Jump to content

Talk:Rule 34

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 1 day ago by New editing editor in topic Replacing the lead images

Replacing the lead images

[edit]

The image used on this page contains an illicit image of inklings from splatoon, which are characters that are 14 years old. Is there any way to report the user who added it and change the image to anything else? Whatever can be done to take down the image is for the best, I feel. ~2025-40178-11 (talk) 08:14, 12 December 2025 (UTC)Reply

pinging @Dabmasterars as the editor who added the illustrations, not to 'report' them as this TA suggested. the choice of images could certainly be improved here. looking at the linked Commons category, the best options I see are Bowsette (Internet famous fan-made character, surprisingly free) and our own mascot Wikipe-tan (the adult version; avoiding as while there is no prohibition per se in using her for pornographic works, it is taboo after she was used in an old version for the article Lolicon).  Juwan  🕊️🌈 13:56, 6 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
@~2025-40178-11 @Juwan
  • 1. This is not pornography. No characters are having sex. These images are erotic, not pornographic.
  • 2. Child pornography involves real children. The characters depicted on the images are purely fictional.
  • 3. The images were already nominated for deletion on Commons but were kept (this was for fan art guideline reasons, but still).
  • 4. The "taboo" of using erotic images of Wikipe-tan was set by Jimmy Wales, who erroneously deleted photos of Wikipetan that were later undeleted (1, 2, 3) due to Wales' deletion reason being pretty much "I don't like it", an invalid reason.
  • 5. Wikipedia is not censored.
If you have any more questions, I'll answer them. Note that I'm neither the creator nor the uploader of these images, I only added them due to them fitting the article. Oh, and don't try remove the images without a proper reason, it will get reverted immediately. Dabmasterars [RU/COM] (talk/contribs) 14:27, 6 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Dabmasterars thanks for the response given. though a lot of it is quite not directed at the point I was trying to make.
  • re point 1–2: the distinction between child pornography and erotic content involving young fictional characters is not too relevant to me, as the concern raised here would apply either way.
  • re point 5 and last sentence: not suggesting to censor but a more suitable replacement (WP:GRATUITOUS). re: for point 4 is not saying that one should avoid solely because of taboo, but laying out my rationale as to avoid a discussion like this from comming up again.
as such, my proposal would to be replace the current images as outlined above.  Juwan  🕊️🌈 15:11, 6 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
Personally, I'd argue that no lead image (as was the case with the Not safe for work article) would be more suitable than the current image. (Frankly I'm surprised that the current image had even survived a deletion request on Commons, but that's a different scenario.) Sugar Tax (talk) 16:38, 14 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
Comment: replaced the thread title to be more be direct to what is being discussed.  Juwan  🕊️🌈 15:23, 6 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
For archiving sake and easier to find, the splatoon example was deleted from Commons in c:Commons:Deletion requests/File:栃木県芳賀町東高橋1233-1で書かれた絵.jpg, per "c:COM:DW of copyrighted characters" Issac I Navarro (talk) 20:37, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • As seen by the page history I originally included this image. However, used the one in current use, as it seems convey the topic more directly.

(File:LoliWikipetan2.jpg Wikipe-tan the unofficial mascot of Wikipedia, in a swimsuit.) Hope that I was helpful, Cheers. Issac I Navarro (talk) 15:02, 19 February 2026 (UTC)Reply

Old thread, however, leaveing this here incase anyone is intrested: there is also File:Mei from Overwatch by nikuriii.png, and File:Playboy parody cover featuring Wikipe-tan.png Issac I Navarro (talk) 02:17, 19 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Overwatch file fits more with Overwatch and pornography, which you deleted it from. Dabmasterars [RU/COM] (talk/contribs) 08:47, 19 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
agreed. plus Playboy-type media is not something one typically Rule 34. Juwan 🕊️🌈 09:09, 19 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Dabmasterars, I changed my mind. If you would like add it to the article, I will support that decision and if others disagrees then the matter could be taken to the Talk. Issac I Navarro (talk) 14:14, 19 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sure thing. It seems like no one else objected to the inclusion in that article. Dabmasterars [RU/COM] (talk/contribs) 15:21, 19 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I absolutely object to using any image of Wikipe-tan for multiple reasons. First of all, the character is a child and was created and envisioned as a child, and having her "aged up" doesn't change that. Secondly, using what is, in effect, a mascot of Wikipedia creates the impression that the image is endorsed by WMF/the community in some way. Especially considering how the image is barely skirting around pedophilia/"lolicon" content, that should not be the message that we want broadcast to the public. ArtemisiaGentileschiFan (talk) 19:33, 8 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@ArtemisiaGentileschiFan, I personally don't get the history of wikipe tan. One of these days I will have to take a look.
However, if you wish to remove sure.
Here are some other alternatives:
Side note there is Commons:Category:Rule 34 of Wikipe-tan
If you find any of these to be acceptable or if there is a different one, send me a ping. However, I am not all that passionate about this subject. Issac I Navarro (talk) 20:01, 8 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Issac I Navarro: I've added a new image. Honestly, it doesn't matter to me which one is used as long as it isn't something as pedophilia-adjacent as Inklings or Wikipe-tan. ArtemisiaGentileschiFan (talk) 20:05, 8 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Okay. Well, then the original claim of the artist making porn of toddler Wikipe-tan is not proven, still.
I doubt that this is an issue, really, unless anything else is shown. The image is depicting a fictional adult. I would strongly support the inclusion of the image. ⚙ Crash >> Organhaver ( it / he | talk to me, maybe? ) 23:04, 9 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Why do you "strongly support" that specific image? It really doesn't matter what image is used as long as the concept of rule 34 is communicated, so why bother using a controversial image if it can be easily avoided? ArtemisiaGentileschiFan (talk) 15:21, 10 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sure, whoops. I just want to keep the status quo from before the more recent discussion here. ⚙ Crash >> Organhaver ( it / he | talk to me, maybe? ) 16:55, 10 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I've always seen it in a "separate the art from the artist" sort of way. Since she's creative commons, there's no possible way for Kasuga to profit from her in any way. Also, her design is based on ME-tan, so I don't think she was made to be fetishistic or a toddler. Plus I think I read somewhere on their Twitter that they're glad they didn't do "anything extreme" with her, so the pornographic art of her they're talking about was probably fan art or a photoshop. New editing editor (talk) 05:28, 11 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
For archiving sake, here's better confirmation where Kasuga says they're "hard [pressed]" to depict Wikipe-tan in a lolicon manner. New editing editor (talk) 19:43, 16 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree. Does this count as enough to restore the old image, or does anyone else have anything last to say?
Also– in the caption it is said to be photoshopped, so, yes. ⚙ Crash >> Organhaver ( it / he | talk to me, maybe? ) 06:20, 11 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Since the new one doesn't convey the rule at all, I'd probably restore the old image. This site has a whole Wikiproject for a show that lines the pockets of a child trafficker, so a basically public domain character is the least of our worries. New editing editor (talk) 07:10, 11 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
On second thought, the image should probably be reverted further back to this one instead. I'm pretty sure that whole "Kasuga made porn of Wikipe-tan" rumor started because that exact image was misattributed to him on Danbooru instead of the person who made the third party edit. New editing editor (talk) 05:03, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
sure, there was consensus previously to use it...
ArtemisiaGentileschiFan, just broke my understanding of Wikipe tan. One of these days I need to do a deep dive for myself. Issac I Navarro (talk) 05:09, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
 Done If it makes you feel any better, Wikipe-tan is DEFINITELY not a fetish thing. According to this video, turning different concepts into maids was just a popular trend on the Japanese internet around the time she was made. New editing editor (talk) 05:28, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@New editing editor, one day, i will do a deep dive and make an informed decision myself, about Wikipe-tan. But for now, I am seeing it as odd, for lack of a better words.
I am okay with fetish stuff. I like to think I can be open-minded. I'm quite active on Commons and have nominated for deletion hundreds of files about nudity and categorized thousands more. So that is not necessarily a hard no for me. But when it comes to kids, that is a hell no! As I've been very blunt at the current RfC on Lolicon. And we should just call it what it is.
It interesting that we do use a drawing by Wikipe-tan' creater for that page, given the very little I just found and what else they apparently draw. Issac I Navarro (talk) 05:44, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I can definitely agree that lolicon is abhorrent. I think for me, knowing that Kasuga is barred from ever monetarily gaining from her and that a ton of the Wikipe-tan example images aren't even made by him anymore eases a lot of the discomfort I have with her usage (but I get why others would feel differently). Maybe that's why Wales said he isn't "particularly agitated" with the fact that people like her, but I digress. New editing editor (talk) 10:40, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I really don't see any reason to restore the Wikipe-tan image. I don't know why it matters so much, the point of having an image is to represent the concept and the current image does that perfectly well. ArtemisiaGentileschiFan (talk) 14:39, 11 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I gave many alternatives above to pick from.5 Issac I Navarro (talk) 15:30, 11 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Rule 34 is about pornographic fan art. The current image doesn't convey the "fan art" part and the five alternates either don't display the concept as well or aren't as high quality as the old image. New editing editor (talk) 16:21, 11 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Need for lead image?

[edit]

As far as I can tell, this article existed without a lead image from 2013 until November of 2025, when Dabmasterars added two now-deleted images. Dabmasterars has since been banned by the WMF. The current image is an aged-up and sexed-up version of Wikipe-tan. I would not have recognized the character without the caption. I don't believe the average reader will be familiar with Wikipe-tan or know how the image differs from the usual version. It is just decoration.

I do not believe that an image is necessary to explain the concept. Is there any objection to returning to the longstanding status of having no lead image? If not, why not? HappyBeachDreams (talk) 16:36, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

There was a bigger discussion already about changing the lead image above, I genuinely think it is fine. Also, really, the character does not have to be recognizable. It just has to represent what the topic is (from WP:LEADIMAGE). I would personally disagree that an image is unnecessary. ⚙ Crash >> Organhaver ( it / he | talk to me, maybe? ) 21:15, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Organhaver, I just removed the file for now per Jimbo Wales idea on his talk page.
I tend to agree with Wales that we probably should find a better more encyclopedic example for this page. Issac I Navarro (talk) 20:25, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Comment: The question isn't which image to use but whether or not the article needs an image at all. The image use policy says The purpose of an image is to increase readers' understanding of the article's subject matter, usually by directly depicting people, things, activities, and concepts described in the article. The correct response in this discussion is an argument about how an image would increase the reader's understanding. If you want to have a discussion about which image to use, please start a separate discussion. HappyBeachDreams (talk) 22:23, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

@HappyBeachDreams, meh. That is how I feel about this. For me it truly doesn't matter what file we use.
I am on the fence though a file would be helpful. Just about evey page that is linked in Glossary of BDSM, has an explicit file that serves an encyclopedic and educational use. Issac I Navarro (talk) 23:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I would oppose adding any image unless scholarly sources state the specific image is an example of Rule 34. — BillHPike (talk, contribs) 23:46, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
What?? That's an extremely strict rule. Its already difficult to get a free-use image of this. ⚙ Crash >> Organhaver ( it / he | talk to me, maybe? ) 00:06, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't think that even is a rule. New editing editor (talk) 00:56, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
You are mistaken. The rule is "Any material whose verifiability has been challenged or is likely to be challenged, must include an inline citation to a reliable source that directly supports the material. Any material that needs an inline citation but does not have one may be removed." --Wikipedia:Verifiability
If there is no reliable secondary source that directly states that an image is an example of rule 34, the image cannot be used. --Guy Macon (talk) 01:08, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
It's talking about claims made inside of the image caption, not the image itself. New editing editor (talk) 01:15, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
What part of "any material" are you having trouble understanding? The caption and the image are both covered by WP:V. Placing an image on the Rule 34 page implies that the image has something to do with Rule 34. The caption should explain what. --Guy Macon (talk) 05:05, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
In the second sentence of the article, it says, "The concept is commonly depicted as fan art of normally non-erotic subjects engaging in sexual activity." The image is in fact fan art of a normally non-erotic subject engaging in sexual activity. New editing editor (talk) 07:40, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Nor is there a WP:RS that talks about any specific file we use for anything? We often use the most appropriate educationally useful file that is available under an appropriate license. For instance, this can be seen in how we use a photograph of BLP; we often use the most recent photo that we have licensed under a CC license. Nothing to do with whether a source has covered the specific photograph. I've never interacted with any file in the way you are suggesting. Further, I haven't seen a FA or GA pages do this. Unless I am grossly misinterpreting what you suggesting. I am deeply perplexed by your suggestion.
Now, to be clear, I am not suggesting that we use File:LoliWikipetan.jpg, but at least we have a source that directly mentions the file: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2008/dec/18/wikipedia-jimmy-wales. That being said, it makes perfect sense why we should not use this on the very basic principle of common sense; having an unofficial mascot represent a 18+ subject matter is just not a good look in any way. Issac I Navarro (talk) 02:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Re "We often use the most appropriate educationally useful file that is available under an appropriate license" indeed we do. All of the time. And in most cases nobody objects; so it isn't "material whose verifiability has been challenged or is likely to be challenged". For example the first image at Dolly Parton. Because it hasn't been challenged, it doesn't need a source that establishes that the image is indeed Dolly Parton. If there was a serious challenge, we would have to provide a source that verifies that or remove it.
As for the Guardian source, it says
"Jimbo once removed a photograph of autofellatio from its relevant article, with the comment: 'This image is completely unacceptable for Wikipedia - I don't even consider this borderline.' ... In June 2007, several lolicon versions of Wikipe-tan were uploaded. In the midst of the deletion debate, Jimbo deleted the images, noting, 'pedophilic sexualization of a community mascot? No. - email me if you have questions.' "
That source does not directly support the claim that LoliWikipetan.jpg> Wikipe-tan Commission 2 by SpagMushrooms.png is an example of Rule 34. Is it even among the images Jimbo deleted? --Guy Macon (talk) 05:05, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
By "material whose verifiability has been challenged or is likely to be challenged" it's referring to unsourced text. By your logic, see also sections and external links would also need citations. New editing editor (talk) 07:32, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
That is correct. If a see also or external link is likely to be challenged, then it needs a citation to a reliable source. "All material" means "All material".
For example, if you added a see also to The TRUTH About Black Helicopters! and I challenged it, claiming no such page exists, the link to the citation proving that it exists would be The TRUTH About Black Helicopters!. A link to a web page is itself a citation establishing that the web page exists at that URL. It is verifiable, and per WP:ABOUTSELF the existence of the web page is a reliable source for the claim that the web page exists.
If instead you added a see also to The Brobdingnag Encyclopedia of Procrastination and I challenged it, claiming no such page exists, you would have to provide a link to a reliable source that establishes that the web page exists at that URL.
These are, of course, silly examples, but the silliness comes from your argument that just because a link to a source is itself a link to a source establishing that the source exists this somehow makes it OK for you to insert totally unsourced claims such as claiming that LoliWikipetan.jpg> Wikipe-tan Commission 2 by SpagMushrooms.png is an example of Rule 34. --Guy Macon (talk) 12:09, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
First of all, I'm not arguing to get LoliWikipetan.jpg on the page, I'm arguing that using the art of the adult version would be harmless. Second of all, In the second sentence of the article, it says, "The concept is commonly depicted as fan art of normally non-erotic subjects engaging in sexual activity." The image is in fact fan art of a normally non-erotic subject (Wikipe-tan's adult design) engaging in sexual activity (BDSM). Third of all, if any random person were to delete a portion of an article and said "these aren't real words" would you have to add a reference to a dictionary for EVERY single word they deleted to bring it back? I feel like you're pulling a WP:FORCEDINTERPRET here. New editing editor (talk) 14:42, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I struck out LoliWikipetan.jpg> and replaced it with Wikipe-tan Commission 2 by SpagMushrooms.png. Which also has zero sources establishing that it is an example of Rule 34. I apologize for the error. --Guy Macon (talk) 17:20, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Guy Macon, you might have missed that in the above message (this comment specifically), I point out, I agree with Wales that it should not be a Wikipe-tan example. In reference to this comment made by Wales on his User talk. Issac I Navarro (talk) 17:31, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
No need to ping me. My apologies. I am well aware of your position and agree with it. Sorry if I implied otherwise. --Guy Macon (talk) 18:38, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
All, good. Apologies for the ping; as I was using mobile it sometimes auto populates the reply I am unsure why those messages are collapsed though? As they seems relevant to the topic at hand. I also merged both sections and added Template:Outdent, after I seen you undo the improper close. Issac I Navarro (talk) 18:55, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Again, the image is fan art of a normally non-erotic subject (Wikipe-tan's adult design) engaging in sexual activity (BDSM), which is exactly what examples of Rule 34 are described as in the second sentence in the article. Per WP:BLUE, it doesn't need a citation to be in the article. Also, the only reason I think it should be used is because it's the highest quality image that follows all the criteria. New editing editor (talk) 18:00, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
WP:BLUE is an essay. WP:V is a policy. If you think that your WP:OR claim (that "Wikipe-tan Commission 2 by SpagMushrooms.png" is an example of Rule 34) is common knowledge comparable to the claims that the sky is blue or that most people have five digits on each hand, I have nothing more to say to you other than a gentle warning that if you edit any page according to your rather unusual interpretation of Wikipedia's policies it will not go well for you. Arguing for your interpretation of Wikipedia's policies is fine, but if you want to actually change the policy you need to make a case on the talk page of the policy -- in this case Wikipedia talk:Verifiability. We can't change policies here, and ignoring the policy isn't an option.
"Any material whose verifiability has been challenged or is likely to be challenged, must include an inline citation to a reliable source that directly supports the material. Any material that needs an inline citation but does not have one may be removed." --Wikipedia:Verifiability
--Guy Macon (talk) 18:38, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Well, the article states The concept is commonly depicted as fan art of normally non-erotic subjects engaging in sexual activity, which is supported by this source. If you're asking for a source that confirms what's depicted in the image fits that criteria, then if clicking on a see also link establishes that it exists, clicking on the image and its link to Commons establishes that it is an example of rule 34 since it's in the category "Rule 34 of Wikipe-tan". New editing editor (talk) 19:21, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you think that inclusion in a wikipedia commons category is a reliable source, with all due respect, you need to stop editing Wikipedia. Competence is required and you appear to lack the capacity to identify reliable sources despite being asked multiple times to read WP:RS. Free clue: anyone can put anything in any category, and the other editors may or may not catch it. --Guy Macon (talk) 20:11, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm not arguing that??? I'm arguing your interpretation of the verifiably policy is faulty. New editing editor (talk) 20:31, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Does this work?

Illustration of adult Wikipe-tan, an unofficial mascot of Wikipedia, wearing lingerie, suggestively looking at the viewer while holding a flogger.
An illustration of Wikipe-tan's adult design in a stylized softcore adult-themed costume, featuring fishnet stockings, stiletto heels, and holding a flogger; the concept of Rule 34 is commonly depicted as fan art of a normally non-erotic subject engaging in sexual activity.[1]

New editing editor (talk) 16:37, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

No. You have once again failed to provide a link to a reliable source linking the image to Rule 34. It takes more than you writing a caption based upon your WP:OR. --Guy Macon (talk) 16:50, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Again, if clicking on a see also link establishes that it exists, clicking on the image and its link to Commons establishes that it is an example of rule 34 since it's in the category "Rule 34 of Wikipe-tan". New editing editor (talk) 16:51, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you think that inclusion in a wikipedia commons category is a reliable source, with all due respect, you need to stop editing Wikipedia. Competence is required and you appear to lack the capacity to identify reliable sources despite being asked multiple times to read WP:RS. --Guy Macon (talk) 20:22, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
The source shows that non-erotic subjects doing erotic things is commonly how Rule 34 is depicted. Do you want a source telling you that the image is fan art of adult Wikipe-tan in fetish gear? New editing editor (talk) 17:00, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Nobody gives a fig about your WP:OR. Provide a link to a reliable source linking the image to Rule 34 or go away.
WP:OR says "The definition of original research includes any analysis or synthesis of published material that reaches or implies a conclusion not stated by the sources. To demonstrate that material is not original research, editors must be able to cite – even if not yet expressly cited – reliable, published sources that are directly related to the topic of the article and directly support the material being presented." This has been explained to you multiple times. You are engaging in tendentious editing. It is very likely that you will be blocked from editing Wikipedia if you don't stop. --Guy Macon (talk) 20:22, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I have started an RFC for this discussion. Please do not threaten to block people for arguing against your interpretation of verifiably. New editing editor (talk) 20:30, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
No threat. I am not an administrator, and could not block you if I were per WP:INVOLVED. That being said, you might want to consider the fact that an editor who has been on Wikipedia for over twenty years and has made 64,000 edits is predicting what is likely to happen if you continue your present pattern of behavior. Or you can continue and find out if I am right. Your choice. I wrote an essay for editors who find themselves in the exact situation you are currently in. You can read it at WP:1AM.
I am going to stop responding to you now. Please refrain from interpreting silence as agreement. --Guy Macon (talk) 03:52, 16 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
@HappyBeachDreams is there a reason you undid my edits on this page? You didn't explain any reason in your edit summary Issac I Navarro (talk) 15:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Issac I Navarro This is not a discussion about image choice. That's why I started it as a separate discussion. Please stop edit warring before I report you. No reply or explanation is necessary, just stop edit warring. HappyBeachDreams (talk) 21:35, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
@HappyBeachDreams, I have yet to WP:3RR, I pinged you here asking for the why you disagree with me changing the header into a subsection. Additionally, I also left in my edit summary why I believe they should be merged as both discussions are really about the same thing when one break down the core issue.
I see no reason to war with you anyone for this matter. Especially for an issue such as trivial as change it to a subsection and removing a collapsed template. Issac I Navarro (talk) 21:42, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
If instead you added a see also to The Brobdingnag Encyclopedia of Procrastination and I challenged it, claiming no such page exists, you would have to provide a link to a reliable source that establishes that the web page exists at that URL. So what you're saying is, even if page DID exist, you'd still have to search for a news outlet that says the page exists to re-add it or an additional primary source linking to the article confirming it exists next to a link to the article? This seems like a huge slap in the face to WP:BLUE. New editing editor (talk) 18:24, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
No. If The Brobdingnag Encyclopedia of Procrastination was a page that existed, clicking on the link would establish that it existed. No news outlet needed. This has been explained to you before. And WP:BLUE is still an essay. You don't have to follow the advice in essays. WP:V is a policy. You are required to follow policies, even if you don't like them. --Guy Macon (talk) 18:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
@New editing editor, if you feel this passionate about it you can always see about starting a WP:RfC. However, this really seems like a minor issue. Issac I Navarro (talk) 17:03, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

You can't cite an image inline. An image is not a "fact or claim". Images are more of a special thing where it can be added/removed based on if editors believe it fits the topic. If I added an image of a [Brand] toothbrush to the Toothbrush page, I do not need to cite that the image is actually a toothbrush or if it is only a different type of brush. It is believed to fall under the definition (being: small tightly clustered bristles and a thin handle). ⚙ Crash >> Organhaver ( it / he | talk to me, maybe? ) 20:21, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Comment: WP:GRATUITOUS is an established consensus, and we are not obliged to provide WP:THERAPY to those who struggle to understand community norms. — BillHPike (talk, contribs) 19:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Is it really that offensive? Perhaps I am just somewhat jaded from having seen far, far, far worse, in Commons deletion discussions and Commons as a whole. But all things considered, File:Wikipe-tan Commission 2 by SpagMushrooms.png is extremely tame. I wouldn't say this is image crosses into WP:ASTONISH. Though, I honestly couldn't care any less what we use or have any preference either way. I concur with the observation that having an unofficial community mascot depicted in an 18+ setting is not exactly the most ideal look. That makes common sense. However, maybe it's WP:NOTCOMMON for others. Thus, if others consider it appropriate for this page, I am not particularly inclined to argue against it either. This is a very softcore example but we do have other alternatives that are not wikipetan. That said, I think it is worth remembering that Wikipedia:Sexual content, generally permits even explicit imagery only in circumstances where its educational value is substantial. (WP:HARDCORE)
To be clear, I am not suggesting that a drawing of a community mascot dressed in an WP:NSFW, BDSM fetish outfit meets that same standard. Nor do I care if others think it does. I can also appreciate the argument that an image may be particularly helpful to readers with aphantasia, who may otherwise face genuine difficulty forming a mental picture of the subject. Furthermore, I have found Wikipedia Signpost: "Explicit sexual content draws fire" to be a good read.
As for the file that was just added File:Rule 34 (Paheal) home page.png, I don't see any sources or mention in the page how this is related to page. And it's WP:ONUS to gain consensus for it. Issac I Navarro (talk) 20:42, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
having an unofficial community mascot depicted in an 18+ setting is not exactly the most ideal look. Weirdly enough, this image went viral on Twitter back in August and the reaction was overwhelmingly positive. New editing editor (talk) 20:58, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Why do I care what happens on social media? How is that relevant to us as an encyclopedia? We are WP:NOTBLOG, nor are we WP:NOTGALLERY.
Apologies if I am contradicting myself; I assume that some may find my stance confusing. However, I genuinely have no preference either way. WP:Wikilawyering is generally frowned upon, but for this instance it seems acceptable. I am simply trying to follow our guidelines and policies to the letter when dealing with a situation such as this one. Issac I Navarro (talk) 21:08, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I wasn't saying the Tweet should be used as a source or anything, I was just showing it wouldn't be reputation-ruining to use the image. Apologies if my intent wasn't clear. New editing editor (talk) 22:45, 14 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I feel like the discussion so far is focusing on the wrong thing. Guy Macon's comment sorta turned this into an argument about the extreme specifics of the verifiably policy when that isn't really what this is about in the first place. Nowhere in the verifiably policy does it say that the citation has to be about the specific image used. It only needs the be about why an image like it would be in the lead of the article, which the new proposed lead does.
Currently, there is a proposition to add the Wikipe-tan image to the lead and move the webcomic to "History." I agree with Gråbergs Gråa Sång that we should reach consensus based on WP:LEADIMAGE guidance instead. New editing editor (talk) 14:17, 16 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

References

  1. ↑ Dewey, Caitlin (April 6, 2016). "Is Rule 34 actually true?: An investigation into the Internet's most risqué law". The Washington Post. Washington, D.C.: Nash Holdings. Archived from the original on May 29, 2020. Retrieved May 27, 2018.

RfC: Do lead images need citations?

[edit]

Does a lead image need a citation to confirm it's an example of the subject? New editing editor (talk) 20:28, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Imagine that I replaced the current lead image at Cockcroft–Walton generator with File:Adolf Hitler colorized.jpg, repeatedly asserting that the image is clearly related to the topic. Would I not be required to back up my assertion with a citation to a reliable source showing the connection? Or can I simply say the magic words "images don't require citations" and expect everyone to assume without evidence that there is a connection simply because I say so?
The reason the question is non-neutral is because the vast majority of lead images on Wikipedia are obviously related to the subject of the page and thus are never challenged. It's like asking "should blonds be put in prison?" when the actual question is "Should Jeffrey Dahmer be put in prison?" --Guy Macon (talk) 22:59, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
What part of the image makes it not an example of Rule 34 though? Sure it's not a popular example of it, but it still follows all the criteria. New editing editor (talk) 23:05, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
What part of "...a reliable source that directly supports the material" are you having trouble understanding? Serious question. I am trying to figure out whether you are doing this on purpose or whether you lack the ability to understand clearly worded sentences in Wikipedia policies. --Guy Macon (talk) 23:17, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Verifiability is the quality or state of being confirmable. The image was removed from the article because it was felt that it might not be needed to illustrate the concept, which does not fall under verifiability. New editing editor (talk) 23:37, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Verifiability discussions work like this:
Step 1: A user calls into question if an image in the article is related to the subject.
Step 2: Discussion is had about the image.
Step 3: If it goes in favor for the image, it gets readded to the article with a citation confirming why the image is used.
Your argument for not using the image is faulty because:
A: Its need in the article is what's being contested, not the verifiably that it displays the concept.
B: Your rationale for step 1 is that step 3 hasn't been completed.
C: The citation does not have to be about the specific image used. It only needs the be about why an image like it would be in the article. New editing editor (talk) 23:55, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
"Needs citation" isn't really helpful here, images are generally (ever?) not cited in the hyperlink sense. Since there is disagreement, what is needed is WP:CONSENSUS, hopefully based on guidance like WP:LEADIMAGE, MOS:IMAGES, WP:USERG (as in why should we use fan-art without any article content/RS-connection to the article) and what have you. A reasonable RFC-question could have been "What, if any, leadimage should we pick for this article?" Gråbergs Gråa Sång (talk) 07:54, 16 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
No there isn't! The policy says "no free equivalent is available, or could be created, that would serve the same encyclopedic purpose". There is nothing else "that would serve the same encyclopedic purpose" - if you like there are alternatives, but no equivalents. Johnbod (talk) 03:55, 16 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Agree with this reasoning. Gråbergs Gråa Sång (talk) 07:56, 16 November 2026 (UTC)Reply