Talk:Fiona Gabbert
Add topic| This article must adhere to the biographies of living persons (BLP) policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libellous. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to this noticeboard.If you are a subject of this article, or acting on behalf of one, and you need help, please see this help page. |
| This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Peer Review by Sue
[edit]You information on Fiona Gabbert is really interesting! here are some comments for you to consider:
- Your writing is smooth and your sections flow from each other. You might consider combining education with something else, since it's only one sentence?
- The lead paragraph could include a framing of the whole article, per the wiki "peer review" guidance. (I didn't include it either, so no blame here!)
- In Awards and Accolades, it would be good to get confirmation of those rather than relying on Goldsmith's. I'm sure each of those has a website with all their past winners, so you should be able to grab those citations easily enough. And if you ccan't get confirmation on websites, etc, it may be better to leave it off. (my opinion only).
- You can cite her research directly in the Research section. If you do a google scholar search for her, this is what you find: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C47&q=fiona+gabbert&oq=Fiona+Gabb From there, you can pull her individual articles and cite them when you're talking about her topics of research. You may already have all those articles, since you have the topics, but using specific citations will be more convincing to your readers than relying on the Goldsmith's of London webpage for so much of the citations.
- It may be worth tracing the history of her research - has it changed over time? matured? What did she start out interested in vs what is she interested in now? Who are her main collaborators and what are her most cited articles (and why, if you can figure that out). I think in general, given her publication history, it may be worth expanding this section significantly. This is, I'm sure, what she'd like to be known for!
- I think you've done a good job of staying neutral in your writing style.
I'm looking forward to seeing the final version of your article! ClinicalMentalHealthStudent2026 (talk) 18:46, 25 February 2026 (UTC)
Peer Review - nah828
[edit]Hey! This is excellent so far, especially working from scratch. Or maybe you are working on an archived page but either way, I can't find hers online and this looks great.
The because in this sentence changes the flow; "She has an international reputation for her research because it has a international impact on police procedure and policy." I suggest trying to negate the because and the word international; also, use "an" instead of "a" Perhaps "Her research on police procedure garnered international attention, impacting ____" (can we briefly specify what it actually impacted so you can get into it more deeply in the research section?
"With the United Nations in particular" in particular is a filler in the same way as because. For concise writing, I suggest negating it and inverting this structure. "Gabbert holds an advisory role with the United Nations regarding the formation of universal protocol on investigative interviewing."
The community engagement paragraph comes off as a biography; since it is statements of fact, I would try to make it more concise, taking out fillers that add a different tone such as "bridging the gap," "this is shown through," "one main way," "in particular," etc. The sentence "This event, in particular, has compelled people outside of the Goldsmiths' community to come and engage with psychology" seems a bit too campaign-y (like we're advertising her somehow, instead of stating facts about her). Is there something more concrete to show people engaging in psychology because of something she's done?
Overall, this is very well written. I would continue to improve conciseness by removing filler throughout the research paragraph. It really helped me to look at other wikipedia pages that are approves and read how direct each paragraph is; there is no semblance of opinion in the best ones, they're very direct statements of fact.
Feel free to take what you want from this and leave what you don't!
Peer Review Maggie G.
[edit]Y'all are doing a great job so far! I know how rough the process of making a whole new article is and you're crushing it :)
Some notes to consider, organized by section
Lead
- Remove one of the internationals in "international reputation for her research because it has a international impact on police” as well as changing a to an for grammar
Education
- Would be nice to add any prior education to this section other than the PhD if you can find it
- If you can find it, did she have a doctoral dissertation relevant to her current research that is publicly available that you can include
Career
- Maybe expand on some of the research she has done to give a broader view or make it more accessible to the average person
- Use full title before all of the abbreviations in the awards section, especially ones that don’t link internally to wikipedia
- Under community engagement maybe change “One main way of community engagement” to “The main way” or “One way”
- Expand on what awards the educational theater has won
- Choppy sentences from “This event” through “consultancy.” consider combining them somehow to make the flow of reading easier
- Expand on the media interviews if you can find sources
Books
- Maybe include some summary of the books, or make into a chart rather than a list for ease of reading
- I don’t know for sure but should you link the books list in references?
Peer Review by Virginia
[edit]You did a great job with your draft! The introduction paragraph does a good job in giving a concise description of who Fiona Gabbert is. The content of the article is interesting and is well organized. One suggestion is maybe formatting the book sections a bit differently so it is easier to read. Another suggestion might be adding the sentence for education to another section since there is only one sentence for that section. You did a good job of presenting the information in a neutral tone. The sources you used were current and did a good job of explaining the topic. A suggestion for the sources might to be find a few more secondary sources if they are available. Overall, the article was well organized, easy to read, and did not have any grammatical errors. This information is interesting and you are doing a great job! Ginny124 (talk) 23:20, 3 March 2026 (UTC)
Ariana's Peer Review
[edit]I wouldn’t include a separate section on education since it’s only one sentence. Maybe the sentence can be rephrased and added to the lead section. I would refer to Dr. Gabbert as such throughout the article, she earned that title, and state her name in the career section before referring to pronouns. This is a new section, who is ‘she’? I think the second to last sentence in the career section might be leading, even though a citation is provided, if you don’t tell us how she is advancing interviewing it makes the reader, me, feel like something is left out. Putting the awards and accolades section at the end of the article before the reference section might help the article flow better. In the awards section, there are a few acronyms, but your readers may not know what they stand for. Providing the full written name before an acronym in parenthesis, as displayed at the end of your lead section, allows the reader to know what is being referenced if acronyms are used further in the article or writing. The verbiage and tone of the community engagement section isn’t very neutral. Changing the phrasing or certain words like “Dr. Gabbert is dedicated to…” to “Dr. Gabbert aims to bridge…” is an example of how to make the tone more neutral. Another area of potential bias is “One main way”. I think the research section should be either before or after the career section to help the article flow. Overall, the article doesn’t seem to need a lot of edits, coming from someone who isn’t knowledgeable on Dr. Gabbert and her work. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Miller.ariana (talk • contribs) 02:19, 11 March 2026 (UTC)
Dr. Ella's feedback
[edit]Overall
- This is a good start, but my main feedback is that you need more and better citations. You cannot rely exclusively on Dr. Gabbert's university bio page.
Lead
- Change from "published psychologist" to "forensic psychologist".
- Link to the wikipedia page for investigative interviewing.
- Change from "she has international reputation..." to "her research is used to shape police procedure and policy internationally" (only if you have sources to back that claim up)
Education
- You cannot cite her LinkedIn as a source. If you cannot find another source for this information, you will have to remove it.
Career
- Avoid using "currently" on wikipedia articles as that requires more frequent upkeep of the article. Instead, use "as of YEAR, ..."
- Need more cites. Especially for what she is doing in these positions. Remember to use a neutral tone.
- Only include awards that you can find independent record of, such as an award announcement from the awarding agency or from her place of employment.
- "Gabbert is dedicated to bridging the gap" is too persuasive. Use a more neutral tone.
- Again, need citations.
Research
- Cite her most popular journal articles and book chapters and other publications as you talk about them.
- Briefly describe the investigative interviewing tools she has created and where they are used to be able to justify the claim in your lead. Again, only if you have sources to back it up.
Books
- Only include the one she is an editor on.
- If a book chapter is highly relevant or highly cited, then it can be cited within the research section as you talk about that part of her research agenda. Emerriwether (talk) 15:49, 17 March 2026 (UTC)
- Biography articles of living people
- C-Class biography articles
- C-Class biography (science and academia) articles
- Unknown-importance biography (science and academia) articles
- Science and academia work group articles
- WikiProject Biography articles
- C-Class WikiProject Women articles
- All WikiProject Women-related pages
- WikiProject Women articles
- C-Class psychology articles
- Unknown-importance psychology articles
- WikiProject Psychology articles
