing.

Becoming an administrator without admitting that you had a previous account risks losing the confidence of the community if the former account is subsequently revealed.

If you want to become an administrator without revealing your former account, it is best to wait rather longer than if you had let people check your former account.

See also

[edit]
  • Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry § Legitimate uses – policy on legitimate uses of alternate accounts.
  • Wikipedia:Consequences of sockpuppetry – discusses how the use of a second account, unless explicitly permitted by the rules, is a violation known to many as sockpuppetry.
  • Wikipedia:Courtesy vanishing – discusses how a user in good standing—upon leaving Wikipedia forever—may request renaming of their account; deletion or blanking of user pages; and possibly the deletion or blanking of discussions related to their conduct.
  • Wikipedia:Retiring – discusses how sometimes active users decide to retire from, or leave, Wikipedia and may return at any point.
  • Wikipedia:Single purpose account – discusses user accounts or IP editors whose editing is limited to one very narrow area or set of articles, or whose edits to many articles appear to be for a common purpose.
  • Wikipedia:Sleeper account – discusses how a sleeper account is still enabled and it is still possible to use it. However, any such use of an account must conform to Wikipedia guidelines, particularly those of sockpuppetry.
  • Right to be forgotten – Legal concept

Consensus is Wikipedia's fundamental method of decision-making. It involves an effort to address editors' legitimate concerns through a process of compromise while following Wikipedia's policies and guidelines. It is accepted as the best method to achieve the Five Pillars—Wikipedia's goals. Consensus on Wikipedia does not require unanimity (which is ideal but rarely achievable), nor is it the result of a vote.

Achieving consensus

[edit]

Editors usually reach consensus as a natural process. After one editor changes a page, others who read it can choose whether or not to further edit. When editors do not reach agreement by editing, discussion on the associated talk pages continues the process toward consensus.

A consensus decision takes into account all of the proper concerns raised. Ideally, it arrives with an absence of objections, but often, we must settle for as wide an agreement as can be reached. When there is no wide agreement, consensus-building involves adapting the proposal to bring in dissenters without losing those who accepted the initial proposal.

Through editing

[edit]
Make an edit deviating from the previous consensus state of the article, and wait. If the article is not edited further, presumed consensus exists favoring your changes. If the article is edited further, but you agree with the changes, presumed consensus exists in favor of the article's new state. If you disagree with the changes, seek a compromise, implement in another edit, and once again wait for further edits to the article.
A simplified flowchart of how consensus is reached. When an edit is made, other editors may either accept it, change it, or revert it. Seek a compromise means "attempt to find a generally acceptable solution", either through continued editing or through discussion.

Wikipedia consensus usually occurs implicitly. An edit has presumed consensus until it is disputed or reverted. Should another editor revise that edit, the new edit will have presumed consensus until it meets with disagreement. In this way, the encyclopedia gradually improves over time.

All edits should be explained (unless the reason for them is obvious)—either by clear edit summaries, or by discussion on the associated talk page, to which the summary should ideally point. Substantive, informative explanations indicate what issues must be addressed in subsequent efforts to reach consensus. Explanations are important especially when reverting another editor's good-faith work.

Except in cases affected by content policies or guidelines, most disputes over content may be resolved through small changes rather than taking an all-or-nothing position. If your first edit is reverted, try to come up with a compromise solution that addresses the other editor's concerns. If you can't, or if you do and your second edit is reverted, discuss the dispute on the talk page.

Be bold, but not rash. Whether changes come through editing or through discussion, the encyclopedia is best improved through collaboration and consensus, not combat and capitulation. Repeated reversions are contrary to Wikipedia policy under edit warring, except for specific policy-based material (such as BLP exceptions) and reversions of vandalism. This is true even if editors are using edit summaries to "discuss" the dispute every time they revert.

Through discussion

[edit]

When agreement cannot be reached through editing alone, the consensus-forming process becomes more explicit: editors open a section on the associated talk page and try to work out the dispute through discussion, using reasons based in common sense, sources, and relevant Wikipedia policies or guidelines; they can also suggest alternative solutions or compromises that may satisfy all concerns. The result might be an agreement that may not satisfy everyone completely, but indicates the overall concurrence of the group. Consensus is an ongoing process on Wikipedia; it is often better to accept a less-than-perfect compromise—with the understanding that the page is gradually improving—than to try to fight to implement a particular preferred version immediately.

When editors have a particularly difficult time reaching a consensus, several processes are available for consensus-building (third opinions, dispute resolution noticeboard, requests for comment), and even more extreme processes that will take authoritative steps to end the dispute (administrator intervention, arbitration). Keep in mind, however, that administrators are primarily concerned with policy and editor behavior (e.g., edit warring) and will not decide content issues (e.g., which words to use in the first sentence) authoritatively. They may block editors for behaviors that interfere with the consensus process (such as abuse of multiple accounts or a lack of civility). They may also make decisions about whether edits are or are not allowable under policy, but will not usually go beyond such actions.

Consensus-building

[edit]

Editors who maintain a neutral, detached, and civil attitude can usually reach consensus on an article through the process described above. They may still occasionally find themselves at an impasse, either because they cannot find rational grounds to settle a dispute or because one or both sides of the discussion become emotionally or ideologically invested in winning an argument. What follows are suggestions for resolving intractable disputes, along with descriptions of several formal and informal processes that may help.

In talk pages

[edit]

In determining consensus, consider the quality of the arguments, the history of how they came about, the objections of those who disagree, and existing policies and guidelines. The quality of an argument is more important than whether it represents a minority or a majority view. The arguments "I just don't like it" and "I just like it" usually carry no weight whatsoever.

Limit article talk page discussions to discussion of sources, article focus, and policy. If an edit is challenged, or is likely to be challenged, editors should use talk pages to explain why an addition, change, or removal improves the article, and hence the encyclopedia. Consensus can be assumed if no editors object to a change. Editors who ignore talk page discussions yet continue to edit in or revert disputed material, or who stonewall discussions, may be guilty of disruptive editing and incur sanctions. Consensus cannot always be assumed simply because editors stop responding to talk page discussions in which they have already participated.

The goal of a consensus-building discussion is to resolve disputes in a way that reflects Wikipedia's goals and policies while angering as few editors as possible. Editors with good social skills and good negotiation skills are more likely to be successful than those who are less than civil to others.

By soliciting outside opinions

[edit]

When talk page discussions fail—generally because two editors (or two groups of editors) simply cannot see eye to eye on an issue—Wikipedia has several established processes to attract outside editors to offer opinions. This is often useful to break simple, good-faith deadlocks, because editors uninvolved in the discussion can bring in fresh perspectives, and can help involved editors see middle ground that they cannot see for themselves. The main resources for this are as follows:

Third opinion (3O)
A neutral third party will give non-binding advice on the dispute. Reserved for cases where exactly two editors are in dispute.
Noticeboards
Most policy and guideline pages, and many wikiprojects, have noticeboards for interested editors. Posting a neutrally worded notice of the dispute on applicable noticeboards (or in some cases only their talk pages) will make the dispute more visible to other editors who may have worthwhile opinions.
Dispute resolution noticeboard (DRN)
For disputes involving more than two parties, moderators help the parties come to consensus by suggesting analysis, critiques, compromises, or mediation, but generally limited to simple disputes which can quickly be resolved.
Requests for comment (RfC)
Placement of a formal neutrally worded notice on the article talk page inviting others to participate which is posted on the RfC noticeboards.
Village pump
Neutrally worded notification of a dispute here also may bring in additional editors who may help.

Many of these discussions will involve polls of one sort or another; but as consensus is determined by the quality of arguments (not by a simple counted majority), polls should be regarded as structured discussions rather than voting. Responses indicating individual explanations of positions using Wikipedia policies and guidelines are given the highest weight.

Administrative or community intervention

[edit]

In some cases, disputes are personal or ideological rather than mere disagreements about content, and these may require the intervention of administrators or the community as a whole. Sysops will not rule on content, but may intervene to enforce policy (such as WP:Biographies of living persons) or to impose sanctions on editors who are disrupting the consensus process. Sometimes merely asking for an administrator's attention on a talk page will suffice; as a rule, sysops have large numbers of pages watchlisted, and there is a likelihood that someone will see it and respond. However, there are established resources for working with intransigent editors, as follows:

Noticeboards
As noted previously, policy pages generally have noticeboards, and many administrators watch them.
Administrators' noticeboard of incidents and general Administrators' noticeboard
These are noticeboards for administrators. They are high-volume noticeboards and should be used sparingly. Use AN for issues that need eyes but may not need immediate action; use ANI for more pressing issues. Do not use either except at need.
Requests for arbitration
The final step for intractable disputes. The Arbitration Committee (ArbCom) may rule on almost any behavioral or policy-interpretation aspect of a dispute, and has broad powers in its decisions. ArbCom does not settle content disputes or change policy.

Pitfalls and errors

[edit]

The following are common mistakes made by editors when trying to build consensus:

  • Off-wiki discussions. Consensus is reached through on-wiki discussion or by editing. Discussions elsewhere are not taken into account. In some cases, such off-wiki communication may generate suspicion and mistrust.
  • Canvassing, sock puppetry, and meat puppetry. Any effort to gather participants to a community discussion that has the effect of biasing that discussion is unacceptable. While it is fine—even encouraged—to invite people into a discussion to obtain new insights and arguments, it is not acceptable to invite only people favorable to a particular point of view, or to invite people in a way that will prejudice their opinions on the matter. Using an alternative persona ("sock puppet", or "sock") to influence consensus is absolutely forbidden. Neutral, informative messages to Wikipedia noticeboards, wikiprojects, or editors are permitted; but actions that could reasonably be interpreted as an attempt to "stuff the ballot box" or otherwise compromise the consensus-building process are considered disruptive.
  • Tendentious editing. The continuous, aggressive pursuit of an editorial goal is considered disruptive, and should be avoided. Editors should listen, respond, and cooperate to build a better article. Editors who refuse to allow any consensus except the one they insist on, and who filibuster indefinitely to attain that goal, risk damaging the consensus process.
  • Forum shopping and admin shopping. Raising essentially the same issue on multiple noticeboards and talk pages, or to multiple administrators or reviewers, or any one of these repetitively, is unhelpful to finding and achieving consensus. It does not help develop consensus to try different forums in the hope of finding one where you get the answer you want. (This is also known as "asking the other parent".) Where multiple issues do exist, then the raising of the individual issues on the correct pages may be reasonable, but in that case, it is normally best to give links to show where else you have raised the question.
  • Spin-doctoring. Queries placed on noticeboards and talk pages should be phrased as neutrally as possible, in order to get uninvolved and neutral additional opinions.

Determining consensus

[edit]

Consensus is ascertained by the quality of the arguments given on the various sides of an issue, as viewed through the lens of Wikipedia policy.

Levels of consensus

[edit]

Consensus among a limited group of editors, at one place and time, cannot override community consensus on a wider scale. For instance, unless they can convince the broader community that such action is right, participants in a WikiProject cannot decide that some generally accepted policy or guideline does not apply to articles within its scope.

WikiProject advice pages, how-to and information pages, template documentation pages, and essays have not gone through the policy and guideline proposal process and may or may not represent a broad community consensus.

  • check Desired outcome: A small number of editors arrive at an agreement about how to best apply sitewide policies and guidelines to a given Wikipedia article.
  • check Desired outcome: Editors determine that a particular sitewide policy or guideline is not relevant to a given situation (e.g., that Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons does not apply because the person died years ago, or that Wikipedia:Non-free content criteria are irrelevant because the content is in the public domain).
  • X mark Impermissible: A group of editors (whether or not a WikiProject) decides that relevant sitewide policies and guidelines should not apply to particular articles.

Wikipedia has a standard of participation and consensus for changes to policies and guidelines. Their stability and consistency are important to the community. Accordingly, editors often propose substantive changes on the talk page first to permit discussion before implementing the change. Undiscussed bold changes are permitted but rarely welcome on policy pages. Improvements to policy are best made slowly and conservatively, with active efforts to seek out input and agreement from others.

No consensus after discussion

[edit]

A "No consensus" result is when a discussion results in no agreement either for or against a proposal. It differs from a "consensus against" outcome, though some editors use the phrase no consensus as a softer way to describe a rejected proposal. No consensus can arise when many ideas are discussed but none gain traction, or when responses to a proposal are evenly divided. Sometimes there is a consensus for change, but no consensus on which change to make, or which action to take.

What happens when a good-faith discussion concludes with no agreement to take or not take an action? It depends on the context:

  • When discussions of proposals to add, modify, or remove material in articles end without consensus, the common result is to retain the version of the article as it was prior to the proposal or bold edit. However:
    • Living people. In discussions related to living people, a lack of consensus often results in the removal of the contentious matter, regardless of whether the proposal was to add, modify, or remove it.
    • Copyright violation. When the material in question is a suspected copyright violation, it must be removed immediately and not restored when a discussion ends without consensus.
    • External links. In disputes over external links, disputed links are removed unless and until there is a consensus to include them.
  • When an article title discussion ends without consensus, the applicable policy preserves the most recent stable title. If there is no prior stable title, then the default is the title used by the first major contributor after the article ceased to be a stub.
  • When a deletion discussion ends without consensus, then the result of the discussion is to maintain the "status quo", generally with the content being kept. See Wikipedia:Deletion process#No consensus for more specific information.

Consensus can change

[edit]

Editors may propose a change to current consensus, especially to raise previously unconsidered arguments or circumstances. On the other hand, proposing to change a recently established consensus can be disruptive.

Editors may propose a consensus change by discussion or editing. That said, in most cases, an editor who knows a proposed change will modify a matter resolved by past discussion should propose that change by discussion. Editors who revert a change proposed by an edit should avoid terse explanations (such as "against consensus") which provide little guidance to the proposing editor (or, if you do use such terse explanations, it is helpful to also include a link to the discussion where the consensus was formed).

Decisions not subject to consensus of editors

[edit]

Certain policies and decisions made by the Wikimedia Foundation (WMF), its officers, and the Arbitration Committee of Wikipedia are outside the purview of editor consensus. This does not constitute an exhaustive list as much as a reminder that the decisions taken under this project apply only to the workings of the self-governing community of English Wikipedia.

  • The WMF has legal control over, and liability for, Wikipedia. Decisions, rulings, and acts of the WMF Board and its duly appointed designees take precedence over, and preempt, consensus. A consensus among editors that any such decision, ruling, or act violates Wikimedia Foundation policies may be communicated to the WMF in writing.
  • Office actions are not permitted to be reversed by editors except by prior explicit office permission.
  • The English Wikipedia Arbitration Committee may issue binding decisions, within its scope and responsibilities, that override consensus. The committee has a noticeboard, Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Clarification and Amendment, for requests that such decisions be amended, and may amend such decisions at any time.
  • Some matters that may seem subject to the consensus of the community at the English-language Wikipedia (en.wikipedia.org) are in a separate domain. In particular, the community of MediaWiki software developers, including both paid Wikimedia Foundation staff and volunteers, and the sister wikis, are largely separate entities. These independent, co-equal communities operate however they deem necessary or appropriate, such as adding, removing, or changing software features (see meta:Limits to configuration changes), or accepting or rejecting some contributions, even if their actions are not endorsed by editors here.

See also

[edit]

For a listing of ongoing discussions and current requests, see the dashboard.

Information pages and Wikipedia essays concerning consensus:

Articles concerning consensus:

Disagreements on Wikipedia are normal; editors will frequently disagree with each other, particularly on content decisions. Editors are expected to engage in good faith to resolve their disputes, and must not personalise disputes. Many disputes can be resolved without external input, through gradual editing, discussion, and attempts to understand the legitimate objections of others.

If discussion stalemates, editors can seek outside input to help resolve the dispute. Disputes over content have multiple venues for outside help, and related discussions can also be advertised on the talk pages of relevant WikiProjects to receive participation from interested uninvolved editors. Processes for resolving content disputes with outside help include asking for a third opinion, seeking help from a mediator, making a request at an appropriate noticeboard, or opening a request for comment. Issues of conduct can be addressed at the incidents noticeboard, and more complex disputes can be taken to the Arbitration Committee.

For issues that demand immediate attention, please see urgent situations.

Resolving content disputes

[edit]

There are many methods on Wikipedia for resolving disputes. Most methods are not formal processes and do not involve third-party intervention. Respond to all disputes or grievances, in the first instance, by approaching the editor or editors concerned and explaining which of their edits you object to and why you object. Use the article talk page or their user talk page to do so; be civil, polite, and always assume good faith.

Follow the normal protocol

[edit]

When you find a passage in an article that is biased, inaccurate, out of date, or insufficiently sourced, the best practice is to improve it if you can, rather than deleting salvageable text. For example, if an article appears biased, edit its wording to make it more neutral, or add balancing material that corrects the bias (including citations for challengeable material added).

To help other editors understand the reasoning behind your edits, explain your changes in the edit summary. If an edit is too complex to explain in an edit summary, or the change is contentious, add a section to the talk page that explains your rationale. Be prepared to justify your changes to other editors on the talk page. If your change is reverted, continue to explain yourself; do not start an edit war.

If you think there is a problem in an article but you do not know how to fix it, you can use its talk page to ask for help.

Discuss with the other party

[edit]
Graham's hierarchy of disagreement: Aim at the top during disputes.

Talking to other parties is not a mere formality, but an integral part of writing the encyclopedia. Discussing heatedly or poorly – or not at all – will make other editors less sympathetic to your position, and prevent you from effectively using the later stages of dispute resolution. Sustained discussion between the parties, even if not immediately successful, demonstrates your good faith and shows you are trying to reach a consensus. Try negotiating a truce or proposing a compromise through negotiation.

Do not continue edit warring; once sustained discussion begins, productively participating in it is a priority. Uninvolved editors who are invited to join a dispute will likely be confused and alarmed if there are large numbers of reverts or edits made while discussion is ongoing.

Talk page discussion is a prerequisite to almost all of Wikipedia's venues of higher dispute resolution. If you wish at any time to request a third opinion (3O) or request for comment, use the dispute resolution noticeboard (DRN), or open a request for arbitration, you will be expected to show there has been talk page discussion of the dispute. Actual discussion is needed; discussion conducted entirely through edit summaries is inadequate.

Focus on content

[edit]

Focus on article content during discussions, not on editor conduct. Comment on the content, not the contributor of that content. Wikipedia is written through collaboration, and assuming that the efforts of others are in good faith is therefore vital. Bringing up conduct during discussions about content creates a distraction, tends to weaken your position, and may inflame the situation. Remember Wikipedia's policy of no personal attacks.

Focusing on content, and not bringing up conduct, can be difficult if it seems other editors are being uncivil or stubborn. Stay cool! It is never to your benefit to respond in kind. When it becomes too difficult or exhausting to maintain a civil discussion based on content, you should seriously consider going to an appropriate dispute resolution venue as detailed below. But at no juncture should you lose your temper or resort to ad hominem attacks. Wikipedia is not like a lot of the Internet: we expect editors to be polite and reasonable at all times.

Disengage

[edit]

Most situations are not actually urgent; there are no deadlines on Wikipedia, and perfection is not required. At all stages during discussion, consider whether you should take a break from the dispute. Taking a deep breath and sleeping on it often helps. You can always return to the discussion later, but at least you will return without an inflamed temper. You may also want to consider leaving the discussion altogether as well.

Take a long-term view of the situation. You'll probably be able to return and carry on editing an article when the previous problems no longer exist and the editor you were in dispute with might have moved on. The disputed article will continue to evolve, other editors may become interested, and they might have different perspectives if the issue comes up again. Even if your position on an article isn't accepted now, it might very well be accepted in the future.

Disengaging is particularly helpful when in dispute with new users, as it gives them a chance to familiarise themselves with Wikipedia's policies and culture. There are currently 7,268,141 articles on Wikipedia; consider focusing your time and attention toward a different article or topic, where you can more easily make constructive edits.

Requesting other editors' help for content disputes

[edit]

If you cannot resolve the dispute through discussion with the other editor, you may request participation from interested editors uninvolved in the discussion, to build consensus for your changes. Several venues are available, listed below, to find editors who may be able to assist. But be mindful that after a couple of editors decline to provide input, you may want to consider going to the next step or disengaging altogether. This is because if you keep seeking input, it may look to others like you are disruptive editing or forum shopping.

Participation in dispute resolution is voluntary and no one is required to participate. However, discussion can still proceed—and consensus may be reached—without the input of a non-participating editor. Also, administrators and the community may take into consideration the degree and nature of an editor's participation in dispute resolution when deciding if an editor's activities have been productive.

Article talk page

[edit]

Most content dispute discussions should start at the disputed article's talk page. This is a good place to talk to the other editor in the dispute, and also to get opinions from additional editors. If the article is on other editors' watchlists, they might see your conversation and join the discussion.

[edit]

If your dispute is related to a certain content area, you can ask your question or publicize a related discussion on the talk page of relevant WikiProjects[a] or other pages. For example, a dispute at the article Battle of Stalingrad could be mentioned at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Military history. To keep discussion centralized at the original talk page, you may just want to leave a link to the original talk page and a brief invitation to join the discussion, rather than restarting the discussion on the new talk page.

Content noticeboards

[edit]

If your dispute is related to the application of a specific policy or guideline, you may wish to post in one of these noticeboards (below) to get input from uninvolved editors familiar with that topic.

Requested move

[edit]

Requested moves (RM) is a process to request community-wide input on the retitling of the article. RMs should be used when there is a dispute about what the title of an article should be, or when the user anticipates that a move would be contentious; while the RM is ongoing, the article should remain at its stable title. To solicit responses from a large number of editors, RMs can further be publicized via noticeboards or relevant WikiProject talk pages. RM discussions take place on a relevant article's talk page.

Third opinion

[edit]

Third opinion is a good fit for small disputes involving only two editors.

Dispute resolution noticeboard

[edit]

The Dispute resolution noticeboard (DRN) is the place where editors involved in a content dispute can have a discussion facilitated by uninvolved volunteers, in an attempt to find compromise and resolution to disputes. The volunteers are experienced Wikipedia editors with knowledge in dispute resolution. Disputes are sometimes referred to a more appropriate venue (such as Requests for Comment). DRN works best when both parties genuinely want outside help in solving the issue and are willing to compromise. If some of the parties do not want outside help or do not want to compromise, then other dispute resolution methods may be more appropriate.

Requests for comment

[edit]

Request for comment (RfC) is a process to request community-wide input on article content. RfCs can be used when there is a content-related dispute, or simply to get input from other editors before making a change. To solicit responses from a large number of editors, RfCs can be publicized via noticeboards or relevant WikiProject talk pages. An RfC bot will also automatically notify the feedback request service pool of editors. RfC discussions related to article content take place on article talk pages.

Resolving user conduct disputes

[edit]

The difference between a conduct and a content dispute is that, in a conduct dispute, the actions of a user (such as how an editor edits or the comments the editor makes about other users) is the overriding issue. If there would be no substantive dispute if the editor was not behaving in a disruptive or unprofessional way, then it is a conduct dispute; if the primary issue is that two editors cannot agree on what the content of an article should be, then it is a content dispute.

User talk page

[edit]

If the issue is a conduct dispute (i.e., editor behavior) the first step is to talk with the other editor at their user talk page in a polite, simple, and direct way. Try to avoid discussing conduct issues on article talk pages. There are several templates you may use to warn editors of conduct issues,[b] or you may choose to use your own words to open a discussion on the editor's talk page. In all cases, and even in the face of serious misconduct, please try to act in a professional and polite manner. Turn the other cheek.

Conduct noticeboards

[edit]

If discussion with the editor fails to resolve the issue, you may ask an administrator to evaluate the conduct of the user. You can ask for an administrator's attention at a noticeboard such as the administrators' noticeboard for incidents (ANI). Conduct complaints that fall into certain sub-categories of misconduct have their own administrators' noticeboard; for example, complaints about edit warring should be made at the edit warring noticeboard (AN3), and requests for enforcing an Arbitration Committee decision at the arbitration enforcement noticeboard (AE). Administrators and the community will look to see if you have tried to resolve the conflict before escalating, and they will look at your behavior as well as the behavior of the other editor or editors. Administrators have wide latitude to use their permissions to stop misconduct and damage to the encyclopedia; for example, an editor who is making personal attacks, and does not stop when you ask them, may be warned by an administrator and subsequently blocked.

Sockpuppet investigations is for evaluating concerns that two users may be sockpuppets (editors who are operating two accounts pretending to be different people, or blocked editors returning under a different account). Requests for comment on usernames and usernames for administrator attention (UAA) are the main methods of bringing attention to usernames which may be inappropriate.

Last resort: arbitration

[edit]

If you have taken all other reasonable steps to resolve the dispute, and the dispute is not over the content of an article, you can request arbitration. Be prepared to show that you tried to resolve the dispute by other means. Arbitration differs from other forms of dispute resolution in that the Arbitration Committee will consider the case and issue a decision, instead of merely assisting the parties in reaching an agreement. If the issue is decided by arbitration, you will be expected to abide by the result. If the case involves serious user misconduct, arbitration may result in a number of serious consequences up to totally banning someone from editing, as laid out in the arbitration policy.

Conduct disputes with administrators

[edit]

If you have a dispute regarding the conduct of an administrator, Wikipedia:Administrators § Grievances by users ("administrator abuse") lists some additional options available to you. These may include posting to administrative action review or the administrators' noticeboard. If you are blocked, you may use the unblock template as directed at Wikipedia:Appealing a block § Direct appeal.

Sensitive issues and functionary actions

[edit]

A small number of user conduct grievances involve sensitive or non-public information. These include issues where an arbitrator, checkuser, or oversighter has stated a privacy issue exists in the case, and disputes where there is a concern of a sensitive or private nature. For example:

  • Non-public details: Grievances where the relevant information and evidence are not accessible to all participants or to the community as a whole. This can also happen due to copyright or privacy reasons, BLP, or when the material is on an unsuitable external link.
  • "Outing" concerns: When discussion may in effect mean "outing", for example if there is a concern that a user is editing with a secret conflict of interest and the evidence would tend to identify them.
  • Serious matters: The issue involves legal concerns, harassment, or allegations that are very serious or perhaps defamatory.
  • Advice on divisive and sensitive issues: The issue may potentially be very divisive and advice is needed on how best to handle it (socking by an administrator is one example).

Disputes or issues of this kind should usually be referred to the functionaries mailing list or Arbitration Committee. In some cases it may be possible to seek advice from an uninvolved trusted administrator by IRC, email or other private means. Where an action is marked as CheckUser, Oversight, VRT (formerly OTRS), or Arbitration Committee, that action should not be reverted without checking beforehand. The presumption is that they have a good reason, and those aware of the reason may need time to recheck, consult, and respond. Sometimes the relevant talk page or other wiki pages will have more details and these are always a good first place to check.

Such actions, if disputed, should initially be raised (by email if necessary) with the agent or functionary concerned. Where a dispute about CheckUser and Oversighter actions cannot be resolved in this manner, it should be referred to the functionaries mailing list or the Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee/Audit where appropriate. Disputes about ArbCom actions should be referred to the Arbitration Committee.

For urgent situations

[edit]

Some situations can be sufficiently urgent or serious that dispute resolution steps are not equipped to resolve the issue. Such situations can be forwarded to the appropriate venue.

Venues for urgent assistance
To request or report: Go to:
Deletion of personal information from logs and page historiesWikipedia:Requests for oversight
Unblocking (if you are blocked)See the Guide to appealing a block
Vandalism of an articleWikipedia:Administrator intervention against vandalism
Blatantly inappropriate usernames, such as usernames that are obscene or inflammatoryWikipedia:Usernames for administrator attention
Suspected sockpuppetryWikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations
Urgent violations of Wikipedia's policies on civilityWikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents
Edit warringWikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Edit warring
Other urgent problems with a user's editsWikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard

The administrators' noticeboards (e.g. AN and ANI) are not the appropriate place to raise disputes relating to content. Reports that do not belong at these noticeboards will be closed, and discussions will need to be re-posted by you at an appropriate forum – such as the dispute resolution noticeboard (DRN).

Words of caution

[edit]

Dispute resolution is sometimes used by editors to try to game the system. This generally backfires badly. Please remember that dispute resolution mechanisms are ultimately there to enable editors to collaboratively write an encyclopedia – not to win personal or political battles.

Under Wikipedia:Decisions not subject to consensus of editors, some disputes are resolved in different forums using those forums' methods.

History

[edit]

From 2002 to 2007, disputes were discussed at Wikipedia:Conflicts between users. The process subsequently moved to Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User conduct until it was shut down in 2014 and replaced by this policy.

The Mediation Committee (MEDCOM) and the Association of Members' Advocates (AMA) assisted in disputes in the early days of Wikipedia. The MEDCOM was created by Jimbo at the same time that he kicked off ArbCom. The Mediation Cabal (MEDCAB) also existed for a number of years to assist in guerilla dispute resolution, and at one point eclipsed the original MEDCOM in popularity and efficacy.

Notes

[edit]
  1. ↑ WikiProjects are usually listed at the top of the article's talk page.
  2. ↑ Please note that some editors have objections to receiving a template message – see the essays Don't template the regulars and Template the regulars for various sides of that issue.
Wikipedia page history showing a severe edit war
Edit warring doesn't help when attempting to resolve disputes. In fact, engaging in such behavior will usually inflame the dispute, poisoning the environment that all Wikipedia editors share.

An edit war occurs when editors who disagree about the content of a page repeatedly override each other's contributions. Editors engaged in a dispute should reach consensus or pursue dispute resolution rather than edit war. Edit warring is unconstructive, creates animosity between editors, makes consensus harder to reach, and causes confusion for readers. Users who engage in edit warring risk being blocked or even banned. An editor who repeatedly restores their preferred version is edit warring, regardless of whether those edits are justifiable. Claiming "My edits were right, so it wasn't edit warring" is not a valid defense.

There is a bright line known as the three-revert rule (3RR). To revert is to undo the action of another editor. The three-revert rule states that an editor must not perform more than three reverts, in whole or in part, whether involving the same or different material, on a single page within a 24-hour period. Any appearance of gaming the system by reverting a fourth time just outside of the 24-hour slot will usually be considered edit warring. There are certain § Exemptions to the three-revert rule, such as reverting vandalism or clear violations of the policy on biographies of living persons. The three-revert rule is a convenient limit for occasions when an edit war is happening fairly quickly; it is not a definition of "edit warring", and it is absolutely possible to engage in edit warring without breaking the three-revert rule, or even coming close to doing so.

What edit warring is

[edit]

What edit warring is not

[edit]

Wikipedia encourages editors to be bold, but while a potentially controversial change may be made to find out whether it is opposed, another editor may revert it. This may be the beginning of a bold, revert, discuss (BRD) cycle. An edit war only arises if the situation develops into a series of back-and-forth reverts. Nevertheless, not every revert or controversial edit is regarded as edit warring:

When reverting, be sure to indicate your reasons. This can be done in the edit summary and/or talk page. Anti-vandalism tools such as Twinkle, Huggle, and Rollback should not be used to undo good-faith changes in content disputes without an appropriate edit summary.

The three-revert rule

[edit]

Editors who engage in edit warring are liable to be blocked from editing to prevent further disruption to the affected page. While any amount of edit warring may lead to sanctions, there is a bright-line rule called the three-revert rule (3RR), the violation of which will usually be considered edit warring, and often leads to the user engaging in the behavior to be blocked.

The three-revert rule states:

An editor must not perform more than three reverts on a single page—whether involving the same or different material—within a 24-hour period. A series of consecutive edits that undoes or manually reverses other editors' actions—whether in whole or in part—counts as a single revert.[a] Violations of this rule often attract blocks of at least 24 hours. Fourth reverts just outside the 24-hour period will usually also be considered edit warring, especially if repeated or combined with other edit-warring behavior. See below for exemptions.

The rule applies to any page on Wikipedia, including those in talk and project spaces. A "revert" is any edit (or administrative action) that reverses or undoes the actions of other editors, in whole or in part, whether involving the same or different material, and whether performed using undo, rollback, or done so completely manually.

The three-revert rule applies per person, not per account; reverts made by multiple accounts operated by one editor count together. Editors violating 3RR will usually be blocked for 24 hours for a first incident. Even without a 3RR violation, an administrator may still act if they believe a user's behavior constitutes edit warring, and any user may report edit warring with or without 3RR being breached. The rule is not an entitlement to revert a page a specific number of times.

If an editor violates 3RR by accident, they should reverse their own most recent reversion. Administrators may take this into account and decide not to block in such cases—for example, if the user is not a habitual edit warrior and is genuinely trying to rectify their own mistake.

Edit warring and 3RR violations are not detected automatically. Either wait for an administrator to take action, or take any of the steps suggested in the § What to do if you see edit-warring behavior section below.

Exemptions

[edit]

The following reverts are exempt from the edit-warring policy:

  1. Reverting your own actions ("self-reverting").
  2. Reverting edits to pages in your own user space, as long as you are respecting the user page guidelines.
  3. Reverting actions performed by banned users in violation of a ban, and sockpuppets or meatpuppets of banned or blocked users.
  4. Reverting obvious vandalism—edits that any well-intentioned user would agree constitute vandalism, such as page blanking, adding profanity or patent nonsense, or inappropriately adding shock images.
  5. Removal of clear copyright violations or content that unquestionably violates the non-free content policy (NFCC). What counts as exempt under NFCC can be controversial, and should be established as a violation first. Consider opening a deletion discussion at Wikipedia:Files for discussion instead of relying on this exemption.
  6. Removal of content that is clearly illegal under U.S. law, such as child pornography and links to pirated software.
  7. Removing contentious material that is libelous, biased, unsourced, or poorly sourced according to Wikipedia's biographies of living persons (BLP) policy. What counts as exempt under BLP can be controversial. Consider reporting to the BLP noticeboard instead of relying on this exemption.
  8. Reverting unambiguous spam, where the content would be eligible for page deletion under criterion G11 if it were a standalone page.
  9. Reverting edits made in violation of the extended confirmed restriction where it is in effect (list).

Considerable leeway is also given to editors reverting to maintain the quality of a featured article while it appears on the Main Page.

If you are claiming an exemption, explain it clearly in an edit summary or on the talk page. When in doubt, do not revert. Instead, follow the guidance below in § Handling of edit-warring behaviors.

Other revert rules

[edit]

Additional restrictions on reverting may be imposed by the Arbitration Committee, by admins under contentious topics procedures, or by the community under General sanctions. These restrictions include:

  • one-revert rule (1RR): The one-revert rule is analogous to the three-revert rule as described above, with the words "more than three reverts" replaced by "more than one revert". There may also be a requirement to discuss each reversion on the talk page, and sometimes the phrase "24-hour period" is replaced by some other time period, such as "one week" or "one month". The rule may be applied to pages (excepting Talk pages) or editors.
  • zero-revert rule (0RR): The zero-revert rule means a complete prohibition on reverts (as defined for the purpose of the three-revert rule).

An imposed rule does not apply retroactively. That is, if an editor has reverted in the past 24 hours before a 1RR has been applied, their first subsequent revert is not a violation, although editors in these instances are strongly encouraged to discuss instead of revert.

Editors of policy and guideline pages are strongly encouraged to follow 1RR or 0RR (see Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines § Bold). Editors may also voluntarily agree to abide by stricter reverting standards on other pages in response to problems in a particular area or as a general editing philosophy. For more details, see Wikipedia:Revert only when necessary.

Handling of edit-warring behaviors

[edit]

How to avoid an edit war

[edit]

Once it is clear there is a dispute, avoid relying solely on edit summaries and discuss the matter on the associated talk page, which is where a reviewing administrator will look for evidence of trying to settle the dispute. Instead of reverting, add an appropriate cleanup tag and keep in mind that there is no due-date. Avoid reverting during discussion.

Some experienced editors deliberately adopt a policy of reverting only edits covered by the exceptions listed above or limiting themselves to a single revert; if there is further dispute, they seek dialog or outside help rather than make the problem worse, i.e., they revert only when necessary. This policy may be particularly appropriate for controversial topics where views are polarized and emotions run high, resulting in more frequent edit warring.

When discussion does not produce a conclusion, bringing wider attention to a dispute can lead to compromise. Consider getting a third opinion or starting a request for comment. Neutral editors aware of the dispute will help curb egregious edits while also building consensus about the dispute. If these methods fail, seek informal and formal dispute resolution.

Rather than reverting repeatedly, discuss the matter with others; if a revert is necessary, another editor may conclude the same and do it (without prompting), which would then demonstrate consensus for the action. Request page protection rather than becoming part of the dispute by reverting.

The bottom line: use common sense, and do not participate in edit wars.

What to do if you see edit-warring behavior

[edit]
If an edit war develops, participants should try to discuss the issue on the talk page and work things out.

It is better to seek help in addressing the issue than to engage in edit warring. When disagreement becomes apparent, one, both, or all participants should cease warring and discuss the issue on the associated talk page or seek help at appropriate venues. Other alternative approaches recommended within the community are suggested in § How to avoid an edit war.

If the edit warring user(s) appear unaware that edit warring is prohibited, they can be told about this policy by posting a {{subst:uw-ewsoft}}, {{subst:uw-ew}}, or {{subst:uw-3rr}} template message on their user talk page. Avoid posting a generic warning template if you are actively involved in the edit war yourself; it can be seen as aggressive. Consider writing your own note to the user specifically appropriate for the situation, with a view to explicitly cooling things down.

If several days have passed since the last edit action, consider doing nothing—our primary objective is to stop active edit wars.

If, despite such efforts, one or more users fail to cease edit warring, refuse to work collaboratively or heed the information given to them, or do not move on to appropriate dispute resolution, then consider making a request for administrative involvement. The standard way to do this is to add a report at Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Edit warring.

Administrator guidance

[edit]

Administrators decide whether to issue a warning or block; these are intended to prevent, deter, and encourage change in disruptive behavior, not to punish it. Where a block is appropriate, 24 hours is common for a first offense; administrators tend to issue longer blocks for repeated or aggravated violations, and will consider other factors, such as civility and previous blocks. Where multiple editors engage in edit wars or breach 3RR, administrators should consider all sides, since perceived unfairness can fuel issues.

According to WP:Administrators, "Administrators should not normally use their tools in matters in which they are personally involved (for example, in a content dispute in which they are a party)."

Notes

[edit]
  1. ↑ A series of consecutively saved edits by one user, with no intervening edits by another user, counts as one revert. If there are intervening edits, then the series of edits can continue to count as a single revert if the intervening edits are to sections of the article that are unrelated to the sections edited in the consecutive edits.

See also

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]

{Wikipedia:Editing policy}}

Harassment is a pattern of repeated offensive behavior that appears to a reasonable observer to intentionally target a specific person or persons. Usually, the purpose is to make the target feel threatened or intimidated, and the outcome may be to make editing Wikipedia unpleasant for the target, to undermine, frighten, or discourage them from editing.

Wikipedia must never be misused to harass anyone, whether or not the subject of the harassment is an editor here. Edits constituting harassment will be reverted, deleted, or suppressed, as appropriate, and editors who engage in harassment are subject to blocking and banning.

Harassment can include actions calculated to be noticed by the target and clearly suggestive of targeting them, even when no direct communication takes place.

Types of harassment and disruption

[edit]

Harassment, including threats, intimidation, repeated annoying and unwanted contact or attention, and repeated personal attacks may reduce an editor's enjoyment of Wikipedia and thus cause disruption to the project. Harassment of an editor on the basis of race, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, age, religious or political beliefs, disability, ethnicity, nationality, etc. is not allowed.

The prohibition against harassment applies equally to all Wikipedians. It is as unacceptable to harass a user with a history of inept or disruptive behavior as it is to harass any other user. Wikipedia encourages a civil community: people make mistakes, but they are encouraged to learn from them and change their ways. Harassment is contrary to this spirit and damaging to the work of building an encyclopedia.

Hounding

[edit]

Hounding on Wikipedia (or "wikihounding") is the singling out of one or more editors, joining discussions on multiple pages or topics they may edit or multiple debates where they contribute, to repeatedly confront or inhibit their work. This is with an apparent aim of creating irritation, annoyance, or distress to the other editor. Hounding usually involves following the target from place to place on Wikipedia.

Many users track other users' edits, although usually for collegial or administrative purposes. This should always be done with care, and with good cause, to avoid raising the suspicion that an editor's contributions are being followed to cause them distress, or out of revenge for a perceived slight. Correct use of an editor's history includes (but is not limited to) fixing unambiguous errors or violations of Wikipedia policy, or correcting related problems on multiple articles. In fact, such practices are recommended both for Recent changes patrol and WikiProject Spam. The contribution logs can be used in the dispute resolution process to gather evidence to be presented in incidents and arbitration cases. Using dispute resolution can itself constitute hounding if it involves persistently making frivolous or meritless complaints about another editor.

The important component of hounding is disruption to another user's own enjoyment of editing, or disruption to the project generally, for no overridingly constructive reason. Even if the individual edits themselves are not disruptive per se, "following another user around", if done to cause distress, or if accompanied by tendentiousness, personal attacks, or other disruptive behavior, may become a very serious matter and could result in blocks and other editing restrictions.

One form hounding may take is for the hounder to create an account (sometimes multiple) that acts like their target but edits in bad faith, which they use to attempt to get their target blocked (or banned if they have already been blocked), as if their target had created their own sockpuppet. This is sometimes called a false flag or Joe jobbing on Wikipedia.

Threats

[edit]

Threatening another person is considered harassment. This includes any real-world threats, such as threats of harm, and threats to disrupt a person's work on Wikipedia. Statements of intent to properly use normal Wikipedia processes, such as dispute resolution, are not threats. Legal threats are a special case of threat, with their own settled policy. Users who make legal threats will typically be blocked from editing indefinitely.

[edit]

Wikipedia has a policy of blocking users who post legal threats on Wikipedia against other editors. It is important not to post comments that others may reasonably interpret as a legal threat; words such as libelous or defamatory are best avoided for that reason. In handling apparent legal threats, users should seek to clarify the poster's intention, explain the policy, and ask them to remove the threat. The existence of a legal dispute between users is not a valid reason to block, so long as no legal threats are posted on Wikipedia.

Posting of personal information

[edit]

Posting another editor's personal information is unacceptable, unless that person has voluntarily posted their own information, or links to such information, on Wikipedia.[note 1] Personal information includes an editor's real-life name, date of birth, identification numbers, home or workplace address, job title and work organisation, telephone number, email address, personal profiles on external sites, other contact information, or photograph, whether such information is accurate or not. Posting such information about another editor is an unjustifiable and uninvited invasion of privacy and may place that editor at risk of harm outside their activities on Wikipedia. Unless unintentional and non-malicious (for example, where Wikipedians know each other off-site and may inadvertently post personal information, such as using the other person's real name in discussions), attempted outing is sufficient grounds for an immediate block. This applies to the personal information of both editors and non-editors.

How to deal with personal information

[edit]

If you have accidentally posted anything that might lead to you being outed (including but not limited to inadvertently editing while logged out, which reveals your IP address, and thus, your approximate location), it is important that you act promptly to have the edit(s) suppressed. Do not otherwise draw attention to the information. Referring to still-existing, self-disclosed posted information is not considered outing, and so the failure of an editor to have the information redacted in a timely manner may remove it from protection by this policy. Further information about protecting private information is at Personal security practices, On privacy, and How to not get outed on Wikipedia.

Any edit that outs someone must be reverted promptly, followed by a request for oversight to delete that edit from Wikipedia. Any administrator may redact it pending oversight, even when the administrator is involved. If an editor has previously posted their own personal information but later redacted it, it should not be repeated on Wikipedia, although references to still-existing, self-disclosed information are not considered outing. If the previously posted information has been removed by oversight, then repeating it on Wikipedia is considered outing.

If you see an editor post personal information about another person, do not confirm or deny the accuracy of the information. Doing so would give the person posting the information, and anyone else who saw the page, feedback on the accuracy of the material. For the same reason, do not treat incorrect attempts at outing any differently from correct attempts. When reporting an attempted outing take care not to comment on the accuracy of the information. Outing should usually be described as "an attempted outing" or similar, to make it clear that the information may or may not be true, and it should be made clear to the users blocked for outing that the block log and notice does not confirm the information.

The fact that an editor has posted personal information or edits under their own name, making them easily identifiable through online searches, is not an excuse to post the results of "opposition research". Dredging up their off-site opinions to repeatedly challenge their edits can be a form of harassment, just as doing so regarding their past edits on other Wikipedia articles may be. Threats to out an editor are treated as personal attacks and are prohibited.

Exceptions

[edit]

Nothing in this policy prohibits the emailing of personal information about editors to individual administrators, functionaries, or arbitrators, or to the Wikimedia Foundation, when doing so is necessary to report violations of confidentiality-sensitive policies (such as conflict of interest or paid editing, harassment, or violations of the child-protection policy). Only the minimum information necessary should be conveyed and the minimum number of people contacted. Editors are warned, however, that the community has rejected the idea that editors should "investigate" each other. Posting such information on Wikipedia violates this policy.

Posting links to other accounts on other websites is allowable in specific situations (but see also Wikipedia:Linking to external harassment):[note 1]

  1. There are job posting sites where employers publicly post advertisements to recruit paid Wikipedia editors. Linking to such an ad in a forum such as the Conflict of interest noticeboard is not a violation of this policy.
  2. If individuals have identified themselves without redacting or having it oversighted, such information can be used for discussions of conflict of interest (COI) in appropriate forums.
  3. If redacted or oversighted personally identifying material is important to the COI discussion, then it should be emailed privately to an administrator or arbitrator—but not repeated on Wikipedia: it will be sufficient to say that the editor in question has a COI and the information has been emailed to the appropriate administrative authority.
  4. To combat impersonation (an editor claiming falsely to be a particular person), it is permissible to post or link to disavowals from that person, provided that the person has explicitly and in good faith given their consent, and provided that there is a high degree of confidence in the authenticity of the source.

Issues involving private personal information (of anyone) could also be referred by email to a member of the functionaries team. While in the limited circumstances outlined above, links to external websites containing solicitations to edit Wikipedia may be posted on Wikipedia to demonstrate that there may be conflict of interest editing, links to personal profiles on external sites should not be connected to any specific Wikipedia editor unless that editor discloses it themselves.

Private correspondence

[edit]

There is no community consensus regarding the posting of private off-wiki correspondence.

The Arbitration Committee has stated a principle that "In the absence of permission from the author (including of any included prior correspondence), the contents of private correspondence, including e-mails, should not be posted on-wiki" and in a second principle that "Any uninvolved administrator may remove private correspondence that has been posted without the consent of any of the creators. Such material should instead be sent directly to the Committee."

User space harassment

[edit]

A common problem is harassment in userspace. Examples include placing numerous false or questionable "warnings" on a user's talk page, restoring such comments after a user has removed them, placing "suspected sockpuppet" and similar tags on the user page of active contributors, and otherwise trying to display material the user may find annoying or embarrassing in their user space.

User pages are provided so that editors can provide some general information about themselves and user talk pages are to facilitate communication. Neither is intended as a 'wall of shame' and should not be used to display supposed problems with the user unless the account has been blocked as a result of those issues. Any sort of content which truly needs to be displayed, or removed, should be immediately brought to the attention of admins rather than edit warring to enforce your views on the content of someone else's user space.

Off-wiki harassment

[edit]

Inappropriate or unwanted public or private communication, following, or any form of hounding, when directed at another editor, violates the harassment policy. Off-wiki harassment, including through the use of external links, will be regarded as an aggravating factor by administrators and is admissible evidence in the dispute-resolution process, including Arbitration cases. In some cases, evidence should be submitted by private email. As is the case with on-wiki harassment, off-wiki harassment can be grounds for blocking, and in extreme cases, banning.

Editors who welcome private communication typically post their preferred contact information on Wikipedia, sometimes enabling email through the Wikipedia interface. Contacting an editor using any other contact information, without first obtaining explicit permission, should be assumed to be uninvited and, depending on the context, may be harassment. Never contact another editor in this way as part of a dispute, or when the editor has asked not to be contacted that way. Unexpected contact using personal information as described above in Posting of personal information may be perceived as a threat to the safety and well-being of the person being contacted. Users who experience inappropriate off-wiki contact should report occurrences privately to the Arbitration Committee or to the emergency response team.

Harassing those outside of the editing community

[edit]

In alignment with the protection of editors from harassment described throughout the rest of this policy, edits that harass living or recently deceased people who are not members of the Wikipedia community are also prohibited. Per the oversight policy, harassing content will be deleted or suppressed. Editors who post such material in any namespace may be indefinitely blocked.

Content and sourcing that comply with the biographies of living persons policy do not violate this policy; neither do discussions about sources and authors of sources, unless comments about persons are gratuitous to determining source quality. See also WP:BLPPRIVACY, WP:BLPCOI, and the associated contentious topic designation.

Dealing with harassment

[edit]

If you feel you are being harassed, first and foremost, act calmly (even if difficult). It is hard to overemphasize this.

If the harassment includes threats of physical harm to you or others, follow the procedures on dealing with threats of harm.

In serious cases or where privacy and off-wiki aspects are an issue (e.g., where private personal information is a part of the issue, or on-wiki issues spread to email and 'real world' harassment, or similar), you can contact the Arbitration Committee. To have personal information removed from page histories contact the oversight team.

For simpler, on-wiki matters, such as a user with whom you have arguments, see dispute resolution as the usual first step. It makes it easier to identify the problem you are having if there are some specific diffs. For more serious cases where you are willing to address it on-wiki, you may request administrative assistance. (Do not open a discussion about outing on behalf of a third party without the victim's permission, unless the relevant page revisions have already been oversighted. It is important not to make violations of privacy more severe.)

Note: If other editors have concerns over your editing, then you will quite likely gain attention from administrators and other concerned users as a result. Any civil and appropriate comments addressed by them to you would not be considered harassment.

Accusing others of harassment

[edit]

Making accusations of harassment can be inflammatory and hence these accusations may not be helpful in a dispute. It can be seen as a personal attack if harassment is alleged without clear evidence that the others' action is actually harassment, and unfounded accusations may constitute harassment themselves if done repeatedly. The result is often accusations of harassment on your part, which tends to create a nasty cycle. At the same time, claims of harassment should be taken seriously and not be summarily dismissed unless it becomes clear the accusations are not well-founded.

Assistance for administrators being harassed

[edit]

Wikipedia administrators' actions can bring them into direct conflict with difficult users and at times they too are harassed. Typically this happens when an administrator decides to intervene in a dispute with a view to warning or blocking disruptive parties or preventing their continual troublesome behavior.

Administrators are volunteer editors like any other user. They are not obligated any more than any other user to take any specific action beyond expected good conduct and responsiveness, and they are not required or expected to place themselves in an uncomfortable situation, to undertake actions which will diminish their enjoyment of working on Wikipedia or place themselves at risk in any way. Administrators who feel that they may have such a situation are advised to seek advice, discuss privately with other administrators, or pass the matter to another administrator willing to make difficult blocks.

Administrators who are confident they are safe from harassment, or willing to address difficult users and their potential actions, may wish to list themselves on the above page, and add the userbox template {{User difficultblocks}} to their user page, which also adds the user to Category:Wikipedia administrators willing to make difficult blocks

This administrator can and will make difficult blocks if needed.
Or use: [[Category:Wikipedia administrators willing to make difficult blocks|{{PAGENAME}}]]

In case of problems, administrators have exactly the same right as any other user to decline or withdraw from a situation that is escalating or uncomfortable, without giving a reason, or to contact the Arbitration Committee if needed.

Reactions to harassment

[edit]

Some people may find it hard to remain calm and to react constructively in the face of real or perceived harassment. It is important that any allegations of misconduct about someone who is being harassed be considered in this context. Suffering real or perceived harassment does not justify an editor's misconduct, but a more cautious approach to sanctions in such situations is preferred.

Consequences of harassment

[edit]

Although editors are encouraged to ignore or respond politely to isolated incidents, that should not imply that they are acceptable or without consequences. A pattern of hostility reduces the likelihood of the community assuming good faith, and can be considered disruptive editing. Users who insist on a confrontational style marked by harassment and/or personal attacks are likely to become involved in the dispute resolution process, and may face serious consequences such as blocks, arbitration, or being subjected to a community ban. Harassment negatively affects editor retention.[note 2]

Blocking for harassment

[edit]
  • In extreme cases, such as legal threats, threats of violence, or outing, protective blocks may be employed without prior warnings.
  • Incidents of wikihounding generally receive a warning. If wikihounding persists after a warning, escalating blocks are often used, beginning with 24 hours.

What harassment is not

[edit]

This policy is aimed to protect victims of genuine harassment which is meant to cause distress to the user, such as repeated and unwanted correspondence or postings. Like the word stalk, harass carries real-life connotations – from simple unseemly behavior to criminal conduct – and must be used judiciously and with respect to these connotations.

However, some editors seem to give "harassment" a much broader, and inappropriate, meaning encompassing normal and appropriate editing practices such as merely editing the same page as another user, or warning another user for disruption or incivility. Such activities are not harassment if done civilly and in good faith.

It is also not harassment to track a user's contributions for policy violations (see above); that is part of what editor contribution histories are for. Editors do not own article content, or their own edits, and any other editor has the right to revert edits as appropriate. Unwarranted resistance to such efforts may be a sign of ownership behavior and lead to sanctions.

Unfounded accusations of harassment are a serious personal attack and dealt with accordingly.

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. 1 2 The definition of "on Wikipedia" has previously been the subject of dispute. A September 2019 RfC clarified that even if a user voluntarily posts their own personal information on a Wikimedia project that is not the English Wikipedia, it may still be outing under certain circumstances to re-post that information on the English Wikipedia.
    • It is generally more acceptable to reference information voluntarily disclosed only on another Wikimedia project if it is clear the user does not mind wider dissemination (e.g. posted on a user's public userpage at another Wikimedia wiki) and less acceptable if it requires much "research" to find (particularly information later removed by the user in question).
    • Editors are urged to take care to err on the side of privacy, and to ask users before posting their personal information if there is any doubt. Posting information which might not constitute outing per se can still be unwise and reflect poorly on the poster's judgment.
    This note only applies to cases where a user has voluntarily disclosed personal information on another Wikimedia project; it does not apply in the vast majority of OUTING cases.
  2. ↑ See Konieczny, Piotr (2018), Volunteer Retention, Burnout and Dropout in Online Voluntary Organizations: Stress, Conflict and Retirement of Wikipedians, Research in Social Movements, Conflicts and Change, vol. 42, Emerald Publishing Limited, pp. 199–219, doi:10.1108/s0163-786x20180000042008, ISBN 978-1-78756-895-2, S2CID 155122668

Do not make personal attacks anywhere on Wikipedia. Comment on content, not on the contributor. Personal attacks harm the Wikipedia community and the collaborative atmosphere needed to create a good encyclopedia. Derogatory comments about other editors may be removed by any editor. Repeated or egregious personal attacks may lead to sanctions including blocks or even bans.

What is considered to be a personal attack?

[edit]

There is no rule that is objective and not open to interpretation on what constitutes a personal attack as opposed to constructive discussion, but some types of comments are never acceptable:

  • Abusive, defamatory, or derogatory phrases based on race, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, age, religious or political beliefs, disability, ethnicity, nationality, etc. directed against another editor or a group of editors. Disagreement over what constitutes a religion, race, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability or ethnicity is not a legitimate excuse.
  • Using someone's affiliations as an ad hominem means of dismissing or discrediting their views—regardless of whether said affiliations are mainstream. An example could be, "You're a railfan so what would you know about fashion?" Note that it is not a personal attack to question an editor about their possible conflict of interest on a specific article or topic. However, be aware that speculation regarding the real-life identity of another editor may constitute outing.
  • Using someone's political affiliations as an ad hominem means of dismissing or discrediting their views, such as accusing them of being left-wing or right-wing, is also forbidden. Editors are allowed to have personal political POV, as long as it does not negatively affect their editing and discussions.
  • Linking to external attacks, harassment, or other material, for the purpose of attacking another editor.
  • Comparing editors to Nazis, terrorists, dictators, or other infamous people. (See also Reductio ad Hitlerum and Reductio ad Stalinum.)
  • Accusations about personal behavior that lack evidence. Serious accusations require serious evidence, usually in the form of diffs and links.
  • Threats, including, but not limited to:

These examples are not exhaustive. Insulting or disparaging an editor is a personal attack regardless of the manner in which it is done. When in doubt, comment on the article's content without referring to its contributor at all.

Why personal attacks are harmful

[edit]

Personal attacks are disruptive. On article talk pages, they tend to move the discussion away from the article and towards individuals. Such attacks tend to draw battle lines and make it more difficult for editors to work together.

Contributors often wish to have their viewpoints included in articles. Through reasoned debate, contributors can synthesize these views into a single article, and this creates a better, more neutral article for everyone. Every person who edits an article is part of the same larger community—we are all Wikipedians.

The prohibition against personal attacks applies equally to all Wikipedians. It is just as unacceptable to attack a user with a history of foolish or boorish behavior, or one who has been blocked, banned, or otherwise sanctioned (that is gravedancing), as it is to attack any other user. Wikipedia encourages a civil community: people make mistakes, but they are encouraged to learn from them and change their ways. Personal attacks are contrary to this spirit and damaging to the work of building an encyclopedia.

Avoiding personal attacks

[edit]

As a matter of polite and effective discourse, arguments should not be personalized; that is, they should be directed at content and actions rather than people.

When there are disagreements about content, referring to other editors is not always a personal attack. A posting that says "Your statement about X is wrong because of information at Y", or "The paragraph you inserted into the article looks like original research", is not a personal attack. However, "The statement..." or "The paragraph inserted..." is less likely to be misinterpreted as a personal attack because it avoids referring to the other editor in the second person. "The paragraph inserted here [diff] into the article looks like original research" is especially advantageous because the diff cuts down confusion. Similarly, discussion of a user's conduct or history is not in itself a personal attack when done in the appropriate forum for such discussion (for example, the other editor's talk page, or Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents).

Editors should be civil and adhere to good etiquette when describing disagreements. The appropriate response to an inflammatory statement is to address the issues of content rather than to accuse the other person of violating this policy. Accusing someone of making personal attacks without providing a justification for your accusation is also considered a form of personal attack. (See also: Incivility.)

Responding to personal attacks

[edit]

First offenses and isolated incidents

[edit]

Often the best way to respond to an isolated personal attack is to simply ignore it. Sometimes personal attacks are not meant as attacks at all, and during heated and stressful debates, editors tend to overreact. Additionally, because Wikipedia discussions are in a text-only medium, nuances and emotions are often conveyed poorly, which can easily lead to misunderstanding (see Emotions in virtual communication). While personal attacks are not excused because of these factors, editors are encouraged to disregard angry and ill-mannered postings of others, if it is reasonable to do so, and to continue to focus their efforts on improving and developing the encyclopedia.

If you feel that a response is necessary and desirable, you can leave a polite message on the other user's talk page. Avoid responding on a talk page of an article, as this tends to escalate matters. Likewise, it is important to avoid becoming hostile and confrontational yourself, even in the face of abuse. Although warning templates may be used for this purpose, a customized message relating to the specific situation may be better received. If possible, try to find a compromise or common ground regarding the underlying issues of content, rather than argue about behavior.

Attacks that are particularly offensive or disruptive (such as physical threats, legal threats, or blatantly bigoted insults) should not be ignored. Extraordinary situations that require immediate intervention are rare, but may be reported at Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents.

Discussion of behavior in an appropriate forum (e.g. user's talk page or Wikipedia noticeboard) does not in itself constitute a personal attack.

Recurring attacks

[edit]

Recurring, non-disruptive personal attacks that do not stop after reasoned requests to cease can be resolved through dispute resolution. In most circumstances, problems with personal attacks can be resolved if editors work together and focus on content, and immediate administrator action is not required.

Removal of personal attacks

[edit]

Derogatory comments about other editors may be removed by any editor. However, there is no official policy regarding when or whether most personal attacks should be removed, although it has been a topic of substantial debate. Removing unquestionable personal attacks from your own user talk page is rarely a matter of concern. On other talk pages, especially where such text is directed against you, removal should typically be limited to clear-cut cases where it is obvious the text is a true personal attack. The {{RPA}} template can be used for this purpose.

Nevertheless, unusual circumstances do exist. The most serious types of personal attacks, such as efforts to reveal nonpublic personal information about Wikipedia editors (outing), go beyond the level of mere invective, and so can and should be removed for the benefit of the community and the project whether or not they are directed at you. In certain cases involving sensitive information, a request for oversight may also be appropriate.

Removing personal attacks is not an exemption to the three-revert rule.

Off-wiki attacks

[edit]

Wikipedia cannot regulate behavior in media not under the control of the Wikimedia Foundation, but personal attacks made elsewhere create doubt about the good faith of an editor's on-wiki actions. Posting personal attacks or defamation off-Wikipedia is harmful to the community and to an editor's relationship with it, especially when such attacks violate an editor's privacy. Such attacks can be regarded as aggravating factors by administrators and are admissible evidence in the dispute-resolution process, including Arbitration cases.

[edit]

Linking to off-site harassment, attacks, privacy violations, or threats of physical violence against any persons who edit Wikipedia, including those who edit for the purpose of attacking another editor, is never acceptable. This is not to be confused with legitimate critique. The inclusion of links in articles is a matter for sound editorial judgment.

The interpretation of this rule is complex. See Wikipedia:Linking to external harassment for guidance on interpretation.

Consequences of personal attacks

[edit]

Although editors are encouraged to ignore or respond politely to isolated personal attacks, that should not imply that they are acceptable. A pattern of hostility reduces the likelihood of the community assuming good faith, and can be considered disruptive editing. Users who insist on a confrontational style marked by personal attacks are likely to become involved in the dispute resolution process, and may face serious consequences through arbitration.

In extreme cases, even isolated personal attacks may lead to a block for disruption. Death threats and issues of similar severity may result in a block without warning. Lesser personal attacks often result in a warning, and a request to refactor. If a pattern of lesser personal attacks continues despite the warning, escalating blocks may follow. However, administrators are cautioned that other resolutions are preferable to blocking for less-severe situations when it is unclear if the conduct severely disrupts the project. Recurring attacks are proportionally more likely to be considered disruptive. Blocking for personal attacks should only be done for prevention, not punishment: a block may be warranted if it seems likely that the user will continue using personal attacks.

See also

[edit]

Wikipedia policies and information pages

[edit]

Wikipedia essays

[edit]

Humor

[edit]
[edit]

All Wikipedia pages and articles are edited collaboratively by the Wikipedian community of volunteer contributors. No one, no matter what, has the right to act as if they are the owner of a particular article (or any part of it). Even a subject of an article, be that a person or organization, does not own the article or have any right to dictate what the article may or may not say. No one, whether a subject or an article creator, has a responsibility to maintain an article or can normally be held responsible for its content.

Some contributors feel possessive about the material they have contributed to Wikipedia. A few editors will even defend such material against others. It is quite reasonable to take an interest in an article on a topic you care about—perhaps you are an expert, or perhaps it is just your hobby; however, if this watchfulness starts to become possessiveness, then you are overdoing it. Believing that an article has an owner of this sort is a common mistake that people make on Wikipedia.

Once you have posted it to Wikipedia, you cannot stop anyone from editing the text you have written. As each edit page clearly states:

Work submitted to Wikipedia can be edited, used, and redistributed by anyone.

Similarly, by submitting your ideas (for article organization, categorization, style, standards, etc.) to Wikipedia, you allow others to challenge and develop them.

If you find yourself in an edit war with other contributors, why not take some time off from the editing process? Taking yourself out of the equation can cool things off considerably. Take a fresh look a week or two later. Or, if someone else is claiming "ownership" of a page, you can bring it up on the associated talk page, appeal to other contributors, or consider the dispute resolution process.

Even though editors can never "own" an article, it is important to respect the work and ideas of your fellow contributors. Therefore, be cautious when removing or rewriting large amounts of content, particularly if this content was written by one editor; it is more effective to try to work with the editor than against them—even if you think they are acting as if they "own" the article. (See also Wikipedia:Civility, Wikipedia:Etiquette, and Wikipedia:Assume good faith.)

Being the primary or sole editor of an article does not constitute ownership, provided that contributions and input from fellow editors are not ignored or immediately disregarded. Editors familiar with the topic and in possession of relevant reliable sources may have watchlisted such articles and may discuss or amend others' edits. This too does not equal ownership, provided it does not marginalize the valid opinions of others and is adequately justified. Often these editors can be approached and may offer assistance to those unfamiliar with the article.

Types of conflicts

[edit]

There are two common types of ownership conflicts between users: those involving one editor and those involving multiple editors.

While ownership behavior is often understood to involve the original creator of the article, it can also involve other editors who have conflicting interests in promoting or opposing the subject, hijacking the original article's direction and emphasis, changing the title to reflect such changes, or, if unsuccessful, blanking or deleting the article as a form of revenge, however this may prove ineffective as been shown to be quickly fixed or blocked.

Single-editor ownership

[edit]

In many cases (but not all), single editors engaged in ownership conflicts are also primary contributors to the article, so keep in mind that such editors may be experts in their field or have a genuine interest in maintaining the quality of the article and preserving accuracy. An editor who appears to assume ownership of an article should be approached on the article's talk page with a descriptive header informing readers about the topic. Always avoid accusations, attacks, and speculations concerning the motivation of any editor. If the behavior continues, the issue may require dispute resolution, but it is important to make a good attempt to communicate with the editor on the article talk page before proceeding to mediation, etc. Editors of this type often welcome discussion, so a simple exchange of ideas will usually solve the problem of ownership.

If you find that the editor continues to be hostile, makes personal attacks, or wages edit wars, try to ignore disruptive editing by discussing the topic on the talk page. You may need to ignore attacks made in response to a query. If ownership persists after a discussion, dispute resolution may be necessary, but at least you will be on record as having attempted to solve the problem directly with the editor. It is important to make a good attempt to communicate with the editor on the article talk page before proceeding to mediation, etc. It may also be wise to allow them to withdraw from the conversation and return when they are ready.

Multiple-editor ownership

[edit]

The involvement of multiple editors, each defending the ownership of the other, can be highly complex. The simplest scenario usually consists of a dominant editor who is defended by other editors, reinforcing the former's ownership. This can be frustrating to both new and seasoned editors. As before, address the topic and not the actions of the editors. If this fails, proceed to dispute resolution, but it is important to communicate on the talk page and attempt to resolve the dispute yourself before escalating the conflict resolution process.

Ownership and stewardship

[edit]

Unless an editor exhibits behavior associated with ownership, it's best to assume good faith on their part and regard their behavior as stewardship. Stewardship or shepherding of an article or group of related articles may be the result of a sincere personal interest in the subject matter or in a cause or organization related to it. The editor might also be an expert or otherwise very knowledgeable in the subject matter and able to provide credible insights for locating reliable sources. The editors in question are no less responsible for adhering to core policies like neutrality of viewpoint, verifiability with reliable sources, and civility.

Wikipedia is the encyclopedia that "anyone can edit", but not all edits bring improvement. In many cases, a core group of editors will have worked to build the article up to its present state and will revert edits that they find detrimental in order, they believe, to preserve the quality of the encyclopedia. Such reversion does not indicate an "ownership" problem, if it is supported by an edit summary referring to Wikipedia policies and guidelines, previous reviews and discussions, or specific grammar or prose problems introduced by the edit.

Where disagreement persists after such a reversion, the editor proposing the change should first take the matter to the talk page, without personal comments or accusations of ownership. In this way, the specifics of any change can be discussed with the editors who are familiar with the article, who are likewise expected to discuss the content civilly. All editors must follow the official policy about discussing disputes and avoid edit warring.

[edit]

While featured articles (identified by a bronze star in the upper-right corner ) are open for editing like any other, they have gone through a community review process as featured article candidates, where they are checked for high-quality sources, a thorough survey of the relevant literature, and compliance with the featured article criteria. Editors are asked to take particular care when editing a featured article; it is considerate to discuss significant changes of text or images on the talk page first. Explaining civilly why sources and policies support a particular version of a featured article does not necessarily constitute ownership. The {{article history}} template on the talk page will contain a link to the featured article candidacy and any subsequent featured article reviews.

User pages

[edit]

Wikipedia offers wide latitude to users to manage their user space as they see fit. Nevertheless, they are not personal homepages, and are not owned by the user. They are still part of Wikipedia and must serve its primary purposes; in particular, user talk pages make communication and collaboration among editors easier. These functions must not be hampered by ownership behavior.

While other users and bots will more commonly edit your user talk page, they have the right to edit other pages in your user space as well. Usually others will not edit your primary user page, other than to address significant concerns (rarely) or to do routine housekeeping, such as handling project-related tags, disambiguating links to pages that have been moved, removing the page from categories meant for articles, replacing non-free content by linking to it, fixing lint errors, or removing obvious vandalism or BLP violations.

Resolving ownership issues

[edit]

While it may be easy to identify ownership issues, it is far more difficult to resolve the conflict to the satisfaction of the editors involved. It is always helpful to remember to stay calm, assume good faith, and remain civil. Accusing other editors of owning the article may appear aggressive and could be perceived as a personal attack. Civilly address the editor with the same amount of respect you would expect. Often, editors accused of ownership may not even realize it, so it is important to assume good faith. Some editors may think they are protecting the article from vandalism, and may respond to any changes with hostility. Others may try to promote their own point of view, failing to recognize the importance of the neutrality policy.

Examples of ownership behavior

[edit]

If an editor consistently demonstrates behavior similar to that shown in the following examples, then they might have issues with page ownership.

Actions

[edit]
  1. An editor disputes minor edits concerning layout, image use, and wording in a particular article frequently. The editor might claim, whether openly or implicitly, the right to review any changes before they can be added to the article. (This does not include the routine maintenance of article consistency, such as preservation of established spelling or citation styles.)
  2. An editor reverts justified article changes by different editors repeatedly over an extended period to protect a certain version, stable or not.
  3. An editor reverts a change simply because the editor finds it "unnecessary" without claiming that the change is detrimental. This has the effect of assigning priority, between two equivalent versions, to an owner's version.
  4. An editor reverts a good-faith change without providing an edit summary that refers to relevant Wikipedia policies and guidelines, previous reviews and discussions, reliable sources, or specific grammar or prose problems introduced by the edit. Repeating such no-reason reversions after being asked for a rationale is a strong indicator of ownership behavior.
  5. An editor comments on other editors' talk pages with the purpose of discouraging them from making additional contributions. The discussion can take many forms; it may be purely negative, consisting of threats and insults, often avoiding the topic of the article altogether. At the other extreme, the owner may patronize other editors, such as by tacitly claiming they lack the deep understanding of the subject necessary to edit the article.
  6. An editor places a personal attack in the edit summary when reverting any edit.

Statements

[edit]

Although the following statements, seen in isolation from any context or other statements, do not indicate ownership behavior or motivation, they may be part of a pattern that indicates ownership behavior. When they occur along with some form of dogged insistence and relentless pushing, without good policy back up, and often including edit warring, they may be an expression of ownership behavior.

  1. "Are you qualified to edit this article?" / "You only have X edits." (pulling rank)
  2. "I created/wrote the majority of this article." (implying some kind of right or status exists because of that)
  3. "I'm an expert on the subject. If you have any suggestions, please put them in the talk page and I will review them."
  4. "Please do not make any more changes without my/their/our approval."
  5. "Please clear this with WikiProject Z first."
  6. "I can see nothing wrong with the article and there is no need to change anything at all." (misapplying WP:AINTBROKE)
  7. "Undo peanut-gallery editor."
  8. "You hadn't edited the article or talk page previously."
  9. "You're vandalizing my hard work."

Responsibility

[edit]

Subjects and authors aren't responsible for updating content. Examples:

  1. The author of an article is not generally required to update an article for outdated information or changes in consensus as long as the content was accurate/according to consensus at the time of creation, see WP:MESS. Keep in mind that not all authors are active or check their watchlist and even those that are/do will not necessarily check every edit or identify a problem with an edit.
  2. The subject of an article is not required to police it for policy violations or otherwise keep it updated, etc. Keep in mind that even though Wikipedia often comes up high on Google searches, the subject may not have yet discovered the article or even if they have, they may not know how to edit it. Although subjects are encouraged to make minor corrections and remove vandalism, they are normally discouraged from making substantial edits, so some subjects may prefer to stay away from editing them at all.

See also

[edit]
[edit]
A toy puppet made from socks with buttons for eyes
In internet jargon, sock puppets are online identities used for disguised activity by the operator.

Sockpuppetry or socking is the misuse of multiple Wikipedia accounts. To maintain accountability and increase community trust, editors are generally expected to use only one registered account. While there are some valid reasons for maintaining multiple accounts, it is improper to use multiple accounts to deceive or mislead other editors, disrupt discussions, distort consensus, avoid sanctions, evade blocks, or otherwise violate community standards and policies.

Sockpuppetry takes various forms:

  • Logging out to create a temporary account[a] to disrupt Wikipedia or to evade a block or ban
  • Creating new accounts or rapidly changing temporary accounts to avoid detection or sanctions, or to evade blocks
  • Using another person's account (piggybacking)
  • Reviving old unused accounts (sometimes referred to as sleepers) and presenting them as different users
  • Persuading other people to create accounts (or edit logged out) for the purpose of supporting one side of a dispute (usually called meatpuppetry)

Misuse of multiple accounts is a serious breach of community trust. It may lead to:

  • a block of all related accounts
  • a ban of the user (the sockmaster or sockpuppeteer) behind the accounts (each of which is a sockpuppet or sock)
  • on-project exposure of all accounts and IP addresses used across Wikipedia and its sister projects
  • the (potential) public exposure of any "real-world" activities or personal information deemed relevant to preventing future sockpuppetry or certain other abuses.[1]

An editor operating multiple accounts for valid reasons should, on each registered account's user page, list all the other registered accounts with an explanation of their purpose (see below). Optionally, the user and user talk pages of some of the accounts can be redirected to those of another. Editors who use unlinked alternative accounts, including temporary accounts, should carefully avoid any crossover on articles or topics because even mundane activities such as copy editing might be considered sockpuppetry.[b]

Inappropriate uses of alternative accounts

[edit]

Editors must not use alternative accounts to mislead, deceive, disrupt, or undermine consensus. This includes, but is not limited to:

Creating an illusion of support
Alternative accounts must not be used to give the impression of more support for a position than actually exists.
Internal discussions
Undisclosed alternative accounts generally may not be used in discussions internal to the project outside of limited circumstances.[2] A legitimate undisclosed alternative account is permitted to contribute to project space discussions that directly affect the alternative account.
Circumventing policies
Policies apply per person, not per account. Policies such as the three-revert rule or DYK quid pro quo are for each person's edits on any account. Using a second account to violate or bypass policy will cause any penalties to be applied to both accounts.
Strawman socks
Creating a separate account to argue one side of an issue in a deliberately irrational or offensive fashion, to sway opinion to another side.
Circumventing blocks, bans or sanctions
Sanctions apply to individual editors as people, not to accounts, unless specified otherwise. Using a second account to edit in violation of an active block, community ban or other sanction imposed on your original account will result in further sanctions, which may include reversion of your contributions. See also Wikipedia:Blocking policy § Evasion and enforcement and Wikipedia:Banning policy § Evasion and enforcement.
Contributing to the same page or discussion with multiple accounts
Editors may not use more than one account to contribute to the same page or discussion in a way that suggests they are multiple people. Contributing to the same page with clearly linked, legitimate, alternative accounts (e.g. editing the same page with your main and public computer account or editing a page using your main account that your bot account edited) is not forbidden. Likewise, contributing to the same page with unlinked temporary accounts is not forbidden either, and can happen for purely technical reasons, where the editor is acting in good faith.
Avoiding scrutiny
Using alternative accounts that are not fully and openly disclosed to split your editing history means that other editors may not be able to detect patterns in your contributions. While this is permitted in certain circumstances (see legitimate uses), it is a violation of this policy to create alternative accounts to confuse or deceive editors who may have a legitimate interest in reviewing your contributions.
"Good hand" and "bad hand" accounts
Using one account for constructive contributions and the other one for vandalism or other types of disruptive editing.
Editing while logged out in order to mislead
Editing under multiple temporary accounts, or editing under both a registered and temporary account, when done deceptively or otherwise violating the principles of this policy, may be treated as the same level of disruption as editing under multiple registered accounts. When editors log out by mistake, they may wish to contact an editor with oversight access to ensure there is no misunderstanding.
Misusing a clean start
Switching accounts or concealing a clean start in a way that avoids scrutiny is considered a breach of this policy; see Wikipedia:Clean start.
Role accounts
Because an account represents your edits as an individual, "role accounts", or accounts shared by multiple people, are (as a rule) forbidden and blocked. Many first-time editors may sign up an account with a username that implies it is a role account or is being shared. Such accounts are permitted only if the account information is forever limited to one individual; however, policy recommends that usernames avoid being misleading or disruptive. As such, if you edit for an organization, please refer to Wikipedia's username policy for guidance on choosing a name or a replacement name that can avoid these problems. Role account exceptions can be made for non-editing accounts approved to provide email access, accounts approved by the Wikimedia Foundation (list below), and approved bots with multiple managers. See Username policy § Sharing accounts.
Deceptively seeking positions of community trust
You may not run for positions of trust without disclosing that you have previously edited under another account, or that you also use an alternative account. Adminship reflects the community's trust in an individual, not an account, so when applying for adminship, it is expected that you will disclose past accounts and/or current alternative accounts openly, or email the Arbitration Committee if the accounts must be kept private. Administrators who fail to disclose past and/or alternative accounts risk being desysopped, particularly if knowledge of them would have influenced the outcome of the RfA.
Using more than one administrator account
Editors may not have more than one account with administrator user rights, except for bots with administrator privileges. However, Wikimedia Foundation staff may operate more than one admin account, though they must make known who they are.
Joe job and false flag accounts
Using an alternative account to imitate another person, especially with the objective of harassing them. More rarely, these terms are used to refer to accounts which are acting like earlier disruptive accounts blocked on their own merit, but which are not obviously the earlier user.

Legitimate uses

[edit]

Alternative accounts have legitimate uses too. For example, editors who contribute using their real name may wish to use a pseudonym for contributions with which they do not want their real name to be associated, meaning they create a separate registered account for this purpose. Long-term users might register a new account to better understand the editing experience from a new user's perspective. These accounts are not considered sockpuppets. If you use a legitimate alternative account, it is your responsibility to ensure that you do not use it in an illegitimate manner according to this policy. Operating a legitimate alternative account, even for a reason listed in this policy, does not prevent the accounts from being connected to one another publicly. Individuals operating undisclosed alternative accounts do so at their own risk and against the recommended operating processes of this project.

Please note: Large language models can analyze the posting patterns and writing styles of pseudonymous users to reveal their identities and connect otherwise separate accounts.[3]

Valid reasons for an alternative account include:

Security
You may register an alternative account for use when accessing Wikipedia through a public computer, connecting to an unsecured network, or other scenarios when there's a risk of your account being compromised. Such accounts should be publicly connected to the main account or use an easily identified name. For example, User:James might use User:James (alt) or User:Jimmy, and redirect that account's user and talk pages to their main account.
Privacy
A person editing an article that is highly controversial within their family, social or professional circle, and whose Wikipedia identity is known within that circle, or traceable to their real-world identity, may wish to use an alternative account to avoid real-world consequences from their editing or other Wikipedia actions in that area. Although a privacy-based alternative account is not publicly connected to your main account, it should not be used in ways outlined in the inappropriate uses section of this page, and if it is, the account may be publicly linked to your main account for sanctions. If you are considering using an alternative account under this provision, please read the notification section below.
Doppelgänger accounts
A doppelgänger account is an account created with a username similar to your main account to prevent impersonation. Such accounts should not be used for editing. Doppelgänger accounts may be marked with the {{doppelganger}} or {{doppelganger-other}} tag, or can simply redirect to the main account's userpage.
Pseudonyms used to edit sister projects in a different language
Users who wish to have a separate account to edit a sister project written in a different script may do so. The other account should be treated as a doppelgänger on the English Wikipedia, and vice-versa. These accounts may be marked with the {{User Alias}} tag.
Clean start under a new name
A clean start is when a user stops using an old registered account in order to start afresh with a new one, usually due to past mistakes or to avoid harassment. A clean start is permitted only if there are no active bans, blocks, or sanctions in place against the old account. Do not use your new account to return to topic areas, disputes, editing patterns, or behaviors previously identified as problematic, and you should be careful not to do anything that looks like an attempt to evade scrutiny. A clean start requires that you no longer use your old account(s), which should note on their user pages that they are inactive—for example, with the {{retired}} tag—to prevent the switch being seen as an attempt to sockpuppet.
Username violations
If you are soft-blocked for having an inappropriate username, and that is the sole reason for the block, you are permitted to create a new account with an appropriate username.
Compromised accounts
If you are unable to access your account because you have lost the password or because someone has obtained or guessed your password, you may create a new account with a clean password. In such a case, you should post a note on the user page of each account indicating that they are alternative accounts for the same person. If necessary, you should also ask for an admin to block the compromised account. You may want to consider using a committed identity in advance to help deal with this rare situation should it arise later.
Humor accounts
The community has accepted some obviously humorous alternative accounts—for example, Bishzilla, Floquenstein's monster, and Lady Catherine Rollbacker-de Burgh (the Late).
Technical reasons
Maintenance
An editor might use an alternative registered account to carry out maintenance tasks, or to segregate functions so as to maintain a user talk page dedicated to the purpose. The second account should be clearly linked to the editor's main registered account.
Bots
Bots are programs that edit automatically or semi-automatically. Editors who use bots are encouraged to create separate accounts, and ask that they be marked as bot accounts via Wikipedia:Bots/Requests for approval, so that the automated edits can be filtered out of recent changes. Bots should be clearly linked to their owner's account. See Wikipedia:Bot policy.
Testing and training
Users who use a lot of scripts and other tools may wish to keep a second, vanilla account, for testing how things appear to others; or for demonstrating Wikipedia's default appearance when training new users. The second account should be clearly linked to the main account, except where doing so would interfere with testing or training.
Two-factor authentication users
Users with two-factor authentication may not be able to log on from certain clients. Such users may create a second linked account such as User:Username (phone) or User:Username (mobile).
Designated roles
Editors with specific roles, such as Wikipedian in residence or Wikimedia Foundation employees, may register specific accounts for those roles. Note the account still belongs to an individual, not the role itself, and should be named as such. For example, User:Username (WIR for Foo Museum) is an acceptable alternative account, but User:Wikipedian-in-residence for Foo Museum is not, because it is named after the role. It is not required that the names match, e.g. the main account User:Jane could have the role account User:Username (WIR for Foo Museum), but the accounts should be clearly connected. If the editor leaves the role, their role account must no longer be used. If a new editor assumes the role, they must create a new account.
Education
Educators and students are encouraged to register a separate account that does not have to be linked to their main registered account for the purpose of managing or participating in student assignments. Use of these accounts should be limited to articles and other pages directly related to students and classwork.

Alternative accounts should, for registered accounts, always be identified as such on their user pages, unless where doing so would defeat the point of the account. Templates such as {{User alternative account}} or one of a selection of user boxes may be used for this purpose.

Editing from temporary accounts

[edit]

There is no policy against someone with a registered account editing the encyclopedia from a temporary account while logged out, per se. This happens for many reasons, including not noticing that the login session had expired, changing computers, and forgetting passwords. Editors who are not logged in to their registered account must not deceive other editors. Editors editing from temporary accounts while logged out from their registered account are not required to connect their usernames to their temporary accounts on-wiki.

If you have concerns that a temporary account is being inappropriately used by someone with a registered account, you can give the temporary account notice of this policy ({{subst:uw-login}} is available for this purpose), and if the behavior continues, you should contact a checkuser privately and present the evidence to them. (Note that checkusers will not publicly link a temporary account to a registered account.)

Alternative account notification

[edit]

Unless when doing so would defeat the purpose of having a legitimate alternative account, editors using alternative registered accounts should provide links between the accounts. Links should ideally take the form of all three of the following:

  1. Similarities in the username (for example, User:Example might have User:Example public or User:Example bot).[4]
  2. Links on both the main and alternative account user pages, either informally or using the userbox templates made for the purpose. To link an alternative registered account to a main account, use the main account to tag any secondary accounts with {{User alternative account | main account}} (using the main account shows it's genuine) or {{Public user}} if the account is being used to maintain security on public computers. The main account may be marked with {{User alternative account name|OtherName|...|OtherName[n]}}.
  3. Links in the alternative account signature: if not linking to both the alternative and main account, link to the alternative account, and if necessary provide a note there requesting contact be made via the main account, or simply redirect the user talk page.

Editors who have multiple registered accounts for privacy reasons should consider notifying the Arbitration Committee if they believe editing will attract scrutiny. Editors who heavily edit controversial material, those who maintain single purpose accounts, and editors considering becoming an administrator are among the groups of editors who attract scrutiny even if their editing behavior itself is not problematic or only marginally so. However, it is worth noting that making such notification does not in any way protect the user or allow them to otherwise violate this policy. Properly maintaining separation between the main account and the alternative account is entirely the responsibility of the user. If the connection is discovered, prior notification is not a "get out of jail free card" and users should not expect that checkusers nor arbitrators will act to conceal the connection if it is made on-wiki. Conversely, neither checkusers nor arbitrators monitor disclosed accounts to ensure compliance with policy. This is also entirely the responsibility of the user. Editors who have abandoned an account and are editing under a new identity are required to comply with the clean start policy.

Meatpuppetry

[edit]

Defining meatpuppetry

[edit]

High-profile disputes on Wikipedia often bring new editors to the site, and some people might encourage like-minded editors to join a dispute. The recruited editors are sometimes referred to as meatpuppets, following a common Internet usage. While Wikipedia assumes good faith, especially for new users, actively recruiting new accounts or users on Wikipedia, or recruiting people (either on-wiki or off-wiki) to create an account or edit anonymously to influence decisions on Wikipedia, is prohibited. A new user who engages in the same behavior as another user in the same context, and who appears to be editing Wikipedia solely for that purpose, may be subject to the remedies applied to the user whose behavior they are joining. Sanctions have been applied to editors of longer standing who have not, in the opinion of Wikipedia's administrative bodies, consistently exercised independent judgment.

The term meatpuppet may be seen by some as derogatory and should be used with care, in keeping with Wikipedia:Civility.

Processes for mitigating meatpuppetry

[edit]

Wikipedia has processes in place to mitigate the disruption caused by an influx of single-purpose editors:

  • Consensus in many debates and discussions should ideally not be based upon number of votes, but upon policy-related points made by editors.
  • In votes or vote-like discussions, new users may be disregarded or given significantly less weight, especially if there are many of them expressing the same opinion. Their comments may be tagged with a note pointing out that they have made few or no other edits outside of the discussion.
  • A 2005 Arbitration Committee decision established: "For the purpose of dispute resolution when there is uncertainty whether a party is one user with sockpuppets or several users with similar editing habits they may be treated as one user with sockpuppets."[5]

Sharing an IP address

[edit]

If two or more editors use the same computer or network connection, so-called closely connected users, their accounts risk being accused of sockpuppetry and may be linked by a checkuser.

Editors who are in this position and have registered accounts are advised to declare such connections on their user pages. There are userboxes available for this; see {{User shared IP address}}. Alternatively, a user could declare (in confidence) this connection by emailing the Arbitration Committee. See WP:AC § Contacting the Committee for contact details. This is not an excuse to sock, nor does it prevent editors from making connections on their own.

It is difficult for editors using temporary accounts to maintain such disclosures, as these accounts expire after 90 days. Temporary accounts were not designed with the need for long-term posting of disclosures in mind. Such editors are best advised to register an account and/or email the Arbitration Committee.

Closely connected users may be considered a single user for Wikipedia's purposes if they edit with the same objectives. When editing the same articles, participating in the same community discussion, or supporting each other in any sort of dispute, closely connected accounts should disclose the connection and observe relevant policies such as edit warring as if they were a single account. If they do not wish to disclose the connection, they should avoid editing in the same areas, particularly on controversial topics.

Handling suspected sockpuppets

[edit]

Sockpuppet investigations

[edit]

Wikipedia:Signs of sockpuppetry lists some of the signs that an account may be a sockpuppet. If you have evidence someone is using sockpuppets or meatpuppets, you should create a report at Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations. In reporting suspected sockpuppetry, you must obey the rules of WP:OUTING with regard to disclosure of personal or identifying information.

CheckUser

[edit]

Editors with access to the CheckUser tool may consult the server log to see which IP addresses are linked to which accounts. The CheckUser tool cannot confirm with certainty that two accounts are not connected; it can only show whether there is a technical link at the time of the investigation. In accordance with the Wikimedia Foundation's Privacy and CheckUser policies, checks are only conducted with good cause, and (subject to the exceptions in those policies) results are reported in ways that minimize disclosure of personal identifying information. "Fishing"—the use of the CheckUser tools without good cause specific to a given user account—is prohibited.

Viewing temporary accounts' IP addresses

[edit]

The ability to view the IP addresses used by temporary accounts can be granted upon request to qualified non-admins who meet certain criteria. This tool is only for combatting policy violations and each use is logged.

Blocking

[edit]

If a person is found to be using a sockpuppet, the sockpuppet account(s) should be blocked indefinitely. The main account may be blocked at the discretion of any uninvolved administrator. IP addresses used for sockpuppetry may be blocked, but are subject to certain restrictions for indefinite blocks.

Banning

[edit]

Editors who are confirmed by a CheckUser to have engaged in sockpuppetry on at least two occasions after an initial indefinite block that is active, for any reason, are considered site banned by the Wikipedia community.[6]

Tagging

[edit]

List of role accounts

[edit]

See also

[edit]

Guidelines

[edit]

Essays

[edit]

Tools

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ↑ All references in this policy to temporary accounts should be read as referring to IP addresses in any context prior to 4 November 2025.
  2. ↑ See also: WP:BMB
  1. ↑ Wikimedia Foundation privacy policy:
    We hope that this never comes up, but we may disclose your personal information if we believe that it's reasonably necessary […] to protect our organization, employees, contractors, users, or the public. We may also disclose your personal information if we reasonably believe it necessary to detect, prevent, or otherwise assess and address potential spam, malware, fraud, abuse, unlawful activity, and security or technical concerns.
    Information under this policy is not gratuitously released, but may be made public at times in the context of detecting, confirming, preventing, and resolving issues related to actual or possible abuse.
  2. ↑ 2021 discussion on Undisclosed alternative accounts
  3. ↑ Goodin, Dan (March 3, 2026). "LLMs can unmask pseudonymous users at scale with surprising accuracy". Ars Technica. Retrieved 2026-09-01.
  4. ↑ Dissimilar names may cause confusion and create an impression of avoiding transparency; remember that the username appears in page histories even if you change the signature.
  5. ↑ Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Regarding Ted Kennedy § Sockpuppets
  6. ↑ March 2018 RfC
[edit]

This policy describes what kinds of usernames are acceptable on the English Wikipedia and how unacceptable or doubtful usernames can be handled. It also specifies that a user account should be used only by one person, and that in most cases one person should use only one account.

You choose your username when creating a user account. All contributions made using that account will then be attributed to the chosen username (contributions made while not logged in to any account are attributed to a temporary account with an automatically generated number as its name). It is also possible to request a change of username, and have your past contributions re-attributed to the new name.

This policy applies to usernames on the English Wikipedia. However, in most cases you will be able to use the same username and password to log in to other language Wikipedias and other Wikimedia Foundation supported projects. See Wikipedia:Unified login.

Introductory clip on usernames

Guidance for new users

[edit]

Your username must represent you as an individual person.

Accounts with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed on Wikipedia:

  • consist only of the name of a company, business, organization, website, musical group, team, club, creative group, or organized event;
  • describe only a particular role, title, or position that can be held by different people, or a department, group, or team within a parent organization or group that includes multiple people;
  • are promotional or show that the user's primary intent is to advertise, promote, sell, gain support for, or increase awareness of any person, company, business, market, product, channel, website, or other good or service; and
  • imply that the user account will be shared between more than one person.

Your username must be truthful, appropriate, and not foster a negative editing environment.

Any and all Wikipedia accounts, regardless of age, with usernames that meet any of the following criteria will be immediately blocked upon discovery:

  • are offensive, profane, violent, threatening, sexually explicit, disruptive, or intended to advocate or encourage such behavior (including criminal or illegal acts);
  • contain statements that are libelous, contentious, or disparaging, or disclose any private or non-public information about another person (either another Wikipedia editor or a notable living person);
  • are deliberately deceptive, confusing, misleading, unnecessarily long, similar to the usernames of other accounts, or intended to impersonate or falsely present themselves as someone or something they are not (another Wikipedia editor, a notable living person, an "official" Wikimedia Foundation account, etc.) in bad faith;
  • imply that the account has explicit ownership of any articles, content, topic areas, or Wikipedia processes; has any kind of "power" or "authority" over other editors; is subject to different standards of accountability under Wikipedia's policies and guidelines than other users (such as implying that certain policies do not apply to them); or has any administrative or "moderator" access levels or user rights;
  • imply the intent to troll, vandalize, or disrupt Wikipedia;
  • imply the intent to personally attack, harass, or threaten other Wikipedia users; and
  • imply that you are not here to build an encyclopedia or will use Wikipedia for purposes that it was not created for.

Note: This box contains a summary of the username policy, and it may not reflect the latest updates to that policy. Please refer to the full text of Wikipedia:Username policy and, in the case of any discrepancy, update this summary if needed.

Your username is a nickname that identifies your account and, by extension, all of your contributions to Wikipedia. You may use your real name as your username if you choose, but choosing a username that discloses your real name or other personal information is not recommended. Regardless, you should be aware of the risks involved in disclosing your real name (or any other personal information) on Wikipedia. Wikipedia usernames are case-sensitive, and if the first character of your username is a letter, that letter will be automatically capitalized. By default, your username appears in your signature on discussion pages. For further details on signatures and how to customize them, see Wikipedia:Signatures.

You will be required to specify a username when creating a new account, and you will use it (together with your password) to log in to that account. Once you have an account, you may create a user page, located at User:XXXX (where "XXXX" is your username), to provide information about yourself to other Wikipedians. You or any other editor may also create a user talk page, located at User talk:XXXX, which people can use to contact you.

Once chosen, a username cannot be easily changed, and changing your username does not hide your previous username from all of the edits that you've made while using it (such as signatures containing your previous username that you left on talk pages). For example, if "Dr. Franz Schröder" is your real name, and you choose this to be your username, your real name and doctorate will be evident in your edits and page histories, and (unless you change your signature) on all messages and replies you make on talk pages. It is highly recommended that you read and understand the section on using your real name as your username before you decide to do so. Using your real name as your username carries risks, and you should proceed only after completely understanding them. Likewise, reusing a name here that you also use on other sites may be as revealing as using your actual name.

The MediaWiki software does not allow you to register a new account with a username that is already taken by an existing account or that is too similar to another account. You can check whether a username is already taken by visiting the global account information page, entering your desired username into the search box, and clicking the "View user information" button. If the page displays the message "There is no global account for 'XXXX'", it means that the desired username is not taken. Please note that the page does not return usernames that are similar to the one that you entered into the search box; it only returns a match if the exact username you entered is already taken by an existing account. You may still be able to obtain a username that is too similar to another account under certain circumstances; see § Similar usernames below.

Your username can be almost any string of characters (subject to a few technical limitations); you can see this list for some examples of usernames that other editors have chosen. However, it should be a name that other users will be comfortable with, complies with all applicable policies and requirements set forth on this page, and does not interfere with the project. A controversial username may create a negative impression among other users; avoiding such usernames is in your interest. This page describes certain types of usernames that are specifically disallowed, primarily because they may be offensive, misleading, promotional, or suggest that the account does not belong to an individual.

Inappropriate usernames

[edit]

This section lists the types of usernames that are considered inappropriate. The same criteria also apply to signatures.

These lists are not necessarily exhaustive. Use common sense in applying these rules; a username containing a word that may seem offensive in one context may have a very different, more benign meaning in another. For guidance on how to handle inappropriate usernames, see § Handling inappropriate usernames below.

Disruptive or offensive usernames

[edit]

Any and all Wikipedia accounts, regardless of age, with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed and will be immediately blocked upon discovery:

  • Usernames that are likely to offend other contributors, disrupt productive Wikipedia processes or discussions, or make harmonious editing difficult or impossible, e.g. by containing profanities or referencing highly contentious events or controversies.[1]
  • Usernames that are profane, violent, threatening, or sexually explicit, or that advocate or encourage any such behavior (including acts that are deemed by most societies to be either extremely immoral, criminal, or illegal).
  • Usernames that deliberately offend, dehumanize, attack, demean, disparage, or discriminate against any race/color, religion, gender, sexual orientation, political affiliation, social group, identity, or status; that support or advocate such behavior; or that imply an intent to do so. Examples include:
    • Usernames that contain discriminatory attacks, racial slurs, or pejorative terms.
    • Usernames that praise highly contentious people, groups (also known as "hate groups"), or events—past, present, or future—associated with efforts intended to cause discriminatory, social, physical, emotional, or psychological harm to members of these groups.
  • Usernames that contain or imply personal attacks, or imply an intent to personally attack, harass, or threaten other Wikipedia editors.
  • Usernames that appear intended to disrupt legitimate Wikipedia discussions and processes by provoking negative emotional reactions from other editors (also known as "trolling").
  • Usernames that show or imply the intent to vandalize, disrupt, or engage in bad-faith editing or other disruptive behaviors that are clearly not intended to help build or improve Wikipedia in a positive or collaborative manner.

These accounts should be immediately blocked by administrators upon discovery. Administrators should also consider whether the usernames should be redacted from logs or edit revisions—especially if they are grossly offensive, destructive, or violent, are likely to offend many editors, or make threats of harm or imply an intent to cause harm. Usernames may still be considered inappropriate if they are offensive or disruptive in another language, satisfy one of the criteria above through misspellings or substitutions, or convey such meanings indirectly.

Usernames involving libelous, contentious, or non-public information

[edit]

Any and all Wikipedia accounts, regardless of age, with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed and will be immediately blocked upon discovery:

  • Usernames that contain contentious or disparaging statements about another person (whether the person is another Wikipedia editor, a notable living or recently deceased person, or someone else).
  • Usernames that are clearly libelous, contain blatantly false or disparaging statements or accusations about another person, or constitute blatant violations of Wikipedia's policy on biographies of living people.
  • Usernames that contain any non-public or personally identifiable information about another person,[2] or contain any other information that would be deemed appropriate for suppression by an oversighter, e.g. usernames that state what the password to the account (apparently) is.

These accounts should be immediately blocked by administrators upon discovery. If such usernames are libelous or contain information that is usually suppressed (such as disclosure of non-public personally identifiable information about another editor, or blatantly libelous statements made about a notable living person), the username should be suppressed from all logs by an oversighter to protect Wikipedia and the subjects involved from any kind of negative fallout or harm as a result of the account creation. Requests for removing attack usernames from logs should be reported to the global stewards team for evaluation and private removal from all Wikimedia Foundation projects. This can be done either via IRC in the #wikimedia-stewards connect channel or via email to the stewards VRT queue at stewards-oversight@wikimedia.org.

Misleading usernames

[edit]

Wikipedia accounts with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed because they may be misleading in a way that disrupts the project:

  • Usernames that impersonate other people (see § Real names and § Similar usernames below).
  • Usernames that give the impression that the account has permissions that it does not have; e.g. by containing the terms administrator, bureaucrat, steward, checkuser, oversight, or similar terms, such as admin, sysop, or moderator.
  • Usernames that imply that the account has explicit ownership of any Wikipedia articles, content, topic areas, or internal processes; has any kind of "power", "command", "control", or "authority" over other editors; or is subject to different standards of accountability under Wikipedia's policies and guidelines than other users (such as implying that certain policies do not apply to them).
  • Usernames that could easily be misunderstood as identifying a bot or script account, unless the account is of that type; such as ABC Bot, XYZ script.
  • Usernames that give the incorrect impression that the account is officially affiliated with the Wikimedia Foundation; e.g. Foo (WMF), Bar (Wikimedia Foundation), Qux-WMF
  • Usernames that resemble temporary account serial numbers (e.g. ~2026-45910-77), IP addresses (historically used to designate non-logged-in users), timestamps (e.g. 23:33, 22 November 2026 (UTC)), or other names which would be confusing within the Wikipedia signature format.
  • Usernames that appear similar to naming conventions used by community administrative processes, such as those starting with Renamed user or Vanished user (see Wikipedia:Courtesy vanishing).

For accounts with usernames that are in this category, you should assume good faith in cases where the username could be interpreted ambiguously. For example, a new user who has a career as a systems operator (or sysop) might include that in their username, unaware of the policy prohibiting it. Before considering further action, attempts should typically be made to discuss the username policy and the specific concerns with the user, and to request that they change their username. In cases where the violation of policy or the user's intent is clear, or likely created in bad faith, you should exhibit the use of common sense and fair and level-headed judgment when determining the appropriate action to take. Accounts with usernames that are blatant and unambiguous violations and are clearly acting in bad faith should be reported by following the instructions on Wikipedia:Usernames for administrator attention.

Promotional usernames

[edit]

Wikipedia accounts with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed because they are considered promotional:

  • Usernames that consist only of the name of a company, business, organization, website, product, musical group or band, team, club, creative group, or organized event (e.g. TownvilleWidgets, MyWidgetsUSA.com, TrammelMuseumofArt, OktoberfestBandConcert2019).
  • Usernames that consist only of email addresses or URLs to domains or websites (especially if they promote a commercial web page) and don't simply identify a person (e.g. sales@example.com).
    • This includes websites that are intended to generate revenue for their owner. Examples include Patreon pages, pages requesting donations, and revenue-generating affiliate links to vendors. Any page designed for one or more of these purposes should be treated as a commercial webpage and is therefore inappropriate for use in a username.
    • Usernames that only contain plain domain names on their own (those that do not include the top-level domain, such as .com, .net, .co.kr, etc. at the end) are sometimes acceptable (such as when the domain is a common word or phrase or the purpose is simply to identify the user as a person).
  • Usernames that are promotional or show that the user's primary intent is to advertise, promote, sell, gain support for, or increase awareness of any person, company, business, market, product, channel, website, or other good or service.

Users who both adopt a promotional username and engage in inappropriate advertising or promotional edits or behaviors – especially when made to their own user space or to articles about the company, business, group, or product – may be immediately blocked from editing Wikipedia and are usually blocked much sooner than users who engage in only one of the two behaviors. In such cases, administrators should examine the user's edits to decide whether to allow them to continue editing under a different username. If there is evidence that the user would continue to edit inappropriately under a new username, the administrator should enable the "autoblock any IP addresses used" and "block account creation" options when blocking the account. If there is no evidence—or if any available evidence is inconclusive—that the user would continue to edit inappropriately under a new username, these block options should be left disabled so that the user can create a new account with an appropriate username or have their current username changed. Before taking action, any disagreements about whether an account's username is acceptable should be discussed at Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User names first. Users who adopt promotional usernames but are not editing problematically in related articles should not be blocked. Instead, efforts should be made to contact the user and request that they change their username.

Usernames implying shared use

[edit]

Wikipedia accounts with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed because they imply shared use under Wikipedia's policy regarding shared accounts:

  • Usernames that unambiguously represent companies or groups (these also fall under § Promotional usernames above). For example, ABC Inc, XYZ Foundation, or Foo University.
  • Usernames that imply shared access between two or more people, such as Jack and Jill.
  • Usernames that consist only of the name of a particular role, title, post, or position that can be transferred or held by different people at different times, such as Secretary of the XYZ Foundation or XYZ Club President.
  • Usernames that consist only of the name of a department, group, or team within a parent organization or group whose membership may include multiple people, such as Accounting Department at Company XYZ or XYZ Foundation Social Media Group.

    However, usernames are acceptable if they contain a company or group name but are clearly intended to denote an individual person, such as Mark at WidgetFactory, Jack Smith at the XYZ Foundation, or FacebookFanatic87.

Promotional editing is not permitted, regardless of any account's chosen username. The conflict of interest guideline advises all users to exercise caution if editing articles about businesses, organizations, products, or other subjects that they are closely connected to. If you choose to edit articles that are in any way related to your company or group, you will need to carefully follow Wikipedia's advice on editing with a conflict of interest.

Non-script usernames

[edit]

Wikipedia accounts with usernames that meet any of the following criteria are not allowed due to the difficulty with some web browsers in viewing non-language Unicode characters:[3]

  • Usernames that contain emoji.
  • Usernames that are considered to be emoticons or otherwise "decorative".
  • Usernames that use any non-language symbols. This includes:

Note that this restriction does not apply to signatures, which are governed by Wikipedia's policies on the use of signatures.

Confusing usernames

[edit]

Some usernames appear problematic without fitting clearly into any of the above categories. This is often the case with confusing or extremely lengthy usernames, which are highly discouraged but which are not so inappropriate on their own as to require action.

Confusing usernames can often be a red flag for other problems. An editor with a confusing username or signature may be blocked sooner than usual for other inappropriate behavior, such as disruption or vandalism, if their confusing username contributes to the disruption.

Exceptions

[edit]

Some accounts with usernames that appear to violate the username policy have been allowed to remain by consensus because they were created before this policy was amended to prohibit those usernames (see grandfather clause). If you find an account with an apparently problematic username that belongs to a long-standing editor, it is likely that the matter has been discussed before. Please search that user's talk page (and archives, if applicable), and the archives of the administrators' noticeboards and requests for comment on usernames page before deciding to take any of the actions described below.

Handling inappropriate usernames

[edit]

If you encounter an account with an inappropriate username as described in the section on Inappropriate usernames, there are several actions that you can take to address the issue. Use common sense when deciding how to respond, and avoid "biting" newcomers.

No action necessary

[edit]

If the account's username is not unambiguously problematic, it may be appropriate to simply ignore it. In these cases, you should assume good faith while noting the grandfather clause described in the Exceptions section of this page. Except in extreme cases, it is usually not worth taking action unless the user has made at least one recent edit.

Talk to the user

[edit]

If you see an account with a problematic username that does not appear to have been created in bad faith, politely point the user to the relevant section of this policy page and encourage them to either create a new account with a different username or request a username change for their current account. You can use the {{subst:uw-username}}, {{subst:uw-uall}} or {{subst:uw-coi-username}} template to leave an appropriate message.

Request for comment

[edit]

If any doubt or disagreement remains as to whether the username is appropriate after discussing it with the editor, you may open a Request for comment on the username. This invites other editors to discuss the issue and provide input.

Report blatant violations

[edit]

If you believe that an account requires an immediate block because its username is a clear violation of the username policy, you can report it to Wikipedia:Usernames for administrator attention. This page should only be used for clear and egregious username violations that warrant an immediate block without prior discussion or warning.

Do not both add a warning to a user's talk page about their username and report the account to Wikipedia:Usernames for administrator attention at the same time. A warning or discussion by another editor should serve as an invitation or an encouragement for the user to change their username or otherwise resolve the issue, while filing a report against the account seeks immediate administrative action without prior discussion or warning. These two actions directly conflict with one another, and taking both actions can cause frustration and confusion and may result in biting newcomers when the assumption of good faith would likely have been the preferred initial response.

Report other problems

[edit]

If an account with an inappropriate username also violates other Wikipedia policies, such as those against spam or vandalism, you should address the other issues under those policies rather than reporting the username. If the user is editing a subject or topic area in a biased or promotional way, or appears to have a personal connection to the subject, report them at the Conflict of interest noticeboard.

Usernames for administrator attention guidelines

[edit]

Wikipedia:Usernames for administrator attention (UAA) is a noticeboard for quickly drawing attention to blatantly inappropriate or abusive usernames. See Wikipedia:Usernames for administrator attention/Instructions for information on how to place or resolve UAA reports, including the options that are available to administrators.

We do not want to block new users; however, blocking is sometimes necessary in order to protect Wikipedia from harm. Users whose usernames are technical or borderline violations of the username policy should generally be given an opportunity to discuss the issue and choose a new username. If such users are reluctant to change their username but are otherwise making positive contributions to the project, they should normally be allowed to continue editing, and further action should not be taken. This exception does not apply to users with clearly offensive or abusive usernames, users engaging in repeated vandalism or disruptive editing, or users whose edits demonstrate problematic bias or a conflict of interest.

Other particular types of usernames

[edit]

Real names

[edit]

All editors — especially younger editors, including children — are strongly discouraged from creating accounts with usernames that reveal their real names, are based on nicknames or usernames used elsewhere online that could be linked to their identities, or contain other personally identifiable information. Furthermore, all editors — regardless of age — should carefully consider the risks and consequences before registering and using an account with a username that contains such information. Using an account with such a username significantly increases the risk of harassment and having personal information posted without permission (also known as doxxing). This risk is especially high if they become involved with controversial topics on Wikipedia. In some countries, editing Wikipedia may be illegal, and using an account with a username that contains personally identifiable information can put users at greater risk of legal consequences. While it is possible to change your username (see § Changing your username below), a record of your previous username is permanently retained on Wikipedia. In addition, not all occurrences of your previous username in existing edits will be hidden or automatically changed to your new one, such as signatures containing your previous username that you left on talk pages.

Do not create an account with a username that is likely to imply that you are (or are related to) a specific identifiable person, unless the username is your real name. If your account's username contains your real name, and if your name is shared by a notable living person to whom you are unrelated, you should clearly state on your user page that you are unrelated to that person.

If an account's username implies that the user is, or is related to, a notable living person, the account may be blocked as a precaution against impersonation until the user provides proof of identity.

If you have been blocked for using your real name, please understand that this measure is intended to prevent impersonation or harassment of you or others who may share the same name. You are welcome to use your real name, but in some cases, you will need to prove that you are who you say you are. You can do this by sending an email to info-en@wikimedia.org. Be aware that emails are handled by a volunteer response team; it can take some time before you receive a reply. Do not send unsolicited scans of your passport or driver's license to the volunteer response team. Instead, you should contact them to find out the best way to prove your identity. The best method will vary, but may involve using an email address on a domain name that belongs to you.

Stage names

[edit]

Users may use their own stage name, pen name, or other nickname as their account's username, provided that it uniquely identifies a single person. This is not considered promotional, even if the name is used for commercial performances or publications, unless the user makes promotional edits within Wikipedia about themselves, their projects, or related subjects. However, users may not use someone else's stage name as their username, as with using someone else's real name — see § Real names.

Usernames with non-Latin characters

[edit]

Users with usernames in non-Latin script writing systems are welcome to edit Wikipedia. There is no requirement that usernames must be in English or that Latin script characters must be used. However, such usernames may appear illegible to other contributors to the English Wikipedia, and not every user's keyboard or input device may have immediate access to non-Latin characters. In addition, sometimes certain characters may not display correctly. As a courtesy to other contributors, and to avoid possible confusion or mis-identification, users with such usernames are encouraged to provide a Latin-character transliteration username on their userpage, and also as (at least part of) their signature. For an example, using the signature Παράδειγμα/Paradigma for User:Παράδειγμα.

The AntiSpoof extension does not allow the creation of usernames that contain characters from certain unusual scripts, such as Runic and Ugaritic. It also does not allow usernames to contain characters from multiple non-Latin scripts (Japanese and Korean languages are exempted, as they are natively written in multiple scripts).

For technical reasons, usernames containing any forbidden characters (# < > [ ] | { } /, as well as @ : =), are not possible.[4] Usernames also cannot contain sequences of three or more consecutive tildes, as these are used to generate signatures, and cannot contain underscores, as the software automatically converts underscores to spaces and strips away any leading and trailing spaces.

Similar usernames

[edit]

Accounts with usernames that are similar to those of existing accounts cannot normally be registered – but if you wish to use one, you may request that the account be created at Wikipedia:Request an account. Requests for accounts with usernames that are similar only to those of unused or inactive accounts are usually approved if no other issues are found. Special:CentralAuth can be used to check whether a username is available. The software that checks for similar usernames during account registration is somewhat oversensitive—if the username is different enough that other people are unlikely to confuse the two users with one another, the request will usually be approved. Users should not choose a username that implies a relationship with an existing editor (unless the account is actually owned by that editor or the relationship is acknowledged by the editor themselves).

If your account's username is similar to that of another editor's account or to the title of an article, you may wish to provide some form of disambiguation, such as by adding {{distinguish}} to the top of your user page.

Commonly misspelled usernames

[edit]

If your username is commonly misspelled, consider helping other editors locate your account more easily by creating redirects from the misspelled versions of your username to your user and user talk pages. You may consider registering the misspelled username as a doppelgänger account to prevent someone else from registering it. The MediaWiki software prevents the registration of new accounts with usernames that are too similar to existing usernames; if you cannot register your doppelgänger account for this reason, you can visit Wikipedia:Request an account for assistance.

UseModWiki-era usernames

[edit]

UseModWiki, the software used on Wikipedia throughout 2001 and early 2002, handled edits by anonymous users differently from the modern-day MediaWiki software. Anonymous users at that time were treated in one of two ways:

  • Domain names: Until about March 2001, an editor whose IPv4 address was "192.0.2.34" and was associated with the domain name "host.2.34.example.net" would have their edits logged under the name "host.2.34.example.net". Examples include office.bomis.com, dhcp-22-128.lclark.edu, and cnts2p46.uwaterloo.ca. Contributions by users with these usernames are affected by T2323. These usernames are usually indefinitely blocked on sight because (a) they don't make good usernames under the criteria described above, (b) they were never genuine usernames and would therefore have been abandoned when the software was migrated to MediaWiki, and (c) a block placed on "User:host.2.34.example.net" using the MediaWiki software will not affect an innocent contributor editing from an IP address that resolves to the domain "host.2.34.example.net".
  • Redacted IP addresses: An editor whose IPv4 address was the same as the example above and was not associated with any domain name would have their edits logged under the name "192.0.2.xxx". All UseModWiki edits made after about March 2001, as well as edits made with the Phase II software, used this format. Examples include 209.69.30.xxx and 62.110.183.xxx.

IP addresses

[edit]

After Wikipedia transitioned to MediaWiki, unregistered users were represented by unredacted IPv4 addresses (such as 86.150.12.90), and later by IPv6 addresses as well (such as 2001:0db8::8a2e:0370:7334), until the introduction of temporary accounts in November 2025. During this period, the terms "IP" and "IP user" were often used to refer to an unregistered user.

Temporary accounts

[edit]

Since November 2025, unregistered users are identified by a temporary account, which is automatically created for them when they publish an edit. Temporary accounts have a randomly-generated username that consists of a tilde, the year of creation, and a randomly generated number (such as ~2026-55910-77). Users have no control over the name of a temporary account, and temporary accounts cannot be renamed.

To prevent impersonation of unregistered users, registered account usernames cannot begin with ~2.

Shared accounts

[edit]

Any user account should represent an individual and not a group (and an individual should normally only have one user account; see § Using multiple accounts). Sharing an account – or the password to an account – with others is not permitted, and evidence of doing so will result in the user being required to stop the practice and change their password, or in sanctions (up to and including the account being blocked), depending on circumstances. For accounts being used to represent a group or organization, see § Promotional usernames and § Usernames implying shared use above.

Exceptions to this rule can be made for non-editing accounts approved to provide email access, accounts approved by the Wikimedia Foundation (see list), and bot accounts that are maintained by more than one contributor, provided the existence of such an arrangement is made clear and has consensus.

Using multiple accounts

[edit]

It is recommended that contributors do not use multiple accounts without good reason. For example, a user may wish to create an alternate account for use on public computers as a precaution to keep their primary account more secure. Contributors operating any sort of automated editing process should do so under an alternative bot account. It is recommended that multiple accounts be identified as such on their user pages; templates such as {{User alternative account}} or one of a selection of user boxes may be used for this purpose.

The use of multiple accounts outside of established policy for doing so is known as sockpuppetry, and is not permitted. For example, multiple accounts may not be used to comment on proposals or requests, cast votes, or engage in edit warring. Because policies apply to individuals, not accounts, blocked or banned users must not use sock puppets to circumvent a block; doing so will result in an extension of the block or ban.

Changing your username

[edit]

Usernames can be changed by global renamers; requests should be made at Special:GlobalRenameRequest. Once a username has been changed, existing contributions will be listed under the new name in page histories, diffs, logs, and user contributions. Signatures on discussion pages will continue to use the old name; while these can be changed manually, it is not recommended unless a contributor wishes to remove as much information as possible about their former name for privacy reasons. In such situations the old name will still be available in old versions of discussion pages, unless revision deletion is used and log entries are hidden from public view. Username changes are listed in the user rename log and the global rename log.

Deleting and merging accounts

[edit]

It is not possible to delete user accounts.[5] Editors seeking privacy per courtesy vanishing or right to vanish can usually have their accounts renamed and their user pages (and, in exceptional cases, user talk pages) deleted.

It is not currently possible to merge two or more user accounts on the English Wikipedia.

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ↑ Note that some valid strings of characters may coincide with profanities or offensive words, like "shit" in some Indian names or "porn" in some German and Thai names. When addressing these potential Scunthorpe problems, administrators should use common sense and assume good faith. User:AmandaNP/UAA/Blacklist notes some common sources of false positives; looking up a username or its components in a search engine may also be helpful.
  2. ↑ The username is considered a violation of this policy, and the creation of the account considered an attempt to disclose non-public or personally identifiable information about another person, regardless of the legitimacy of the information shared and whether or not the information is accurate.
  3. ↑ Decided after an 2017 RfC
  4. ↑ The "/" character is used for subpages of userpages. Just under 40,000 legacy usernames contain one or more of these last three characters; see Quarry 87858.
  5. ↑ See bug T34815

User:User97104/Very Helpful/VANDRightPlace

On Wikipedia, vandalism has a very specific meaning: editing (or other behavior) deliberately intended to obstruct or defeat the project's purpose, which is to create a free encyclopedia, in a variety of languages, presenting the sum of all human knowledge.

The malicious removal of encyclopedic content, or the changing of such content beyond all recognition, without any regard to our core content policies of neutral point of view (which does not mean no point of view), verifiability and no original research, is a deliberate attempt to damage Wikipedia. There are, of course, more juvenile forms of vandalism, such as adding irrelevant obscenities or crude humor to a page, illegitimately blanking pages, and inserting obvious nonsense into a page. Abusive creation or usage of user accounts and temporary accounts may also constitute vandalism.

Vandalism is prohibited. While editors are encouraged to warn and educate vandals, warnings are by no means a prerequisite for blocking a vandal (although administrators usually block only when multiple warnings have been issued).

Any good faith effort to improve the encyclopedia is not vandalism, even if misguided, willfully against consensus, or disruptive. For example, edit warring over how exactly to present encyclopedic content is not vandalism. Careful consideration may be required to differentiate between edits that are beneficial, edits that are detrimental but well-intentioned, and edits that are vandalism. If it is clear that an editor is intending to improve Wikipedia, their edits are not vandalism, even if they violate some core policy of Wikipedia. Mislabeling good faith edits "vandalism" can be harmful, as it makes users less likely to respond to corrective advice or to engage collaboratively during a disagreement. For that reason, avoid using the term "vandalism" unless it is clear the user means to harm Wikipedia; this is even true when warning a user with a user warning template. Choose the template that most closely matches the behavior you are trying to correct.

Types of vandalism

[edit]

Vandalism on Wikipedia usually falls into one or more of these categories:

Abuse of tags

[edit]
  • Bad faith placing of non-content tags such as {{afd}}, {{db}}, {{sprotected}}, or other tags on pages that do not meet such criteria
  • This includes baseless removal of {{policy}} and related tags.

Avoidant vandalism

[edit]
  • Removing {{afd}}, {{copyvio}} and other related tags in order to conceal deletion candidates or avert deletion of such content

However, this is often mistakenly done by new users who are unfamiliar with AfD procedures and such users should be given the benefit of the doubt and pointed to the proper page to discuss the issue.

Edit summary vandalism

[edit]
  • Making offensive edit summaries in an attempt to leave a mark that cannot be easily expunged from the record
  • Often combined with malicious account creation

To elaborate, edit summaries cannot simply be "reverted" and require administrative action if they have to be removed from a page's history.

Hidden vandalism

[edit]
  • Any form of vandalism that makes use of embedded text, which is not visible to the final rendering of the article but visible during editing
  • This includes link vandalism, or placing malicious, offensive, or otherwise disruptive or irrelevant messages or spam in hidden comments for editors to see.

Illegitimate blanking

[edit]

Content removal is not considered to be vandalism when the reason for the removal of the content is readily apparent by examination of the content itself, or where a non-frivolous explanation for the removal of apparently legitimate content is provided, linked to, or referenced in an edit summary.

Blanking that could be legitimate includes blanking all or part of a biography of a living person. Wikipedia is especially concerned about providing accurate and unbiased information on the living; blanking may be an effort to remove inaccurate or biased material. Due to the possibility of unexplained good faith content removal, {{uw-test1}} or {{uw-delete1}}, as appropriate, should be used as initial warnings for content removals without more descriptive edit summaries.

Inappropriate page creation

[edit]
  • Creating new pages with the sole intent of malicious behavior
  • It also includes personal attack pages (articles written to disparage the subject), hoaxes and other intentionally inaccurate pages.

There are many other types of pages that merit deletion, even speedy deletion, but which are not vandalism. New users sometimes create test pages containing nonsense or even autobiographies, and doing so is not vandalism; such pages can also be moved to become their sandbox or userpage. Pages on non-notable topics are not vandalism. Blatant advertising pages, and blatant POV pushes, are not vandalism, but frequently happen and often lead to editors being blocked. It's important that people creating inappropriate pages be given appropriate communication; even if they aren't willing to edit within our rules, they are more likely to go away quietly if they understand why their page has been deleted.

Image vandalism

[edit]
  • Uploading shock images, inappropriately placing explicit images on pages, or simply using any image in a way that is disruptive

Please note though that Wikipedia is not censored and that explicit images may be uploaded and/or placed on pages for legitimate reasons (that is, if they have encyclopedic value).

[edit]
  • Adding or changing internal or external links on a page to disruptive, irrelevant, or inappropriate targets while disguising them with mislabeling

Page-move vandalism

[edit]
  • Changing the names of pages to disruptive, irrelevant, or otherwise inappropriate names

Only autoconfirmed or confirmed users can move pages. Because of this, vandals of this variety will often create "sleeper" accounts to gain autoconfirmed status.

Redirect vandalism

[edit]
  • Redirecting or changing the target of redirect pages to other pages that are vandalism, nonsense, promotional, non-existent pages, or attack pages
  • This can also manifest as changing the target of a pre-existing redirect from an appropriate target to an inappropriate one.
  • This also applies when a redirect or its title is created only to disparage its subject.

Pages that redirect to non-existent or deleted pages are also applied with G8.

Silly vandalism

[edit]

This is one of the most common forms of vandalism. However, the addition of random characters to pages is often characteristic of an editing test and, though impermissible, may not be malicious.

Subtle vandalism

[edit]
  • Vandalism that is harder to spot, or that otherwise circumvents detection, including:
    • adding plausible misinformation to articles (such as minor alteration of facts or additions of plausible-sounding hoaxes)
    • hiding vandalism (such as by making two bad edits and reverting only one)
    • simultaneously using multiple accounts (including temporary accounts) to vandalize
    • abuse of maintenance and deletion templates
    • reverting legitimate edits with the intent of hindering the improvement of pages

Impersonating other users by signing an edit with a different username or IP address also constitutes subtle vandalism, but take care not to confuse this with appropriately correcting an unsigned edit made by another user.

Some vandals even follow their vandalism with an edit that states "Rv vandalism" or similar in the edit summary in order to give the appearance the vandalism was reverted.

What is not vandalism

[edit]

Although at times the following situations may be referred to colloquially as "vandalism", they are not usually considered vandalism within the context of Wikipedia. However, each case should be treated independently, taking into consideration whether or not the actions violate Wikipedia policies and guidelines. If an editor treats situations which are not clearly vandalism as such, it may harm the encyclopedia by alienating or driving away potential editors.

A user who, in good faith, adds content to an article that is factually inaccurate in the belief that it is accurate, is trying to contribute to and improve Wikipedia, not vandalize it. If you believe inaccurate information has been added to an article in good faith, remove it or correct it once you are certain it is inaccurate, and consider discussing its factuality with the user who has added it.

While intentionally adding nonsense to a page is a form of vandalism, sometimes honest editors may not have expressed themselves correctly (e.g. there may be an error in the syntax, particularly for Wikipedians who use English as a second language). Also, connection errors, browser extensions, or edit conflicts can unintentionally produce the appearance of nonsense or malicious edits. In either case, assume good faith.

Bold edits, though they may precede consensus or be inconsistent with prior consensus, are not vandalism unless other aspects of the edits identify them as vandalism. The Wikipedia community encourages users to be bold and acknowledges the role of bold edits in reaching consensus.

Uploading or using material on Wikipedia in violation of Wikipedia's copyright policies is prohibited, but is not vandalism. It is at least as serious an issue as vandalism and persistent offenders will ultimately get blocked, but it is well worth spending time communicating clearly with those who violate copyright, as they may not understand why what they are doing is wrong.

Disruptive editing or stubbornness

[edit]

Some users cannot come to an agreement with others who are willing to talk to them about an editing issue, and repeatedly make changes against consensus. Edit warring is not vandalism and should not be dealt with as such. Dispute resolution may help. See also: Tendentious editing.

Starting a deletion process in bad faith is disruptive editing, but is not vandalism. However, misusing deletion template messages with no intention to start a deletion process is vandalism by abuse of tags.

In short, all vandalism is disruptive editing, but not all disruptive editing is vandalism.

Edit summary omission

[edit]

The edit summary is important in that it helps other editors understand the purpose of your edit. Though its use is not required, it is strongly recommended, even for minor edits, and is considered proper Wikipedia etiquette. Even a brief edit summary is better than none. However, not leaving edit summaries is not considered vandalism.

Editing tests by experimenting users

[edit]

Users sometimes edit pages as an experiment. Such edits, while prohibited, are treated differently from vandalism. These users should be warned using the uw-test series of user warning templates, or by a talk page message including, if appropriate, a welcome and referral to the Wikipedia sandbox, where they can continue to make test edits without being unintentionally disruptive. Registered users can also create their own sandboxes as a user subpage. If a user has made a test edit and then reverted it, consider placing the message {{uw-selfrevert}}, on their talk page. Pages created as test edits outside of userspace may be deleted under speedy deletion criterion G2. Editing tests are considered vandalism only when a user continues to make test edits despite receiving numerous warnings.

Editors are encouraged to be bold. However, making edits to Wikipedia policies and guidelines pages, such as this one, does require some knowledge of the consensus on the issues. If people misjudge consensus, it would not be considered vandalism; rather, it would be an opportunity to discuss the matter with them, and help them understand the consensus.

Personal attacks and harassment are not allowed. While some harassment is also vandalism, such as user page vandalism, or inserting a personal attack into an article, harassment in itself is not vandalism and should be handled differently.

Incorrect wiki markup and style

[edit]

Inexperienced users are often unfamiliar with Wikipedia's formatting and grammatical standards, such as how to create internal and/or external links or which words should be bolded or italicized, etc. Rather than label such users as vandals, just explain to them what the standard style would be for the issue at hand, perhaps pointing them towards the documentation at How to edit a page, and the like.

Some users are not familiar with Wikipedia's purpose or policies and may start editing it as if it were a different medium—such as a forum or blog—in a way that it appears as unproductive editing or borderline vandalism to experienced users. Although such edits can usually be reverted, it should not be treated as vandalism.

The neutral point of view policy is difficult for many of us to understand. Even Wikipedia veterans occasionally introduce material which is not ideal from an NPOV perspective. Indeed, we are all affected to a greater extent than we estimate by our beliefs. Though the material added may be inappropriate, it is not vandalism in itself.

Reversion or removal of unencyclopedic material

[edit]

Even factually correct material may not belong on Wikipedia, and removing such content when it is inconsistent with Wikipedia's content policies is not vandalism.

Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced—whether the material is negative, positive, neutral, or just questionable—should be removed immediately and without waiting for discussion, per Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons.

Make sure that the removed content is consistent with Wikipedia's standards before restoring it or treating its removal as vandalism.

How to spot vandalism

[edit]

Useful ways to detect vandalism include:

  • Recent changes patrolling, using the recent changes link with filters to spot suspicious edits
  • Keeping an eye on your watchlist
  • The edit history of an article can be checked for recent suspicious edits. Article size, as given in bytes, usually increases slightly with time, so a sudden large decrease may indicate a section blanking. Similarly, if an article's size change is inappropriately large for the stated edit summary (e.g. "Fixing typo" while removing 100 bytes), the page may have been vandalized.

In all the three methods above, examples of suspicious edits are those performed by temporary accounts, red linked, or obviously improvised usernames. A good way to start is to click on every edit in watchlists, histories etc. with the least suspicion of being vandalism. Increased experience will probably give a sense of which edit descriptions are worth to check further and which may likely be ignored. Some descriptions like "Fixed typo" may be vandalism as that is one of the default edit summaries. Anonymous editors should not be approached with the assumption that they are vandals. Although many vandals do vandalize without registering an account, there are many anonymous editors who are great contributors to Wikipedia. Always read the actual changes made and judge on that, rather than who made the changes or what was entered in the edit summary.

  • See the what links here pages for Insert text, Link title, Headline text, Bold text and Example Image to detect test edits. (See also {{toolbar experiments}}).
  • The auto-summary feature can also help users spot vandalism.
  • Viewing the abuse log or this version if the regular abuse log is cluttered by spambots.
  • Watching for edits tagged by the abuse filter. However, many tagged edits are legitimate, so they should not be blindly reverted. That is, do not revert without at least reading the edit.
  • Plausible, subtle changes not supported by sources or by text elsewhere in the article, particularly without an edit summary, may suggest vandalism. Changing numbers, sometimes by 1, is a common stealth tactic.

How to respond to vandalism

[edit]

Upon discovering vandalism, revert such edits, using the undo function or an anti-vandalism tool. Once the vandalism is undone, warn the vandalizing editor. Notify administrators at the vandalism noticeboard of editors who continue to vandalize after multiple warnings, and administrators should intervene to preserve content and prevent further disruption by blocking such editors. Users whose main or sole purpose is clearly vandalism may be blocked indefinitely without warning.

If you see vandalism on a list of changes (such as your watchlist), then revert it immediately. You may use the "undo" button (and the automatic edit summary it generates), and mark the change as minor. It may be helpful to check the page history to determine whether other recent edits by the same or other editors also represent vandalism. Repair all vandalism you can identify.

For a new article, if all versions of the article are pure vandalism, mark it for speedy deletion by tagging it with {{Db-g3}}. [a]

To make vandalism reverts easier you can ask for the rollback feature to be enabled for your registered Wikipedia account. This feature is only for reverting vandalism and other obvious disruption, and lets you revert several recent edits with a single click. See Wikipedia:Requests for permissions/Rollback.

If you see that a user has added vandalism you may also check their other contributions. If most or all of these are obvious vandalism you may report the user immediately at the Administrator intervention against vandalism noticeboard, though even in this case you may consider issuing a warning message first, unless there is an urgent need to block the user. Otherwise, you can leave an appropriate warning on the user's talk page. Remember that any editor may freely remove messages from their own talk page, so they might appear only in the talk history. If a user continues to cause disruption after being warned, report them also at the Administrator intervention against vandalism noticeboard. An administrator will then decide whether to block the user.

For repeated vandalism by one or more temporary accounts, it is helpful to have the temporary account IP viewer permission, which allows you to see the IP addresses of temporary accounts and determine if multiple temporary accounts share an IP address. Usage of this tool is governed by the Access to Temporary Account IP Addresses Policy.

Undetected vandalism

[edit]

Sometimes vandalism takes place on top of older, undetected vandalism. With undetected vandalism, editors may make edits without realizing the vandalism occurred. This can make it harder to detect and delete the vandalism, which is now hidden among other edits. Sometimes bots try to fix collateral damage and accidentally make things worse. Check the page history to make sure you're reverting to a "clean" version of the page. Alternatively, if you can't tell where the best place is, take your best guess and leave a note on the article's talk page so that someone more familiar with the page can address the issue—or you can manually remove the vandalism without reverting it.

For beginners

[edit]

For relatively inexperienced Wikipedians, use these simple steps to quickly respond to what you consider vandalism. This is essentially an abridged version of the above page.

  1. Assess whether the edit was made in good or bad faith. If in good faith, it is not vandalism as such, so question the accuracy of information on the talk page or add an inline cleanup tag, such as a "{{dubious}}" tag, to the disputed edit. If it is in bad faith, then it is vandalism and you may take the appropriate steps to remove it.
  2. Revert the vandalism by viewing the page's history and selecting the most recent version of the page prior to the vandalism. Use an edit summary such as 'rv/v' or 'reverted vandalism' and click on 'Publish changes'.
  3. Warn the vandal. Access the vandal's talk page and warn them. A simple note explaining the problem with their editing is sufficient. If desired, a series of warning templates exist to simplify the process of warning users, but these templates are not required. These templates include
    • Level one: {{subst:uw-vandalism1}} This is a gentle caution regarding unconstructive edits; it encourages new editors to use a sandbox for test edits. This is the mildest warning.
    • Level two: {{subst:uw-vandalism2}} This warning is also fairly mild, though it explicitly uses the word 'vandalism' and links to this Wikipedia policy. It is the first to warn that further disruptive editing or vandalism may lead to a block; however, it uses the wording "loss of editing privileges" rather than "block".
    • Level three: {{subst:uw-vandalism3}} This warning is sterner. It is the first to warn that further disruptive editing or vandalism may lead to a block while actually using the word "block".
    • Level four: {{subst:uw-vandalism4}} This is the sharpest vandalism warning template, and indicates that any further disruptive editing may lead to a block without warning.
    • Level four-im: {{subst:uw-vandalism4im}} This warning template should be used only in the worst conditions of vandalism. It indicates that this is the only warning the target will receive, and that further disruptive edits will result in a block without warning.
  4. Watch for future vandalism from the vandal by checking the user's contributions. If bad faith edits continue, revert them and warn them again, letting the users know that they can be blocked. Note that it is not necessary to use all four warning templates in succession, nor is it necessary to incrementally step through warnings.
  5. Report vandals that continue their behavior after being warned to Wikipedia:Administrator intervention against vandalism. While not strictly required, administrators there are most likely to respond rapidly to requests which include at least two warnings, culminating in the level-four "last chance" template.

Template and CSS vandalism

[edit]

If no vandalizing edits appear in the page's edit history, or the vandalism obscures the page tabs so you can't easily access the history or edit the page, it is probably template or Cascading Style Sheets vandalism. These are often not difficult to fix, but can be confusing.

To access the page history or edit the page when the "View history" or "Edit" tabs are inaccessible, use Wikipedia keyboard shortcuts. You can also access the history through a vandalism patrolling tool if you're using one, or from your watchlist if you are watching the page), or from your user contributions if you have edited the page. Or, enter the URL manually into the address bar of your browser: it will take the form https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_of_article?action=edit or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_of_article?action=history.

If vandalizing edits do not appear in the page history, the vandalism is likely in a transcluded template instead of the page itself. To find the template page, edit the article (using Wikipedia keyboard shortcuts if necessary); toward the bottom of the edit page is a list of all templates transcluded into the page. Look for vandalism in the transcluded templates not protected. Alternatively, look for {{Template name}} or {{Template name|parameter ...}} in the text, approximately where the vandalism appears, then go to the page Template:Template name and revert any vandalism. When you return to the original page, the vandalism should be gone, though you may need to purge the page.

Image vandalism

[edit]

Images are occasionally used for vandalism, such as by placing shock or explicit images where they should not be. When an image has been created exclusively for vandalism, it can be requested for speedy deletion: under criterion G3 if hosted on Wikipedia or as vandalism if hosted on Commons (a file repository for Wikimedia Foundation projects). When an image is used for vandalism due to its explicit nature but has legitimate encyclopedic uses (Wikipedia is not censored) or is hosted on Commons and has legitimate uses on other projects, it can be requested for being added to the bad image list, which precludes its addition on any page except those specified.

How not to respond to vandalism

[edit]

Warnings

[edit]
Warning templates
PageName is optional

See additional templates and examples of output

The purpose of warning a user who has vandalized is to inform the user that the user's conduct is abusive and prohibited, and seek the user's compliance. Not all that appears to be vandalism is in bad faith, and a warning can politely advise and correct users unaware of the nature of their actions. A warning may even dissuade a user acting in bad faith from continuing, particularly as the warnings escalate and the user is informed of the consequences of continuing.

Warning a user for vandalism is generally a prerequisite to administrator intervention. Because of this, users should be warned for each and every instance of vandalism.

How to warn vandalizing users

[edit]

A list of user warning templates, with descriptions and instructions for their use, is at Wikipedia:Template messages/User talk namespace. In addition to a series of user warning templates for vandalism, there are series for specific types of vandalism. Use the most specific user warning template for the conduct. The existence of these templates is intended as a convenience, and their use is not required. A specifically tailored note, written personally and directly addressing the problematic behavior is equally as acceptable as a form of warning, and in many cases, will often result in better engagement with the user in question.

Assume good faith (such as that the user is simply unaware of the policies and guidelines) unless it is clear that the user is deliberately harming Wikipedia from the outset, for instance in cases of abusive, vulgar, or juvenile vandalism.

If you do choose to use warning templates, please choose templates that are appropriate to the type and level of problem in question. If edits are questionable, but not clearly vandalism, please start with lower-level templates (level 1 or 2) and wait for a few further contributions to see if the other editor responds or changes their behavior. For clear but more innocuous vandalism such as memes and silliness, lower-level templates are also an appropriate place to start. If the behavior continues, or if it is clear the edits are in bad faith and more abusive from the outset, the use of a higher-level template (level 3 or 4) may be appropriate. If, after receiving multiple warnings, the behavior persists past the point where good faith can be extended, or it becomes clear that the user has had the opportunity to notice they have been warned, and they still persist with the problematic behavior, consider reporting them to the Vandalism noticeboard.

Administrator response to vandalism

[edit]

Response from administrators at the vandalism noticeboard varies depending on the type of vandalism and the specifics of the report. Keep in mind:

  • Admins are unlikely to block a user who has not been warned at all, or who has been warned, but has stopped editing since being warned. It must be clear that the user has been told to stop vandalizing, and still persists despite such warnings, except for egregious cases.
  • Reports of vandalism from registered accounts are handled differently than that from temporary accounts, and reports from newly registered accounts are handled differently from accounts of experienced Wikipedia users.
    • IP addresses may or may not be kept by the same person for long periods of time; a dynamic address which appears to have stopped vandalizing will probably not be blocked, while one that is actively vandalizing will likely receive a short (1–2 day) block. If there is evidence that an IP address is being used by the same person over a long period of time to repeatedly vandalize Wikipedia, or if it is clear the IP address is being used by multiple people to vandalize Wikipedia (such as a school-based IP, which can sometimes attract lots of juvenile vandalism over long periods of time from many different people) then an administrator may block the IP for a longer time period (several months to a year). IP addresses are almost never blocked indefinitely.
    • Brand-new accounts who repeatedly vandalize despite multiple warnings are usually blocked indefinitely, especially when there is no history of quality editing on the account.
    • Reports which involve experienced Wikipedia users rarely result in blocks for vandalism, as these reports are usually mislabeling other problematic behavior (such as misrepresenting sources, or removing text, or edit warring) as vandalism. The vandalism noticeboard is not designed to litigate disputes or to investigate complex behavior problems. Instead, other noticeboards such as the edit warring noticeboard or the incidents noticeboard are more appropriate to deal with those issues.
  • Check back in to the vandalism noticeboard to see how your report has been dealt with. If an administrator declines to block someone you report, they will always leave a note explaining why they did not respond as you requested. Often, this does not mean the person you reported is behaving properly, or should not be dealt with, but merely that the mechanisms of the vandalism noticeboard are not well suited for handling many types of reports. Consider taking the issue up at a more appropriate noticeboard, which has been tailored to the specific type of problem you are seeing. Other times, a report is declined for being stale (blocks to abandoned accounts, or to temporary accounts which have been dormant for some time are rarely done), or to the admin being unable to easily identify the edits as vandalism.
  • If the vandalism in question is "subtle vandalism", is being committed by a person who was blocked under a prior account or temporary account, or requires in-depth and direct knowledge of a prior problem, consider taking the report to the incidents noticeboard instead. There are hundreds of Wikipedia administrators, and many of them are unfamiliar with the intricacies of past cases. Unless it is the sort of vandalism that needs no explanation at all, it should be taken elsewhere and not WP:AIV.

Reminding responding users to correctly warn

[edit]

Because warnings for vandalism are generally a prerequisite to administrator intervention, it is important that users responding to vandalism warn vandalizing users. To inform responding users of this responsibility, use the user warning template {{uw-warn}}.

Likewise, incorrect use of user warning templates, even if well-intended, should be identified to the mistaken user. The {{uw-tempabuse}} series of user warning templates may be used, but a detailed talk page message is better.

Tracing temporary accounts

[edit]

If you have temporary account IP viewer (TAIV) permissions and believe two temporary accounts are the same person, you can view the IP addresses of the temporary accounts to see if they are the same. If they are not the same but you believe they are still the same person, the owners of the IP addresses can be found using:

If an address is not in one registry, it will probably be in another.

Identifying associated IP addresses

[edit]

If you're trying to determine whether a set of IP addresses involved in vandalism is related, a command-line WHOIS query will generally list this information, or can be shown using the Routeviews DNS name server asn.routeviews.org reverse IP look-up to find the CIDR and ASN for a set of IP addresses. This can be done using IP lookup tools.

A WHOIS query will typically return NetRange, CIDR, NetName, NetHandle, and OriginAS, all of which identify specific network spaces. Data and labeling vary considerably by WHOIS registrar.

The Routeviews data is far more uniformly structured and returns ASN and CIDR as a reverse-lookup TXT query result. It is more useful and faster than WHOIS when checking multiple IP addresses and can be scripted or automated.

CIDR identifies a set of related addresses ("network space") and ASN identifies an Autonomous System—that is, a single administrative entity with control over multiple (and often very many) addresses. Some (though not all) abuse from multiple sources does come from such unified spaces—possibly corresponding to a set of hosts within a single facility.

Abuse originating in a short period of time from different IP addresses within the same CIDR or ASN may indicate a dedicated non-distributed attack, as opposed to a distributed denial of service attack.

Proxies, VPNs and Tor exit nodes

[edit]

It's possible that a user's source location is being masked by routing traffic through a Proxy server, VPN or the Tor network. Such addresses typically serve many, not just one, person, and though they can be valid present challenges when used for abuse.

A proxy VPN is not necessarily detectable, but commercial services may be indicated by the hostname when resolving an IP address.

Users of the Tor anonymity network will show the IP address of a Tor "exit node". Lists of known Tor exit nodes are available from the Tor Project's Tor Bulk Exit List exporting tool.

See also

[edit]

Tools

[edit]
  • AntiVandal – Web-based counter-vandalism tool. (requires rollback permission).
  • Huggle – Cross-platform application for dealing with vandalism (requires rollback permission).
  • Twinkle – JavaScript gadget allowing reversion of vandalism from page diffs.
  • Ultraviolet – User-friendly Javascript-based diff browser and counter-vandalism tool (works with or without rollback permissions).

Guidelines

[edit]

Essays

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ↑ Or simply {{G3}}