Jump to content

Talk:Woolton Hall

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 1 year ago by A.D.Hope in topic Post-fire hall is a shell, not destroyed.

Nicholas Ashton - something very wrong

[edit]

The article can't be right. We are saying that Nicholas Ashton bought the place in 1722 and died 111 years later in 1833. I'm not sure where the info comes from because it is not cited. - Sitush (talk) 17:36, 23 August 2019 (UTC)Reply

We're also saying he was High Sheriff at the time of purchase, which seems likely to be an anachronism because the only mention at High Sheriff of Lancashire (also seemingly unsourced) says 1770. - Sitush (talk) 17:40, 23 August 2019 (UTC)Reply

@Sitush: Thanks for spotting these errors, I have made amendments and added a source. It appears that the house was actually bought by Ashton in 1772 not 1722 and Ashton was only High Sheriff in 1770. Tsange (Talk) 13:54, 25 August 2019 (UTC)Reply

Post-fire hall is a shell, not destroyed.

[edit]

IP user 86.141.68.92 has repeatedly edited the article with a claim that the hall has been totally destroyed post-fire. This BBC article from 30 August shows that the hall is currently a shell, with its outer walls appearing to be substantially intact. It is therefore inaccurate to describe the current state of the hall as 'completely' or 'totally detroyed'. A.D.Hope (talk) 18:35, 31 August 2025 (UTC)Reply

A bare shell with no remnant of the interior can, I think, be described fairly as "totally destroyed". 86.141.68.92 (talk) 18:48, 31 August 2025 (UTC)Reply
The exterior of the house survives, so far as we know, so it has not been 'totally destroyed'. The interior has probably been destroyed, however as far as I am aware we have no information on its exact state at present. A.D.Hope (talk) 19:08, 31 August 2025 (UTC)Reply
Totally destroys implies burnt to the ground, only some rubble remaining. Definitely seems like an overstatement from images. Most importantly, sources like The Independent calls it "gutted". However, the BBC has a caption calling it "totally destroyed", though it later states "The roof of Woolton Hall was completely destroyed, and only the outer walls remain" which seems contradictory with "totally". So best in my opinion (from the sources) to refer to it as gutted, severely damaged, or mention that the roof and interior were completely destroyed, leaving only the walls. Cerebral726 (talk) 15:05, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
There are talks that it could be "used again" , so definitely not "completely" or "totally" destroyed. Cerebral726 (talk) 15:08, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
Hi Cerebral726. Can I just check if your comments are a response to my third opinion request, or simply a coincidence in timing? A.D.Hope (talk) 15:11, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
I happened to have submitted a 3O recently, saw this request, and commented after finding it interesting. I didn't really follow the 3O procedure, just giving my input. Sorry if that causes an issue! Cerebral726 (talk) 15:20, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
I do appreciate the input, however third opinions can only be given for disputes between two parties and so your comments may actually cause an issue. I expect you could make your comments the third opinion if you wished, though? A.D.Hope (talk) 15:35, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
Don't think it matters. A "formal" 3O holds no more bearing than someone random stopping in and commenting, as we are all just editors gaining consensus. I agree with your argument, feel free to do with that as you will. Cerebral726 (talk) 15:37, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
Thank you for your input. A.D.Hope (talk) 15:41, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply


Response to third opinion request:
The BBC article uses the word "gutted", which is an apt description for a fire which burns out the interior of a building while leaving interior and exterior walls standing as is the case here. So does the WP:HEADLINE of this article in the Independent. The word "shell" might imply that only the exterior walls remain standing, but would be an accurate enough description. In the article I might write something like, According to reports by the BBC and the Independent, the fire "gutted" the building, leaving only interior and exterior walls standing. This way we attribute the subjective term to sources, while describing the damage in Wikivoice. Xan747 (talk) 16:28, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
Addendum: agree that totally destroyed is an overstatement. But it is effectively destroyed. I think that once the article establishes that most of the walls remained standing, simply calling it "destroyed" rather than the more slang term "gutted" is appropriate. Xan747 (talk) 16:39, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
Thank you for the third opinion, I appreciate it. In reponse to your comments and those by @Cerebral726 I've re-worded the passage relating to the fire in the final paragraph of the 'history' subsection following your suggested wording, and added the BBC 'How a battle to save a piece of history was lost' article as a source. I've also reverted to 'gutted' in the lead, this being supported in the body.
My inclination isn't to use 'destroyed' elsewhere in the article, as the walls of the house have not been destroyed. The building's significance derives in part from its external architecture, and this remains substantially intact. As far as I'm aware 'gutted' in this sense is not a slang term. A.D.Hope (talk) 16:49, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
You're welcome. You're right, gutted isn't really slang, but I was grasping for a better word. Less encyclopedic perhaps. In any case I think your edits are fine. If other editors disagree with me, feel free to give us a ping, or for any other reason. Cheers. Xan747 (talk) 17:35, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
Thanks, much appreciated! A.D.Hope (talk) 17:37, 5 September 2025 (UTC)Reply