Jump to content

Talk:Walter Hooper

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 1 year ago by Bigturtle in topic Controversy section has partisan overtones

Corroborative evidence for Lewis's authorship

[edit]

Users of this site might want further information regarding 'a man named Alistair Fowler.' Prof. Fowler is a Regius Professor Emeritus in the University of Edinburgh. His article, 'C.S. Lewis: Supervisor' was published in the Yale Review (LXXXXI/4 (October 2003), pp. 64-80 and concerns his relationship with Lewis when Prof. Lewis was his doctoral supervisor as he, Fowler, prepared his Oxford D. Phil. thesis. Prof. Fowler is a leading scholar in his field and his word on this bizarre charge by Mrs Lindskoog should be decisive among anyone seriously wishing to understand the valuable work undertaken by Walter Hooper. From Dr J.E.B. Munson, M.A., D. Phil. (Oxon.) (This section moved from the article page to the talk page by Bigturtle 23:41, 6 June 2007 (UTC).)Reply

That was added to the article by User:James Munson 12:23, 6 June 2007 (UTC)Reply
--P64 (talk) 20:06, 17 October 2015 (UTC)Reply

Placement issue

[edit]

Should the article begin with the 'controversy' aspect. I realise that this was/is an ongoing issue for those involved, but one man's life is hardly defined by the response provoked from others by the particular matter, and placing it at the head of the article does seem to lend it an undue nucleal space. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 109.77.99.158 (talk) 21:41, 13 April 2012 (UTC)Reply

Chronicle of Higher Education Article

[edit]

Without getting in the middle of the Hooper/Lindskoog debate, I have to note that the Chronicle of Higher Education article which is cited does not support Hooper's position. Nor Lindskoog's position, for that matter. It merely details the controversy, and should not be used as a "proof" one way or the other. --Fatherz 16:04, 10 October 2007 (UTC)Reply

This comment has lingered here unaddressed for nearly a decade, but I'd like to second it. The Chronicle article from 2001 (which is no longer available, but can be seen in the Wayback Machine here -- we ought to fix that link) does not obviously support the claim that "independent research exists to disprove the accusations and confirm the authenticity of the posthumous Lewis works edited by Hooper", the statement for which that link is cited as a reference. I think we ought to be careful, obviously, in discussing allegations made against a living person, which have involved legal threats at the very least, if not legal action. But we also, I think, ought to be careful not to simply dismiss charges against that person as being "disprove[d]" when, to my knowledge, that "proof" is still in dispute. There are other cited claims in the article which I think give a good sense of the evidence in support of Hooper -- the memories of some former students/friends of Lewis about a manuscript they saw many years prior -- but I think we should rephrase the statement about "independent research", and honestly we should probably give a slightly clearer statement of what Lindskoog's charges are against Hooper, to the extent that we can do so in a BLP article. Anyone have any thoughts on this? Jwrosenzweig (talk) 23:38, 27 February 2017 (UTC)Reply

Hagiography

[edit]

I think there might be a more satisfactoy way of referring to Hooper's "high ethical standards and love of C. S. Lewis". Myopic Bookworm (talk) 19:46, 5 February 2008 (UTC)Reply

Small change made to reflect this proposal. Bigturtle (talk) 23:22, 5 February 2008 (UTC)Reply

Arts and entertainment

[edit]

In the WP:WPBIO banner above, I reallocated him from science-and-academia to arts-and-entertainment. (Same as Talk: Kathryn Lindskoog. Yes, they both had teaching jobs for a time but they are notable for independent work in the literature field.)

We say here that Hooper was an American college instructor with M.A. in education, age about 30, when he 'loped to visit England and CSL, evidently in 1963. Briefly private secretary, then literary executor. Assistant Anglican priest, then Roman Catholic. At the head of our list of works we say "a literary executor and advocate rather than independent scholar". --P64 (talk) 20:18, 17 October 2015 (UTC)Reply

Biography

[edit]

There is much more info available via the new section External links, especially those at UNC-Chapel Hill and Wheaton College. I do not expect to work on the body of this article myself. --P64 (talk) 20:55, 17 October 2015 (UTC)Reply

Controversy section has partisan overtones

[edit]

I apologize for the length of this comment, but the devil, as usual, is in the details.

The Controversy section begins with a small, careless error and, I would like to argue, does not, overall, report on the Lindskoog-Hooper controversy in a neutral manner.

First, the careless error. The section begins, "In 1977, Hooper published C. S. Lewis's unfinished science fiction novel The Dark Tower, an abandoned sequel to his interplanetary trilogy." However, Hooper stated that The Dark Tower appeared to be an abandoned sequel to the _first book_ of the trilogy, not a sequel to the trilogy as such ("My guess is that Lewis began writing the story almost immediately after completing _Out of the Silent Planet_ in 1938 . . . " - The Dark Tower, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1977, p. 8).

The text goes on to say, "Hooper rejected Lindskoog's accusations, and her assault on [Hooper's] integrity is now generally acknowledged to be baseless." The terms "accusations, "assault on his integrity," and "baseless" smack of partisanship and, I suggest, are unsuitable in an encyclopedia. Also, only one citation is given for the claim that the view described is "generally acknowledged," but a single review does not establish generality.

This also appears: "Professor Alastair Fowler of the University of Edinburgh, whose doctoral research Lewis supervised in 1952, recalled The Dark Tower as a story that Lewis had discussed with him." Fowler did recall this (see his 2003 essay at https://www.lewisiana.nl/fowler/), but implicitly offering his recollection as dispositive of the whole controversy smacks of both original research and a weak evidential standard. I suggest either deleting mention of this item or framing it in a more cautious manner. Although the following details may not belong in the article, I offer them to support the need for caution:

 a) Fowler's statement was specific to _The Dark Tower_ and therefore did not go to Lindskoog's claims about the forgery of various other manuscripts. Therefore, even if assumed accurate, it does not settle the controversy as a whole and should not be implicitly or explicitly put forward as doing so.
 b) Fowler's recollection about having seen the Dark Tower manuscript was first offered in 2003, ~50 years after the date in question and ~25 years after the beginning the Dark Tower controversy. Like any non-contemporaneous personal recollection made in the midst of a partisan controversy and unbacked by objective evidence, Fowler's statement should not be _assumed_ accurate.   
 c) The perfect accuracy of Fowler's memory must be questioned.  In his 2003 essay Fowler recalled seeing both The Dark Tower and the unrelated Lewis fragment "After Ten Years" on the same occasion in the early 1950s.  However: 
     • Fowler, in his contribution to the 1965 Lewis collection _Of Other Worlds_ (a paragraph about "After Ten Years"), did not mention having seen the "After Ten Years" MS (or any other writings) in the 1950s.  So far as I know, he did not mention any such recollections until 2003. 
     • Roger Lancelyn Green, in his own 1965 contribution to _Of Other Worlds_, recalled that "After Ten Years" was not commenced until 1959, when he discussed it with Lewis (p. 155). But in 2003, Fower recalled having seen the "After Ten Years" MS in the _early_ 1950s.  It does not appear that both men can be right. Fowler's version may be correct, but if Green's is, then Fowler did not see the "After Ten Years" manuscript in the early 1950s and his memory is therefore inaccurate about at least some of what he saw and/or when he saw it. To be blunt, 50 years is a long time, memory can err, and by 2003 the longstanding Dark Tower controversy may have triggered unintentional confabulation on Fowler's part. Or he may indeed have seen Dark Tower MS in 1952, as stated; but his memory of having done so is not proof that he did, and there is testimony (much closer to contemporaneous) that tends to contradict a closely related memory of his of that period.
 d) The reliability of Fowler's elderly memory is called into further doubt by certain details in his 2003 essay. E.g., he says that the writings of J.R.R. Tolkien feature "teleportation rings," which they do not. Also, it is not clear that he understood that "Lewis’s pleasure in fantasies of whipping" was a feature of his teen, not adult years (Collected Letters of C.S. Lewis, Vol. I, p. 13 ). Also, he recalls seeing Lewis in the 1950s "engrossed in Astounding Science Fiction," but if true, this is surprising; Astounding emphasized hard-science SF, the "fiction of Engineers," a genre for which Lewis said he had "not the slightest taste" (essay "On Science Fiction," 1955), whereas we know that he was an admirer of the quite different Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, in which he published stories in 1956 and 1958. A small point, but how accurately Fowler was remembering 1952 in 2003 is crucial here.

I suggest that Fowler's belief that he saw the Dark Tower MS circa 1952 should, if mentioned in this Wikipedia article, not be implicitly or explicitly presented as _proof_ that the Dark Tower MS was not forged after Lewis's death (as Lindskoog charged).

Finally, is the Lindskoog-Hooper controversy really as over and done with as this article makes out? Hooper, Fowler, and Lindskoog are all dead and no new testimonial or documentary evidence has appeared on either side, so far as I know, since Fowler's 2003 essay. Fowler's testimony is not dispositive, as reviewed above, and as recently as 2009 and 2018, researchers have applied computer stylometry to the question of whether the Dark Tower MS matches the style of other Lewis writings and have published their results in peer-reviewed journals:

  •  Thompson, J. R., & Rasp, J. (2009). "Did CS Lewis write The Dark Tower?: An examination of the small-sample properties of the Thisted-Efron tests of authorship." Austrian Journal of Statistics, 38(2), 71-82.
  •  Oakes, Michael P. "Computer stylometry of CS Lewis’s The Dark Tower and related texts." Digital Scholarship in the Humanities 33, no. 3 (2018), 637-650.

The two papers' findings are opposed; Thompson and Rasp conclude that the style of The Dark Tower is not Lewisian, while Oakes concludes that it is. Perhaps the controversy would be most accurately described as simmering or unresolved, rather than as settled. The latter strikes me as a partisan preference, not a fact.

In any case, I believe that a clearer, more neutral version of the Controversy section is called for.

Respectfully,

Larry Lgilman909 (talk) 16:00, 3 June 2025 (UTC)Reply

What evidence, or points of evidence, could move this issue towards resolution? Based on the thoughtful tone used by the previous commenter, if there is something out there that can resolve this controversy, all could agree that it ought to be deployed; but what if no definitive evidence exists - are we then morally required to maintain this as an unresolved issue forever? I would prefer to rely upon non-definitive evidence than this maintenance. Respectfully, Bigturtle (talk) 21:11, 3 June 2025 (UTC)Reply