Talk:Karmia

Neutrality: "Karmia (Hebrew: כַּרְמִיָּה) is a kibbutz in southern Israel."

Karmia is situated in the area controlled by Israel after the 1948 War and on the Israeli side of the 1950 Armistice lines. However, in international, as opposed to Israeli, law, what is legitimately considered Israel is determined by the 1947 UN Partition Plan borders. According to the Plan, the area Karmia is built on should have become part of a proposed Arab state and therefore, pending a full peace agreement, not part of Israel. The area, though, is not considered to be under Israeli occupation, as are the areas seized by Israel from 1967 onwards. It is a Wikipedia requirement that, to be neutral, articles should reflect the contents of all reliable sources. Clearly the current article only reflects the Israeli point-of-view and the phrasing needs modification.     ←   ZScarpia   17:10, 27 November 2025 (UTC)