Talk:Southeastern Archaeological Conference
Add topicNotability discussion
[edit]A user raised a question of notability. Currently there are multiple independent sources that speak to the importance of the Conference, one of which (Lyon) is a major secondary source that primarily focuses on the impact of the New Deal on Southeastern Archaeology, which included specifically the founding of this Conference in 1937 as a response to New Deal archaeology, and elaborates on that at length. The Tushingham source covers the Conference repeatedly and thoroughly. The Griffin source explicitly credits the conference as building the methods he used. The Howe source talks about the spread of SEAC-driven work to Chicago and then back through the Southeast via the spread of Chicago trainees, most of whom ended up working in the southeast and publishing frequently via SEAC. The journal also has an Impact score. This is a notable regional journal and a notable regional professional organization. TriNotch (talk) 18:14, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- @Boynamedsue: I see you reverted my revert, as it were, and still feel there's a notability issue. I feel the notability issue has already been addressed here as you requested. But rather than going back and forth reverting, I will await clarification from you as to why you feel these sources do not adequately address the issue. TriNotch (talk) 18:45, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Hi TriNotch, thanks for leaving the tag on there while I checked the sources.
- I agree Lyon seems to be a reliable source, and from the googlebooks copy which is available online, I can see there is clearly significant coverage.
- I've only been able to read the
introductionthe précis to Tushingham, which mentions SEAC but in the sense of acknowledgements. I would argue that this constitutes routine coverage, in the same way that thanking a coworker, friend or spouse in the acknowledgments section would be. From what I have seen, the source is reliable, but it doesn't provide significant coverage. However, if any of the individual chapters, which you haven't cited, give significant coverage, that would count. Could you specify which chapter it is that gives coverage and say how much and what the context is? - Howe is a masters thesis, and as such can't contribute to notability, though it may be reliable for certain facts in the text.
- Griffin (in the 1966 edition I could find online) appears to mention the Southeastern Archaeological Conference only once on page 4. I don't think this constitutes sigcov, but if you have access and were able to describe it as being at least 2 paragraphs dedicated solely to SEAC rather than describing the methodology used, we could count it as a source giving WP:SIGCOV.
- So, overall, we need multiple reliable sources giving significant coverage, usually two are accepted. Lyon is one. Tushingham's introduction probably isn't, nor is Griffin likely to be. But if you could describe Griffin in more detail, or, more promisingly, if one of the chapters in Tushingham focuses more clearly on the SEAC, I should be able to mark the article as reviewed and remove the tag.Boynamedsue (talk) 21:11, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- @Boynamedsue:, thanks for the explanation. I may need to hit the library for this one; my own reference library is packed away. I'll leave the tag untouched until I can get back with more support. I believe the Tushingham chapters would do it but I don't have immediate access either. I can check Griffin, I think. Anyway, I shall return shortly, perhaps not today. TriNotch (talk) 23:13, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- Ok, if you get the chance that's great. All I need is something like "p27-28, discusses the conferences contributions to the excavation of _______". As we work on good faith, if you can assure me it's there and tell me what and where it is, it should be enough.Boynamedsue (talk) 06:15, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Got it, I have online access via my current employer (but had to be physically there to use it). Chapter 4, Stanley South and Kathy Deagan, Historical Archaeology in the Southeast, 1930-2000, pg 36. "The decade of the 1930s was very influential in shaping the directions of historical (and Pre-Columbian) archaeology throughout the country... the formalization of professional archaeology in the Americas occurred that same year <1935> with the establishment of the Society for American Archaeology, followed shortly by the establishment of the Southeastern Archaeological Conference in 1938." Chapter 20, Ken Sassaman, "Histories by the archaeologist, for the archaeologist," pg. 242: "SEAC itself is testimony to the integrative skills of individuals to transcend the limitations of resource and opportunity across states. Despite recent claims to the contrary, SEAC is perhaps the closest thing we will ever have to a truly egalitarian and democratic professional community. We should all be proud to share in its tradition and to sustain its existence." I feared these would not be adequate for you (The rest of the book talks a great deal about southeastern archaeology's history, but does not EXPLICITLY state that what it's saying happened at SEAC conferences or in SEAC publications, although it largely did) so I also got Jay Johnson's edited volume Development of Southeastern Archaeology (which I will edit into the article as well). Chapter 2, Jon Gibson, "Ceramics," pg. 20. Gibson is explaining that Southeastern-focused archaeological literature was being under-published in American Antiquity and other national outlets: "Still, southern archaeological literature was flourishing. It was simply being published at home. The South has always had a strong regional publishing base. The Southeastern Archaeological Conference proceedings and newsletters have dispensed much of the literature, and state geological departments and professional-caliber state archaeological societies have also been important outlets." Gibson is a well-known regional archaeologist famous for work on Poverty Point. That's about as explicit a statement of the importance of the conference as anyone could want, I think. I'll add it to the article but will leave the tag until you consent to its removal. TriNotch (talk) 19:07, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks, these are debatable on their own, but I think perhaps, given how solid Lyon is, the existence of the journal and the cumulative quantity of small references, the article is probably justified. I've reviewed and I'll take the tags off now. Apologies for dragging this out, but given the nature of the sourcing, if I hadn't done this there is a fair chance it would have sat on the NPP waiting list for a year or more or even indefinitely. Thanks for your constructive attitude.Boynamedsue (talk) 20:02, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Thank you for the compliment, and the article is stronger now, so thanks also for driving me to establish notability more clearly. As an insider to the Conference it was confusing - SEAC is the second-largest archaeology conference in North America when it comes to pre-Columbian research, probably in the top 5 or 6 for all of the Americas on the same subject, and it defined much of the course of the discipline - of course it's notable. Archaeology conferences a tenth of its size and a fraction of its importance are notable ("The Iowa Archaeology Society." "The Archaeological and Anthropological Society of Victoria." They cover a fraction of the scope of SEAC.). But I understand that neither you, the encyclopedia, nor any other editor or reader outside the field would know that without clear demonstration in the article. Anyway, this was a pleasant exchange. I'll likely add more to the article in the future. See you around. TriNotch (talk) 20:57, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks, these are debatable on their own, but I think perhaps, given how solid Lyon is, the existence of the journal and the cumulative quantity of small references, the article is probably justified. I've reviewed and I'll take the tags off now. Apologies for dragging this out, but given the nature of the sourcing, if I hadn't done this there is a fair chance it would have sat on the NPP waiting list for a year or more or even indefinitely. Thanks for your constructive attitude.Boynamedsue (talk) 20:02, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Got it, I have online access via my current employer (but had to be physically there to use it). Chapter 4, Stanley South and Kathy Deagan, Historical Archaeology in the Southeast, 1930-2000, pg 36. "The decade of the 1930s was very influential in shaping the directions of historical (and Pre-Columbian) archaeology throughout the country... the formalization of professional archaeology in the Americas occurred that same year <1935> with the establishment of the Society for American Archaeology, followed shortly by the establishment of the Southeastern Archaeological Conference in 1938." Chapter 20, Ken Sassaman, "Histories by the archaeologist, for the archaeologist," pg. 242: "SEAC itself is testimony to the integrative skills of individuals to transcend the limitations of resource and opportunity across states. Despite recent claims to the contrary, SEAC is perhaps the closest thing we will ever have to a truly egalitarian and democratic professional community. We should all be proud to share in its tradition and to sustain its existence." I feared these would not be adequate for you (The rest of the book talks a great deal about southeastern archaeology's history, but does not EXPLICITLY state that what it's saying happened at SEAC conferences or in SEAC publications, although it largely did) so I also got Jay Johnson's edited volume Development of Southeastern Archaeology (which I will edit into the article as well). Chapter 2, Jon Gibson, "Ceramics," pg. 20. Gibson is explaining that Southeastern-focused archaeological literature was being under-published in American Antiquity and other national outlets: "Still, southern archaeological literature was flourishing. It was simply being published at home. The South has always had a strong regional publishing base. The Southeastern Archaeological Conference proceedings and newsletters have dispensed much of the literature, and state geological departments and professional-caliber state archaeological societies have also been important outlets." Gibson is a well-known regional archaeologist famous for work on Poverty Point. That's about as explicit a statement of the importance of the conference as anyone could want, I think. I'll add it to the article but will leave the tag until you consent to its removal. TriNotch (talk) 19:07, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- Ok, if you get the chance that's great. All I need is something like "p27-28, discusses the conferences contributions to the excavation of _______". As we work on good faith, if you can assure me it's there and tell me what and where it is, it should be enough.Boynamedsue (talk) 06:15, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
- @Boynamedsue:, thanks for the explanation. I may need to hit the library for this one; my own reference library is packed away. I'll leave the tag untouched until I can get back with more support. I believe the Tushingham chapters would do it but I don't have immediate access either. I can check Griffin, I think. Anyway, I shall return shortly, perhaps not today. TriNotch (talk) 23:13, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
- So, overall, we need multiple reliable sources giving significant coverage, usually two are accepted. Lyon is one. Tushingham's introduction probably isn't, nor is Griffin likely to be. But if you could describe Griffin in more detail, or, more promisingly, if one of the chapters in Tushingham focuses more clearly on the SEAC, I should be able to mark the article as reviewed and remove the tag.Boynamedsue (talk) 21:11, 9 November 2026 (UTC)