Jump to content

Talk:Queerbaiting

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Inadequate reliable sources

[edit]

The sources used most heavily in this article in its current state are:

  • Scout, Emmett. "Please Do Not Bait the Queers". The Next. University of Washington. This is a dead link to an "editorial" where the domain name does not appear to have any connection with the University of Washington.
  • Bridges, Rose. "How Do We Solve A Problem Like 'Queerbaiting'?". AutoStraddle. This is a blog post on a website which describes itself as "a serious labor of love that started out as a group of friends" and "still run by a dedicated team of passionate weirdos" who have "thrown parties, arranged worldwide meet-ups and launched a very successful line of t-shirts, stickers, bags, tank tops, crop tops, hoodies, boyshorts and ‘zines".
  • Panigrahi, Kerishma. "Queerbaiting in Online Communities: Television, Fandom, and the Politics of Representation" (PDF). Wordpress. A Wordpress posting with no further information immediately available about its provenance.
  • Nordin, Emma (2015-01-01). "From Queer Reading to Queerbaiting : The battle over the polysemic text and the power of hermeneutics". Master's thesis. Like it says, someone's Master's thesis.

That's very much lacking in the sort of reliable sources we would like to see to establish notability of what may just be a neologism. MPS1992 (talk) 12:13, 12 August 2018 (UTC)Reply

I disagree with the statement that the article is lacking in reliable sources to prove notability. The first article does have a connection to University of Washington. per the archived version of the page cited in the article. As for the second one, I think it's fine, honestly, as she also wrote for Anime News Network, Bitch, and elsewhere, according to her bio on the site. The third one, I've put a note on it to ask for a better source. The fourth one is fine, as I see no issue with citing master's theses here, especially since that source is only cited once in the entire article. Historyday01 (talk) 14:37, 6 January 2026 (UTC)Reply

Re: Sherlock

[edit]

I agree with the commenter in the archive who asserts the claim about Sherlock is poorly sourced. I've seen the show several times and love it; it depicts a friendship between two men; there's no queerbaiting at all. I think the confusion arises here because the depiction of actual friendships between men is so rare. Viriditas (talk) 02:09, 18 January 2026 (UTC)Reply

I'm not exactly sure which commenter in the archive you are referring to. BigNole said "the top of the page has Sherlock and Watson, with the disclaimer that everyone attached the show deny any romantic underpinnings, but because you can find some "critics" that view it as romantic you're making the leap that it is "queerbaiting"." while Czarnibog said incorrrectly that the article "does not read like an actual encyclopedic discussion of an LGBT issue but one person's angry blog post about Supernatural and Sherlock not featuring enough canonical slash" (the article has changed since), and rambling from an IP address which is not comprehensible. I'd argue there really hasn't been a substantive discussion of those who say Sherlock is queerbaiting, or not. Presently the sources on whether John and Sherlock are queerbaiting are: The Daily Dot, YouTube (cast denying it), Autostraddle, and The Next. Even so, I would argue that there is enough evidence at Johnlock#Accusations of queerbaiting to justify keeping it here. If so, we need to improve the sourcing of this claim, and attribute it appropriately, as saying the series is queerbaiting is only one interpretation, as others like yourself note that there is no queerbaiting. Historyday01 (talk) 05:11, 18 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Viriditas, the article does not (and should not) claim that Sherlock is queerbaiting. It merely documents that "some critics have described the depiction as queerbaiting". This assertion is well sourced. I don't think that we have the sources needed to come to a conclusion, as Wikipedia, whether the allegation of queerbaiting is correct. Sandstein 20:23, 18 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
Exactly right. You said exactly what I was thinking as well. Historyday01 (talk) 17:59, 29 January 2026 (UTC)Reply

Stranger Things: Byler

[edit]

I think that rather than depicting Sherlock as the queerbaiting frontman it should be changed with something about Byler-gate that was arguably the most elaborate and impacting queerbaiting of recent times. Way more notorious and important than ever seen Tancristo (talk) 17:56, 29 January 2026 (UTC)Reply

For Wikipedia to write about the Byler queerbait, we need proof that it is notable! We need to link articles about Byler being a queerbait. As of now, I haven’t yet found any, but I have found articles about Stranger Things giving poor romantic arcs for queer people. Like this one, and this one! ~2026-66612-5 (talk) 17:22, 3 February 2026 (UTC)Reply
I can agree on that. Previous sourcing on this was not good, which is why it was removed. We need reliable sourcing about possible queerbaiting in Stranger Things. Historyday01 (talk) 12:47, 4 February 2026 (UTC)Reply

Neutrality

[edit]

Hello! I have a question. Do others feel the lead on this page is written from a neutral point of view? If queerbaiting is defined as a marketing technique, in my mind that would mean that marketing professionals are consciously, explicitly using it, with that label, in their work. But the rest of the article gives me the impression that queerbaiting is a term used by those who critique the practice, not those who engage in it. Please let me know your thoughts. OrdinaryOtter (talk) 13:57, 3 February 2026 (UTC)Reply

I think it's fine. I don't think marketing professionals are going to openly say "oh, we are queerbaiting, that is what we do," as they'd receive backlash, but they will do it, either consciously or subconsciously, just as people don't, usually, openly say they are racist, transphobic, etc. It is a term to describe what marketing professionals, and others, do. Historyday01 (talk) 17:23, 3 February 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks for the reply. I have rewritten the first paragraph in an attempt to make it clear that queerbaiting is not a set-in-stone practice that is always clearly occurring in a certain way, but rather is subjective, as various people will perceive (or not perceive) it in certain ways. I invite further discussion on this issue, but I was hoping to offer a version of the lead that more clearly illustrates my concerns. OrdinaryOtter (talk) 22:23, 5 February 2026 (UTC)Reply

Proposal to reconsider inclusion of Stranger Things / Mike Wheeler and Will Byers

[edit]

Hello,

I would like to propose reconsidering the inclusion of the relationship between Mike Wheeler and Will Byers from ''Stranger Things'' in the examples section of this article.

I am not proposing that Wikipedia state as an established fact that the Duffer Brothers or Netflix deliberately intended to queerbait viewers. Rather, I am proposing that the article document a media-criticism issue that has been independently discussed by multiple commentators: the characterization and promotion of the Mike/Will relationship has repeatedly been discussed in connection with queerbaiting, including before the series finale.

There is also precedent for this. Earlier versions of the English Wikipedia article included ''Stranger Things'', specifically Will Byers and Mike Wheeler, among the examples of queerbaiting. The pairing is also currently represented in the Spanish and German versions of the article. I therefore believe that reconsidering its inclusion in the English article is reasonable, particularly given the additional sources that have appeared since the earlier English-language inclusion.

Independent coverage before the series finale

The queerbaiting discussion surrounding Mike and Will is not solely a retrospective reaction to the conclusion of the series.

In June 2022, ''The Independent'' published an article titled “Stranger Things viewers accuse show of ‘queerbaiting’ after repeatedly teasing Will Byers’ sexuality.” The article specifically discusses Will's feelings for Mike Wheeler and reports accusations that the series was queerbaiting viewers.

In July 2022, ''The Independent'' published “I love Stranger Things, but I feel queerbaited by Will’s storyline.” This article discusses the Season 3 confrontation between Mike and Will, Will's feelings for Mike, the Season 4 painting storyline and the show's treatment of Will's sexuality, explicitly framing the author's interpretation in terms of queerbaiting.

In October 2022, ''The Boar'' published “Queerbaiting in Stranger Things: Volume 2?”, which directly examines whether the treatment of Will's sexuality and his relationship with Mike constitutes queerbaiting. The article discusses the Season 3 “you don't like girls” exchange, Will's feelings for Mike, the Season 4 storyline and relevant cast interviews.

These sources are particularly relevant because they establish that the queerbaiting debate existed substantially before the final season. They therefore distinguish the issue from a purely retrospective fandom reaction to the eventual ending.

The distinction between Will's sexuality and the Mike/Will question

I think an important distinction should be maintained in any potential Wikipedia wording.

The argument is not simply that Will being gay constitutes queerbaiting. By the later seasons, Will's sexuality is explicitly established.

The disputed issue is whether the narrative created and sustained the possibility that Mike might reciprocate Will's romantic feelings, and whether the show's treatment of that possibility contributed to accusations of queerbaiting.

This distinction is also reflected in contemporary commentary. Sources discussing the issue frequently distinguish between Will's confirmed sexuality and the unresolved question of Mike's feelings toward Will.

Accordingly, I would not suggest wording that describes Will's sexuality itself as queerbaiting. The more specific and supportable subject is the treatment of the Mike/Will relationship and the possibility of reciprocal romantic feelings.

Promotional and paratextual context

There is also substantial evidence that the discussion cannot be limited entirely to the episodes themselves.

''Stranger Things'' has an unusually extensive promotional ecosystem involving Netflix, Netflix Geeked, official social-media accounts, cast interviews, promotional photographs, trailers, posters and other material designed to generate audience discussion and engagement.

This broader promotional context has also been examined academically. A 2025 peer-reviewed article by Filipa Antunes, “Building the Netflix brand: Franchise logic, authorship, and distinction in the promotion of Stranger Things,” published in ''Television & New Media'', examines Netflix's promotional discourse surrounding ''Stranger Things'' and treats promotional interviews and other paratextual material as significant to the construction and marketing of the franchise.

I am not suggesting that promotional material by itself proves the private intentions of the Duffer Brothers. Rather, it is relevant to the concept of queerbaiting because queerbaiting can involve promotional practices as well as the narrative text itself.

There is also a substantial body of primary material concerning the promotion of Mike and Will specifically. I have compiled this separately in a research archive, including official promotional material, social-media posts, interviews and other examples. I would not suggest using my compilation itself as the principal Wikipedia source; instead, I believe the individual primary materials should only be used where necessary and alongside independent secondary sources.

Continued discussion after the finale

The question did not disappear after the conclusion of the series.

During the fifth-season promotional period, entertainment publications continued to discuss the Mike/Will relationship and the significance of the “Byler” phenomenon. Following the conclusion of the series, further commentary explicitly revisited the question of queerbaiting in ''Stranger Things''.

For example, ''The Thunderword'' published an article titled “Queerbaiting in Stranger Things” in February 2026 that discusses the Mike/Will relationship and the distinction between Will's established sexuality and the question of whether Mike reciprocates his feelings.

This later coverage is relevant because it demonstrates that the queerbaiting interpretation remained a subject of public media discussion after the conclusion of the storyline rather than being limited to speculation before the finale.

Proposed wording

If editors consider the available sources sufficient, I suggest wording the example in a neutral and attributed manner rather than presenting queerbaiting as an uncontested fact.

One possible formulation would be:

'''Stranger Things''' — The relationship between Mike Wheeler and Will Byers has been discussed by commentators in the context of queerbaiting, particularly regarding the depiction of Will's romantic feelings for Mike and the possibility of reciprocal feelings.

Alternatively:

'''Stranger Things''' — Commentators have accused the series of queerbaiting in its treatment of Will Byers' romantic feelings for his best friend Mike Wheeler, particularly in relation to the show's queer subtext and promotional material.

I believe the first formulation may be preferable if editors wish to emphasize attribution rather than characterize the series itself as having definitively engaged in queerbaiting.

Why I believe this merits consideration

My purpose in raising this is not to argue that Wikipedia should determine whether Mike and Will “should” have become a couple, nor to establish one fandom interpretation as objectively correct.

The reason I believe the subject is appropriate for consideration is that it has become a documented example of a broader media criticism. The issue:

  • was discussed publicly before the final season;
  • has been covered by independent publications;
  • concerns a major internationally distributed television series;
  • involves both the narrative treatment of LGBTQ+ themes and the promotional environment surrounding the series;
  • continued to generate commentary after the conclusion of the series; and
  • has previously appeared as an example in the English Wikipedia article.

I also recognize that there are commentators who do not consider the storyline queerbaiting. I do not think those interpretations should be excluded. If the article includes the example, I believe the wording should accurately attribute the accusation and avoid presenting disputed interpretations as established facts.

I am continuing to collect independent sources, particularly material concerning the promotional and marketing aspects of the Mike/Will relationship. I would be grateful for editors' assessment of whether the sources currently available satisfy the sourcing requirements for inclusion, and, if not, what additional type of independent sourcing would be needed.

Thank you for considering the proposal.

ADDITIONAL:

Key sources

The main sources I am currently relying on for this proposal are:

  • ''The Independent'', June 2022: [https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/news/stranger-things-season-4-will-byers-b2091644.html “Stranger Things viewers accuse show of ‘queerbaiting’ after repeatedly teasing Will Byers’ sexuality”]. This is particularly relevant because it documents the queerbaiting criticism while Season 4 was still being released, before the series finale.
  • ''The Independent'', July 2022: [https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/stranger-things-4-queerbaiting-will-lgbt-b2122037.html “I love Stranger Things, but I feel queerbaited by Will’s storyline”]. This is a first-person opinion piece, but it is useful as evidence that the queerbaiting interpretation was being discussed publicly in mainstream media during Season 4.
  • ''The Boar'', October 2022: [https://theboar.org/2022/10/queerbaiting-in-stranger-things-volume-2/ “Queerbaiting in Stranger Things: Volume 2?”]. This article directly examines whether the treatment of Will's sexuality and his relationship with Mike constitutes queerbaiting, while also presenting an alternative interpretation of the storyline.
  • Filipa Antunes, ''Television & New Media'', 2025: “Building the Netflix brand: Franchise logic, authorship, and distinction in the promotion of ''Stranger Things''.” This peer-reviewed academic source is relevant to the broader question of how Netflix promotes ''Stranger Things'' and how promotional and paratextual material contributes to the construction of the franchise.
  • ''The Thunderword'', February 2026: [https://thunderword.highline.edu/2026/02/26/queerbaiting-in-stranger-things/ “Queerbaiting in ‘Stranger Things’”]. This provides post-finale discussion of the queerbaiting interpretation and specifically discusses Mike and Will in the context of the show's Season 5 promotion and storyline.
  • Earlier versions of the English Wikipedia article, which previously included ''Stranger Things'' / Will Byers and Mike Wheeler as an example. These are relevant as evidence of the article's editorial history, rather than as independent sourcing.
  • The Spanish and German versions of the ''Queerbaiting'' article, which currently include Mike Wheeler and Will Byers / ''Stranger Things''. I would treat these as cross-language editorial precedent rather than as independent reliable sources.

SalamiAsami (talk) 17:41, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply