Talk:Weaponization of antisemitism
Add topic| This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Weaponization of antisemitism article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the subject of the article. |
Article policies
|
| Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL |
| Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16Auto-archiving period: 2 months |
You are an administrator, so you may disregard the message below You are seeing this because of the limitations of {{If extended confirmed}} and {{If admin}}
You can hide this message box by adding the following to a new line of your common.css page: .ECR-edit-request-warning {
display: none;
}
Stop: You may only use this page to create an edit request This article is related to the Arab–Israeli conflict, which is subject to the extended-confirmed restriction. You are not an extended-confirmed user, so you must not edit or discuss this topic anywhere on Wikipedia except to make an edit request. (Additional details are in the message box just below this one.) |
Warning: active arbitration remedies The contentious topics procedure applies to this article. This article relates to the Arab–Israeli conflict.The following restrictions apply to everyone editing this article:
Editors who repeatedly or seriously fail to adhere to the purpose of Wikipedia, any expected standards of behaviour, or any normal editorial process may be blocked or restricted by an administrator. |
| This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to multiple WikiProjects. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is requested that an image or photograph of Weaponization of antisemitism be included in this article to improve its quality. Please replace this template with a more specific media request template where possible. Wikipedians in Israel may be able to help! The Free Image Search Tool or Openverse Creative Commons Search may be able to locate suitable images on Flickr and other websites. |
This article has been mentioned by multiple media organizations:
|
Robert Fine
[edit]In case I forget, I'm making a note of the fact that there's a whole article on weaponisation by antisemitism scholar Robert Fine here. We quote Brian Klug from the same collection, but it's the actual topic of Fine's article: this is the kind of best source we ought to be using to identify examples from. BobFromBrockley (talk) 15:36, 15 April 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks. I'll add to the pile this article quoting from a relevant Soviet manifesto. ꧁Zanahary꧂ 15:49, 15 April 2026 (UTC)
- I'm not sure I see the relevance of Shrayer's article here. Might be good in articles that focus on anti-Zionism, but how would we use it here? BobFromBrockley (talk) 14:27, 16 April 2026 (UTC)
…those Zionist wheeler-dealers try to persuade the world's public opinion that, allegedly, in the USSR there exists the "Jewish question.
꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:45, 17 April 2026 (UTC)- Similar sources (keyword "allegations of Soviet anti-semitism"): https://link.springer.com/book/10.1057/9781137008305; https://www.nytimes.com/1967/01/22/archives/us-reds-shelve-appeal-on-jews-party-leaders-now-denying.html ꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:50, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- This Herbert Aptheker pamphlet: https://www.marxists.org/subject/jewish/aptheker-anti-semitism.pdf ꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:57, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- Review of Butler: https://muse.jhu.edu/article/721497/summary ꧁Zanahary꧂ 07:01, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- More Soviet stuff (keyword "Jewish question"): https://doi.org/10.1080/13501678308577433; https://www.jta.org/archive/state-dept-says-attack-against-zionism-by-a-soviet-group-is-an-anti-semitic-diatribe; https://encyclopedia.yivo.org/article/66; https://www.nytimes.com/1983/04/02/world/8-soviet-jews-seek-to-combat-zionism.html; https://www.jstor.org/stable/23602994?seq=1; https://www.pressreader.com/uk/the-jewish-chronicle/20230317/281960316984154; https://www.jta.org/archive/anti-zionist-manifesto-seen-as-new-soviet-gambit-to-close-doors-to-any-jewish-emigration; https://www.nytimes.com/1967/01/22/archives/us-reds-shelve-appeal-on-jews-party-leaders-now-denying.html;https://www.marxists.org/subject/jewish/cps-soviet-jewry.pdf ('propaganda'; this is in "Soviet Jewry and Human Rights" by Isi Leibler); https://www.jta.org/archive/lord-russell-lashes-out-again-at-soviet-mistreatment-of-jews; https://www.commentary.org/articles/bertrand-russell/soviet-anti-semitism-an-exchange/;And here, there's a relevant piece ("There was a widespread charge")Keyword: "dismissing": https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9781032693859-35/philosophy-anti-semitism-samuel-lebens; http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/1721172.stmKeyword: "dismiss": https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2979/israelstudies.24.2.12; https://ultraviolet.library.nyu.edu/records/xebx5-npq11 (especially good); https://www.jpr.org.uk/sites/default/files/attachments/__tsclient_C_Users_admin_Downloads_ITI%20Ottolenghi%202005.pdf; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13613324.2026.2652251#d1e1223; https://tools.bard.edu/wwwmedia/files/8850342/10/CONFERENCEANTHOLOGY.pdfhttps://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-05-26/ty-article/.premium/simply-a-pr-exercise-irish-president-belittles-claims-of-antisemitism-in-ireland/0000018f-b511-d24f-a5df-fff766580000; https://www.timesofisrael.com/irish-jews-cry-foul-over-antisemitic-presidents-planned-holocaust-memorial-speech/; https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world/article/s1hdirbd1g; https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2025/0117/1491495-president-higgins-holocaust-memorial-day-ireland/ ꧁Zanahary꧂ 17:07, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- Paragraph 30: https://books.openedition.org/ceup/1312 ꧁Zanahary꧂ 13:48, 18 April 2026 (UTC)
- https://www.commentary.org/articles/bret-stephens/jews-have-honor-of-being-hated/; https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/12/29/israel-the-maga-world-s-new-obsession_6748918_4.html; https://forward.com/fast-forward/793261/vance-declines-to-draw-a-line-against-rising-influence-of-antisemitic-figures-in-republican-party/; https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/vance-claims-antisemitism-in-us-a-real-backlash-to-american-foreign-policy/; https://www.jpost.com/american-politics/article-881028 ꧁Zanahary꧂ 13:54, 18 April 2026 (UTC)
- Keyword “labeled”: https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780271086712-005/html ꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:08, 23 April 2026 (UTC)
- Support a lot of this material going in to article, especially where authors are notable and expert. BobFromBrockley (talk) 16:07, 4 May 2026 (UTC)
- @Bobfrombrockley Please feel free to start, if the mass of links isn’t too useless! ꧁Zanahary꧂ 07:46, 21 May 2026 (UTC)
- It's on my list! I saw a new article this week on Fathom by David Seymour that also looks useful. Hope other editors can join in too! BobFromBrockley (talk) 08:59, 21 May 2026 (UTC)
- Hey @Bobfrombrockley, do you still plan on adding material from that Seymour article? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:30, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
- Slipped off my crowded to do list. It definitely has content that would augment this article BobFromBrockley (talk) 21:20, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
- Hey @Bobfrombrockley, do you still plan on adding material from that Seymour article? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:30, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
- It's on my list! I saw a new article this week on Fathom by David Seymour that also looks useful. Hope other editors can join in too! BobFromBrockley (talk) 08:59, 21 May 2026 (UTC)
- @Bobfrombrockley Please feel free to start, if the mass of links isn’t too useless! ꧁Zanahary꧂ 07:46, 21 May 2026 (UTC)
- Support a lot of this material going in to article, especially where authors are notable and expert. BobFromBrockley (talk) 16:07, 4 May 2026 (UTC)
- Keyword “labeled”: https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780271086712-005/html ꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:08, 23 April 2026 (UTC)
- More Soviet stuff (keyword "Jewish question"): https://doi.org/10.1080/13501678308577433; https://www.jta.org/archive/state-dept-says-attack-against-zionism-by-a-soviet-group-is-an-anti-semitic-diatribe; https://encyclopedia.yivo.org/article/66; https://www.nytimes.com/1983/04/02/world/8-soviet-jews-seek-to-combat-zionism.html; https://www.jstor.org/stable/23602994?seq=1; https://www.pressreader.com/uk/the-jewish-chronicle/20230317/281960316984154; https://www.jta.org/archive/anti-zionist-manifesto-seen-as-new-soviet-gambit-to-close-doors-to-any-jewish-emigration; https://www.nytimes.com/1967/01/22/archives/us-reds-shelve-appeal-on-jews-party-leaders-now-denying.html;https://www.marxists.org/subject/jewish/cps-soviet-jewry.pdf ('propaganda'; this is in "Soviet Jewry and Human Rights" by Isi Leibler); https://www.jta.org/archive/lord-russell-lashes-out-again-at-soviet-mistreatment-of-jews; https://www.commentary.org/articles/bertrand-russell/soviet-anti-semitism-an-exchange/;And here, there's a relevant piece ("There was a widespread charge")Keyword: "dismissing": https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9781032693859-35/philosophy-anti-semitism-samuel-lebens; http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/1721172.stmKeyword: "dismiss": https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2979/israelstudies.24.2.12; https://ultraviolet.library.nyu.edu/records/xebx5-npq11 (especially good); https://www.jpr.org.uk/sites/default/files/attachments/__tsclient_C_Users_admin_Downloads_ITI%20Ottolenghi%202005.pdf; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13613324.2026.2652251#d1e1223; https://tools.bard.edu/wwwmedia/files/8850342/10/CONFERENCEANTHOLOGY.pdfhttps://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-05-26/ty-article/.premium/simply-a-pr-exercise-irish-president-belittles-claims-of-antisemitism-in-ireland/0000018f-b511-d24f-a5df-fff766580000; https://www.timesofisrael.com/irish-jews-cry-foul-over-antisemitic-presidents-planned-holocaust-memorial-speech/; https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world/article/s1hdirbd1g; https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2025/0117/1491495-president-higgins-holocaust-memorial-day-ireland/ ꧁Zanahary꧂ 17:07, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- Review of Butler: https://muse.jhu.edu/article/721497/summary ꧁Zanahary꧂ 07:01, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- This Herbert Aptheker pamphlet: https://www.marxists.org/subject/jewish/aptheker-anti-semitism.pdf ꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:57, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- Similar sources (keyword "allegations of Soviet anti-semitism"): https://link.springer.com/book/10.1057/9781137008305; https://www.nytimes.com/1967/01/22/archives/us-reds-shelve-appeal-on-jews-party-leaders-now-denying.html ꧁Zanahary꧂ 06:50, 17 April 2026 (UTC)
- I'm not sure I see the relevance of Shrayer's article here. Might be good in articles that focus on anti-Zionism, but how would we use it here? BobFromBrockley (talk) 14:27, 16 April 2026 (UTC)
This talk page is periodically archived so i suggest you to use one of the following templates:
- Template:Todo
- Template:Refideas
- Template:Refideas-nonotice
Visite fortuitement prolongée (talk) 13:36, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Self-hating Jews in lead
[edit]The following lead text: Some Jews critical of Israel have been labeled "self-hating Jews".
blurbs a tiny section of the article—two sentences. These two sentences cite two sources, plus a third that just quotes one of the other two. None of these sources treats the self-hating Jew matter in any depth; they’re just mentions. There is also a single mention of the concept elsewhere, citing a Brian Klug article that, again, makes a single passing mention of the concept (and doesn’t take a stance on whether this is generally a facet of weaponization, or an earnest designation). This is not due for the lead. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 19:01, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- There should be more sources concerning the concept of “self-hating Jew” (and closely related terms, such as Trump’s characterization of Kamala Harris’ husband as a “crappy Jew”). Such terms are based on the notion that Jews should be a monolith, with all Jews having the same opinion that Israel deserves Jews’ unconditional support no matter what it does. That notion that Jews who disagree are not legitimate Jews is itself anti-semitic. Jews are a diverse group of people, not a monolith. It’s due for a mention in the lead. NightHeron (talk) 19:21, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- If, as you say, it’s a significant aspect of this topic as covered in reliable sources, then those sources should be added to the article. Presently, the sources are very few, and the lead is meant to summarize the body. A two-sentence section of the article does not merit a lead summary. If you think the coverage of this concept is too small in the article, then you should back it up by bringing those sources and adding them to the article’s body. That’s not a problem you can solve by just magnifying the concept in the lead while leaving the body thin. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 19:25, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- There are several usable sources in Self-hating Jew (see [5, 8, 20, 21, 22, 43, 44, 46, 48] in the references). NightHeron (talk) 22:31, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- Great, please use them to duly improve the article, and maybe the body’s material on this matter will be brought to such prominence that a lead summary of it won’t violate WP:LEADREL. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 00:27, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- Many of those look like bad sources. My Jewish Learning and HuffPost Contributors are discouraged here, and the columnist writing about Atzmon (a Holocaust denier who is proud to be self-hating) seems to be quoted out of context. And I don’t think it would be due to say that like Marqusee’s dad was weaponising antisemitism against his son. BobFromBrockley (talk) 07:29, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- Which of the nine references I listed are you evaluating as “bad sources.” When I get time to draft a possible addition to the main body about the term “self-hating Jew,” I’ll stear clear of those sources. I should have also mentioned reference [4] in the Self-hating Jew article. It contains a half-dozen quotes that make it clear that the charge of “anti-semitism” and the charge of “self-hating Jew” against critics of Israel — the first generally used against non-Jewish critics and the second against Jewish critics — are two sides of the same coin, and so a brief section about “self-hating Jew” (with a reference to the more detailed article on the subject) and a mention in the lead are due for this article. NightHeron (talk) 12:41, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- NightHeron, if you find sources that convince you that
the charge of “anti-semitism” and the charge of “self-hating Jew” against critics of Israel … are two sides of the same coin
, that is still not a policy-based case to include it in the lead. The lead is supposed to quite proportionally represent the aspects and concepts in the body, which is supposed to quite proportionally represent the aspects and concepts in the literature. If the SHJ concept is very prominent in the literature, and this article’s body in turn treats the SHJ concept with such prominence that it would be proportionate to include the concept among the lead’s six sentences, then that’s a case for the concept’s inclusion in the lead. At this moment, the SHJ concept still represents a very small amount of article text, much less than material on Communism in Europe, the UK Labour Party, the Livingstone Formulation, and even David Duke, none of which are blurbed in the lead. The persistence of this proportion after your planned additions, and the supposed gap between the article’s current emphasis on the concept and the literature’s emphasis on the concept, are the crux here—not whether you believe that the SHJ concept is antisemitic, or treats Jews as a monolith, or is otherwise very important for reasons that don’t have to do with its prominence among reliable sources’ treatments of the article topic. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 13:46, 31 October 2026 (UTC)- The SHJ concept is far more fundamental to this topic than
Communism in Europe, the UK Labour Party, the Livingstone Formulation, and even David Duke
. Those are just examples, whereas SHJ is a whole category. Onceinawhile (talk) 13:57, 31 October 2026 (UTC)- Okay then, if that’s the case, then you (or someone) should update the article so that this critical concept is not just a lead mention and a few body sentences citing passing mentions of the concept. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:21, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- The SHJ concept is far more fundamental to this topic than
- I’ve mentioned 4 in my comment. I’ll look at the other 5 and the new one later and give you my thoughts. In general, we’d want good sources that also discuss SHJ specifically in the context of weaponisation BobFromBrockley (talk) 12:16, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- NightHeron, maybe in the meantime you can workshop your proposed additions? I’d open a separate Talk section to avoid clutter. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 08:23, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I had been thinking of expanding the section “Against Jewish critics” to include more sources that explain how the charge of “self-hating Jew” is a form of weaponization similar to the charge of “antisemite” used against non-Jewish critics of Israel. In addition, a reader who wanted more details (such as a history of the term) would see a prominent “see also” linking to the article Self-hating Jew. I thought the addition of the “see also” link would be uncontroversial. But when I had to self-revert and found no consensus on the talk-page to put it back, I realized that other edits I might make to the section would likely also be unsupported on the talk-page, in which case they would be a waste of everyone’s time, including mine. NightHeron (talk) 09:58, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- NightHeron, maybe in the meantime you can workshop your proposed additions? I’d open a separate Talk section to avoid clutter. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 08:23, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- NightHeron, if you find sources that convince you that
- Which of the nine references I listed are you evaluating as “bad sources.” When I get time to draft a possible addition to the main body about the term “self-hating Jew,” I’ll stear clear of those sources. I should have also mentioned reference [4] in the Self-hating Jew article. It contains a half-dozen quotes that make it clear that the charge of “anti-semitism” and the charge of “self-hating Jew” against critics of Israel — the first generally used against non-Jewish critics and the second against Jewish critics — are two sides of the same coin, and so a brief section about “self-hating Jew” (with a reference to the more detailed article on the subject) and a mention in the lead are due for this article. NightHeron (talk) 12:41, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- There are several usable sources in Self-hating Jew (see [5, 8, 20, 21, 22, 43, 44, 46, 48] in the references). NightHeron (talk) 22:31, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- If, as you say, it’s a significant aspect of this topic as covered in reliable sources, then those sources should be added to the article. Presently, the sources are very few, and the lead is meant to summarize the body. A two-sentence section of the article does not merit a lead summary. If you think the coverage of this concept is too small in the article, then you should back it up by bringing those sources and adding them to the article’s body. That’s not a problem you can solve by just magnifying the concept in the lead while leaving the body thin. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 19:25, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- This is very clearly a notable and significant component of the overall topic, and thus absolutely due weight for the lead. I agree the body should be built out further on this topic. Examples like Derek Penslar, described in the article as a Jewish person accused of antisemitism, could be built into it. Many anti-Zionist Jews could be added as further examples.
- Instead of damaging the lead, while we wait for it to be developed, we could create a sub-section on the topic with an “Expand section” template tag. Onceinawhile (talk) 13:54, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- I see that the proposer here was the same person who deleted a bunch of sources on this topic out of the lead just over a year ago. Onceinawhile (talk) 14:04, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
- @Onceinawhile, are you willing to expand the section? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 11:20, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- @Mangroves, I'd like to resolve the undue weight tag you added to the lede about this. Could we replace it with an 'expand section' tag in the "Against Jewish critics/Accusations of "self-hatred" section?
- If not, what specifically would you like to see done to resolve this tag? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:55, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- The tag can be removed when there is consensus about whether the concept is due in the lead. You can add an “expand section” tag, but that wouldn’t suddenly make the concept proportional and resolve my and BfB’s objection; that would only happen when the new, larger section is written and agreed to justify the clause in the lead. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 21:16, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- As you're the one disputing that the content is due, I'm asking you what specifically you would want to see to demonstrate the content is due. Tags exist to identify problems so they can be solved. Please tell me specifically how I can solve the problem. How big would the section have to become to be proportional in your view? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 21:34, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I have no word count quota; if the section is expanded substantively and proportionally to the sources' treatment of the concept in relation to the article topic such that the mention no longer violates WP:LEADREL, then I will no longer object to its presence in the lead. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:13, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- But you're still not giving a specific target that can be met. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 22:52, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don't believe editors staking positions on lead relevance are required to offer unconditional relevance-meeting word-counts. The text blurbs a tiny section of the article, and for that reason I object to it. If your position is that the section ought to be expanded, then there's no reason for you not to add an expansion tag or start expanding it. If the result generates consensus that the lead mention is appropriate, then the lead tag will no longer be truthful or necessary. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:57, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- By the way, if no consensus is formed, I'm happy to do an RfC, though I've never made one that wasn't about a move. I just don't want to do that before the editors in favor of section expansion have had a chance to try adding to the article and resolving the LEADREL objections. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:05, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Actually reading WP:LEADREL, it states that "According to the policy on due weight, emphasis given to material should reflect its relative importance to the subject, according to published reliable sources."
- I'll add an 'expansion needed' tag to the section and add a bunch of RS. Would that resolve the need for the due weight tag in the lead for you? Note how many results there are for searching Google Scholar for "self-hating" and "Israel": IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 23:11, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Adding the expansion tag would not change my position, because I don't agree that the concept is significant enough per reliable sources to belong in the lead. If you expand the section such that consensus emerges that the concept is significant enough for the lead, then of course that would change my position, because then there would be consensus, and the tag would be useless and wrong. That Scholar string is super expansive. A case for the concept's relative significance within the article topic can be made with cited encyclopedic prose in the context of the article. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:15, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Let us please keep this very simple and focused. You say "I don't agree that the concept is significant enough per reliable sources to belong in the lead." I've added a large number of sources to support this content's dueness, does that now satisfy younit is due for inclusion? If not, how many sources would you like to see to be satisfied this content is due? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 00:27, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’ll take a look this week; thanks for searching. There’s no chance that I’ll support the lead text with the tiny section in place. If the section is expanded a lot, duly, and well, and I’m convinced by its bibliography that it’s a major enough aspect of the article topic to warrant discussion in the lead, then I will support the lead text as due. I cannot give you numerical targets on word count or source count; that’s not how I make judgments about encyclopedic weight. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:26, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Then what do you make such judgements on? I do not feel that you are being reasonable - please be aware of WP:OWN and WP:SATISFY. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:33, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- I make judgments about dueness based on the treatment of the topic in reliable sources and the supposed symmetry between the lead and the body. I’m not aware of any guidance on Wikipedia that offers numerical benchmarks on word count or source count to determine questions of due weight.
- I’m glad you linked WP:SATISFY, because I kept typing and erasing something to that effect as I wrote my past few responses—I feel I’ve made my position clear repeatedly, always in response to your inquiries, and I don’t think further repetitions, wherein you ask me to commit to a simple quota at which I will agree with you, will be constructive.
- My final, one-sentence summary until I change my position: I don’t currently think the concept is important enough, and I currently think the section is too small for a lead mention. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:41, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Then what do you make such judgements on? I do not feel that you are being reasonable - please be aware of WP:OWN and WP:SATISFY. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:33, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’ll take a look this week; thanks for searching. There’s no chance that I’ll support the lead text with the tiny section in place. If the section is expanded a lot, duly, and well, and I’m convinced by its bibliography that it’s a major enough aspect of the article topic to warrant discussion in the lead, then I will support the lead text as due. I cannot give you numerical targets on word count or source count; that’s not how I make judgments about encyclopedic weight. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:26, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Let us please keep this very simple and focused. You say "I don't agree that the concept is significant enough per reliable sources to belong in the lead." I've added a large number of sources to support this content's dueness, does that now satisfy younit is due for inclusion? If not, how many sources would you like to see to be satisfied this content is due? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 00:27, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Adding the expansion tag would not change my position, because I don't agree that the concept is significant enough per reliable sources to belong in the lead. If you expand the section such that consensus emerges that the concept is significant enough for the lead, then of course that would change my position, because then there would be consensus, and the tag would be useless and wrong. That Scholar string is super expansive. A case for the concept's relative significance within the article topic can be made with cited encyclopedic prose in the context of the article. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:15, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- By the way, if no consensus is formed, I'm happy to do an RfC, though I've never made one that wasn't about a move. I just don't want to do that before the editors in favor of section expansion have had a chance to try adding to the article and resolving the LEADREL objections. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:05, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don't believe editors staking positions on lead relevance are required to offer unconditional relevance-meeting word-counts. The text blurbs a tiny section of the article, and for that reason I object to it. If your position is that the section ought to be expanded, then there's no reason for you not to add an expansion tag or start expanding it. If the result generates consensus that the lead mention is appropriate, then the lead tag will no longer be truthful or necessary. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:57, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- But you're still not giving a specific target that can be met. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 22:52, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I have no word count quota; if the section is expanded substantively and proportionally to the sources' treatment of the concept in relation to the article topic such that the mention no longer violates WP:LEADREL, then I will no longer object to its presence in the lead. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:13, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- As you're the one disputing that the content is due, I'm asking you what specifically you would want to see to demonstrate the content is due. Tags exist to identify problems so they can be solved. Please tell me specifically how I can solve the problem. How big would the section have to become to be proportional in your view? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 21:34, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- The tag can be removed when there is consensus about whether the concept is due in the lead. You can add an “expand section” tag, but that wouldn’t suddenly make the concept proportional and resolve my and BfB’s objection; that would only happen when the new, larger section is written and agreed to justify the clause in the lead. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 21:16, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Pinging recent talk page contributors to get furthwr input on whether or not it is due to mention in the lede that Jewish critics of Israel being called self-hating Jews. @NightHeron, @NadVolum, @Bobfrombrockley, @Onceinawhile, @Bluethricecreamman, @DanielRigal
- Note the number of sources this information is currently cited to:
Sources demonstrating notability of "self-hating Jew" in lede |
|---|
|
- -IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:43, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- youve already pinged us below? And it might be better to just post on a noticeboard wrt the dispute. Alternatively start an RFC/workshop an RFC? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:57, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- I appreciate the ping. Listing sources we don’t yet cite cannot convince us that it is due IN THE LEAD. The sources, if they’re good, can convince us that the content in the body should be expanded and THEN it would naturally and uncontroversially mean it was due in the lead. So I’ll look at these sources to identify whether I think they’re would belong in an augmented body, not if they should be cited in the lead. BobFromBrockley (talk) 11:31, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Normally to identify if topic x (in this case [the accusation of] self-hating Jews - SHJ) is due for discussion in an article, we’d look at the best sources on the article topic y (in this case weaponisation of antisemitism - WoA) and see whether they give topic x attention. The peculiar nature of this article is that there isn’t really a literature in topic y, WoA, but it’s already been largely pulled together from brief mentions in quite a disparate literature. This is why weak sourcing has been a persistent concern raised on the talk page. So, given the article exists, to assess whether SHJ merits more attention what is the literature we should be reviewing? I would say it need to be primarily well regarded scholarship on antisemitism and the question in reviewing would be “while discussing WoA do the authors give attention to SHJ?”
- On that basis, I would discard Chomsky, Friedman, Goldstein, Finlay, Putra et al, Reitter, and Momberg, and probably Zalloua
- Chomsky’s quote is an incoherent throwaway comment and he is writing as an activist not a scholar. (He’s a linguist.) Friedman is not an expert on this topic and does not mention WoA when discussing SHJ. Goldstein (an independent scholar who runs (or perhaps is) a slightly fringey self-declared institute) is writing polemical in the journal he edits about an entirely different topic and just has one paragraph on antisemitism. Finlay seems to be a v good source on SHJ but doesn’t mention WoA once. Putra et al are writing about a different topic and have no expertise on this topic; the brief mention of WoA/SHJ could be used to follow up the three texts they cite (Freund, Patterson, Bogdanor) but is no use itself. Reitter seems like a v good source on SHJ but I can’t see discussion of WoA. I can’t access Momberg (a Research Fellow on Systematic Theology And Ecclesiology) but the title suggests the chapter isn’t about this topic and the extract says WoA and SHJ are two strategies of Zionism not that SHJ is an element of WoA. Zalloua is writing about a different topic and mentions SHJ in passing only.
- Segal on the other hand has a lot to say about WoA but only mentions SHJ once briefly, so doesn’t help either. Cheyette is the sort of scholar we should be citing, but given the mention of SHJ is very in passing it doesn’t help make the case for dueness.
- Borderline: Dy-Liacco (a theologian who has no other publications about antisemitism) does say that SHJ is a central element of WoA so might be useful. But given it’s published in a pretty obscure location it’s not very strong for establishing dueness. Chaim Rochester (a psychoanalyst in private practice) also does say that SHJ is a central element of WoA, but he was a graduate student when he wrote this and he has no other publications related to antisemitism. “Grabelsky is a doctoral candidate in philosophy at CUNY Graduate Center. She works primarily in social and political philosophy, with a focus on related issues in social epistemology and philosophy of language. Additionally, she has interests in philosophy of art (bad movies in particular).” She has one paragraph about WoA in an article about SHJ. Mann and Yona is a v good source on WoA which ought to be in our article; they only spend a brief moment on SHJ though so don’t do much for us.
- I think Zaher and Mintchev do say what you want our article to say, so it seems we could cite them and attribute their opinion in the body. I’d note that neither of them have published any other text on a relevant topic; their main academic expertise is unrelated to this so I’m sure they make the case for dueness.
- That leaves Abraham, Lerman and Butler. I don’t have access to them so can’t comment. I note use of Lerman has been criticised in the archives of this talk page as an advocacy/opinion text rather than scholarship.
- Judaken is an excellent source. I lent my paper copy to someone and can’t access the text online. What does he say about WoA/SHJ?
- I’m presuming this list is the result of a pretty thorough sweep, so it has left me more convinced it’s not going to be due in the lead as the results are very weak. BobFromBrockley (talk) 13:49, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks for this review! I’ll take a look and offer my own thoughts when I can. Doesn’t Friedman mention WoA when she says the concept is likely used to discredit Jewish critics of Israel? Or do you think that her ascription of intent to discredit doesn’t necessarily imply dishonesty/weaponization? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 16:01, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- And thanks for raising the issue of non-expert and advocate sources; they may be due in the body if they’re significant or covered secondarily, but they can’t be used for a wikivoice lead mention. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 16:02, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don't agree with this narrow view that the topic of this article is solely about bad faith or dishonest accusations. I know that is how the lede currently defines the topic but I don't believe the RS support this definition. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 02:45, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- If you want to radically alter the article’s scope, you should start a separate discussion about that; it shouldn’t be an auxiliary topic to this narrow discussion. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 07:57, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- You can't just decide to discard reliable sources. Experts who specialize in antisemitism are definitely among the best sources here but there are other fields of expertise which are equally relevant as well. Experts on Israel, Zionism, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, etc. for instance. There's no reason an academic who "works primarily in social and political philosophy, with a focus on related issues in social epistemology and philosophy of language" (like Grabelsky) wouldn't be a best source for this topic.
- It is simply unreasonable to suggest we "discard" a source like Finlay's Pathologizing dissent: Identity politics, Zionism and the self-hating Jew which clearly couldn't be more relevant to this topic. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 02:42, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- I can't say I agree. Finlay's work would absolutely be germane to Self-hating Jew, but the abstract doesn't include the word "antisemitism", and doesn't seem to be about that at all, any more than the weaponization of information is relevant because Masada2000 weaponizes information. They key here is that we only summarize what reliable sources say about the topic. Finlay's work holds wisdom, but it's not specifically about this topic, so it would be misleading to use it here. EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:10, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- I havent had a chance to read either but im ok with inclusion of a source if its shown to be due for inclusion wrt topic. So for example, an article page talking about climate change denial could include sources about how climate change is accepted even without talking about denial.
- i suppose the question then is if extended discussion of the concept of self hating jew is due for inclusion and if its especially due in the lede if sourcing isnt talking about weaponization of antisemitism ? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 04:00, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- I'm sorry but did you read the article or just the abstract? The article uses the word "anti-Semitism" 40 times and very clearly relates the topic of this article. You might consider retracting or striking your comment if you haven't even read the article. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 04:21, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Did you read the article or just count the words? It discusses antisemitism in European/western culture, and the question of whether this was internalised by Jews. It does not discuss the weaponisation of antisemitism, which of course is the topic of this article. BobFromBrockley (talk) 05:38, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- To answer your question, I did not have access to the fulltext, and no quotes were presented, so I had to go with what I had in-hand. If there are particularly salient passages, quotes would be appreciated. EducatedRedneck (talk) 14:58, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Not to mention that the very concept of a self-hating Jew implies an internalized antisemitism. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 04:55, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes of course but not the weaponisation of it BobFromBrockley (talk) 05:39, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Accusing all Jewish critics of Israel of having internalized antisemitism is of course a weaponization of antisemitism. NightHeron (talk) 10:15, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Sources discussing or deploying the charge of Jewish self-hatred without reference to or suggestion of weaponization, and which are not discussed in reliable receptive literature as cases of weaponized accusations, cannot just be judged by editors to be examples of weaponized charges because of the editor’s personal assessment of the concept. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 11:47, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Earlier in this thread several sources were given (for example, in the hatted list of sources) that link SHJ directly with weaponization and that emphasize the role that SHJ plays in carrying over the weaponization of antisemitism to Jewish critics of Israel. I don’t think there are RS that describe the SHJ accusation as a MEDRS-compliant diagnosis of a psychiatric malady, “self-hating disorder,” shared by the many millions of Jews who agree with the international consensus that the Israeli government under Netanyahu is committing genocide. NightHeron (talk) 14:55, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- An argument about the state of sources backed up by examples of those sources (or, if we’re lucky, tertiary literature that describes the state of the sources for us) is relevant; an argument about reality (specifically, the reality of whether the SHJ concept is necessarily weaponized and dishonest) in a discussion about due weight is not relevant. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:05, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Earlier in this thread several sources were given (for example, in the hatted list of sources) that link SHJ directly with weaponization and that emphasize the role that SHJ plays in carrying over the weaponization of antisemitism to Jewish critics of Israel. I don’t think there are RS that describe the SHJ accusation as a MEDRS-compliant diagnosis of a psychiatric malady, “self-hating disorder,” shared by the many millions of Jews who agree with the international consensus that the Israeli government under Netanyahu is committing genocide. NightHeron (talk) 14:55, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Sources discussing or deploying the charge of Jewish self-hatred without reference to or suggestion of weaponization, and which are not discussed in reliable receptive literature as cases of weaponized accusations, cannot just be judged by editors to be examples of weaponized charges because of the editor’s personal assessment of the concept. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 11:47, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Accusing all Jewish critics of Israel of having internalized antisemitism is of course a weaponization of antisemitism. NightHeron (talk) 10:15, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes of course but not the weaponisation of it BobFromBrockley (talk) 05:39, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- You can't just decide to discard reliable sources. I think you can and indeed sometimes should. A chemist might be a reliable source for facts in an article about physics but is not going to be a best source. In assessing due weight, we don’t see how much attention something gets in all reliable sources but in the relevant ones. In a physics article, we wouldn’t count mentions in chemistry sources as establishing weight. And this is especially true when you’re dealing with a contentious topic, so being scrupulous with sources is even more important. BobFromBrockley (talk) 05:45, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- I can't say I agree. Finlay's work would absolutely be germane to Self-hating Jew, but the abstract doesn't include the word "antisemitism", and doesn't seem to be about that at all, any more than the weaponization of information is relevant because Masada2000 weaponizes information. They key here is that we only summarize what reliable sources say about the topic. Finlay's work holds wisdom, but it's not specifically about this topic, so it would be misleading to use it here. EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:10, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Self-correction. Finlay does link SHJ to WoA in a different passage - see below - so I might have discarded him too hastily. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks for this review! I’ll take a look and offer my own thoughts when I can. Doesn’t Friedman mention WoA when she says the concept is likely used to discredit Jewish critics of Israel? Or do you think that her ascription of intent to discredit doesn’t necessarily imply dishonesty/weaponization? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 16:01, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
NightHeron re this:
I explained already in the talk above why Friedman doesn’t belong here, which nobody has contradicted. This is newly added content so the onus is on editors wanting to add the material to get consensus, so please self-revert until you have that. BobFromBrockley (talk) 00:31, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Your assertion that we should simply "discard" a large number of RS ("Chomsky, Friedman, Goldstein, Finlay, Putra et al, Reitter, and Momberg, and probably Zalloua") is simply not reasonable.
- Your assertion that Friedman "does not mention WoA [weaponization of antisemitism] when discussing SHJ [self-hating Jews]" is clearly refuted by the quotation which was included in the citation which reads
"In debates over Israeli policies, it is very likely that the concept of Jewish self-hatred is used by Israel supporters to try to discredit Jewish critics of Israel without having to present any political arguments. The charge of Jewish self-hatred suggests that Jewish criticism of Israeli policies is based not on genuine wrongness in the policies but instead on mere bias or prejudice and is therefore to be summarily discredited."
- You have also argued that Finlay "does not discuss the weaponisation of antisemitism" which is a misrepresentation of the source. Does this quotation from Finlay (which had already been presented when you made this claim) not refer to weaponization?:
"In the case of current Middle Eastern politics, the concept of self-hatred is used by right-wing Zionists to label those who criticize policies of the current Israeli government as disloyal and pathological."
- What about in the quotation
"The term self-hate is still commonly used in the Jewish press. [among other examples] to discount Jews who criticize Israeli policies or particular Jewish practices."
- Or when Finlay writes
"I have argued, therefore, that the notion of self-hate can be usefully understood as a rhetorical concept which serves to encourage certain expressions of group identity and to label others as treacherous and pathological. The functions of the concept for the early Zionist movement, and the use of the concept to discount critics of the policies of the current Israeli government have therefore been described."
- Can you explain how "the use of the concept [of self-hating Jews] to discount critics of the policies of the current Israeli government" does not refer to the topic of this article? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:52, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- I did not “assert” that we should “simply” discard a large number of RS; I argued case by case by that we should exclude 7 or 8 sources from a list seeking to establish dueness, asking if the RSs constituted well regarded scholarship on antisemitism and if, while discussing WoA, the authors give attention to SHJ. In the case of Friedman and that of Finlay, the quote refers to weaponised accusations of self-hatred, and not to weaponised accusations of antisemitism. It is only if you a priori regard self-hating as a form of antisemitism (not a claim made by these sources) that you would have a case, but that would be synth. Once again: if you want to establish due weight for SHJ here, you need to show the RSs on WoA prominently discuss it. And, once again, if you want this new content to be in the article, get consensus (and in the meantime please self-revert if you haven’t). BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:32, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- PS per BRD it would have been legitimate for me to revert the whole of the bold edit adding SHJ to the lead. As it’s clear there isn’t consensus here, I might just do that to avoid it getting consensus by default. BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:34, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- What "bold edit adding SHJ to the lead" are you talking about? The self-hating Jews content has been in the lede for well over a year from what I can tell. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:17, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- This edit. 10th November = pretty new. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:19, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- This edit just added citations to existing content. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 23:03, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Sure. And there clearly isn’t consensus for those references. BobFromBrockley (talk) 23:30, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- This edit just added citations to existing content. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 23:03, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- This edit. 10th November = pretty new. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:19, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- What "bold edit adding SHJ to the lead" are you talking about? The self-hating Jews content has been in the lede for well over a year from what I can tell. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:17, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- "the quote refers to weaponised accusations of self-hatred, and not to weaponised accusations of antisemitism." This is another unreasonable argument. You say that "It is only if you a priori regard self-hating as a form of antisemitism (not a claim made by these sources) that you would have a case, but that would be synth." That Jewish self-hatred is a form of antisemitism is obviously true; it's not a "claim". I would suspect the authors don't state this explicitly precisely because of how obvious it is. But even then, Finlay does make this pretty clear when the first lines introducing the topic of his work are: "The notion of self-hatred and anti-Semitism among Jews" - these are not separate concepts, nor are they treated as such by Finlay, and the following passage shows that clearly:
IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:15, 14 November 2026 (UTC)"for Booker self-hatred is a fundamental explanation for why Jews might criticize Israel: ‘While one may argue that these issues are only political, it is important to consider the component of Jewish self-hate that exists in the left-directed anti-Israel slant. . .’ (1991, pp. 96–97). This statement can only be understood if one accepts the prior assumption that, ‘It is a short step from a generalized anti-Zionism to anti-Semitism’ (p. 96). The logic of this argument is as follows: Zionism is a core value of Jewish identity. Criticism of Israel is, therefore, anti-Semitism (Chomsky, 1989, provides further examples of this, describing this equation as an attempt to ‘exploit anti-racist sentiment for political ends’ [p. 316]). Jewish criticism of Israel must then be the result of the internalization of anti-Semitism."
- Finlay is disagreeing with that assertion though right? But I agree on reading again that in that passage he links the accusation of SHJ to the weaponisation of AS, so I’ll take back my inclusion of that source in the list of those that I’d reject immediately, but it remains very week for establishing that SHJ is due in the lead in this article. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:25, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Also, the sources are reliable. Period. You can not discard them for not meeting your own personally designed criteria without basis in Wikipedia policy. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:28, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Surely you know that doesn’t make sense. We don’t include every reliable source. We identify what is due, what sources are best and most relevant. Sources about a different topic that mention an article’s topic in passing - or not at all - tend not to be included in a lead. That’s pretty basic policy. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:30, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Determining the subject-matter relevance and reliability of sources is in accordance with Wikipedia’s sourcing policy. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:36, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- PS per BRD it would have been legitimate for me to revert the whole of the bold edit adding SHJ to the lead. As it’s clear there isn’t consensus here, I might just do that to avoid it getting consensus by default. BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:34, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- I did not “assert” that we should “simply” discard a large number of RS; I argued case by case by that we should exclude 7 or 8 sources from a list seeking to establish dueness, asking if the RSs constituted well regarded scholarship on antisemitism and if, while discussing WoA, the authors give attention to SHJ. In the case of Friedman and that of Finlay, the quote refers to weaponised accusations of self-hatred, and not to weaponised accusations of antisemitism. It is only if you a priori regard self-hating as a form of antisemitism (not a claim made by these sources) that you would have a case, but that would be synth. Once again: if you want to establish due weight for SHJ here, you need to show the RSs on WoA prominently discuss it. And, once again, if you want this new content to be in the article, get consensus (and in the meantime please self-revert if you haven’t). BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:32, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I read Bobfrombrockley’s source review from 13:49, 10 November 2026. It said, in summary, that there are very few detailed sources that cover this topic as a whole. That observation is then contorted to make a claim that this notable subtopic is not as relevant as other components of the article in the lede.
WP:LEAD says The lead should stand on its own as a concise overview of the article's topic. It should identify the topic, establish context, explain why the topic is notable, and summarize the most important points, including any prominent controversies.
The amount of time given to debating this question of “self-hatred” in these talk pages establishes beyond doubt that this element of the topic is highly notable and important. Why else would some editors be so persistent in their support or opposition to it?
Onceinawhile (talk) 23:51, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- To be clear, you’re saying that those who oppose the concept’s lead dueness are not, as we claim, skeptical of the concept’s significance as an aspect of the article topic, but are instead threatened by the concept and its importance, and are lying about our supposed skepticism to try and censor the contested material from its rightful spot in the lead?
Or are you saying that any material subject to long editorial debates by Wikipedia editors about relevance is necessarily due in the lead of the article in question, because the fervor of the debate establishes beyond doubt that this element of the topic is highly notable and important
? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:22, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- No one is saying anyone is “lying” or “feeling threatened” or any of those other things. Please don’t put words into other editors’ mouths. The truth of the matter is that we’re just puzzled about why you and a couple of other editors are so adamantly opposed to this article having a significant section and a mention in the lead about SHJ. Jewish people are an important group in any discussion of Zionism, Israel, and allegations of antisemitism. When defenders of Israel weaponize the charge of antisemitism in order to delegitimize critics of Israel, in the case of Jewish critics of Israel the charge of antisemitism is commonly replaced by the charge of self-hating (which can be thought of as internalized antisemitism). Several of the sources say this.
- This lengthy debate seems far from reaching a consensus. Perhaps it would make sense to use dispute resolution or an appropriate noticeboard to resolve the due vs undue issue. NightHeron (talk) 03:41, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’m equally perplexed by the editors who are determined to include it. The logical thing to do would have been to build the body and then add a sentence to the lead but instead the lead was inflated with material not in the body and a couple of us couldn’t understand why. The determination of the editors who think it goes in the lead is not, by any Wikipedia policy, evidence of dueness. At any rate, we don’t yet have consensus (although my attempt to trim some new references was reverted against policy) so we should keep it out until we do. I’m actually open to it being in the lead if there were decent sources so am sure we can find a way forward if extra eyes joined in. Conflict resolution seems overkill for something so minor. What would be the best noticeboard? BobFromBrockley (talk) 09:41, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- I actually want the section expanded (at least as a precondition to the lead mention), but nobody in favor of inclusion seems to actually want to do that. We’ve arrived at “it’s inherently notable because editors disagree about it” before anyone tried actually expanding the section with evidence of the concept’s alleged extreme and inherent significance. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 10:27, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- I considered drafting a revision of the section, per your suggestion, but then something as routine as a “see also” link to a full article on the subtopic of the section was reverted and led to an endless talk-page discussion with no resolution. At that point I realized that anything I wrote would probably be reverted (including sources) and lead to yet another long, inconclusive talk-page discussion. The result would not be improvement of the article, but rather just a big waste of time.
- What you’re doing is asking editors to spend time writing a better section on SHJ, but without agreeing that the subtopic is notable enough to deserve such a section. So it comes off as a request for us to waste our time. NightHeron (talk) 11:13, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- That talk page section was neither endless nor left unresolved. Consensus was that the hatnote was not additive.
- I’m not asking that the section be expanded, I’m saying that there’s no way I’ll support the lead mention when the article section is so tiny. Multiple editors in support of the lead mention agreed that the section is too small. We have since achieved a refbomb in the lead and an expand section template. And now a novel interpretation that any material subject to a long debate about dueness is necessarily due. In other words: anything but actually expanding the section and making the case for lead relevance based on body composition and treatment in the literature. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 13:09, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- Your claim in your first paragraph that there is a consensus against our sources and link supporting the SHJ subtopic is directly contradicted by your mention of “Multiple editors in support of the lead mention” in your second paragraph. Multiple editors disagreeing with you means that there is no consensus supporting your POV.
- On a talk-page with only a small number of editors participating, two or three are enough to block a consensus. The trouble is that you and one or two others are determined to revert and challenge the sources. You claim that the authors have to be scholars on the subject of weaponization, and throw out an obvious source like Noam Chomsky, described by Wikipedia as “an American intellectual, philosopher, linguist, political activist, and social critic.” What’s required, per WP:RS, is that the sources reliably support the relevance and importance of the subtopic — that SHJ is a common term used against Jewish critics of Israel that is widely regarded as closely related to weaponization of antisemitism. An author can be a reliable source for this without being a professor of Jewish Studies or Poli Sci. NightHeron (talk) 14:14, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- No, I’m saying clear consensus formed against your proposed hatnote. Obviously there’s no consensus on at least three elements of the lead currently being discussed.
You claim that the authors have to be scholars on the subject of weaponization
No I don’t; I argue that a throwaway remark from Noam Chomsky, who is not an expert on Israel or antisemitism, cannot be cited to support a wikivoice affirmation that some Jews critical of Israel have been accused of self-hatred (a piece of prose that doesn’t even explain the fact’s relation to the article topic; properly phrased it would say that some critics have linked the accusation of Jewish self-hatred to weaponization or said that it is often a form of weaponization taken when the target is Jewish). ꧁Mangroves꧂ 14:38, 15 November 2026 (UTC)- When Chomsky is writing about linguistics he’s writing as a scholar. When he’s writing about this topic he’s writing as an activist. That doesn’t invalidate him, but it means it’s not going to be NPOV if we give him too much space.
- Nobody has said only antisemitism scholars belong here (let alone poli sci scholars!), but surely you agree that Wikipedia should be biased towards relevant experts? By definition, substantial discussion in a highly cited article by mainstream scholars on the topic at hand is better than passing mention in an obscure article by a little known scholar who specialises in other topics. That’s not a contentious thing to say! (Unlike delegitimising mainstream scholarship on antisemitism as “fringe”.) BobFromBrockley (talk) 16:47, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- I assume your “little known scholar” comment was not a reference to Chomsky. If it was, that certainly is not what his BLP says about him (“Chomsky has been a defining Western intellectual figure, central to the field of linguistics and definitive in cognitive science, computer science, philosophy, and psychology… known as one of the most important intellectuals of his time.”) Chomsky’s main area of scholarly work is in linguistics, but he also has written extensively about the Israel/Palestine conflict (including the two books “Gaza in Crisis” and “On Palestine”, coauthored with Ilan Pappé). He is well qualified to comment on the tactics used by defenders of Israel to delegitimize criticism from both Jews and non-Jews. NightHeron (talk) 17:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- Correct, those relate to two sets of citations. As I said, Chomsky has written about the adjacent topic of Israel/Palestine, but as an activist not a scholar. The little known scholars are many of the others cited in the lead BobFromBrockley (talk) 19:37, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- I assume your “little known scholar” comment was not a reference to Chomsky. If it was, that certainly is not what his BLP says about him (“Chomsky has been a defining Western intellectual figure, central to the field of linguistics and definitive in cognitive science, computer science, philosophy, and psychology… known as one of the most important intellectuals of his time.”) Chomsky’s main area of scholarly work is in linguistics, but he also has written extensively about the Israel/Palestine conflict (including the two books “Gaza in Crisis” and “On Palestine”, coauthored with Ilan Pappé). He is well qualified to comment on the tactics used by defenders of Israel to delegitimize criticism from both Jews and non-Jews. NightHeron (talk) 17:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- I wouldn’t say “multiple editors”. This whole debate has involved - I believe - just six editors, evenly split on this question. BobFromBrockley (talk) 16:33, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
The prominent “see also” link to Self-hating Jew that I inserted and you reverted also supports the relevance of that topic to the subject of this article. The lead to the SHJ article says: “In modern times the term has been used for political purposes as a form of weaponization of antisemitism to delegitimize anti-Zionist Jews or shield against criticism of the Israeli government.” If it’s “a form of weaponization of antisemitism,” it certainly deserves significant coverage in this article. NightHeron (talk) 15:17, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- NightHeron, you tried, and found consensus that editors do not support the hatnote. I also don’t see how the presence of the hatnote would have constituted a case for the lead mention?
- As for your citing the SHJ article: Wikipedia is not a reliable source! ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:31, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Would it be okay to link the section "Against Jewish critics" to Self-hating Jew?
[edit]I added "See also: Self-hating Jew" at the beginning of the subsection "Against Jewish critics" and at Mangroves' insistence (on my talk-page) I've self-reverted pending a discussion here. Please comment on whether or not it's a good idea to refer the reader to an article having a more detailed discussion of the topic. Thanks. NightHeron (talk) 04:14, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’m afraid I don’t see an additive difference in linking the article in a “see also” note rather than in the first sentence of the section. This is what hyperlinks are for. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 05:42, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think the prominent location of the "see also" note, right under the section title, would make it more likely that an interested reader would follow the link to the article that covers the topic in more detail. NightHeron (talk) 05:57, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- Maybe, but under this principle we would add “see also” hatnotes to every single section. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 06:31, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- Doubtful. And this argument sounds like whataboutism. NightHeron (talk) 12:10, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’m afraid I don’t understand your argument here. What is doubtful? That “the hatnote is more visually prominent, so it should replace the first hyperlink” is applicable to basically any section? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:14, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- Doubtful that every section is about something as basic to the topic as SHJ is to this article that a reader would likely want to read a separate more extensive article about it.
- Could we pause this back-and-forth while we wait for other editors to comment? NightHeron (talk) 15:33, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’m afraid I don’t understand your argument here. What is doubtful? That “the hatnote is more visually prominent, so it should replace the first hyperlink” is applicable to basically any section? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 15:14, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- Doubtful. And this argument sounds like whataboutism. NightHeron (talk) 12:10, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- Maybe, but under this principle we would add “see also” hatnotes to every single section. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 06:31, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think the prominent location of the "see also" note, right under the section title, would make it more likely that an interested reader would follow the link to the article that covers the topic in more detail. NightHeron (talk) 05:57, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- There is already a link to "self-hating Jews" in the lead section and once again in the Against Jewish critics section, so it is already covered. It should not be used as a See also item because it is already sufficiently linked. It should not be upgraded to a "main article" link in that section as that would be an unacceptably POV endorsement of the contested view that this is a manifestation of self-hatred. The section is about the contested nature of that view.
- In other words, it is currently linked the correct amount and should not be linked any more than it already is. Anybody wanting to know more about the alleged phenomenon of "self-hating Jews" has adequate opportunities to find that article. To link it more would provide no additional value and fall into POV problems. --DanielRigal (talk) 20:10, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- +1 User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 20:15, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
- “
It should not be upgraded to a "main article" link in that section as that would be an unacceptably POV endorsement of the contested view that this is a manifestation of self-hatred.
” Huh?? Please read the article I’ve proposed linking to. It does not endorse the notion that Jewish criticism of Israel is a manifestation of self-hatred or hatred of one’s own religion. Rather, much as Weaponization of antisemitism discusses the use of the charge of antisemitism to delegitimize criticism of Israel by non-Jews, the article Jewish self-hatred discusses the use of the self-hatred accusation to delegitimize criticism of Israel by Jews. From the Jewish self-hatred article’s lead: “In modern times the term has been used for political purposes as a form of weaponization of antisemitism to delegitimize anti-Zionist Jews or shield against criticism of the Israeli government.” How could the “see also” link possibly be “an unacceptably POV endorsement of the contested view that this is a manifestation of self-hatred
”?? NightHeron (talk) 22:29, 1 November 2026 (UTC)- The lead of that article probably shouldn’t include that content as the body of that article currently doesn’t have a decent section on this topic and the lead goes way beyond what’s in the body. The body section needs ripping up and rewriting as it’s currently basically about a 2014 John Stewart interview and an autobiographical comment by Chomsky from the same year. BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:47, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
- “
- +1 BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:44, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
- +1 User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 20:15, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
@NightHeron: I agree it should be a "main article" link. Mangroves wanted the section built out, in order to match the lede. Having a "main article" link is consistent with that. Onceinawhile (talk) 23:37, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
To add to article: McCarthyism and antisemitism
[edit]Note to self (unless anyone else actions it!): many accused McCarthy and the Rosenberg trial of antisemitism, but others (including the ADL) said this was weaponisation. Meanwhile McCarthy accused his attackers of antisemitism for how they discussed Roy Cohn, a charge that was in turn described as weaponisation. BobFromBrockley (talk) 05:08, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
- Ah, I came across one source about this but never added it, because I didn’t know it was a general phenomenon. Thanks for flagging! ꧁Mangroves꧂ 00:41, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
AFT resolution
[edit]I came across this powerful statement while looking for something else. I don’t know if it got the secondary coverage to tell us it’s DUE so just posting here to log it in case it is:
- "Calling for a Bilateral Cease-Fire in Gaza and Promoting a Two-State Solution and an End to the Weaponization of Hate". American Federation of Teachers. 2024-01-30. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
The other sort of weaponisation
[edit]I’ve noticed that there is a body of literature that talks about the weaponisation of antisemitism in a radically different opposite way this article currently does, to focus on the instrumentalisation of actual antisemitism (rather than false accusations) as a political weapon, eg by far right parties, authoritarian leaders or elites. Examples:
- DeVega, Chauncey (2024-07-31). ""The savior of Israel": Antisemitism expert on what Trump's "good Jew and bad Jew sorting" signals". Salon.com. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Diab, Khaled (2026-10-26). "Auschwitz-Birkenau and the death of human empathy". The Chronikler - The annals of history in the making. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Bar, Neil (2026-02-02). "Golden Dawn's Antisemitic Meta-Conspiracy of Hate and the Defiance of European Norms" (PDF). Nationalities Papers. Cambridge University Press (CUP): 1–18. doi:10.1017/nps.2026.10128. ISSN 0090-5992. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Schwaeber-Issan, Cookie (2026-03-29). "How modern antisemitism is weaponized through words". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Heller, Chaia (2023-11-20). "Authoritarianism, Anti-Jewish racism, and The Israel-Hamas War: An Open letter to the Left". Institute for Social Ecology. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Balint, Barnabas (2026-03-15). "Writing a history of animals during the Holocaust". Patterns of Prejudice. 60 (1–2): 17–38. doi:10.1080/0031322X.2026.2658402. ISSN 0031-322X. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Kaufman, Amy S. (2017-05-23). "Anti-Semitism Is Older Than You Think". The Public Medievalist. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Sužiedėlis, Saulius (2025-03-25). Crisis, War, and the Holocaust in Lithuania. Academic Studies Press. doi:10.2307/jj.36233902. ISBN 979-8-88719-491-2. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
- Bénédicte Sère (2026-11-03). "The Pope, the Jews, the Schism: Contested Authority and Coercive Polemics". iberome.hypotheses.org. Retrieved 2026-11-03.
Should this usage be covered in the article? BobFromBrockley (talk) 06:39, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
- There was a debate about this somewhere in the archives. I think not; to me this is a totally different meaning captured by the same euphemism. If this article were more descriptively titled, it would be called Bad-faith accusations of antisemitism (or Disputes about bad-faith accusations of antisemitism. It’s kind of arbitrary that this article is so titled instead of being called Antisemitism as a smear. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 13:56, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
- They'd come more under antisemitism, and in both cases political leaders exploit them, so the title is rather unfortunate. This article's topic is different though in being more of a specific defence rather than a general attack. I can't see a straightforward way to a separate article about weaponization by people like Trump and neonazis, there doesn't seem to be a good name for that, and it is part of a more general theme of politicians attacking minorities or enemies to unify and galvanize their support base. NadVolum (talk) 13:55, 4 November 2026 (UTC)
Masada2000
[edit]@Mangroves, could you please explain why you removed so much of the content I added about Masada2000?
Especially in this edit where you removed that "People on the list were often described using insulting language, including the slur kike. In some cases, their personal and professional contact information was publicized on the list." IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 18:39, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I can’t look at it in detail now, but from my memory and the edit summary, I think the "kike" detail must have come from a source that didn’t connect the Masada2000 list to weaponization. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 18:41, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I specifically remember the Jewish Currents source and the Encyclopedia source not making any suggestion that the list’s designation of its constituents as antisemitic was weaponized or dishonest (with JC mostly mocking the list as silly/disagreeable in its claims), and I remember a third source written by a college student that I’m pretty sure also did not connect the list to weaponization. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 18:46, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- The list is explicitly connected to weaponization in the source Friedman, M. (2014). "Jewish Self-hatred, Moral Criticism and Autonomy", in Mariana A. L. Oshana (Ed.), Personal Autonomy and Social Oppression: Philosophical Perspectives, pp. 203-222. New York: Routledge:
Occasionally in these debates, one hears Jewish supporters of Israeli policies try to discredit the arguments of Jewish critics of Israeli policies by accusing the critics of being “self-hating Jews.”
This criticism turns up emphatically on the website Masada2000. The Masada2000 website publishes a list of what its creators call “Self-Hating and/or Israel-Threatening Jews,” in other words the “SHIT list.”3 This list names nearly 9,000 Jews worldwide who are supposed to be either Jewish self-haters or threats to Israel—or both.- The Jewish Currents source[1] and "the Encyclopedia source"[2] add further detail about the site's practices. They are clearly relevant and should not have been removed simply because each of them do not explicitly say that Masada2000's practices are weaponization. I also disagree that these sources are "not making any suggestion that the list’s designation of its constituents as antisemitic was weaponized or dishonest" - I certainly read them as suggesting or implying that. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 19:09, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, the Friedman source is explicitly and directly relevant, and it remains in the article (and I expanded on it with some quotes). But those removed sources did not relate, and we can’t justify them as related because they cover a topic now transitively linked to this article’s topic thanks to Friedman’s use of it as an exemplar of SHJ as linked to WoA. We cannot cite and bring in information from sources that do not relate to the article topic. For instance, we have information in the article about the Slansky trial, drawn from sources that do explicitly show a link between that trial and the article topic, but adding information about the trial from sources that contain no direct relevance to the article’s topic would be synthetic. I don’t believe a single source across this article’s bibliography is presumed to make no reference to the article topic, and that’s a good thing.
- If you disagree that the removed sources did not contain references to the article topic, that’s another story. Can you quote them to explain your interpretation? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 21:20, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Masada2000 calling Jewish people antisemitic for criticizing Israel is 100% relevant to this article's topic. How can you disagree with that when this has been very explicitly established by RS (the Friedman source)? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 21:43, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- If you quote the portions of the sources you are referring to, I can better explain. There is a critical distinction between a source claiming that an accusation of antisemitism (and the identification of antisemitism with anti-Israel rhetoric) is errant, or stupid, and a source claiming that an accusation of antisemitism is a lie. Only the latter, wherein the charge of bad faith and censorious intent is raised, is within this article's scope. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:16, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- We have an RS (Friedman) which explicitly states that Masada2000's "SHIT list" is an example of "Jewish supporters of Israeli policies try[ing] to discredit the arguments of Jewish critics of Israeli policies by accusing the critics of being “self-hating Jews.”" So Masada2000's "SHIT list" is therefore clearly established as relevant and due for this article. Each individual source does not need to make that explicit statement themselves.
- For example, if one source says "Organization X is a neo-Nazi organization" and another source says "Organization X frequently attacks protestors", it would be appropriate to say "Organization X is a neo-Nazi organization which frequently attacks protestors" - even if source two doesn't explicitly say "Organization X is a neo-Nazi organization". If Organization X is established by RS to be a neo-Nazi organization, any sources describing Organization X are relevant and due to the topic of neo-Nazi organizations and it would be absurd to suggest sources discussing Organization X be discarded as completely unrelated if they do not explicitly themselves identify Organization X as being neo-Nazi. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 22:34, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think that details coming only from sources that don't relate a subject to the article topic do not belong in the article; if those details were relevant to the article topic, then some reliable source would raise them in relation to the article topic.I see this as run-of-the-mill SYNTH, like
"Jonathan Greenblatt has been accused of weaponizing antisemitism.[1] He is bald.[2]"
cited to one relevant source, and one irrelevant source mentioning his baldness, on the basis that the first statement's source established Greenblatt and all details about him as broadly relevant to the article topic. You disagree, I take it, which is cool. We should cease our back-and-forth and allow third parties to voice their opinions, as it's clear you and I just disagree on how source relevance works. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:42, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think that details coming only from sources that don't relate a subject to the article topic do not belong in the article; if those details were relevant to the article topic, then some reliable source would raise them in relation to the article topic.I see this as run-of-the-mill SYNTH, like
- If you quote the portions of the sources you are referring to, I can better explain. There is a critical distinction between a source claiming that an accusation of antisemitism (and the identification of antisemitism with anti-Israel rhetoric) is errant, or stupid, and a source claiming that an accusation of antisemitism is a lie. Only the latter, wherein the charge of bad faith and censorious intent is raised, is within this article's scope. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:16, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Masada2000 calling Jewish people antisemitic for criticizing Israel is 100% relevant to this article's topic. How can you disagree with that when this has been very explicitly established by RS (the Friedman source)? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 21:43, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- I specifically remember the Jewish Currents source and the Encyclopedia source not making any suggestion that the list’s designation of its constituents as antisemitic was weaponized or dishonest (with JC mostly mocking the list as silly/disagreeable in its claims), and I remember a third source written by a college student that I’m pretty sure also did not connect the list to weaponization. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 18:46, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Pinging recent contributors of this talk page for further input: @NightHeron, @NadVolum, @Bobfrombrockley, @Onceinawhile, @Bluethricecreamman, @DanielRigal. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 21:53, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- what exactly is the dispute here? that in one part of the article there is talk about weaponization of antisemitism and the other they use the slur against some jewish people on the list? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 22:07, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- One article talks about weaponization and doesn't mention the slur, and a separate article, which doesn't talk about weaponization, mentions the slur. WP:SYNTH says:
If one reliable source says A and another reliable source says B, do not join A and B together to imply a conclusion C not mentioned by either of the sources.
In this case, the synthetic prose implies a connection between the use of the slur and the animal depictions to weaponization of antisemitism, a link which no source draws. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:17, 9 November 2026 (UTC)- Posted on ORN ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:27, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- It is not synth. There is nothing being stated that is not directly supported by the sources.
- All we are saying is that Masada2000's "SHIT list" is an instance of weaponizing accusations of antisemitism - this is supported by Friedman - and that this "SHIT list" engages in X,Y,Z tactics and has targeted XYZ people - this is supported by Wecker and Edwards.
- None of this is synth. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 22:42, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- One source (Friedman 2014) states that Masada2000's "SHIT list" is an instance of the weaponization of antisemitism. Two other sources (Wecker 2007 and Edwards 2008) go into detail about this "SHIT list" of Masada2000, describing how ~"People on the list were often described using insulting language, including the slur kike. In some cases, their personal and professional contact information was publicized on the list."
- Mangroves argues that these other two sources "do not relate to the article topic" since they do not themselves explicitly state that Masada2000's "SHIT list" is an instance of weaponization. My view is that the topic and all these sources are relevant and due for this article. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 22:18, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- One article talks about weaponization and doesn't mention the slur, and a separate article, which doesn't talk about weaponization, mentions the slur. WP:SYNTH says:
- what exactly is the dispute here? that in one part of the article there is talk about weaponization of antisemitism and the other they use the slur against some jewish people on the list? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 22:07, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Arriving from WP:NORN. First, I think footnote 4 needs a major trim. If you need more than 1 or 2 sources for a statement, it's probably WP:SYNTH. To elaborate, if I want to say in Wikivoice, "Chocolate is worse than vanilla", I'd need a couple damn fine sources saying so. What I can't do is have a list that goes off my screen of individual people, even culinary experts, claiming vanilla is better than chocolate. Frankly, the claim about some people calling others "Self-hating Jews" is so tame, it only needs a single source noting this is done to suffice.
- Regarding the disputed edit, as it's written now citing only Friedman, yeah, that's WP:SYNTH because Friedman doesn't say that. That doesn't mean we can't put that information in, only that we need to contextualize it. I suggest something like,
- ...known as the "S.H.I.T. List", naming nearly 9,000 Jewish public figures as self-hating Jews or threats to Israel.[Cite Friedman] Members of this list were further insulted with labels such as "socialists, communists, anarchists and so-called 'human rights' junkies and 'peace and justice' activists."[Cite to that quote]
- This preserves the information, and doesn't synthesize by keeping the two claims separate. If there isn't a cite for the above quote, than we can still cite the kike insult to the Jewish Currents source. EducatedRedneck (talk) 02:09, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Which footnote are you calling footnote 4 and saying needs a trim?
- And when you say "as it's written now citing only Friedman, yeah, that's WP:SYNTH because Friedman doesn't say that." Which text/version are you referring to? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 02:30, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Citation #4 in the current version. The only reference with over 1,000 words. EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:42, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- I'm not sure we're understanding each other. All I'm proposing here is that we add to the Masada2000 info on this page content cited to Wecker and Edwards stating that "People on the list were often described using insulting language, including the slur "kike". Persons on the list often had their photograph and personal information published on the site." Perhaps we should also mention a few people who were included on the list, which could also be cited to Wecker and/or Edwards.
- Is the simple addition of such information what you are suggesting would be synth? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:57, 11 November 2026 (UTC) Edited 02:09, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- It appears you don't believe these additons would be synth per your statement about "we can still cite the kike insult to the Jewish Currents source." This is precisely the crux of the debate and this is what Mangroves is alleging would be synth. Could you give your thoughts on that? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 02:30, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- @IOHANNVSVERVS First, you understand what I mean by footnote 4 needing a trim? I don't want to take a hacksaw to it if you object.
- Second, it sounds like we are in agreement that the slur, properly sourced, can be added. The issue was the disputed version read,
People on the list were often described using insulting language, including the slur kike. In some cases, their personal and professional contact information was publicized on the list.
That then evolved into a generalization that they were described as socialist, communist, etc., none of which were in the cited source, hence synth. - Now you are asserting they were "often described" as such. Okay, sounds plausible. Can you provide a quote to this effect? I'm not sure which source you're referring to and haven't yet seen a source which would back that quote. EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:01, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- I certainly understand your point about footnote 4.
- Thanks for catching the use of the word "often" there. I believe I made an error with the Wecker source using 'often' to desribe the inclusion of photographs and personal information rather than the use of insulting language. That word can be removed if needed, though likely would be fine to keep per the large number of instances of insulting language given in the sources. Anyway that is a minor detail - it appears you agree that using content cited to Wecker and Edwards here would not be synth, which is the crux of this debate. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 03:21, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- In principle, yes, provided the source/quote mention the weaponization of antisemitism. (E.g., discuss it in one part of the work, and clearly intend Masada2000 to be an example). I might dither on the wording to avoid flirting with SYNTH, but if you provide a quote from an RS that talks about Masada2000 doing that kind of stuff, the core seems solid. Thanks for talking it out; I know I can be a bit dense, especially when my brain hasn't started, so I appreciate your patience with me! EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC) EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:34, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Likewise. This is a mess of a discussion to jump into, thank you for taking the time. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 03:31, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- (ec) Amended my earlier statement for clarity and stepped on your edit. Apologies! But yeah, I think this is something which we'll all get sorted. Cheers! EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:34, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Likewise. This is a mess of a discussion to jump into, thank you for taking the time. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 03:31, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- In principle, yes, provided the source/quote mention the weaponization of antisemitism. (E.g., discuss it in one part of the work, and clearly intend Masada2000 to be an example). I might dither on the wording to avoid flirting with SYNTH, but if you provide a quote from an RS that talks about Masada2000 doing that kind of stuff, the core seems solid. Thanks for talking it out; I know I can be a bit dense, especially when my brain hasn't started, so I appreciate your patience with me! EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC) EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:34, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Citation #4 in the current version. The only reference with over 1,000 words. EducatedRedneck (talk) 03:42, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yeah thats how you handle it in general, separate out two sources as two sentences. I think one issue was whether a source is due though if it doesnt mention weaponization of antisemitism? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 04:19, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- i've read more of the conversation, think I'd also support the inclusion of the fact that people on the Masada2000 list were described via various slurs and insults if the fact is separated out as per EducatedRedneck's suggestion.. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 14:16, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
It’s been clear from the beginning that SHJ is a big part of the topic of weaponization of antisemitism – as Chomsky, Friedman, and others have said. According to AP News, 25% of religious Jews and 40% of secular Jews in the U.S. believe that Israel’s actions in Gaza amount to genocide. The supporters of Israel, realizing that no one’s going to believe that all those Jews are antisemites, has taken to calling them “self-hating Jews,” apparently hoping that calling all those Jews “self-hating” will sound more plausible than calling them antisemitic. I’m puzzled about why there’s so much opposition to even the most obviously necessary changes in this article — a modest expansion of the section on SHJ, along with a “see also” link to the more detailed article on the subject, a sentence or two in the lead about SHJ, and some copy-edits to improve the writing. Just a few hours ago I copy-edited a sentence in the SHJ section to make it clear and grammatical. My ce was immediately reverted and replaced by a run-on sentence with a major grammar error (dangling participle). This gets to be discouraging — a disincentive to devoting time to this article. NightHeron (talk) 22:37, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, I believe there is a serious issue with WP:OWN by Mangroves on this page. I'm not sure what the appropriate venue for resolving that would be however. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 22:43, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- unless it is beyond self evident, or clear diffs are given, its always a bit hard to adjudicate user behavior on article talk page anyways. The “obvious” venue is an admins noticeboard, or ae not here, though I’m not sure we are at that point yet? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 22:58, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- How does the proportion of religious and secular American Jews who believe that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza relate to questions of SYNTH policy for our coverage of a website that predates the Gaza war by two decades? Did you mean to comment this in the above section about the lead? ꧁Mangroves꧂ 22:45, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, I guess my comment belongs in the previous section. I thought we were still debating our coverage of SHJ. As several sources comment, the claim that Jewish critics of Israel are “self-hating” is the way supporters of Israel try to delegitimize their viewpoint, when they realize that calling them “antisemitic,” as they do for non-Jewish critics of Israel, would not work. The relevance of the statistics about the high proportion of American Jews who are sharply critical of Israel is that it shows the magnitude of the “self-hating” slur. The fact that it’s slandering such a large number of Jews is a reason why it’s WP:DUE for discussion in an expanded section and in the lead. It’s a big issue, not a minor matter. NightHeron (talk) 04:23, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- That is not an encyclopedic argument. The concept’s significance is to be determined by its treatment in reliable sources, not by your original calculation of how many people it offends. But if you want to discuss this, please move up to the SHJ section. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 07:53, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think folks can do as much WP:Synth as they want in talk page when discussing dueness, as long as none of the synth goes into article space. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 13:59, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Eh, WP:DUE notes,
Keep in mind that, in determining proper weight, we consider a viewpoint's prevalence in reliable sources, not its prevalence among Wikipedia editors or the general public.
I agree that WP:OR doesn't apply to talk pages, but I don't think personal conclusions are useful for determine WP:DUE. - Since there seems to be disagreement on this, perhaps someone would be willing to do a source review? I know I'd be convinced if I saw a post that said, "I put 'Self-hating jew' in Google Scholar and looked at the first 20 results. Of the 7 I could access, 3 referred to SHJ in the context of antisemitism." (Or whatever the numbers may be.) EducatedRedneck (talk) 14:54, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Eh, WP:DUE notes,
- I think folks can do as much WP:Synth as they want in talk page when discussing dueness, as long as none of the synth goes into article space. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 13:59, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- That is not an encyclopedic argument. The concept’s significance is to be determined by its treatment in reliable sources, not by your original calculation of how many people it offends. But if you want to discuss this, please move up to the SHJ section. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 07:53, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, I guess my comment belongs in the previous section. I thought we were still debating our coverage of SHJ. As several sources comment, the claim that Jewish critics of Israel are “self-hating” is the way supporters of Israel try to delegitimize their viewpoint, when they realize that calling them “antisemitic,” as they do for non-Jewish critics of Israel, would not work. The relevance of the statistics about the high proportion of American Jews who are sharply critical of Israel is that it shows the magnitude of the “self-hating” slur. The fact that it’s slandering such a large number of Jews is a reason why it’s WP:DUE for discussion in an expanded section and in the lead. It’s a big issue, not a minor matter. NightHeron (talk) 04:23, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
References
- ↑ Menachem Wecker (May 2007). "In Defense of 'Self-Hating' Jews: Conversations with the Targets of Masada2000's S.H.I.T. List". Jewish Currents. Archived from the original on March 12, 2017. Retrieved July 21, 2007.
- ↑ Edwards, Richard (2008). "Masada2000.org". In Spencer C. Tucker (ed.). The Encyclopedia of the Arab-Israeli Conflict: A Political, Social, and Military History. Santa Barbara, Calif.: ABC-CLIO. pp. 669–670. ISBN 978-1-85109-841-5.
Lead sentence and WP:Wikivoice
[edit]IOHANNVSVERVS, removing "alleged" from the opening sentence turns a disputed characterization into an objective fact in Wikipedia's voice, a direct and fundamental violation of WP:NPOV and WP:WIKIVOICE.
A substantial portion of this article (Hirsh on Livingstone Formulation, Schraub, Rensmann, and Julius), documents scholars arguing that charges of weaponization are frequently themselves bad-faith deflections used to dismiss genuine antisemitism. The current language of the lead presupposes the validity of the charge rather than describing it neutrally.
If we prefer to avoid "alleged" per MOS:ALLEGED (refers to alleged instances
), we still have to condition the framing rather than stating it as objective reality with an alternative like refers to the claim
.
Can we agree on a conditioned formulation to bring the opening sentence into compliance with WP:NPOV? —Biosketch (talk) 14:08, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Pinging (non-tbanned) participants in previous discussions about attribution and wikivoice in the lead (Archive 9, Archive 15, Archive 12): @Bobfrombrockley, @Llll5032, @Onceinawhile, @AndreJustAndre, @Dauntbares, @Lewisguile
- In my opinion, it is acceptable to refer in wikivoice to both weaponization and use of the claim of weaponization to delegitimize or deflect criticism, since it’s clear by these claims’ natures that they’re discursive and in direct controversy with each other. But the current state, where weaponization is reified in wikivoice and the criticisms are attributed in-text to critics, does not make sense. But "alleged" is too scary; if we standardize non-wikivoice for the lead, we should come up with a less clunky and incredulous formulation, akin to our formulation for the criticism blurb. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 14:46, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- It's been a hot minute since I've looked at this, and it seems the article has undergone some evolution since I last checked. There are "accusations", "allegations", and "controversies" in the article section headers which I usually wouldn't support, but those do seem to exist mainly for allegations of weaponisation, rather than rebuttals of those allegations. So I don't think it's as one-sided as you suggest.
- Looking at the lede, it seems fairly balanced and maintains NPOV. I don't like "refers to", but this is one of those areas where it's arguably okay. There's a lot more passive voice than I'd like, but again, this is also something that's arguably okay in a lede. We use "some critics", etc., but that avoids long lists, and we do it for both sides of the debate. However, it seems we are even-handed in not using attribution for the claims for or against in the current draft in the current lede, so I don't see the issue. I think the opening is definitely stronger without "alleged", and I would argue that's also true for the article body (as far as we can manage it).
- I hope this helps. Lewisguile (talk) 15:50, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don't think a change is necessary. The lead as written now reads,
The weaponization of antisemitism refers to instances where accusations of antisemitism are made in bad faith
(Emphasis mine.) The statement appears agnostic to how prevalent such instances are. Farther down in the lead, after using lots of equivocating language like "some scholars", discusses a more widespread use, and uses the language,The charge of weaponization...
which seems to have the "alleged" baked in. Maybe I'm missing something, though. I'll pipe down and let others weigh in. EducatedRedneck (talk) 14:48, 12 November 2026 (UTC)- Yes, this makes sense. Instances is definitely more WP:NPOV than allegations. Lewisguile (talk) 15:50, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Actually, an even shorter version would be:
The weaponization of antisemitism refers to accusations of antisemitism made in bad faith, particularly to deflect or suppress criticism of Israel, anti-Zionism, or broader debate regarding the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
- This still retains "accusations", which is less than ideal, but I'm stumped for an alternative. "Reports" feels too weak, since it implies somebody has flagged something rather than levelling an actual accusation. I think we previously tried "charges", but that could imply legal charges. "Complaints" carries its own negative connotations, too. Lewisguile (talk) 16:01, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Maybe "assertions of antisemitism"? I mean, it's going to be negative anyway given the context, but I feel like "assertion" captures that one party's proposition is that the other is disingenuously applying the label of antisemitism, without trying to pick apart whether or not it's true. EducatedRedneck (talk) 17:17, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don’t see an issue with accusations, and every alternative is weird/confusing/wrong in its implications. Accusations matches the letter or tone of most sources on the subject. "Assertions" is very clunky to my eye, and "instances" carries a very different meaning. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 18:33, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- I won't object to "accusations". EducatedRedneck (talk) 18:47, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- I would not object either. (This is a large section sorry if im attending to this all sporadically) User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 02:13, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- I won't object to "accusations". EducatedRedneck (talk) 18:47, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don’t see an issue with accusations, and every alternative is weird/confusing/wrong in its implications. Accusations matches the letter or tone of most sources on the subject. "Assertions" is very clunky to my eye, and "instances" carries a very different meaning. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 18:33, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- What about something like:
The weaponization of antisemitism is the use of accusations of antisemitism for political purposes, particularly to deflect/suppress/dismiss/stigmatize/delegitimatize criticism of Zionism or the State of Israel.
- We shouldn't be restricting our definition/scope to include only accusations explicitly identified as being made in bad faith. Most sources do not define the concept this way and intention (good or bad faith) is not a black and white matter, nor is it something easily scrutable for determining whether an accusation belongs in this article or not. The defining characteristic seems to be that the accusation is being 'used' for some political purpose. Which is why "the instrumentalization of antisemitism" is another term used in RS to describe the concept, as are "the exploitation of" or "the politicization of". IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:06, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think this article topic’s scope is quite clearly defined in secondary literature as dishonest and bad-faith. I have not encountered any sources that discuss the misuse of earnestly-levied accusations of antisemitism for political purposes. They refer explicitly to ulterior motives, lies, smears, strategies to silence dissent, etc. And the receptive literature that responds to these claims in turn characterize them as claims of bad faith, dishonest intentions, attempts to smear and censor rather than to earnestly raise about extant antisemitism. None of this article’s sources is about the political consequences of honestly-made and believed claims of antisemitism. Also, the notion of a charge of antisemitism being "used" for something other than to call attention to what the complainant is understood to truly believe is actual antisemitism, when the complainant’s supposed belief is not rejected, makes no sense. Prose that doesn’t make sense and doesn’t represent the article’s content nor the state of the literature defining its topic is not helpful. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think that unless it is obviously unanimous that an act is antisemitic, its a dangerous slope to state that it applies only to a binary definition of antisemitism when that definition is often the debate User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 02:17, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- You say "I think this article topic’s scope is quite clearly defined in secondary literature as dishonest and bad-faith." I disagree. Most sources discussing the topic do not specify whether the weaponization is done in good or bad faith. You set up a false dichotomy between bad faith accusations and "earnestly-levied" accusations - but there is a lot of grey area between earnestness and dishonesty.
- Some examples:
- Goldstein, W. S. (2026). The weaponization of antisemitism. Critical Research on Religion, 14(1), 3-10. https://doi.org/10.1177/20503032261435612: "The leadership of the Jewish state, as a rhetorical weapon, has labelled anything anti-Israel as antisemitic. Anyone who criticizes Israel is labelled an antisemite (or a self-hating Jew). [...] All too frequently, antisemitism has been weaponized. It has long been used by the state of Israel to deflect criticism of their actions".
- Friedman, M. (2014). "Jewish Self-hatred, Moral Criticism and Autonomy", in Mariana A. L. Oshana (Ed.), Personal Autonomy and Social Oppression: Philosophical Perspectives, pp. 203-222. New York: Routledge: "In debates over Israeli policies, it is very likely that the concept of Jewish self-hatred is used by Israel supporters to try to discredit Jewish critics of Israel without having to present any political arguments. The charge of Jewish self-hatred suggests that Jewish criticism of Israeli policies is based not on genuine wrongness in the policies but instead on mere bias or prejudice and is therefore to be summarily discredited."
- The Nexus Project speaks of "Using accusations of antisemitism as a tool to suppress criticism of Israel"
- Dencik, L. (2022). On the Ethical Implications and Political Costs of Misinterpreting and Abusing the Notion “Anti-Semitism”. In A. Lange, K. Mayerhofer, D. Porat & L. Schiffman (Ed.), Volume 4 Confronting Antisemitism from Perspectives of Philosophy and Social Sciences (pp. 283-304). Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110671971-014: "This article focuses on how the notion "antisemitism" in the contemporary era is sometimes used by different political interests as a vehicle for promoting certain political goals."
- All of these quotations are referring to the topic of this article (weaponization/exploitation/instrumentalization/politicization of antisemtism) without speculating to what extent these accusations are made in earnestness or bad faith.
- If we are to account for sources like these and more we should define the concept simply as ~"the use of accusations of antisemitism for political purposes, particularly to deflect/suppress/dismiss/stigmatize/delegitimatize criticism of Zionism or the State of Israel".
- To include the bad faith element in our definition would result in us having to discard all the above sources as out of scope since they don't specifically describe the accusations as being made in bad faith. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 04:24, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- This is now a radical dispute about the article’s scope. I would separate it into its own section and seek consensus for your interpretation, because this is going to involve a lot of heavy quoting from sources. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 07:21, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- I'll note that for over two years the lede of this article didn't specify bad faith in its definition. Until just over two weeks ago when Mangroves added it with an unclear edit summary and no talk page discussion.
- I'll be reverting your bold unexplained alteration of the lede sentence @Mangroves, per the sources I've cited above and per WP:ONUS. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:21, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- This discussion is a live one about the lead (and it’s not about my formulation). ꧁Mangroves꧂ 07:17, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- I think this article topic’s scope is quite clearly defined in secondary literature as dishonest and bad-faith. I have not encountered any sources that discuss the misuse of earnestly-levied accusations of antisemitism for political purposes. They refer explicitly to ulterior motives, lies, smears, strategies to silence dissent, etc. And the receptive literature that responds to these claims in turn characterize them as claims of bad faith, dishonest intentions, attempts to smear and censor rather than to earnestly raise about extant antisemitism. None of this article’s sources is about the political consequences of honestly-made and believed claims of antisemitism. Also, the notion of a charge of antisemitism being "used" for something other than to call attention to what the complainant is understood to truly believe is actual antisemitism, when the complainant’s supposed belief is not rejected, makes no sense. Prose that doesn’t make sense and doesn’t represent the article’s content nor the state of the literature defining its topic is not helpful. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- Maybe "assertions of antisemitism"? I mean, it's going to be negative anyway given the context, but I feel like "assertion" captures that one party's proposition is that the other is disingenuously applying the label of antisemitism, without trying to pick apart whether or not it's true. EducatedRedneck (talk) 17:17, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, this makes sense. Instances is definitely more WP:NPOV than allegations. Lewisguile (talk) 15:50, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- It is an undisputed fact that accusations of antisemitism are sometimes weaponized. There is no need to say this is alleged.
- The sources that you cite represent a fringe POV, one that is vastly overrepresented on this page. Note that Hirsh, Rensman, and Julius are all closesly affiliated - with Rensman and Julius being members of the editorial board of the Journal of Contemporary Antisemitism, a journal which Hirsh founded, and which appears to serve primarily to promote the concept of "new antisemitism". Hirsh and Julius are also connected as both being advisory editors of Fathom journal, a publication of the pro-Israel Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre, with Hirsh and Julius serving as advisory editors.
- This is the actual problem with the page - the overrepresentation of fringe scholars like these. There are other scholars part of this network overrepresented on this page as well, for example Lesley Klaff and Daniel Allington, with Klaff being the editor-in-chief of Hirsh's Journal of Contemporary Antisemitism, and Allington its deputy editor. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 19:34, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
- It is absolutely not the case that these scholars are fringe and extraordinary you’d say that. Hirsh for example is a professor who has been published in multiple peer reviewed journals (eg Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, Journal for the Study of Antisemitism) and by Routledge, who leads the European Sociological Association’s Research Network on Antisemitism, who has been cited in the UK Parliament as an expert on antisemitism. Like it or not, his position is the mainstream one. BobFromBrockley (talk) 07:13, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- These are absolutely not fringe scholars, the JoCA is not a fringe journal, and the Livingstone Formulation is not a fringe concept. All of these are widely cited and have currency in the field of antisemitism studies and more broadly in studies of racial and political rhetoric. This is mainstream antisemitism scholarship. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 07:23, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- Okay, speaking as an uninterested observer: the word “alleged” should not be in the first sentence simply because it is wrong.
- Weaponization of antisemitism refers to actual instances of it occurring, not alleged instances, because that’s how words work. For example, the word “red” is not a term for objects that are alleged to be red, it’s for objects that simply are red. 296cherry (talk) 18:14, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
- IOHANNVSVERVS, declaring "weaponization" as an
undisputed fact
while at the same time acknowledging that intent isnot easily scrutable
makes the exact case for conditioning in Wikipedia's voice. - And dismissing tenured scholars published in leading university press as WP:FRINGE does not erase a mainstream academic debate. Mangroves pointed out the obvious asymmetry that you treat "weaponization" as established, objective fact in the opening sentence while attributing its criticism later in the lead in violationg of WP:NPOV.
- Until the opening sentence is conditioned rather than asserting disputed motives as facts, this remains a fundamental neutrality violation. —Biosketch (talk)
- IOHANNVSVERVS, declaring "weaponization" as an
There seems to be some confusion here. It is certainly correct to say that non-fringe opinions differ widely on what exactly is a case of weaponization of antisemitism, just as opinions can differ widely on what exactly constitutes antisemitism. But denying the existence of weaponization (just like denying the existence of antisemitism) is an extreme viewpoint subject to WP:Fringe. NightHeron (talk) 12:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
- Exactly. Even Biosketch's initial argument only says that the scholars they cite argue that "charges of weaponization are frequently themselves bad-faith deflections used to dismiss genuine antisemitism." This is not the same as arguing that weaponizationed accusations of antisemitism do not exist, so there is no need to say it is something only alleged to exist. All that is disputed is which specific instances and how frequently antisemitism accusations are weaponized. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 01:20, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- NightHeron, IOHANNVSVERVS, nobody here has claimed that false or politically motivated accusations never happen so putting words in my mouth to paint this as WP:FRINGE denialism is an absurd straw man. And comparing this to antisemitism is completely off the mark. Bigotry against Jews is a real-world prejudice, "weaponization" is an accusation about someone's hidden motives.
- Let's get back to substantive, policy-based discussion of proper application of WP:WIKIVOICE and WP:NPOV. —Biosketch (talk) 04:43, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- If "nobody here has claimed that false or politically motivated accusations never happen", then why would we be describing the concept of false or politically motivated accusations as "alleged"? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:22, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Because some are false and politically motivated, while others are wholly correct, and many are in a grey area in between that we can’t rule on in our voice. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:32, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Some alleged vegetables are actually fruits, but it would be absurd to overemphasize that in the vegetable article. This article should focus on weaponization, per the title. Its derivative, “weaponization of claims of weaponization”, is a subsidiary point. Onceinawhile (talk) 23:33, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- I believe the sources currently cited in the first sentence of this lead are pretty partisan and in some cases pure opinion pieces (and far more close to “fringe” than the antisemitism scholarship described as such in this thread). Surely we can use better, more reputable and more neutral sources to make that claim? BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:35, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Actually, I don’t think we need any citation in the first sentence. It summarises body. BobFromBrockley (talk) 23:31, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Because some are false and politically motivated, while others are wholly correct, and many are in a grey area in between that we can’t rule on in our voice. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:32, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- If "nobody here has claimed that false or politically motivated accusations never happen", then why would we be describing the concept of false or politically motivated accusations as "alleged"? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 05:22, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- One editor here has been regularly deleting citations without consensus. Onceinawhile (talk) 23:34, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- New citations that don’t have consensus yet? That’s the R in BRD so fine. Or old citations that haven’t been opposed? That’s the B in BRD so you can revert and discuss. BobFromBrockley (talk) 09:46, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
- One editor here has been regularly deleting citations without consensus. Onceinawhile (talk) 23:34, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
- Which sources are you describing as "partisan" and "pure opinion"? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 04:30, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
- Highly partisan:
- Landy|Lentin|McCarthy; White|2020; Mearsheimer|Walt
- Partisan opinion piece:
- Roth-Rowland
- Interview:
- Medico International|Rothberg
- These are sources we can quote with attribution but shouldn’t just put in a footnote for a claim in our voice. Especially in the lead. BobFromBrockley (talk) 21:39, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
- I'm assuming you consider Landy, Lentin, McCarthy, and Ben White as partisan because each author is involved in pro-Palestinian activism/organizations?
- Why do you consider Walt and Mearsheimer partisan?
- What Roth-Rowland opinion piece are you referring to? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 02:36, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, they are scholars but also activists. They can be cited for their opinions with attribution, but we should not use them to footnote a statement in our voice, especially in the lead. Whereas scholars like Rothberg, Cheyette, Penslar, Feldman or Judaken are widely respected and cited by people on both sides of the debate, these are polarising figures who are sharply criticised by the other side. That doesn’t mean they’re fringe, just that we can’t use them without attribution and must balance them with views from the other side. The same is true of partisans on the other side such as Hirsh or Herf, who are not fringe but nevertheless can’t be used as sources for statements in our voice.
- Roth-Rowland’s opinion piece in 972 magazine was also previously cited in the lead along with these people. Rothberg was there too, but from a media interview rather than a scholarly publication. BobFromBrockley (talk) 14:19, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
- Makes sense. What about Walt and Mearsheimer? I'm not aware of them being involved in activism. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 19:12, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
- Maybe not activists but (as is clear from their article’s WP article) their conclusions are extremely controversial so I don’t think we can cite them for a statement in our voice. BobFromBrockley (talk) 22:30, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
- You said they were "highly partisan". Are you retracting that claim? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 00:27, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- No BobFromBrockley (talk) 09:03, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- Then could you explain what makes you call them partisan? That their conclusions are controversial ≠ that they are partisan. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 13:22, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- I understand partisan to mean highly one-sided, taking a side in a contention. I think that’s an apt description but I’m not really here to argue the exact word if you don’t think this is the right term. What I’m certain of is that it’s not a good source to cite for a claim we make in our own voice. BobFromBrockley (talk) 14:55, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- So little in this article is even in wikivoice. Aside from the recounting of uncontroversial historical events, every opinion on the article topic (it’s a big deal; it’s bullshit; it’s in between; etc.) is attributed outside of Wikipedia’s own voice. The only exception that I can spot is the article’s first sentence. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:04, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- And that was the sentence previously citing the sources I was talking about. BobFromBrockley (talk) 04:51, 20 November 2026 (UTC)
- So little in this article is even in wikivoice. Aside from the recounting of uncontroversial historical events, every opinion on the article topic (it’s a big deal; it’s bullshit; it’s in between; etc.) is attributed outside of Wikipedia’s own voice. The only exception that I can spot is the article’s first sentence. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:04, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- I understand partisan to mean highly one-sided, taking a side in a contention. I think that’s an apt description but I’m not really here to argue the exact word if you don’t think this is the right term. What I’m certain of is that it’s not a good source to cite for a claim we make in our own voice. BobFromBrockley (talk) 14:55, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- Then could you explain what makes you call them partisan? That their conclusions are controversial ≠ that they are partisan. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 13:22, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- No BobFromBrockley (talk) 09:03, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- You said they were "highly partisan". Are you retracting that claim? IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 00:27, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
- Maybe not activists but (as is clear from their article’s WP article) their conclusions are extremely controversial so I don’t think we can cite them for a statement in our voice. BobFromBrockley (talk) 22:30, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
- Makes sense. What about Walt and Mearsheimer? I'm not aware of them being involved in activism. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 19:12, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Onceinawhile, comparing vegetables to antisemitism accusations is even less relevant than apples and oranges. Whether something is a vegetable isn't a matter of opinion, claiming an accusation was made in "bad faith" is. Between the unconditioned WP:WIKIVOICE and WP:NPOV issues in the lead noted by Mangroves (inconsistent attributed framing) and Bobfrombrockley (use of WP:RSOPINION sourcing), there is clearly an unresolved WP:NPOV dispute over the lead. I am adding {{POV}} for the lead until we can reach consensus on this fundamental matter that is based on actual policy rather than rhetorical, erroneous analogies. —Biosketch (talk) 22:27, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don't see what the POV tag is about. Putting alleged into the lead sentence would be wrong in the definition. Accusations of weaponizaton do happen and are reliably cited and described in the article, That doen't mean it has actually happened in circumstances where an accusation is made, and the lead says nothing like that. Quite the opposite, it points out controversies about the topic. NadVolum (talk) 00:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Fathom journal
[edit]I don't believe we should be citing Fathom journal, which is a publication of the pro-Israel Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre (BICOM). IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:04, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It’s a mainstream, widely-cited journal in antisemitism studies. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:09, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It's a publication of a pro-Israel lobby/advocacy group. I don't see how it could be considered reliable for an article such as this which is about a controversial pro-Israel propaganda technique. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:12, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It’s reliable because it’s an academic journal that publishes legitimate scholarship and is edited by some of the most prominent antisemitism scholars. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:13, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It’s obviously biased, but it’s also in my view clearly reliable. Its contributors include some of the most highly regarded antisemitism scholars. Its founding editor had decent academic credentials. Several of the articles in have been republished in books, in particular in a Routledge series which includes some of the best antisemitism scholars. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:20, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- @Bobfrombrockley and @Mangroves, you have both consistently argued against the inclusion of partisan sources in this article. Now a pro-Israel publication is being deemed "clearly reliable"? This is becoming absurd. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:32, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It’s a reliable scholarly publication. All of the Fathom authors in this article are experts. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:33, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- I don't think I have argued against the inclusion of (reliable) partisan sources. In a recent thread I've insisted that we cannot use partisan sources to cite statements made in Wiki voice. Where due, we can quote and attribute biased reliable sources. For example, of sources such as Landy et al, I said just a couple of days ago: "we can’t use them without attribution and must balance them with views from the other side. The same is true of partisans on the other side such as Hirsh or Herf, who are not fringe but nevertheless can’t be used as sources for statements in our voice." I think I've been fairly consistent in arguing for a consistent approach to partisan sources: quote with attribution where due; don't use them to make claims in our voice. What's absurd is asking that we should employ a double standard: that we should use partisan anti-Israel scholars for statements in our voice but eliminate partisan pro-Israel scholars from the article entirely. This article is about a contentious topic, which requires balancing biased sources and approaching them in a non-battleground way. BobFromBrockley (talk) 21:26, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- @Bobfrombrockley and @Mangroves, you have both consistently argued against the inclusion of partisan sources in this article. Now a pro-Israel publication is being deemed "clearly reliable"? This is becoming absurd. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:32, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- I’m glancing at the bibliography here. Matthew Abraham, Landy et al and White are activists. Human rights watch is an advocacy group. Noam Chomsky writes on this topic as an activist and not as a linguist. Finkelstein is a hyperpartisan controversialist. Zed Books identifies as a left-wing, anti-imperialist publisher. The Journal of Palestine Studies is an explicitly partisan journal. Jewish Currents identifies as anti-Zionist. If we remove Fathom and keep them, the article would be nakedly POV-pushing. If you want to remove a source for bias, then remove all of the biased sources. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:28, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- Please do not sidetrack this discussion. We should not be using any unreliable partisan sources. But each source needs to be discussed one at a time. Let us focus here on Fathom. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:33, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- You just brought up other sources and previous discussions about them yourself. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:34, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- To be clear, no source should be removed for bias. Sources should be removed for irrelevance or unreliability. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:35, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- Please do not sidetrack this discussion. We should not be using any unreliable partisan sources. But each source needs to be discussed one at a time. Let us focus here on Fathom. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:33, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It’s obviously biased, but it’s also in my view clearly reliable. Its contributors include some of the most highly regarded antisemitism scholars. Its founding editor had decent academic credentials. Several of the articles in have been republished in books, in particular in a Routledge series which includes some of the best antisemitism scholars. BobFromBrockley (talk) 20:20, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It’s reliable because it’s an academic journal that publishes legitimate scholarship and is edited by some of the most prominent antisemitism scholars. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 20:13, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- It's a publication of a pro-Israel lobby/advocacy group. I don't see how it could be considered reliable for an article such as this which is about a controversial pro-Israel propaganda technique. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:12, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- Fathom's current editor (editor-in-chief) is Calev Ben-Dor, who has worked previously in the Policy Planning Division of the Israeli Foreign Ministry, and has served as the Public Affairs and Press Department of the Israeli Embassy in London.[1]
- One of Fathom's current editors is Efraim Halevy, former head of the Mossad...
- This is a blatantly partisan publication and we should not be citing it in this article. I shouldn't have to do this, but I'll now take this to the reliable sources noticeboard. IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 20:43, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
Since a notice was posted on Talk:Academic journal, a few remarks.
- Fathom is a journal in the very generic sense of the word wikt:journal. It is not academic in nature, though often cited by academics (which themselves aren't free of bias) for various reasons. This is effectively a publication from a think tank, featuring writings of various members of the Isreali/Jewish intelligentsia, all with their own particular views. It's clearly a significant publication, but as with all things opinions, they're only as good as their origins. So the issue becomes does the opinion of that person warrant inclusion. Is it WP:DUE? Do we make it clear that this is that person's viewpoint? Etc... Headbomb {t · c · p · b} 21:21, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
- I agree with that. It's not a peer-reviewed scientific journal. But many of its contributors are scholars with multiple peer reviewed articles. Reliability and dueness require triangulating author and publication in relation to the topic. A leading antisemitism scholar publishing in a reputable journal is better than a leading antisemitism scholar publishing in Fathom; but the latter is likely to be due, while a pro-Israel activist published in Fathom is unlikely to be. BobFromBrockley (talk) 21:34, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
References
- ↑ Reut Institute, 2010, "The Reut Institute’s Political Security Team." Building a Political Firewall Against Israel’s Delegitimization: Conceptual Framework: Version A, pp. 4–4. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep10571.3
- C-Class Israel-related articles
- Low-importance Israel-related articles
- WikiProject Israel articles
- C-Class Palestine-related articles
- Mid-importance Palestine-related articles
- WikiProject Palestine articles
- C-Class Judaism articles
- Low-importance Judaism articles
- C-Class Discrimination articles
- Low-importance Discrimination articles
- WikiProject Discrimination articles
- C-Class Marketing & Advertising articles
- Low-importance Marketing & Advertising articles
- WikiProject Marketing & Advertising articles
- C-Class politics articles
- Low-importance politics articles
- WikiProject Politics articles
- C-Class psychology articles
- Low-importance psychology articles
- WikiProject Psychology articles
- C-Class Religion articles
- Low-importance Religion articles
- WikiProject Religion articles
- C-Class Jewish history-related articles
- Low-importance Jewish history-related articles
- WikiProject Jewish history articles
- C-Class Ethnic groups articles
- Low-importance Ethnic groups articles
- WikiProject Ethnic groups articles
- C-Class history articles
- Low-importance history articles
- WikiProject History articles
- C-Class Christianity articles
- Low-importance Christianity articles
- WikiProject Christianity articles
- Wikipedia requested photographs in Israel

