Talk:Penguin Colony
Add topicRoundup of Metacritic reviews
[edit]So, looking at the reviews currently indexed by Metacritic, the numerical average is listed as 74/100, which Metacritic automatically summarizes as "Mixed or Average". I think that this is a poor summary of the reviews listed, as follows:
- ScreenHub 90/100
- Checkpoint Gaming 85/100
- The Wand Report 80/100
- Guardian 80/100
- ScreenRant 60/100
- Gamekult 60/100
- Gamegrin 60/100
- RockPaperShotgun unscored
- Polygon unscored
So, while 74/100 is the average, this misses that both of the unscored reviews were very positive, and that all three of the 60/100 reviews were mixed rather than negative, with statements like Penguin Colony offers something novel, but at the same time lacks any real variety or replayability in the long run.
; Penguin Colony offers an original and absurd take on Lovecraft, yet it simultaneously manages to capture the author’s essence perfectly...fans of the author with a good grasp of English will find the three-hour playtime quite enjoyable.
; Penguin Colony crafts a compelling vibe with an interesting new take on a classic horror story, but the retelling struggles to deliver a definitive punch.
Taking that into mind, I think that describing this range as "mixed to positive" is more accurate than Metacritic's automatic summary, although I think it's fine to keep the Metacritic average listed in the box. signed, Rosguill talk 19:09, 20 October 2026 (UTC)
- I feel like the more accurate version of this might be "polarized" or "divided critics"? Mixed makes it sound like the gameplay is middle of the road, but I think people took away very different thoughts from it. My two passing cents here as someone who hasn't read all the reviews yet. Nomader (talk) 18:32, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
- Which review has a more negative view than mixed in your view? ScreenRant and Gamegrin's reviews to me seem like the most negative of the bunch so far, but both of them mix a fair amount of praise into their criticism (Gamekult's recommendation is considerably more positive despite having the same numerical score). None of these reviews so far has panned the game outright. signed, Rosguill talk 18:39, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
- I feel like I'm becoming a hallucinating AI chatbot or something in my older years now!! I could have sworn I read more negative feedback! But I guess it was all just very focused on specific elements instead in generally positive reviews. Ignore my comment above, I think that's just fine the way you've written it out. Nomader (talk) 19:31, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
- FWIW, I'm also surprised that there haven't been any outright negative reviews. I would have predicted that the game's political statements would have polarized at least some critics, but perhaps it's not a high profile enough release to get attention like that. signed, Rosguill talk 13:48, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
- I feel like I'm becoming a hallucinating AI chatbot or something in my older years now!! I could have sworn I read more negative feedback! But I guess it was all just very focused on specific elements instead in generally positive reviews. Ignore my comment above, I think that's just fine the way you've written it out. Nomader (talk) 19:31, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
- Which review has a more negative view than mixed in your view? ScreenRant and Gamegrin's reviews to me seem like the most negative of the bunch so far, but both of them mix a fair amount of praise into their criticism (Gamekult's recommendation is considerably more positive despite having the same numerical score). None of these reviews so far has panned the game outright. signed, Rosguill talk 18:39, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
- C-Class video game articles
- Low-importance video game articles
- Video game articles requesting identifying art
- Video game articles requesting screenshots
- WikiProject Video games articles
- C-Class Australia articles
- Low-importance Australia articles
- WikiProject Australia articles
- C-Class New Zealand articles
- Low-importance New Zealand articles
- WikiProject New Zealand articles


