Talk:One Battle After Another
Add topic| This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the One Battle After Another article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the subject of the article. |
Article policies
|
| Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL |
| This article is written in American English, which has its own spelling conventions (center, color, defense, realize, traveled) and some terms may be different or absent from other varieties of English. According to the relevant style guide, this should not be changed without broad consensus. |
| This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
This article has been viewed enough times in a single week to appear in the Top 25 Report 5 times. The weeks in which this happened:
|
| This article has been viewed enough times in a single year to make it into the Top 50 Report annual list. This happened in 2025, when it received 9,929,720 views. |
| The following reference(s) may be useful when improving this article in the future: |
Confirmation of title
[edit]There is no confirmation this is the title of the film. Change it NOW. 2600:6C50:147F:BF5A:C054:BC08:2EF6:D38B (talk) 22:32, 26 October 2024 (UTC)
- Agreed 2.97.219.149 (talk) 17:31, 11 January 2025 (UTC)
- why has it not been changed? 2600:6C50:147F:BF5A:64D4:76E8:8299:BA2F (talk) 22:29, 1 March 2025 (UTC)
Semi-protected edit request on 11 January 2025
[edit]This edit request to The Battle of Baktan Cross has been answered. Set the |answered= parameter to no to reactivate your request. |
Can the title The Battle of Baktan Cross be removed seeing as no official source or studio has ever said what the film was called plus variety just did an article talking about films and their box office potential which clearly lists the film as Untitled Paul Thomas Anderson Film. The Battle of Baktan Cross could end up being the official title but until it’s announced what the title is, I think it needs removing. (UTC) https://variety.com/2025/film/box-office/box-office-2025-predictions-superman-jurassic-world-4-wicked-2-1236261990/ 2.97.219.149 (talk) 14:16, 11 January 2025.
- It is odd to use a title that I can only find in one of the sources and that is a blog that links to another source that looks like a another blog. KylieTastic (talk) 10:30, 12 January 2025 (UTC)
- fixed, not sure why it got that name as it is against article naming convention Ramdom-kid-editor (talk) 15:21, 12 January 2025 (UTC)
Title
[edit]The film has a title, and more details. IDK how to edit the title: https://thefilmstage.com/paul-thomas-andersons-one-battle-after-another-test-screens-confirmed-to-be-modern-update-on-vineland/, https://www.worldofreel.com/blog/2025/1/24/pta Ketlag (talk) 01:18, 25 January 2025 (UTC)
- Remove "Untitled Paul Thomas Anderson film" and replace with "One Battle After Another" Ktb393 (talk) 17:05, 25 January 2025 (UTC)
Semi-protected edit request on 25 January 2025
[edit]This edit request to Untitled Paul Thomas Anderson film has been answered. Set the |answered= parameter to no to reactivate your request. |
Title confirmed as "One Battle After Another" and confirmed as Thomas Pynchon "Vineland" adaptation. https://thefilmstage.com/paul-thomas-andersons-one-battle-after-another-test-screens-confirmed-to-be-modern-update-on-vineland/ Ktb393 (talk) 17:04, 25 January 2025 (UTC)
Not done: it's not clear what changes you want to be made. Please mention the specific changes in a "change X to Y" format and provide a reliable source if appropriate. M.Bitton (talk) 00:28, 26 January 2025 (UTC)
- Multiple sources are reporting the title, so I suspect the request is for a page move. Barry Wom (talk) 13:11, 26 January 2025 (UTC)
- Can anyone do that or is there some process? Ketlag (talk) 00:07, 27 January 2025 (UTC)
- Multiple sources are reporting the title, so I suspect the request is for a page move. Barry Wom (talk) 13:11, 26 January 2025 (UTC)
Title credibilty
[edit]I'm more curious as to where the two titles originate from because i have not seen a single news outlet (that's trustworthy) or studio officially announce the title.
https://deadline.com/2025/01/warner-bros-executive-exits-2025-movies-1236256895/ 'The Batman 2' Now Opening Fall 2026 in Theaters] (deadline article)
this official article from an official source that has proven trustworthy spoke about the film and it did not mention one battle after another.
Could we perhaps remove the title.
With regards 78.148.94.78
78.148.94.78 (talk) 17:30, 2 March 2025 (UTC)
- That article is nearly a year old. Barry Wom (talk) 18:37, 2 March 2025 (UTC)
- this might be more accuate to what i am saying.
- Why Warner Bros Shook Up Executive Ranks As It Prepares For 2025 Slate deadline articule and this was what was listed. the title one battle after another was not mentioned.
- with regards 78.148.94.78 78.148.94.78 (talk) 19:03, 2 March 2025 (UTC)
- https://deadline.com/2025/01/warner-bros-executive-exits-2025-movies-1236256895/ there that should i hope clarify what i was saying just now 78.148.94.78 (talk) 19:04, 2 March 2025 (UTC)
- That article is six weeks old. Movie title has been announced. Barry Wom (talk) 19:49, 2 March 2025 (UTC)
- not by an actually reliable source or studio it's world of reel which is almost never reliable to quote Krimuk2.0 '' World of Reel seems to be the source for the title change. Unfortunately, that site often makes up info. I'd suggest moving it back to untitled until there is some official confirmation'' 78.148.94.78 (talk) 20:22, 4 March 2025 (UTC)
- Has any official source confirmed this title? Krimuk2.0 (talk) 06:06, 5 March 2025 (UTC)
- No offical source has i'm afraid. 193.60.143.41 (talk) 10:54, 5 March 2025 (UTC)
- Could it perhaps be moved to untitled Paul Thomas Anderson film User:Krimuk2.0 78.148.94.78 (talk) 19:58, 5 March 2025 (UTC)
- This seems to be a bit more complicated. I see even Variety is referring to the film as One Battle After Another. Krimuk2.0 (talk) 07:03, 6 March 2025 (UTC)
- ''Meanwhile, Paul Thomas Anderson’s long-secretive project is finally taking shape. Though still untitled, the film boasts a reported $115 million budget. The star-studded cast includes Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Regina Hall and Teyana Taylor. Early test screenings reportedly clock in at nearly three hours — with eight noms on PTA’s resume, this makes for an instant Oscar conversation starter'' nope they have not mentioned a title 193.60.143.41 (talk) 10:22, 6 March 2025 (UTC)
- i stand corrected my aologies 193.60.143.41 (talk) 10:23, 6 March 2025 (UTC)
- ''Meanwhile, Paul Thomas Anderson’s long-secretive project is finally taking shape. Though still untitled, the film boasts a reported $115 million budget. The star-studded cast includes Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Regina Hall and Teyana Taylor. Early test screenings reportedly clock in at nearly three hours — with eight noms on PTA’s resume, this makes for an instant Oscar conversation starter'' nope they have not mentioned a title 193.60.143.41 (talk) 10:22, 6 March 2025 (UTC)
- This seems to be a bit more complicated. I see even Variety is referring to the film as One Battle After Another. Krimuk2.0 (talk) 07:03, 6 March 2025 (UTC)
- Could it perhaps be moved to untitled Paul Thomas Anderson film User:Krimuk2.0 78.148.94.78 (talk) 19:58, 5 March 2025 (UTC)
- No offical source has i'm afraid. 193.60.143.41 (talk) 10:54, 5 March 2025 (UTC)
Can we remove the Vineland adaptation + crime thriller info. from the page?
[edit]The WGA page previously linked 404s and the project is not listed on Paul Thomas Anderson's page. There's no official confirmation presently: https://directories.wga.org/member/paultanderson/
Basically anything citing the BC Project info from the WGA site should be removed for now. Iheartmylibrary22 (talk) 19:42, 20 March 2025 (UTC)
- Disregard - made the changes myself. Iheartmylibrary22 (talk) 19:47, 20 March 2025 (UTC)
- It was already confirmed that was inspired by that novel, of course. Possibly nominate Best Adapted Screenplay. GeniusTaker (talk) 12:29, 1 October 2025 (UTC)
- Objectively the movie isn't "based on" Vineland, the credit is that it's '"inspired by" it. Therefore I would say this credit should at least be removed from infobox. P1234427 (talk) 18:56, 10 November 2025 (UTC)
- It was already confirmed that was inspired by that novel, of course. Possibly nominate Best Adapted Screenplay. GeniusTaker (talk) 12:29, 1 October 2025 (UTC)
Semi-protected edit request on 24 March 2025
[edit]This edit request has been answered. Set the |answered= parameter to no to reactivate your request. |
The project spent about a week at the end of February filming at various historic spots in San Juan Bautista, CA.
[2] 2600:6C52:6000:4D9:B85:5A7F:B505:664C (talk) 00:07, 24 March 2025 (UTC)
Not done: it's not clear what changes you want to be made. Please mention the specific changes in a "change X to Y" format and provide a reliable source if appropriate. 21:48, 29 March 2025 (UTC)
Adam Somner
[edit]This film is the sixth collaboration between P.T. Anderson and Adam Somner, not the fifth. RedSkyRider (talk) 17:37, 28 March 2025 (UTC)
Locations
[edit]This Wiki page is missing Borrego Springs, CA where over three weeks of filming occurred for "One Battle After Another." The shooting occurred in May 2025. Then known as the B.C. Project. Jdeanloring (talk) 22:19, 18 April 2025 (UTC)
Why all black women?
[edit]|
Is there a historical basis for that, or is it simply Hollywood promoting interracial sex as it usually does..? Also, the article contains SPOILERS which should be noted. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 68.119.167.188 (talk) 05:03, 1 October 2025 (UTC)
|
Genre in lead
[edit]Per MOS:FILMLEAD: Genre classifications should comply with WP:WEIGHT and reflect what is specified by a majority of mainstream reliable sources. Oversimplification won't work, most sources refer to the comedic nature of the movie. CABF45 (talk) 12:06, 2 October 2025 (UTC)
- Almost but not quite, see also MOS:LEADSENTENCE, WP:FILMGENRE with particular note to WP:WEIGHT. Weight is not an excuse to cherry pick some reviews that happen to mention the genre you prefer.(diff) in fact it is the opposite, weight means the primary genre most important and holds most weight. Although a film may include mix of other genres the subgenres do not hold enough weight to be forced into the first sentence. They can still potentially be mentioned in the Production/Writing sections, or Critical response, they just aren't important enough to be forced into the very first sentence of the lead.
- The WP:STATUSQUO of this article was that the primary genre is "action thriller" (or synonymously a "crime thriller" according to the BBFC). That fact that other subgenres are also mentioned by reviewers does not change the weight of the primary genre and it does not change the fact that there is no need to overload the first sentence with self indulgent fancruft that doesn't actually server the needs of normal readers. The fact that this film also contains darkly humorous elements can be addressed elsewhere, the Critical response section for example, there is no need to overload the first sentence. The WP:LEAD is supposed to summarize the key elements, the first sentence especially so. Imagine you're trying to explain the key points to a grandmother: it is an action thriller, it is directed by Paul Anderson, it stars Leo DiCaprio. Overloading the first sentence with multiple genres doesn't help normal readers. This is not supposed to be a fansite, or a film review, this is supposed to be an encyclopedia article. -- 109.79.161.185 (talk) 14:48, 3 October 2025 (UTC)
- AFI calls it action crime drama. -- 109.79.161.185 (talk) 15:01, 3 October 2025 (UTC)
- Sorry but are really trying to deny a comedy movie is a comedy movie? PepGuardi (talk) 16:25, 15 October 2025 (UTC)
- No, we're trying to restrict the number of genres in the lede to the main ones only. Barry Wom (talk) 16:34, 15 October 2025 (UTC)
Col. Steven J. Lockjaw’s branch of service
[edit]The article currently reads that “Through his vehement anti-immigrant efforts, Lockjaw has become a colonel in the United States military,” but does the film show him leaving the police and joining the military? The police are certainly militarized, but are they military? I watched the movie again last night and Lockjaw and his soldiers are always wearing POLICE on their armor, right through the end. The only mention of him being in the military is that when he’s meeting with the Christmas Adventurers Club and Virgil Throckmorton says membership is sometimes considered for “members of the military.” —Psammeticus (talk) 13:43, 4 October 2025 (UTC)
Mercenaries or a militia?
[edit]Are we sure the 'mercenaries' in the penultimate paragraph of the plot section wouldn't be better described as a militia? I feel it fits what we see in the movie more. Admittedly a very minor thing though, I admit. Didn't want to edit without getting the opinions of others. As far as I know, there's no source in the plot section, as is common, but don't know how to decide it then. Saeleriela (talk) 18:10, 4 October 2025 (UTC)
- Agreed, it seems the group is based on other militias like the three percenters and is intended as a satire of the American militia movement. V. L. Mastikosa (talk) 01:18, 5 October 2025 (UTC)
Repeated removal of valid information
[edit]Someone explain to me what's wrong with this info, which editor(s?) are repeatedly removing based on nothing more than their(?) personal opinion:
Thanks. 216.168.91.20 (talk) 01:35, 14 October 2025 (UTC)
References
- On the contrary, it was removed because those links were basing "flop" remarks entirely on the first weekend, which is premature and frankly a bad habit each linked piece indulged in. Treating opening weekend totals as a guaranteed make-or-break is overly presumptuous and violates WP:CRYSTALBALL when there's no way to tell for certain how much will later be grossed. Don't listen to anybody who suggests otherwise. You carelessly are ignoring how none of those links say anything about subsequent earnings. On the other hand, if somebody were to make "box office flop" remarks AFTER a theatrical run has ended, then that would be easier to take at face value. It therefore wasn't actually "valid information" which got deleted. I also know I'm not the only one who removed the assessments on this basis. SNUGGUMS (talk / edits) 02:29, 14 October 2025 (UTC)
- Wrong. Such articles are commonplace in the movie reporting industry and they don't need to wait until movies "after their box office run" or whatever. YOU are the only one making that determination. Even Variety is on board with this. Knock it off. 216.168.91.112 (talk) 12:50, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- I noticed you didn't remove the edit with projected losses under your same reasoning, such as it is, so I removed it for you. 216.168.91.112 (talk) 12:56, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- Your invocation of WP: crystalball is just plain wrong. The edit isn't saying that the movie is a flop. It's saying that some reporters are calling it a flop, which is absolutely factual. Your grasp of Wikipedia guidelines is shitty. Why are you even allowed to edit here? 216.168.91.112 (talk) 15:09, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- First and foremost, disagreeing with someone is no excuse for your needlessly insulting remarks on my grasp on things and ability to edit. Please don't ever belittle me or anyone else on Wikipedia like that again per WP:No personal attacks as well as WP:Civility. Secondly, adding flop remarks before the theatrical run concludes came off as an attempt to enable/validate hasty assessments. My point on WP:CRYSTALLBALL was we shouldn't treat speculation on future/overall total grosses as a guaranteed outcome. Third, I actually DID remove projected losses, which aren't the same thing as somebody guessing a movie needs a certain amount of earnings to be profitable. Let's not conflate those matters. Fourthly, another user named Rulue took out premature remarks also because the movie still is playing. SNUGGUMS (talk / edits) 17:08, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- Your nonsense doesn't matter. This information is being reported by reliable sources. Don't like it? Tough. There is absolutely no rule on Wikipedia that says a movie can't be called a flop or a box office bomb before it's out of theaters. None. You're so stuck on misusing guidelines, but you can't admit that. 107.115.207.47 (talk) 20:36, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- Don't be so quick to dismiss my comments as "nonsense", IP, or arrogantly assume I'm "stuck on" anything. You've shown no concern at all for the fact that so far sources are only SPECULATING on what it'll obtain. By no means is that a firm indication of what will follow. Wikipedia actually is not supposed to be a place for mere guesses on the future. Evidently you're willing to disregard that when eager to add any potential outcome the moment somebody writes an article pondering it. SNUGGUMS (talk / edits) 21:40, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- They're not reliable sources anyway. They are blogs / listicles. I could start a blog right now with an article that states One Battle After Another is the biggest box office hit of the decade. That wouldn't make it true, and it wouldn't make it appropriate to add on Wikipedia. SubSeven (talk) 22:26, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- Don't be so quick to dismiss my comments as "nonsense", IP, or arrogantly assume I'm "stuck on" anything. You've shown no concern at all for the fact that so far sources are only SPECULATING on what it'll obtain. By no means is that a firm indication of what will follow. Wikipedia actually is not supposed to be a place for mere guesses on the future. Evidently you're willing to disregard that when eager to add any potential outcome the moment somebody writes an article pondering it. SNUGGUMS (talk / edits) 21:40, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- Your nonsense doesn't matter. This information is being reported by reliable sources. Don't like it? Tough. There is absolutely no rule on Wikipedia that says a movie can't be called a flop or a box office bomb before it's out of theaters. None. You're so stuck on misusing guidelines, but you can't admit that. 107.115.207.47 (talk) 20:36, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
- First and foremost, disagreeing with someone is no excuse for your needlessly insulting remarks on my grasp on things and ability to edit. Please don't ever belittle me or anyone else on Wikipedia like that again per WP:No personal attacks as well as WP:Civility. Secondly, adding flop remarks before the theatrical run concludes came off as an attempt to enable/validate hasty assessments. My point on WP:CRYSTALLBALL was we shouldn't treat speculation on future/overall total grosses as a guaranteed outcome. Third, I actually DID remove projected losses, which aren't the same thing as somebody guessing a movie needs a certain amount of earnings to be profitable. Let's not conflate those matters. Fourthly, another user named Rulue took out premature remarks also because the movie still is playing. SNUGGUMS (talk / edits) 17:08, 17 October 2025 (UTC)
Box-office bomb
[edit]The article intro currently says:
The initial budget of $115 million climbed to $175 million during production, making the budget four times larger than any of Anderson's previous films. [...] It has grossed $149 million worldwide, becoming Anderson's highest-grossing film.
Most any other article about an unprofitable film clearly states right in the intro that the film was a "box-office bomb", regularly using that exact expression and linking to that article. It's a bit embarassing for Wikipedia when PTA-fans get to awkwardly word the article around stating the obvious, leaving the reader to do the math and infer the meaning of it.
I understand that this article has become a weird little political battleground of sorts, but that's not an excuse for such poor and biased writing. 2A0A:A54A:A31E:0:1548:4536:1092:14AA (talk) 13:50, 19 October 2025 (UTC)
- Always fun when the WP:SPA starts accusing everyone else of bias. If you have any sliver of good-faith inside you, chill out, wait for the box office to wrap up, and see if RELIABLE SOURCES give this movie such a label. --SubSeven (talk) 18:11, 21 October 2025 (UTC)
The redirect Upcoming Paul Thomas Anderson film has been listed at redirects for discussion to determine whether its use and function meets the redirect guidelines. Readers of this page are welcome to comment on this redirect at Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2025 October 27 § Upcoming Paul Thomas Anderson film until a consensus is reached. –CopperyMarrow15 (talk ⋅ edits) 04:23, 28 October 2025 (UTC)
A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion
[edit]The following Wikimedia Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion:
Participate in the deletion discussion at the nomination page. —Community Tech bot (talk) 07:51, 24 November 2025 (UTC)
Humor
[edit]There seems remarkably little indication in this article of the comic aspects of the movie. According to Variety the film will compete as a comedy at the Golden Globes: "The film's tonal balancing act — mixing absurdist humor with Anderson's trademark intensity — seemed obviously comedic to casual awards observers, and the filmmakers, along with studio awards strategists, felt similarly."
Reading the plot summary here, I find no mention of any of what is funny about this very droll film. Practically the only acknowledgement is quoting the critic's consensus on Rotten Tomatoes, which uses the word "screwball."
(If you reply to this and specifically want me to see it, please ping; I don't currently maintain a watchlist on en-wiki.) - Jmabel | Talk 20:17, 26 November 2025 (UTC)
- Seems enough reason to add "comedy" to the genres in the lede. Barry Wom (talk) 10:42, 27 November 2025 (UTC)
To be clarified
[edit]'He hunts for Willa to cover up his interracial relationship'
His interracial relationship with Perfidia? If so, this should be specified. The plot summary doesn't mention that Perfidia is black, so when this issue suddenly turns up, it's a bit confusing. ~2025-38000-28 (talk) 00:14, 5 December 2025 (UTC)
Add award nomination
[edit]| This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest has now been answered. Set |answered=no to reactivate the request if necessary. |
- What I think should be changed:
Add the following award nomination: 2026 Cinema for Peace Dove for The Most Valuable Film of the Year.
- Why it should be changed:
This nomination is a notable international recognition granted by Cinema for Peace and is relevant to the film’s awards history. Including it would improve the completeness and accuracy of the article by reflecting verifiable, significant industry acknowledgment consistent with Wikipedia’s coverage of major awards and nominations.
- References supporting the possible change (format using the "cite" button):
Candela Victoria Costa Krause (talk) 15:27, 13 January 2026 (UTC)
References
- ↑ https://www.cinemaforpeace-foundation.org/latest-news/2025/11/24/cinema-for-peace-unveils-nominees-for-2026#:~:text=Cinema%20for%20Peace%20Dove%20for%20The%20Most%20Valuable%20Film%20of%20the%20Year.
{{cite web}}: Missing or empty|title=(help) - ↑ https://deadline.com/2026/01/cinema-for-peace-2026-awards-jafar-panahi-venezuela-1236676250/#:~:text=Cinema%20for%20Peace%20Dove%20For%20The%20Most%20Valuable%20Film%20of%20the%20Year.
{{cite web}}: Missing or empty|title=(help)
Erroneous and misleading “Big Four"
[edit]The National Board of Review is a subscriber-based consumer film club and NOT a critics group. There is no such thing as the “Big Four.” This is a made-up phrase with golden quotations from a trade awards shill and not used in industry parlance. You will find no legitimate reference anywhere else on the web. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 13:47, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Hi @Callbsonstudiopubs, even if this is the case (I have not tried to verify), you removed several citations along with your edit which were verifying the content. I am undoing this except for the part you mentioned here, just thought you would want to know so you can avoid this mistake in the future. Cheers. 🌸wasianpower🌸 (talk • contribs) 14:00, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- While restoring the content, I also noticed that the citations cite several sources for this claim, see WP:VARIETY
While each group has its own identity, influence and taste profile, three of them — NYFCC, NBR and LAFCA — are considered part of the so-called “Big Four” critics’ awards (the National Society of Film Critics completes the quartet when it announces on Jan. 3). Only three films in history have swept all four: “Schindler’s List” (1993), “L.A. Confidential” (1997) and “The Social Network” (2010). Only “Schindler” went on to win the Oscar for best picture.
and Indiewire ,“One Battle After Another” emerged early on in awards season as the presumptive frontrunner, winning Best Picture at the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, National Board of Review, National Society of Film Critics, and New York Film Critics Circle, becoming only the fourth film in history to accomplish this feat.
As a result, I've gone with a full revert instead of a partial. 🌸wasianpower🌸 (talk • contribs) 14:08, 2 February 2026 (UTC)- The other sources do not call these wins the "Big Four." And this is for the reason stated. There is no "Big Four." And The National Board of Review is a consumer group and NOT a critic's group. I will try to edit accordingly. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 15:08, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- My edit has been undone by Barry Wom, rightly stated that I first need a consensus. Are you good with the following?
- One Battle After Another won Best Picture from the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, National Society of Film Critics, New York Film Critics Circle and London Film Critics' Circle, only the fifth film in history — after Schindler's List (1993), L.A. Confidential (1997), The Social Network (2010) and Tár (2022) — to sweep all four major critics groups.Additionally, it won Film of the Year by the National Board of Review, making it just the fourth film to win this organization's top prize in addition to winning the four major critics’ groups. The others being Schindler's List, L.A. Confidential, and The Social Network.
- This is clearer, and makes distinction between actual Critics Groups (NYFCC, LAFCA, NYFC, LFCC) and a consumer film subscription organization (National Noard of Review) Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 17:02, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- The current wording regarding the "Big Four" seems to be properly sourced. Do you have a source which contradicts this by including the London Film Critics' Circle as one of the "four major critics groups"? Barry Wom (talk) 17:14, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- The “Big Four” phrase is made up by a FYC trade writer. Any reference to this, other than that FYC trade writer, is simply drafting off him.
- As to “four major critics groups," this is well-known in the industry, but in no way citable.
- May I suggest the following?
- One Battle After Another won Best Picture from the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, National Society of Film Critics, New York Film Critics Circle and London Film Critics' Circle, only the fifth film in history — after Schindler's List (1993), L.A. Confidential (1997), The Social Network (2010) and Tár (2022) — to sweep these critics groups. In addition to the aforementioned groups, the National Board of Review (a non critics group) awarded it film of the year, making it just the fourth film to win all five groups. The others being Schindler's List, L.A. Confidential, and The Social Network. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 17:44, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- If it is "in no way citable" then obviously it cannot be included. Barry Wom (talk) 17:47, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, which is why I cheanged “four major critics” to “these critics groups.” Are you okay with that? Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 17:54, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Let's try a different tack. Do you have a source which confirms that the term "Big Four" was invented by an "FYC trade writer" (whatever that is) and that the likes of Variety, IndieWire and ScreenRant are using it erroneously? Barry Wom (talk) 17:58, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- I oppose avoiding the "big four" language. This is not the place to WP:RIGHTGREATWRONGS in terms of how NBR is or is not different from other organizations. If reliable sources are categorizing as such, we should follow them. Any reliably-sourced general critique of NBR as an organization belongs at that organization's article. Here, it is too much WP:EDITORIALIZING. 18:05, 2 February 2026 (UTC) Erik (talk | contrib) 18:05, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- No. But Clayton Davis is an awards writer fed hyperbolic language like this from the studios. It wouldn’t so eggregious if it wasn’t in quotes. The wikipedia list “Big Four” is an artifact of this. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:06, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Hmmm Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:07, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- NBR is not a critics group. To list them as such is inaccurate and misleading. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:08, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- They are dishing out awards which attract significant coverage, so in the broader sense they are indeed "critics". Barry Wom (talk) 18:16, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- No, they are not critics. They categorize themselves as non professional New York film enthusiasts. They pay to join and get to watch films. These are not cinema writers ot journalists. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:18, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- They do not publish, they vote. That distinction is important. Using your definition in the broader sense would make AMPAS critics. But they’re not. They’re film professionals. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:21, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- This feels like WP:OR. Though I understand your personal objections to the way these groups are described, we shouldn't be imparting our personal objections onto the article. We should just follow the sourcing's language, which describes those groups as the "big four". (Side note — whatever the result of this discussion, we currently use the same language on LA Confidential (film) and The Social Network, so whatever the consensus it should apply to those pages as well). 🌸wasianpower🌸 (talk • contribs) 18:42, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- I just contributed to the AfD for List of Big Four film critics awards. Considering my findings, perhaps it is appropriate to do some kind of WP:INTEXT attribution of who calls it the "Big Four"? From my WP:SET, the label is very sporadically used. Saying who groups these may be helpful. Erik (talk | contrib) 18:52, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- This feels like WP:OR. Though I understand your personal objections to the way these groups are described, we shouldn't be imparting our personal objections onto the article. We should just follow the sourcing's language, which describes those groups as the "big four". (Side note — whatever the result of this discussion, we currently use the same language on LA Confidential (film) and The Social Network, so whatever the consensus it should apply to those pages as well). 🌸wasianpower🌸 (talk • contribs) 18:42, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- They do not publish, they vote. That distinction is important. Using your definition in the broader sense would make AMPAS critics. But they’re not. They’re film professionals. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:21, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- No, they are not critics. They categorize themselves as non professional New York film enthusiasts. They pay to join and get to watch films. These are not cinema writers ot journalists. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:18, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- They are dishing out awards which attract significant coverage, so in the broader sense they are indeed "critics". Barry Wom (talk) 18:16, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- NBR is not a critics group. To list them as such is inaccurate and misleading. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:08, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Hmmm Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 18:07, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Let's try a different tack. Do you have a source which confirms that the term "Big Four" was invented by an "FYC trade writer" (whatever that is) and that the likes of Variety, IndieWire and ScreenRant are using it erroneously? Barry Wom (talk) 17:58, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- Yes, which is why I cheanged “four major critics” to “these critics groups.” Are you okay with that? Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 17:54, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- If it is "in no way citable" then obviously it cannot be included. Barry Wom (talk) 17:47, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- The other sources do not call these wins the "Big Four." And this is for the reason stated. There is no "Big Four." And The National Board of Review is a consumer group and NOT a critic's group. I will try to edit accordingly. Callbsonstudiopubs (talk) 15:08, 2 February 2026 (UTC)
- While restoring the content, I also noticed that the citations cite several sources for this claim, see WP:VARIETY
Setting
[edit]When and where is it set? This seems like some basic information that should be covered in the article. Nosferattus (talk) 22:26, 16 March 2026 (UTC)
The "Controversies" or "Criticisms" section
[edit]The section as it was is simply TOO much of a WP:SOAPBOX. Enough to mention that it was controversial among far-right conservatives without making arguments on their behalf here as to why they are right (or even wrong for that matter). Opening this section to debate if necessary. But a good reason to condense that section as it is IS because the article is already too bloated. And the information isn't all that WP:NOTABLE to begin with.
Share thoughts here.~2026-17566-54 (talk) 03:48, 21 March 2026 (UTC)
- You have a point. Plus it mentions that the point the conservatives are using as leverage (ICE and Kirk shootings) aren't even really solid since the film was finished way before any of that happened (plus this script was in development twenty something years ago from what I've heard). Nguyk (talk) 03:45, 24 March 2026 (UTC)
- Some points are debatable but how about looking at what actually was removed (and I had no part in adding the ICE and Kirk shootings).
- The IP's removal of two negative criticisms of the film on the bases of UNDUE/FRINGE (per edit summary) are blatantly false. Neither Bret Easton Ellis nor Reason Magazine (reason.com) are aligned with either or any political "wing". The fact that a massive wall of text devoted to adulatory, lavish, orgiastic praise from mostly hard-left media sources was left untouched (despite the IP's purported concerns about SOAPBOX and the article being too big and needing to be "condensed") while two validly sourced quite small relatively dissenting critiques were removed because frankly the IP doesn't like them, agree with them or otherwise finds them distasteful. This is Marxist censorship, nothing more.
- Oh, and let's not forget actress Jennifer Lawrence's opinion -- I didn't realize she had become a recognized film expert or critic! I removed that as an example of COATRACK.
- This IP has only
onethis one edit credited to him or her or whatever (I don't solicit pronouns) but obviously is not a newbie and edits under a range of IPs, piecemeal. Paolakansas (talk) 18:13, 24 March 2026 (UTC)
- What really guts me is that no intervening editors or admins even noticed and/or cared. This is not how an encyclopaedia is supposed to function. Paolakansas (talk) 18:35, 24 March 2026 (UTC)
Casting Director Cassandra Kulukundis’ name is missing - she will n the first Casting Director Oscar after all.
[edit]Add Cassandra Kulukunidis' name to ~2026-10565-35 (talk) 04:52, 23 March 2026 (UTC)
Yup
[edit]@Hamiltondamonae Are you referring to opinion pieces in the paragraph in your claims of it being a WP:SOAPBOX? It's a reception section. There was and is currently a substantial amount of discussion in the film world regarding what the politics of OBAA actually are, and that informs people's, especially critics', opinions of the movie.
I think you are reading the paragraph in a different way from how I wrote it, but it is, before considering any other rule, balanced. 1) the paragraph sets up that political opinions are varied, according to the political spectrum 2) it gives a left-wing opinion in the form of the NYT quote 3) it gives two centrist/center-right/maybe libertarian opinions in the form of the variety/film comment quote 4) it gives a conservative opinion in the form of the national review quote.
Now, as for fringe/notable/falsebalance? Well, National Review might be one or some of these-"Giving "equal validity" can create a false balance" per WP:FALSEBALANCE, maybe? I would be OK if it were gone. I would personally still include it, because at least it's from a literal magazine, from a famous movie critic; it's not like Alex Jones writing for InfoWars. In case you mean the New York Times or Film at Lincoln Center are fringe or not notable sources-they are not.
What we have left is a quote about how "One Battle After Another is not, in fact, a left-wing movie", in my personal opinion, I think it is a horseshit take, essentially completely blind to the entire 3-hour movie, but I still include it in the paragraph because it's clearly an opinion from a major source. Per WP:SUBJECTIVE: "Aesthetic opinions are diverse and subjective—we might not all agree about who the world's greatest soprano is. However, it is appropriate to note how an artist or a work has been received by prominent experts, critics, and the general public." There's no difference in the opinionated quality of it and the NYT quote.
Grungeosmunge (talk) 02:48, 24 March 2026 (UTC)
- Accidentally @ 'd someone else sorry lol Grungeosmunge (talk) 02:57, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Furthermore, Glieberman's is quite literally an opinion piece. Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:01, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge In agreement there, so it has been moved to industry response, where it belongs as he is advocating on behalf the industry as a prominent lead critic and film journalist, albeit, from a place of opinion.
- As for the where this debate started, and hopefully ends, on film pages we are NOT primarily concerned as to how they fare "politically." See MOS:FILM for guidelines and etiquette. Unless the film is an obvious propaganda film, like "Triumph of the Will" or "2000 Mules" then that is not our concern here to discuss how Fox News, Breitbart, Msnbc, Michael Moore, Donald Trump or anyone for that matters feels about a movie unless they were SO outspoken about it that it had some WP:NOTABLE affect on the history of this film as it was experienced, released, and existed from its inception. Cheers. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 03:28, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Furthermore, Glieberman's is quite literally an opinion piece. Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:01, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge I agree with the Gleiberman piece being in the wrong place. That should be moved to "Industry response" so it doesn't serve as a rebuttable. It was mistakenly included again because of the revert.
- As for the rest, that this movie didn't sit well with those on the far-right of the political spectrum isn't all that notable regarding the history of this movie. Yes, we should report that this movie was indeed controversial (as we have) and, sure, that it stirred up some controversy, with some examples here and there.
- But unlike say, a critic discussing what they didn't like about the movie, or even accusing the movie of being too political, we certainly don't need to bloat up this article more than we are doing by representing the views (by way of outrage) of each and every far-right commentator. This isn't Crossfire on CNN (remember that show?)
- I digress.
- We have to be careful not to act as WP:EDITORS in the sense of discussing in what the ways a movie is right or wrong, as that is beyond our scope here, and rather simply reflect the history of this film without trying to overly represent a minority view here, in this case, that the far-right media blogsophere thinks this is left-leaning propaganda piece. Or something along those lines.
- As you have said, you think "[That] One Battle After Another is not, in fact, a left-wing movie", in my personal opinion, a horses*** take, essentially completely blind to the entire 3-hour movie" and, on your main page, you said you "like to edit about "political stuff", so you are in a sense blind yourself IMHO.
- Hopefully fixing the Gleiberman part will address your concern, which I agree is not very neutral, as the rest is blantantly a WP:SOAPBOX about those who don't like the movie from a biased political perspective. Which has been reported and included, but by way of observation AND NOT advocacy (which would be wrong to represent on the right AND left).
- Take care. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 03:21, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Just to be clear, if you're referring to National Review, it's fine to get rid of that from my perspective, whatever. Do you have any problem with the not-far-right NYT and Film Comment quotes?
- As for "As you have said, you think "[That] One Battle After Another is not, in fact, a left-wing movie", in my personal opinion, a horses*** take, essentially completely blind to the entire 3-hour movie" and, on your main page, you said you "like to edit about "political stuff", so you are in a sense blind yourself IMHO." I'm not following, sorry; are you just doing a political jab, or are you refuting a specific point? Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:28, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Some more stuff. I get that you wanna end the discussion, buuuuut regarding your point "Unless the film is an obvious propaganda film, like "Triumph of the Will" or "2000 Mules"
- Does it really have to be exclusively a "propaganda film" to elicit such a political section, MOS:FILM considered? This is a movie containing the following lines:
- "We are a political organization…. that is free from the eyes, the ears, and most important… of the weapons of the imperialist state, and this fascist regime. You are a political prisoner on the French 75, motherfucker. You have been captured by the French 75. Bitches… Fuck the police! Viva La Revolucion!" "Senator Wilson, this is a warning for you. We planted a bomb at the Haymarket office in your reelection campaign. We warned you that abortion ban, you didn’t want to fucking listen." "Revolutionary violence is the only way. No one’s telling me to vote. No one’s telling me to overcome. Nobody moves. Nobody gets hurt. Shit, it doesn’t matter. Everybody paints." etc etc
- Where do we draw the line between a "propaganda film" and a "film that has significant political subtext"? Hopefully, not on whether or not we personally enjoy it. That would be quite POV. Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:37, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge So, do we change how we approach most John Wayne movies? Or movies by Oliver Stone?? Or the Bible movies of the 1950s???
- With enough history, and time in retrospect, maybe we could.
- But THIS movie, OBAA, is barely out for a year and all this discussion in the article itself about how a film allegory about authoritarianism is liberal this or anti-Trump that is subjective.
- Ever watch "Escape from New York"? Or even "Planet of the Apes"?? OR how about "Red Dawn"???? Those are also movies similar to this in style and tone, yet they don't call out or mention Reagan or Nixon. Last I checked, OBAA doesn't feature MAGA or Trump. So we reported here that, yes, subtext is being placed on the movie by the culture experiencing it now BUT we don't have to fully represent nor advocate both sides of said subtext. Again, consult MOS:FILM and consider my examples. I think given your political leanings you are too close to this, given your desire to edit "political stuff" (your words on your homepage, not mine) and so maybe play devil's advocate or consult those other forums I mentioned for guidance on this. Take care. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 03:46, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- I disagree generally, but I don't like your assumption that I'm doing left-wing political activism; I try to promote Wikipedia's neutrality the best I can. The quote on my profile that you're using is precisely meant to show this: "I edit articles about political stuff, but I am not a member of, or associated with, any political organization or Wikipedia-centric political activist group! I am simply attempting to improve the encyclopedic quality of this site, and I stand by its neutrality." As for "Devil's Advocating", this entire website is built off of people playing Devil's Advocate. That's like the main thing talk pages are for. Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:59, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Well, anyways, because you added the NYT comment back, and I don't really care to defend the National Review/Film Comment parts, I guess we're done with that part. The last thing I have to say is that "Notable controversies" still doesn't make sense. Perfidia is controversial, yes, but the part under "U.S. immigration policies" doesn't have any people criticizing that aspect of the film. It's people praising the film for being accurate to life. Grungeosmunge (talk) 04:06, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge I am all for a better title for sure. Suggestions?? Hamiltondamonae (talk) 04:09, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- I was thinking that it might be worth it to just put that bit about ICE into the critical reception part above—it seems to work, critics praising the film for being accurate—and make the Perfidia section its own Subheading titled "Reception to Perfidia's character", then get rid of the "Notable controversies" line. If there won't be a "political section", then, I think, the ICE and Perfidia things are no longer really related encyclopedically, and shouldn't be put under a joint subheading.
- This then brings up some new problems. 1) That quote where the film's own producer is praising the film for being accurate; she's not a critic. Maybe that can get put into Industry Response? 2) I think the Bovino line is not compatible with your view of the article's scope, and so it should be deleted. Thoughts? Grungeosmunge (talk) 04:26, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Actually, I didn't really think the Bovino line was necessary in the first place, but that was also added by another editor. Grungeosmunge (talk) 04:28, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Good feedback. Will give it some thought, maybe try some of this out to see how it fits. I think it can be reworked into the "Critical reception" without all the segmenting, as it really is just a "Critical response" etc. etc. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 04:43, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- I'll leave it up to you.
- I just noticed this, though: I don't think PTA's statement about Perfidia should be in Industry Response. It seems kind of misleading, or maybe not encyclopedically helpful, to not have the director's response to a controversy about his movie be within the section about that controversy. Even though PTA's quote is right below, people might finish reading the Perfidia section and then not read further. I think you put it there because he said it at the Oscars, but I dunno, it's kinda strange for the director himself to be considered "the industry" reacting to the movie. Grungeosmunge (talk) 05:06, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge I decided to sleep on it. Went ahead today with what we discussed.
- I feel like the "political content" page is better framed, and now allows for titles like "political views" as this really is just "Critical analysis", politically speaking. So the Armond White AND Gleiberman content can now return.
- Also, with "political views" restored and other material, I think this strikes a good compromise on all sides, though I will add "and controversies" since that qualifies it better (i.e. it is MORE than just someone's views here, as it is an expression of the cultural wars at present). Hamiltondamonae (talk) 17:22, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Yeah, "Critical analysis" is good. I appreciate your work here! Grungeosmunge (talk) 01:52, 29 March 2026 (UTC)
- Sorry for going Caps Lock in my edit summary btw haha I get heated sometimes Grungeosmunge (talk) 01:54, 29 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge It's okay. I was just teasing you anyways. I can get cranky too. It's all good. Take care mate. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 06:28, 3 April 2026 (UTC)
- Sorry for going Caps Lock in my edit summary btw haha I get heated sometimes Grungeosmunge (talk) 01:54, 29 March 2026 (UTC)
- Yeah, "Critical analysis" is good. I appreciate your work here! Grungeosmunge (talk) 01:52, 29 March 2026 (UTC)
- Good feedback. Will give it some thought, maybe try some of this out to see how it fits. I think it can be reworked into the "Critical reception" without all the segmenting, as it really is just a "Critical response" etc. etc. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 04:43, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Actually, I didn't really think the Bovino line was necessary in the first place, but that was also added by another editor. Grungeosmunge (talk) 04:28, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge I am all for a better title for sure. Suggestions?? Hamiltondamonae (talk) 04:09, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge As I offered, English is not my first language. Sorry if that comes off as a lame excuse. But if I understand you properly, then my honest feelings are that you are NOT doing "left-wing political activism".
- My bigger concern is that you wanted a special section for how this film, and maybe others, are "politically received" as that isn't appropriate here if that was your point UNLESS in certain exceptional cases. Movie like 2000 Mules or Triumph of the Will or, most recently, Melania are examples where you can't seperate the politics from the movies themselves even as they declare themselves to be non-political. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 04:08, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Well, anyways, because you added the NYT comment back, and I don't really care to defend the National Review/Film Comment parts, I guess we're done with that part. The last thing I have to say is that "Notable controversies" still doesn't make sense. Perfidia is controversial, yes, but the part under "U.S. immigration policies" doesn't have any people criticizing that aspect of the film. It's people praising the film for being accurate to life. Grungeosmunge (talk) 04:06, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- I disagree generally, but I don't like your assumption that I'm doing left-wing political activism; I try to promote Wikipedia's neutrality the best I can. The quote on my profile that you're using is precisely meant to show this: "I edit articles about political stuff, but I am not a member of, or associated with, any political organization or Wikipedia-centric political activist group! I am simply attempting to improve the encyclopedic quality of this site, and I stand by its neutrality." As for "Devil's Advocating", this entire website is built off of people playing Devil's Advocate. That's like the main thing talk pages are for. Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:59, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge Maybe copy and paste there what other quotes you were hoping to include so we can see if they are appropriate and WP:NOTABLE?
- I'm not making a jab, nor am I being sarcastic. I'm acknowledging that you that you personally believe this movie to be "a left-wing movie" and as I said elsewhere (or read MOS:FILM for etiquette on how we write film articles) we do not typically include a section about the "political reception" or a film unless an extreme circumstance presents itself. "Melania" was an obvious propadanda/informercial for the Trump movement. Same goes for "Triumph of the Will" or "2000 Mules", obvious political propaganda movies. Movies by Michael Moore are usually very political in nature, as that is their subject matter.
- Just because "Return of the Jedi" was Lucas' allegory where he presented "The Empire as America getting its arse kicked by the Vietnamese" (his words, paraphrased), because Lucas is VERY liberal, doesn't mean we need a big section discussing both sides of that opinion of his, beyond maybe a passing mention, as it really wasn't that WP:NOTABLE as far as ROTJ's history is concerned. This is an example.
- P.S. English is not my first language, so maybe some problems there. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 03:39, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- "The New York Times' Michelle Goldberg claimed it was "an antifascist movie at a fascist moment", a film which "was made in the America that existed before Donald Trump's return" to office eight months earlier; Goldberg wondered "if such a forthrightly antifascist film could be produced in Hollywood today".
- "Film Comment, a publication of Film at Lincoln Center, wrote that One Battle After Another "illustrate[s] not ideology, but rather the infrastructure of allegiance"."
- I actually didn't add either of these. I changed the wording, but they were already in different sections, and I moved them into this paragraph. So lol if it's worth debating more, it might be worth getting the editors who added it first.
- The Film Comment quote I don't have much to say about. But as for Goldberg, to be clear, their implication is that if production on OBAA's script was finished nowadays, the studios might not greenlight it out of fear of upsetting Trump and getting into a business kerfuffle, similar to ABC cancelling Jimmy Kimmel Live at the request of Trump's FCC. I think that even if this is ultimately unknowable now, this is a substantial statement coming from a New York Times columnist, and I don't think it's fringe. Grungeosmunge (talk) 03:52, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge Agreed about "The New York Times", so we should definitely put that back in. I will include it now. Thank you. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 03:56, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Cool, thanks. Grungeosmunge (talk) 04:01, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Grungeosmunge Agreed about "The New York Times", so we should definitely put that back in. I will include it now. Thank you. Hamiltondamonae (talk) 03:56, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- I SEE NO CONSENSUS regarding Michelle Goldberg's vile SOAPBOX rant, except between two editors (Hamiltondamonae and Grungeosmunge) nor do I see why her unhinged comments remain except that Hamiltondamonae decided he or she or they like the comments and are manning the gates. Does anyone else have a voice? Or do just certain editors get to decide what's SOAPBOXing and what's not? Paolakansas (talk) 19:20, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- Ironically, my edits were reverted by Hamiltondamonae as "rv obvious non-neutral point of view pushing" but Michelle Goldberg's non-neutral point of view pushing -- for which she is paid handsomely -- stays (with the imprimatur of Wikipedia)??!! Paolakansas (talk) 19:31, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- @Paolakansas The uncalled for "paid-handsomely" attack by you against the source (your words) betrays your intentions, and there are other examples of your agenda, and is itself a form of WP:OR and proof of why wikipedia is WP:NOTAFORUM. If you are WP:NOTHERE to respect an etiquette for how we edit an article about a fictional film, then please go over to MOS:FILM boards to refresh yourself on who we do things here, or please move onto a political article please as this just WP:editwarring at this point. Cheers Hamiltondamonae (talk) 19:49, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- Ironically, my edits were reverted by Hamiltondamonae as "rv obvious non-neutral point of view pushing" but Michelle Goldberg's non-neutral point of view pushing -- for which she is paid handsomely -- stays (with the imprimatur of Wikipedia)??!! Paolakansas (talk) 19:31, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- I SEE NO CONSENSUS regarding Michelle Goldberg's vile SOAPBOX rant, except between two editors (Hamiltondamonae and Grungeosmunge) nor do I see why her unhinged comments remain except that Hamiltondamonae decided he or she or they like the comments and are manning the gates. Does anyone else have a voice? Or do just certain editors get to decide what's SOAPBOXing and what's not? Paolakansas (talk) 19:20, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
Re: Reagan
[edit]The former Sacramento mansion of Governor Ronald Reagan was used for exterior shots for the Christmas Adventurers Club's headquarters.
I wonder if some effort could be made to note how this ties the film back into the original novel, with Pynchon's focus on Reagan. This isn't at all immediately clear for the general audience. Viriditas (talk) 03:24, 31 March 2026 (UTC)
- @Viriditas I think so.
- Maybe it could be worded like this,
- "The former Sacramento mansion of Governor Ronald Reagan was used for exterior shots for the Christmas Adventurers Club's headquarters, tying the film back into the original novel, with Pynchon's focus on Reagan." ~2026-19999-80 (talk) 18:48, 31 March 2026 (UTC)
Critical analysis section
[edit]Hoping that those editing an article on a 'fictional movie' will realize that there is a difference between a critic, of even a politically-biased ideologue, stating their 'opinion' that they think a movie is "good or bad" (artistically speaking) and the listing their reasons as to why they feel that way AND outlier types making serious 'allegations' (which go beyond mere opinion) that a fictional movie like this one is "seditious", "treasonous", "part of a left-wing conspiracy by the left-wing press and the leftist Hollywood cabal to prop up this movie"(to loosely paraphrase). Saying a movie is good or bad is different than saying a movie is 'right' or 'wrong' or nationalist reasons, ethical reasons, and so on and so forth. We are not talking about obvious rare examples like "Triumph of the Will" or "2000 Mules" which are a form of film fraud. Certainly pornography, films featuring animal torture, or snuff films are exceptions to the rule. But we need not have a WP:FALSEBALANCE on a fictional film article about a movie that, in actuality, is anti-authoritarian.
The film is NOT anti-MAGA. The movie never mentions Trump or current events. It's not anymore "seditious" than a movie like "Escape From New York" or "Robocop" or "Red Dawn" or "Mad Max" which present a fictional dystopian future as authoritarian or even fascistic with anti-heroes trying to dismantle said anti-democratic forces.
And should the culture attach a subtext or meaning that is political in nature, remember this can happen even in artistically benign cases (e.g. George Lucas declared his Star Wars movies as anti-America movies where the Empire is a stand-in for America and the Ewoks were the Vietnamese winning THEIR war with the help of a fantasy rebellion of sorts) which no one seriously would allege are "seditious" in nature.
So, keep in mind, the current section IS designed to respect the encyclopedic nature of our project and mission here. If the history of the film is that the movie was highly controversial for political reasons, then we report it. But we do not WP:EDITORIALIZE, nor is it our job to debate whether this movie is "treasonous" or "seditious" or part of a "left-wing conspiracy" nor a "rallying cry for left-wing causes." We simply reflect what the consensus is in the press, so we need not advocate on behalf of elites or forces that love OR hate this movie for personal reasons that are, at best, opinions OR allegations (i.e.and our job isn't to debate said allegations if there are any).Hamiltondamonae (talk) 19:10, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- The film is NOT anti-MAGA.. LMFAO. Seriously? Did you read any of the written film reviews you are defending? Paolakansas (talk) 19:22, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- @Paolakansas There is a difference between subtext by critics that the movie is casting allusions to this and that, and then outright allegations that the enterprise of the movie itself and the community embracing it is engaging in seditious behavior. Ridiculous. No, MAGA is not mentioned ONCE in the movie. You could say "Escape from New York" or even "Robocop" were anti-Reaganism movies with the same logic, but again, that is subtext.
- Again, the reviews making 'allegations' are making allegations about the press and Hollywood that are not simply opinion based, but empirical in nature, sans evidence to back said allegation. Sorry, this simply suffers WP:UNDUE weight in your attempt to indict this movie by way of your WP:SOAPBOX and WP:GAME here. Cheers. Start an RFC if you like to see if the rest of the community should support bending the etiquette here for a fictional movie about "authoritarianism." We are not going to WP:FALSEBALANCE authoritarianism here.Hamiltondamonae (talk) 19:43, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
- The film is NOT anti-MAGA.. LMFAO. Seriously? Did you read any of the written film reviews you are defending? Paolakansas (talk) 19:22, 6 April 2026 (UTC)
Steven or Lockjaw
[edit]@Movie Lover 111 I feel like this character should really be referred to as Lockjaw, because that's what the characters in the movie all call him, while Bob is called Bob. I didn't even realize Lockjaw's first (or middle) name was mentioned. Aaron Liu (talk) 00:47, 26 April 2026 (UTC)
- I strongly agree, so I did the inevitable and changed every Steven, except for the first mention, back to Lockjaw. Furthermore, I left an edit summary acknowledging that it was per your argument as the reasoning for the change. Movie Lover 111 (talk) 03:03, 26 April 2026 (UTC)
Meaning of title
[edit]There's an interesting passage in Vineland on p. 236 of the paperback edition that seems to explain the meaning of the title. It's far deeper than I thought, and perhaps the director left it unsaid so that people would read the novel and figure it out for themselves. Viriditas (talk) 02:06, 23 June 2026 (UTC)
- Update. Just finished the book. 75% of the book was jettisoned for the film, while the 25% that was used was altered and rewritten. Would be interesting to find sources that talk about this as the adaptation process is really a magical process in some respects. Viriditas (talk) 02:39, 6 July 2026 (UTC)
Armond White again
[edit]Removed claim lacking secondary source. Left in second White source since it is supported by a secondary. Viriditas (talk) 02:01, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
What's with the description Header?
[edit]it makes it sound like Penn is the hero. Because remember that's not what's up. He's not trying to bring any one to justice. He is trying to murder an teenage girl. So like yeah ~2026-52488-82 (talk) 17:40, 28 September 2026 (UTC)
- Added amoral Septagram (talk) 07:39, 29 September 2026 (UTC)
- Wikipedia articles that use American English
- C-Class film articles
- C-Class American cinema articles
- American cinema task force articles
- WikiProject Film articles
- C-Class United States articles
- Low-importance United States articles
- C-Class United States articles of Low-importance
- Low-importance American cinema articles
- WikiProject United States articles
- Pages in the Wikipedia Top 25 Report
- Implemented requested edits

