User:KeysAMX
|
Why I Do Not Regard Wikipedia as a Neutral or Trustworthy Source
[edit]Although I infrequently edit, correct and look after articles relating to my local area, or handful of close interests, I do not support Wikipedia, nor do I regard it as the politically neutral source of information that it presents itself as being. This is not because I believe everything published on Wikipedia is false. Much of its mundane factual material is perfectly useful. My objection concerns subjects where history, politics, ideology, race, culture and contemporary social questions intersect. On these subjects, I believe Wikipedia's claim to neutrality is undermined by the very system through which its content is created and controlled.
Wikipedia describes its Neutral Point of View policy as fundamental. It states that articles should represent significant viewpoints “fairly, proportionately, and, as far as possible, without editorial bias.” It further states that articles should not take sides and that seriously contested claims should not simply be presented as unquestionable facts. These are admirable principles. My criticism is that principles are only as neutral as the people interpreting and enforcing them.
Wikipedia is governed to an extraordinary degree through editorial consensus. Its own policy calls consensus its “fundamental method of decision-making.” Editors determine content through editing, talk-page discussions, Requests for Comment and other community processes. Wikipedia even makes clear that administrators normally do not authoritatively decide content questions such as “which words to use in the first sentence.” Those questions are ultimately settled through the editorial consensus process.
That distinction is important. Wikipedia is not simply a collection of facts checked against an external objective standard. On contentious matters, a comparatively small group of editors may decide which wording is acceptable, which interpretation receives prominence, which descriptions appear in the opening paragraph and which opposing perspectives receive little or no space.
Wikipedia insists that consensus is not merely majority voting and that arguments should be judged according to their quality and compliance with policy. In theory, this offers substantial protection against ideological mob rule. In practice, however, those policies must themselves be interpreted by editors. Terms such as “due weight,” “fringe,” “reliable,” “significant viewpoint” and “editorial bias” are not mechanically measurable quantities. Someone has to decide what they mean in each dispute.
This becomes particularly important in the treatment of sources.
Wikipedia's reliable-sources guideline says that articles should generally depend upon independent published sources with reputations for fact-checking and accuracy. Yet it also stresses that reliability is contextual and requires “editorial judgment.” Consequently, publication by a respectable newspaper, historian, academic or other apparently credible source does not automatically guarantee that an editor may use it for a particular proposition.
English Wikipedia has gone considerably further by developing its "Perennial Sources" system, in which repeatedly disputed publications are classified through community discussion and consensus. These decisions can have a considerable practical effect on whether material from those publications survives in articles.
Again, there is nothing inherently unreasonable about assessing sources. Some publications really are more reliable than others. My objection concerns the obvious possibility for ideological asymmetry in determining that reliability. A sufficiently established editorial community can regard sources compatible with its worldview as mainstream while subjecting ideologically unwelcome publications, historians or interpretations to considerably greater scepticism.
The danger is circular. Editors decide which sources are sufficiently reliable. Those approved sources then define what Wikipedia regards as the mainstream position. Alternative arguments are subsequently rejected because they supposedly lack support from the approved mainstream sources. The established interpretation is then described as “consensus,” making it progressively more difficult to challenge.
Wikipedia's own rules acknowledge that politically biased sources can nevertheless be reliable. Its reliable-sources guideline specifically says that a source need not be neutral or objective and gives examples involving radical feminist, Marxist communist and conservative writers. Yet this sensible principle still depends upon editors applying it consistently.
There is evidence that concerns about ideological bias are not imaginary. Shane Greenstein and Feng Zhu examined more than 28,000 Wikipedia articles relating to American politics and found that Wikipedia's earlier political content, on average, leaned Democratic. Their later comparison between Wikipedia and Encyclopaedia Britannica found Wikipedia articles to be more slanted towards Democratic viewpoints and more biased overall, although the difference diminished as articles received more revisions.
An especially revealing 2019 study published in Nature Human Behaviour found that politically diverse groups of Wikipedia editors produced higher-quality articles than ideologically homogeneous groups. The effect was particularly apparent in political articles. This is precisely why ideological concentration amongst editors concerns me. Wikipedia works best when opposing perspectives continually challenge each other's assumptions. Where one worldview becomes dominant, its assumptions can cease to be recognised as assumptions at all.
There is also considerable inequality in who actually produces Wikipedia. A Nature Human Behaviour editorial reviewing research into Wikimedia projects observed that collaborative online knowledge is disproportionately produced by a comparatively small group of contributors rather than evenly by the enormous population of people who merely read it. Thus the slogan that Wikipedia is “the encyclopaedia anyone can edit” does not mean that every viewpoint has anything approaching equal practical influence.
My particular objection concerns the treatment of modern history. I believe that sections of Wikipedia's activist editorial community perpetuate what amounts to a politically useful mythology of twentieth-century and subsequent history. I do not mean that every date, battle, election, casualty figure or biography is invented. The problem is more subtle and, in my view, more consequential.

Historical bias can be created through selection, emphasis, terminology and omission.
One set of events may be discussed at enormous length while comparable events receive little attention. One ideology's crimes may be described as inherent consequences of that ideology while another ideology's crimes are treated primarily as aberrations, disputed classifications or matters requiring elaborate contextual qualification. The motives of one movement can be interpreted in the most hostile terms available while another is described largely through its own intellectual framework. Even when individual sentences can technically be sourced, the resulting article can convey a highly selective picture.
That is propaganda at its most effective: not necessarily inventing facts, but determining which facts matter, which interpretations are respectable and which questions may legitimately be asked.
I believe activist editors can use Wikipedia's formidable procedural apparatus to defend such narratives. Contrary evidence can be challenged as undue, fringe, insufficiently secondary, contextually unreliable or based upon an unacceptable source. A newcomer confronting an entrenched group of experienced editors is therefore not participating on equal terms merely because the website allows him to press an Edit button.
An example (amongst many) of an area in which I believe Wikipedia's supposed neutrality frequently fails is its treatment of nationalism, and particularly ethnic nationalism. These, in my opinion, rank as some of today's most important ideological positions in a modern world where white people are not only a minority on a global scale, but now face becoming a minority in their own ancestral homelands, potentially within their lifetimes. In my view, a considerable portion of Wikipedia's activist editorial culture approaches nationalism not as a political philosophy to be described impartially, but as something to be morally graded according to the ethnic identity of the people asserting it. Concepts such as indigenous identity, cultural preservation, collective memory, ancestral connection to territory and ethnic self-determination are often treated sympathetically when applied to peoples whom contemporary progressive politics regards as historically marginalised. Yet when comparable arguments are made by European peoples concerning the preservation of their own historic identities, the language can change rapidly to that of exclusion, xenophobia, nativism or extremism.
I regard that distinction as fundamentally inconsistent. Either ancestry, historical continuity, collective identity and attachment to a homeland are legitimate considerations for peoples, or they are not. A principle cannot reasonably be presented as enlightened when asserted by one ethnic population and inherently sinister when asserted by another. I do not believe Europeans should be required to regard their own ethnic and cultural continuity as uniquely illegitimate while simultaneously being encouraged to recognise the importance of continuity, indigenous identity and self-determination elsewhere in the world.
This is particularly relevant to immigration. I reject the assumption that opposition to very high levels of immigration must arise from hostility towards individual immigrants. A country is more than an economic zone populated by interchangeable individuals. It is also the product of generations of historical continuity: language, customs, families, institutions, shared experiences, local traditions and an inherited sense of belonging. Immigration conducted on a sufficiently large and sustained scale can alter the demographic character of a country permanently. Once such changes have occurred across generations they cannot simply be reversed like a temporary economic policy.

For that reason, I believe the native populations of European countries have a legitimate interest in their own demographic future. That proposition should not become unacceptable merely because those populations happen to be European. Peoples of European origin constitute a minority of the world's population, although attempts to assign a precise worldwide percentage to categories such as “white” are methodologically dubious because racial classifications differ substantially between countries. The broader point does not require an invented statistic: European populations represent only one relatively small part of humanity, and there is nothing inherently unreasonable about wanting their distinctive identities, cultures and historical continuity to survive.
I am therefore deeply sceptical of an ideological outlook which celebrates ethnic consciousness and demographic preservation in some parts of the world while treating the same concerns as morally suspect in Europe. I believe that this double standard also influences the language through which immigration and nationalism are presented. Mass immigration may be described primarily in terms of diversity, enrichment, economic contribution and individual opportunity, while concerns about social cohesion, cultural displacement, population change or the long-term position of historic populations can be framed as manifestations of prejudice. In such circumstances, supposed neutrality can become little more than the vocabulary of one political philosophy presented as objective common sense.
My objection is not that Wikipedia must adopt my conclusions. A genuinely neutral encyclopedia should not adopt anyone's political programme. My objection is that it should describe competing positions according to the strongest arguments their proponents actually make, rather than defining one side through sympathetic terminology and the other principally through the language of its opponents. If ethnic self-determination is regarded as legitimate in one context, Wikipedia ought at least to explain fairly why some Europeans believe an analogous principle applies to them. If large-scale demographic change is a legitimate subject of political concern elsewhere, it should remain a legitimate subject of discussion in Britain and Europe as well.
This returns to the central problem discussed throughout this essay. A community of editors does not cease to possess political assumptions merely because it labels the outcome of its deliberations “consensus.” Where those assumptions are widely shared among the people controlling an article, they can determine terminology, prominence, acceptable sources and the boundaries of respectable debate without ever having to announce themselves explicitly. The resulting article may comply meticulously with Wikipedia procedure while still presenting the world through a recognisably ideological lens.
That is why I cannot regard Wikipedia's assertion of neutrality as sufficient evidence of actual neutrality. On questions of nationhood, ethnicity, immigration and demographic continuity, I believe readers are better served by examining population statistics, historical evidence, political philosophy and competing arguments directly. A subject becomes no less worthy of rational examination simply because prevailing political fashion considers one possible conclusion uncomfortable.
I should be allowed to advocate for the rights, interests, and survival of my people, but the people who gatekeep Wikipedia consider this to be a fundamental social wrong.
None of this proves that every controversial Wikipedia article is left-wing propaganda, nor would I claim that every editor acts dishonestly. Wikipedia's own research record suggests that vigorous ideological disagreement can actually improve it. That is part of my argument rather than a concession against it.
The problem arises when an institution claiming neutrality becomes sufficiently ideologically homogeneous that its preferred interpretations are mistaken for neutrality itself.
For that reason, I regard Wikipedia as useful for basic reference but untrustworthy as an authority on politically or historically contentious questions. I would rather consult the underlying scholarship, competing historians and primary evidence myself than accept the product of an anonymous editorial consensus whose ideological assumptions I neither share nor regard as neutral.
Wikipedia tells its readers that its purpose is to inform rather than influence. My objection is that, on many contentious subjects, I believe the distinction has become considerably less clear than Wikipedia would like its readers to think.
My Contributions
[edit]New Articles
[edit]- Eden - Article on Eden, a village in Northern Ireland (Stub at present)
- Boneybefore - Article on Boneybefore, a village in Northern Ireland (Stub at present)
- Andrew Jackson Centre - Article on the "ancestral home" of Andrew Jackson, 7th President of the United States (Stub at present)
- The Belfast Entries - Article on the "Entries" in Belfast city centre, such as "Pottinger's Entry"
Major Contributions
[edit]- Carrickfergus Waterfront - (Changed the name of the article. Extensive re-working.)
- Greenisland - (Researched and added a History section, which was previously missing.)
- Belfast quarters - (Completely re-did article.)