Talk:Jane Fernandes
Add topic| This article must adhere to the biographies of living persons (BLP) policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libellous. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to this noticeboard.If you are a subject of this article, or acting on behalf of one, and you need help, please see this help page. |
| This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Untitled
[edit]9thprez.com is a propaganda website. Heavily biased websites are unacceptable in wikipedia.
To that person working for the Univ adm who keeps on deleting the paragraph about the protest: It is a FACT that there is a large number of students and the faculty protesting her selection. Accept it. Leave the page alone.
"Students objected to the appointment of Jane Fernandes ... because she did not grow up using American Sign Language." I'm quite sure washington post is considered as a verified source. If you don't like WP's opinion, tough. Anyway, this appear to be one of the major reason for objection initially which was later switched to something more acceptable.Vapour
Nope, the Washington Post didn't understand the reasons for protesting at first due to communication problems. It's really unethical of you to include early newspaper coverage when reporters didn't understand the subject fully. Pulsar20
What reasons if not cultural?
[edit]"Specifically, Fernandes attracted opposition due to her opposition to establishing an ASL-only environment on campus..." This is a pure conjecture. Not to mention the fact that JKF never indicated such a position, she actually uses ASL both on and off campus. The crucial reason for the protest against JKF's appointment and the subsequent JKF defeat is JKF's lack of leadership. At no time have we seen supporters rallying behind her during the protest.
Hello, I've been trying to follow this controversy and have been having a hard time. Basically, the first version of the story I've heard is the "not deaf enough" version; later, I've heard that this is a "caricature", but haven't heard any specific other reasons cited. This article is frustratingly vague on the subject, saying only that "The protesters point to her past decisions that they feel are questionable and don't reflect qualities of a solid leader" and "Some students also criticized Fernandes for not having warm relations with students". These strike me as being extremely nonspecific for someone who has engendered such depth of feeling. I'm not doubting that there are other reasons for opposition to her appointment, but I would like to hear more specific reasons. What past decisions of hers are questionable and reflect poorly on her leadership? Are there specific incidents of relations with students that are less than warm? And if protest signs at Gallaudet are readin "You're killing our culture!" (as cited here), how does that fit in with the alternative explanation? --Jfruh (talk) 01:35, 20 October 2006 (UTC)
Jfruh, you can find all answers from the other side of the coin (from JKF): Gallaudet FSSA's website: http://about.gufssa.com/ . You will see the 4 core issues that FSSA has regarding the protest and you can also click on the questions on the right side for additional details. Hope this helps. Cflannagan 23:44, 25 October 2006 (UTC)
Quote from application
[edit]What's with all the references to her race in the quote? Does this have some meaning within the Deaf community that people outside of that community do not understand? Like is there some significant difference between the white Deaf community and the Deaf communities of other races? This needs to be explained. As it stands, it looks like she might be racist for mentioning her race, even repeatedly, when it doesn't appear to be at all relevant. If there's some info that would clarify this to people outside the Deaf community, it really needs to be added. --68.239.140.92 19:54, 3 November 2006 (UTC)
I'm a Gallaudet student and I can say nobody understands her intention for making a such statement. You can read the whole thing: http://72.14.209.104/search?q=cache:yrxsPs0KB80J:pr.gallaudet.edu/presidentalsearch/%3FID%3D8639+jane+fernandes+white+gallaudet&hl=en&gl=us&ct=clnk&cd=4&client=safari (the statement's near the closing) My guess is that she was trying to show how aware she is of the importance of racial identity. pulsar20
Again
[edit]I'm sorry for doing POV (I thought the "reproaches on her non-ASL education as well as misgivings concerning her position on racial issues" were the reasons for the protests, and thus considered "facts"). If, however, my "try" to explain the meaning failed, the question that the quote should express has to be rewarmed! Even more, as I can't find any reference to verify it. FloK 23:54, 26 January 2007 (UTC)
Clarification
[edit]My guess...some may think "Fernandes" may indicate she is Hispanic/Latina. She is clarifying that she is white, so that she is not wrongly assumed to be a diversity hire. 24.167.52.195 (talk) — Preceding undated comment added 02:14, 15 September 2014 (UTC)
Bringing NPOV Back
[edit]I was astonished to find the entire section about the protest was pro-Fernandes. Commentary on the opposing views was derisive and a clear negative subtext was present. I was tempted to wipe out the entire section and start over, but in the interest of keeping things as NPOV as possible, I simply provided an alternative viewpoint. Whoever was posting such pro-Fernandes commentary and criticizing the protesters so harshly, please respect the NPOV goals of Wikipedia and leave both sections intact. -Etoile 14:04, 7 September 2007 (UTC)
Citation of Application
[edit]I'll be honest, while I find the conclusion of her application kind of odd, I think its unfair to cite the part that is cited, as she follows it up with the statement that she DOES believe in visual communication. I'm going to change it so its a fuller quote (though it still oddball as hell to mention that she's white over and over again, when the issue she seems most concerned about is the fact that she was a late user of ASL and her family was oral, not visual). SiberioS (talk) 07:39, 11 January 2008 (UTC)
weird sentence
[edit]I have no idea what this means, and I speak pretty good English: "In the meaning time she has generations of Deaf families." So I can't even try to edit this into something meaningful; I don't know the meaning of it. 188.204.147.121 (talk) 09:25, 18 October 2011 (UTC)
- It refers to the fact that her parents and several other family members are deaf. The sentence is unspecific and irrelevant, given that her parents' deafness is mentioned in the preceding line. As it's not important to the article, I've taken out the sentence. -Etoile ✩ (talk) 11:47, 18 October 2011 (UTC)
"Viewpoint of Fernandes Supporters" Section
[edit]The content of the Viewpoint of Fernandes Supporters section seems to only contain negative information about her. It would seem that most of it is more appropriate for the Viewpoint of Fernandes Opponents section. I am unfamiliar with this situation, but the article seems not to be neutral to me. Specifically, the following excerpts from this section do not seem to characterize "support" of Fernandes:
- scores of students protested against her appointment
- Students objected to the appointment of Jane Fernandes
- Some students also criticized Fernandes for...
- Opponents of Fernandes claim...
- Fernandes also attracted opposition due to...
- Allegations of racism in appointing Fernandes, who is white, were also raised.
- organizations of students of color had protested...
- 36% gave Fernandes an "acceptable" rating, compared to 53% and 64% for the two other finalists.
King Jordan’s mistake
[edit]King’s quote in the article can easily imply he made a mistake appointing JK as Provost. I was on the board at the time. The appointment of her as Provost was one of the best decisions he made. The mistake was not asking the board first. That is not clear and think should be fixed to be more clear in the article…thanks ~2026-37974-43 (talk) 21:19, 2 July 2026 (UTC)
As a former student, Jane's presidency over Guilford wasn't as rosy as this article makes it out
[edit]This is a little hard to write, but I am going to give it my best shot. I remember Jane's tenure at Guilford being somewhat scandal-marred, including a Title 9 lawsuit, faculty salaries, and the "Guilford Edge," a change from a traditional 15 week Semester to a "3-week, 12-week" Semester. And, of course, there was the financial crisis which threatened the school's accreditation, which began to unfurl in 2019, when Interim President Carol Moor alluded to financial turmoil in one of the "Town Hall" style meetings with students and faculty to justify budget cuts, but would come to a head in the early 2020s.
The Title IX lawsuit complaint alleged retaliation against two coaches as well as lack of basic provisioning for Women's teams compared to Men's teams including the lack of access to locker rooms; I have not yet been able to determine what happened in the Retaliation claims, but I can find that, in the consent decree settled between Guilford and Plaintiffs in 2019, one of the provisions made was that the Women's Rugby Team "would have access to a locker room just as all other varsity athletes do." https://www.duffylawct.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Cash_Consent-Decree.pdf Section B. Women's Developmental Varsity Rugby Team
Additionally, the Treatment Issues include requirements placed upon Guilford to ensure that, among others, "Women's teams in-season will have priority use of their dedicated locker rooms including over visiting teams, visiting coaches, and referees and game officials," and "Softball players will be attended to with the same level of urgency and attention as injured athletes in other sports." Taken together, these create a very unflattering image of the Guilford College athletics program as it existed for the majority of Jane's presidency, one wherein women's teams, especially the rugby team, would be denied access to locker rooms or simply lacked them, and where softball players did not receive prompt and effective medical care for urgent injuries. This bears the weight of the factual allegations presented in the original complaint, which include (among others) that the Head Athletic trainer would deny care to and made several disparaging remarks about women athletes, and that women athletes routinely lacked access to treatment equipment and even access to ice. https://www.duffylawct.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Guilford-College-Complaint.pdf
All of this also contrasts sharply with the sole reference given to the scandal in the article as it currently reads, "President Fernandes supported gender equity in athletic participation, practice, and experience necessary for the student body."
To switch from the Athletic perspective to the Academic, the "Consumer Information and Student Right to Know Information", sourced from the college's website, shows that four-year graduation rates deteriorated under Jane's presidency: starting at 46% (and out of a goal of 50%) in 2013-2014, the total rate would plummet to 32% for the 2014-2015 class, increase to 41% for the 2015-2016 class (the class which would be graduating during the implementation of the Guilford Edge and therefore be largely unaffected by it), then decreasing to 35% for the 2016-2017 class and then 33% for the 2017-2018 class. There is truth to the claim that the Covid-19 pandemic impacted Graduation rates for the classes between 2016 and 2018, but this was likely exacerbated by the implementation of the Guilford Edge, which had been noted in Student Government meetings in the year before implementation (if, somehow, someone has digitized access to these meetings' minutes 7 years later, that would be wonderful) would put students and faculty at greater academic risk and under increased burden should the school be subject to a closing; at the time, these remarks were made in the context of two consecutive years of multi-day closings for inclement weather, including an early snowstorm and torrential rains which were the after-effects of a hurricane. I know this because I attended an All-Student meeting in my capacity as Senator (the title for GSBA representatives at the time) for the Guilford College Yachting Club, and those two events were used as examples.
https://www.guilford.edu/sites/default/files/2023-03/Consumer%20Information%20and%20Student%20Right%20to%20Know%20Information_1.pdf (source for graduation rates)
The Guilford Edge, for which Jane was a spearheading proponent, has faced criticism for the strain placed on students and faculty for condensing a 15-week course into a 12- or 3-week course, as well as only seeming to benefit students who could afford to study abroad and heavily disfavors adult, commuting students, or those with full-time employment. It also involved the discontinuing of several minor programs, and was rushed in its implementation, and all of this would be revealed in extremely dramatic fashion when the Covid-19 pandemic hit and students had to move home while learning was moved-online in slapdash fashion.
https://www.guilfordian.com/opinion/2018/10/05/guilford-edge-ambiguity-confuses-students-campus/
All of these occurred under Jane's stewardship. While they may not have seen as much national attention as the Gallaudet controversy, reference to this still belongs in discussion of her legacy, especially as concerns Guilford College. ArianeSignalis (talk) 16:46, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
- Biography articles of living people
- Start-Class biography articles
- WikiProject Biography articles
- Start-Class deaf articles
- Unknown-importance deaf articles
- WikiProject Deaf articles
- Start-Class United States articles
- Unknown-importance United States articles
- Start-Class United States articles of Unknown-importance
- Start-Class Massachusetts articles
- Unknown-importance Massachusetts articles
- WikiProject Massachusetts articles
- WikiProject United States articles
