Talk:Hacker Murphy LLP
Add topic| This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Cornell case mention
[edit]@Fredraggia: On the Cornell removal in your 10:32 edit: the separate heading was overweight and I appreciate your input. One sentence I'd like to discuss further, so putting it here on talk.
WP:BLPCRIME protects the accused. The sentence names no defendant and describes no allegation; the only person named is the firm's lawyer, acting as counsel, as reported by ABC News and The Independent (the latter without naming his client). That tracks 2024 Cornell University rape allegations, which keeps the seven unnamed but names two defence attorneys in its "Defendants' statements" section.
On weight: a regional firm's lawyer named in national coverage of a case with its own article is not routine news, and the article already covers the firm's other high-profile representations. Proposed, under Notable cases, no subheading:
- In October 2026 firm attorney James C. Knox, representing one of the defendants in the civil suit arising from the 2024 Cornell University rape allegations, asked the court to bar the parties and their lawyers from commenting publicly on the case, citing a risk of prejudice to potential jurors; the plaintiff's attorney opposed the request.[1][2][3]
If the firm's role stays a footnote as the case develops, it can come out. Failing agreement, WP:3O or a neutral note at WP:BLPN. Duncan pinderhughes (talk) 16:08, 16 October 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks for raising this here. You're right that BLPCRIME isn't the strongest argument, since no defendant is name, I overstated that. My concern is mainly weight: the other entries under "Notable cases" are matters where the firm was lead counsel and there's an outcome, whereas this is a single procedural motion for one of seven defendants in an ongoing case. I'd suggest waiting until the firm's role is more substantial in coverage (a ruling on the motion, a trial, etc.) per WP:NOTNEWS. That why, I won't fight hard over one neutral sentence, if you feel strongly, a WP:3O is fine with me.
- One unrelated question: do you have any connection to the firm? If so, please see WP:COI and consider disclosing it on your user page. Have a good day! Fredraggia (talk) 09:31, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks — agreed that weight is the real question. The threshold you set has since been met: the motion was decided on October 16. Perry-Bond denied it, finding the statements complained of were mostly opinion and could not justify restricting counsel's First Amendment rights. That Courthouse News report also names Hacker Murphy as the defendant's counsel and Knox and Bhimani as the attorneys, so the firm's role is independently sourced. Motion, national coverage, disposition: the same shape as the other entries, counsel for a party with a reported outcome. Revised sentence, no heading:
- In October 2026 firm attorneys James C. Knox and Alishah Bhimani, representing one of the defendants in the civil suit arising from the 2024 Cornell University rape allegations, asked the court to restrict out-of-court statements by the parties and their lawyers, citing a risk of prejudice to potential jurors; Justice Phaedra Perry denied the request on October 16, 2026, finding that the statements at issue were largely opinion and did not justify limiting counsel's First Amendment rights.[4][5]
- No connection to the firm or to anyone in the case. If you still think it's premature, I see no issue in waiting a year to add this context. Duncan pinderhughes (talk) 16:01, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks — agreed that weight is the real question. The threshold you set has since been met: the motion was decided on October 16. Perry-Bond denied it, finding the statements complained of were mostly opinion and could not justify restricting counsel's First Amendment rights. That Courthouse News report also names Hacker Murphy as the defendant's counsel and Knox and Bhimani as the attorneys, so the firm's role is independently sourced. Motion, national coverage, disposition: the same shape as the other entries, counsel for a party with a reported outcome. Revised sentence, no heading:
References
- ↑ Charalambous, Peter; Katersky, Aaron (October 13, 2026). "Accused Cornell University student asks for gag order". ABC News.
- ↑ Lubin, Rhian (October 12, 2026). "One of the 'Cornell 7' wants a gag order to limit what can be said publicly about alleged gang-rape". The Independent – via Yahoo News.
- ↑ "James C. Knox". Hacker Murphy LLP.
- ↑ Charalambous, Peter; Katersky, Aaron (October 13, 2026). "Accused Cornell University student asks for gag order". ABC News.
- ↑ Pullano, Nina (October 16, 2026). "Judge in Cornell Jane Doe suit declines to issue gag order on attorneys". Courthouse News Service.
Troy history
[edit]@Fredraggia: No objection to cutting the listing details and the address table; WP:NOTDIRECTORY covers both and the sources were listings. The removal also took the link between the firm's Troy history and the 2026 headquarters announcement. The article now says the Jones firm was founded in Troy in 1898 and that the firm is moving its headquarters to Albany, but nothing says the merged firm stayed based in Troy for the decade in between. Proposed addition to "Offices and real estate", no addresses or prices:
- After the merger the combined firm remained based in Troy, in the Jones firm's 19th-century building, which Super Lawyers described in 2022 as the Gilded Age townhouse that "serves as the home of E. Stewart Jones Hacker Murphy".[1][2] The Times Union still described the firm as Troy-based in May 2024.[3]
Further clarifications that are needed: the January 2026 release says the firm will "expand into a new headquarters" in Corporate Woods, so "move its headquarters" should match the source; and the "next to the Troy Savings Bank Music Hall" sentence is cited to a listing, which I'll replace or cut. Duncan pinderhughes (talk) 16:08, 16 October 2026 (UTC)
- Agreed. The sentence about the firm remaining based in Troy is useful context, the Times Union source works well, and matching "expand into a new headquarters" to the press release is right way. Also, cutting or replacing the Music Hall sentence makes sense too. Thanks Fredraggia (talk) 09:33, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
References
- ↑ Levine, David (August 25, 2022). "The Most Popular Guy in the Neighborhood". Upstate New York Super Lawyers.
- ↑ Levine, David (August 11, 2014). "Bearing His Name". Upstate New York Super Lawyers.
- ↑ "Attorney E. Stewart Jones faces possible discipline over escrow funds". Times Union. May 21, 2024.