Talk:Daniel Pipes
Add topic| This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Daniel Pipes article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the subject of the article. |
Article policies
|
| Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL |
| Archives (index): 1, 2, 3Auto-archiving period: 30 days |
| This article must adhere to the biographies of living persons (BLP) policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libellous. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to this noticeboard.If you are a subject of this article, or acting on behalf of one, and you need help, please see this help page. |
| This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| The subject of this article is controversial and content may be in dispute. When editing this article, be bold, but not reckless. Feel free to try to improve it, but don't take it personally if your changes are reversed; instead, use the talk page to discuss them. Content must be written from a neutral point of view. Include citations when adding content and consider tagging or removing unsourced information. |
Response To 11/16/2022 Deletions
[edit]The Daniel Pipes page that has been on-line for sometime is a very biased, one-sided critique of Mr. Pipes that attempts to paint him as a hater of Islam. The purpose of the edits was to balance this, using links to articles he wrote. One example to begin with: in paragraph 3, it says: "Pipes is a prominent critic of Islam". This was changed to say that he is "a prominent critic of radical Islam." In other words, he is not anti-Islam; in fact, he supports moderate Islam. He's against Islamic extremists and radicals. The word "radical" was added to make that distinction clear, yet it was deleted.
The best source for this distinction is the Wikipedia article itself: The article quotes Pipes' position (which contradicts the claim that he is a "critic of Islam"): "It's a mistake to blame Islam, a religion 14 centuries old, for the evil that should be ascribed to militant Islam, a totalitarian ideology less than a century old. Militant Islam is the problem, but moderate Islam is the solution." So the article that has been on Wikipedia for some time says in the third paragraph he opposes "Islam", and yet in the text makes clear that what he opposes is radical or militant Islam and believes moderate Islam is the solution. Clearly someone who "opposes Islam" doesn't believe "moderate Islam is the solution."
Another example, also from the third paragraph: "Pipes has made false statements about alleged "no-go" zones" in France. Is it appropriate in Wikipedia to state as a fact that some statement is "false?" The claim that this is false is supported with a citation to an article, but if you look at the article, all the article says is that Pipes' statement is false; it doesn't say why it's false or attempt to show evidence that it's false. So the claim in Wikipedia that it's false is supported simply by an article saying it's false. The claim that it is a "false" statement appears to be an opinion, and therefore inappropriate.
In general, the sourced quotes about him are all one-sided; very negative. The article should be balanced with quotes from the numerous sources that are positive toward his work, and also not delete the references to his own writings. Cnemore (talk) 16:50, 16 November 2022 (UTC)
"Is it appropriate in Wikipedia to state as a fact that some statement is 'false?'"
Yes, it is appropriate to describe a statement as"false"
in wikivoice if reliable sources do so and there are no countervailing reliable sources describing the statement as true. In fact, not doing so (thereby repeating the false claim without context, or presenting the fact as attributed opinion) would likely violate WP:FALSEBALANCE.TheTimesAreAChanging (talk) 19:21, 16 November 2022 (UTC)- I meant--is it appropriate to say something is false if there is no support for that claim, other than someone claiming in another website that it's false, but gives no authority? Especially when you're using as a sources websites that are opinionated, so Wikipedia is simply relying on someone else's opinion on another website where the opinion in the other website doesn't give or even attempt to show why something is false? Cnemore (talk) 22:07, 16 November 2022 (UTC)
- @Cnemore We do this in multiple articles. If a source is deemed a reliable source we don't then try to analyse why they say what they say. And we aren't just using "other websites", a newspaper online isn't just another website, nor is a book. Doug Weller talk 09:10, 17 November 2022 (UTC)
- Thank you for the response.
- The article as now written is slanted in an attempt to paint Mr. Pipes in a negative light.
- I will review further with the intention of making edits (consistent with Wikipedia’s guidelines) to make the article more balanced. Cnemore (talk) 16:21, 17 November 2022 (UTC)
- @Cnemore We do this in multiple articles. If a source is deemed a reliable source we don't then try to analyse why they say what they say. And we aren't just using "other websites", a newspaper online isn't just another website, nor is a book. Doug Weller talk 09:10, 17 November 2022 (UTC)
- I meant--is it appropriate to say something is false if there is no support for that claim, other than someone claiming in another website that it's false, but gives no authority? Especially when you're using as a sources websites that are opinionated, so Wikipedia is simply relying on someone else's opinion on another website where the opinion in the other website doesn't give or even attempt to show why something is false? Cnemore (talk) 22:07, 16 November 2022 (UTC)
- No that’s not true, he IS an anti-Islam, not just an anti radical Islam. First he smear the image of Islam then he pretends in front of everyone that ‘he is just attacking radical Islam’, he was doing that thousands of times a long years ago until now and he is still doing that. Daniel Pipes is very well known for being a big hater of Islam and Muslim people he is a multi faced man with a hypocritical and duplicity opinion. I hope you should double check your information before you rush by your opinion. Ahmad.R.K (talk) 13:59, 19 March 2025 (UTC)
Factual corrections and updates (COI edit request)
[edit]Factual corrections and updates (COI edit request)
[edit]| This edit request by an editor with a conflict of interest was declined. |
I am User:Emahyar, and I have a conflict of interest: I work for the Middle East Forum, which Pipes founded. I will not edit the article myself. I ask an uninvolved editor to consider the following corrections. Each is limited to verifiable facts and cites a source. Emahyar (talk) 23:33, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
1. Middle East Forum role (lead, and end of the "Post-academia" section)
- Current (lead): "He is the president of the Middle East Forum, and publisher of its
Middle East Quarterly journal."
- Proposed (lead): "He is the founder of the Middle East Forum, which he headed until 2025."
- The statement that he is publisher of the Middle East Quarterly is out of date and should
be dropped.
- Proposed addition (end of "Post-academia"): "Pipes headed the Forum from 1994 to 2025."
- Source: "Biographical Sketch of Daniel Pipes". danielpipes.org. February 2025. ("Daniel Pipes is founder of the Middle East
Forum ... He headed the Middle East Forum 1994-2025.")
2. Number of books (lead, fourth paragraph)
- Current: "Pipes has written sixteen books"
- Proposed: "Pipes has written eighteen books"
- Source: "Biographical Sketch of Daniel Pipes". danielpipes.org. February 2025. (lists the eighteen titles, and separately
two edited volumes).
3. Hoover Institution dates (lead, fourth paragraph)
- Current: "was the Taube Distinguished Visiting Fellow at Stanford University's Hoover
Institution"
- Proposed: "was the Taube Distinguished Visiting Fellow at Stanford University's Hoover
Institution from 2008 to 2012"
- Source: as in item 2; "Daniel Pipes". Hoover Institution.
4. Orbis dates and Fulbright Board ("Post-academia" section)
- Current: "From 1986 to 1993, he was director of the Philadelphia-based Foreign Policy Research
Institute (FPRI) and editor of its journal, Orbis."
- Proposed: "From 1986 to 1993, he was director of the Philadelphia-based Foreign Policy Research
Institute (FPRI); he edited its journal, Orbis, from 1986 to 1990."
- Proposed addition (same section): "He was also a presidential appointee as vice-chairman of the
J. William Fulbright Foreign Scholarship Board."
- Sources: "Daniel Pipes". Hoover Institution.; "Biographical Sketch of Daniel Pipes". danielpipes.org. February 2025.
5. Origin of the Middle East Forum, and Legal Project date ("Post-academia" section)
- Current: "In 1990, he organized the Middle East Forum as a unit of FPRI; it became an
independent organization with himself as head in January 1994."
- Proposed: "In 1990, he organized the Middle East Council as a unit of FPRI; renamed the
Middle East Forum, it became an independent organization with himself as head in January 1994."
- Sources: Pipes, Daniel (October 21, 1992). "Trip Report: Central Asia". Middle East Council Wire. (editorial note: "'Middle East Council' was the initial name of the Middle East Forum,
before MEF became an independent organization in January 1994"); Library of Congress name authority record for "Middle East Council" (Foreign Policy Research Institute), https:// id.loc.gov/authorities/names/n92091898.html
- Current: "He established Campus Watch as a project of the Middle East Forum in 2002,
followed by the Legal Project in 2005, Islamist Watch in 2006, and the Washington Project in 2009."
- Proposed: "He established Campus Watch as a project of the Middle East Forum in 2002,
followed by Islamist Watch in 2006, the Legal Project in 2007, and the Washington Project in 2009."
- The Legal Project was founded in 2007, not 2005; Pipes announced it in June 2007. The dates for
Campus Watch (2002), Islamist Watch (2006) and the Washington Project (2009) are correct as they stand. (The list is reordered to stay chronological.)
- Sources: Pipes, Daniel (January 24, 2019). "The Middle East Forum at 25: Failure and success". The Jerusalem Post. ("Campus Watch (2002), Islamist Watch
(2006), the Legal Project (2007) ... the Washington Project (2009)"); "About Islamist Watch". Middle East Forum. ("Launched in 2006, Islamist Watch is a project of the Middle East Forum."); Pipes, Daniel (June 5, 2007). "Islamists in the Courtroom: The Islamic Society of Boston Case". The New York Sun. ("The Middle East Forum is establishing a 'Legal Project' to protect counterterror and anti-Islamist researchers and analysts.")
6. Obama section: anachronism and chronology
- Problem: the section calls Obama "President" in January 2008, when he was a senator and
candidate. It also presents the Media Matters and Politico criticism as responses to Pipes's January 7, 2008 article. Both responded to an earlier article, "Was Barack Obama a Muslim?" (December 24, 2007). The January 7 article was Pipes's reply to Media Matters. The Chicago Tribune piece by Kim Barker (March 25, 2007) predates both.
- Proposed replacement for the section's first two sentences: "In a December 24, 2007 article,
Pipes argued that Barack Obama, then a U.S. senator and presidential candidate, had been born a Muslim and had a 'reasonably Muslim upbringing' as a child in Indonesia.[1] [[Media Matters for America]] responded that he relied on a Los Angeles Times article whose key claims had been disputed in March 2007 by Kim Barker in the Chicago Tribune. Pipes replied in a January 7, 2008 article titled 'Confirmed: Barack Obama Practiced Islam'." (Existing citations retained.)
- Lead: change "about U.S. President Barack Obama practicing Islam" to "that Barack Obama had
practiced Islam as a child".
7. Date error (Reception)
- Current: "Kristine McNeil described Pipes in 2003"
- Proposed: "Kristine McNeil described Pipes in 2002". The cited Nation article is dated
November 11, 2002 (print edition November 25, 2002).
8. Citation errors (no change to article text)
- "Iran" section: the citation for "How to Save the Obama Presidency: Bomb Iran" links to a
different article (danielpipes.org/article/1026, "Iran's Good Fortune", 1980). Correct URL: https://www.danielpipes.org/7921/bomb-iran-save-obama-presidency. The work is National Review Online, February 2, 2010.
- "Iran" section: the reference coded
<ref name=tilt>">shows a stray
"> in the text. It should be <ref name=tilt>.
- "Views on American foreign policy": in the citation "A Neo-Conservative's Caution", the author
fields are reversed (last=Daniel, first=Pipes). The April 2009 statement quoted in the article is the article's update dated April 9, 2009.
9. Select bibliography
- Add: Israel Victory: How Zionists Win Acceptance and Palestinians Get Liberated (2024),
Wicked Son; Islamism vs. The West: 35 Years of Geopolitical Struggle (2023), Wicked Son; Face à l'islam radical (2012, with Guy Millière), David Reinharc; Löwengrube (2012), Critic; L'islam radical à la conquête du monde (2008), Cheminements.
- Correct: The Long Shadow (1989, not 1999); The Hidden Hand (St. Martin's, 1996);
Conspiracy (Free Press, 1997); The Rushdie Affair (Birch Lane, 1990); In the Path of God (Basic Books, 1983); Syria Beyond the Peace Process (1996). Mark Sandstorm (1993) and Friendly Tyrants (1991) as edited volumes.
- Relabel: Ending Syria's Occupation of Lebanon: The U.S. Role (2000) is not a book by Pipes
but the report of the Middle East Forum's Lebanon Study Group, which he co-chaired with Ziad Abdelnour. Proposed entry: "* with Abdelnour, Z. (co-chairs) (2000), Ending Syria's Occupation of Lebanon: The U.S. Role, report of the Lebanon Study Group, Middle East Forum, ISBN 0-9701484-0-2" (or remove it from the list of books).
- Source for the report: ""All Syrian Forces Must Leave Lebanon"". Middle East Quarterly. September 2000. (cites "Daniel Pipes and Ziad Abdelnour, co-
chairs, Ending Syria's Occupation of Lebanon: The U.S. Role").
- Sources: "Books by Daniel Pipes". danielpipes.org.; "Biographical Sketch of Daniel Pipes". danielpipes.org. February 2025.
10. Photograph ("Work in academia" section)
- Proposed: add the public-domain photograph File:Policy Planning Staff, U.S. Department of State, 12 October 1982.jpg beside the sentence "In 1982–83, Pipes served on the policy-planning
staff at the State Department."
- Wikitext:
[[File:Policy Planning Staff, U.S. Department of State, 12 October 1982.jpg|thumb|Pipes (center) with the State Department's Policy Planning Staff, October 12, 1982]] - The image is an official U.S. Department of State photograph and is in the public domain as a
work of the U.S. federal government. Details are on the file page at Wikimedia Commons.
11. "Never held a permanent academic position" (lead, first paragraph; and "Work in academia")
- Current (lead): "Pipes taught at universities including Harvard, Chicago, Pepperdine, and the
U.S. Naval War College on a short-term basis but never held a permanent academic position."
- Proposed (lead): "Pipes taught at universities including Harvard, Chicago, Pepperdine, and the
U.S. Naval War College, where he was a professor from 1984 to 1986."
- Current ("Work in academia"): "...and policy and strategy at the Naval War College from
1984 to 1986."
- Proposed ("Work in academia"): "...and was a professor of policy and strategy at the [[Naval
War College]] from 1984 to 1986."
- Reason: Pipes held a permanent faculty appointment as a professor at the Naval War College from
1984 to 1986, and left of his own accord in 1986, the year he became director of the Foreign Policy Research Institute. The source cited for the lead sentence, Lockman (2005), says on p. 91 only: "Pipes taught at various universities for short stints and held minor government posts but never secured a permanent academic position; instead, he made something of himself in right-wing foreign policy circles." Lockman gives no source or evidence for this sentence; it is an assertion in an essay critical of Pipes, and the published record cited below says otherwise. Under WP:BLP and WP:NPOV, a disputed and unsourced characterization of a living person's career by a critic should not be stated in Wikipedia's voice, least of all in the lead. The article's own "Work in academia" section also records four years at Chicago (1978–82) and two at the Naval War College (1984–86), which does not fit "on a short-term basis". I suggest replacing the sentence with the proposed wording. If editors wish to keep Lockman's view, it belongs in the body and attributed to him, e.g. "Zachary Lockman, a critic, wrote that Pipes 'never secured a permanent academic position'", citing p. 91.
- Source: Harvard and Radcliffe Class of 1971 Fiftieth Anniversary Report. Cambridge, MA: Printed for the Class. 2021. p. 918. ("Offices
held: ... professor, 1984-86, US Naval War College; lecturer, 1983-84, Harvard; member, policy planning staff, 1982-83, US Dept. of State.")
Thank you for considering these. Emahyar (talk) 23:33, 26 October 2026 (UTC) Emahyar (talk) 23:33, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
- ↑ Pipes, Daniel (December 24, 2007). [https://www.danielpipes.org/5286/
was-barack-obama-a-muslim "Was Barack Obama a Muslim?"]. FrontPageMagazine.com.
{{cite web}}: Check|url=value (help); line feed character in|url=at position 34 (help)
- Biography articles of living people
- C-Class biography articles
- WikiProject Biography articles
- C-Class Conservatism articles
- Low-importance Conservatism articles
- WikiProject Conservatism articles
- C-Class Islam-related articles
- Low-importance Islam-related articles
- WikiProject Islam articles
- C-Class Journalism articles
- Low-importance Journalism articles
- WikiProject Journalism articles
- C-Class Chicago articles
- Low-importance Chicago articles
- WikiProject Chicago articles
- Wikipedia controversial topics
- Declined requested edits