Jump to content

Talk:Christopher Trychay

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 27 days ago by Endymion.12 in topic Dates in infobox

Did you know nomination

[edit]
The following is an archived discussion of the DYK nomination of the article below. Please do not modify this page. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as this nomination's talk page, the article's talk page or Wikipedia talk:Did you know), unless there is consensus to re-open the discussion at this page. No further edits should be made to this page.

The result was: promoted by AirshipJungleman29 talk 11:02, 23 January 2025 (UTC)Reply

  • Source:
Created by Pbritti (talk). Number of QPQs required: 3. Nominator has 63 past nominations.

Pbritti (talk) 01:04, 8 January 2025 (UTC).Reply

  • I do not recall ever seeing, let alone reading, an article about a scholarly history book, so thank you for the opportunity. All three articles are recent, long enough, and fully comprehensive. To call them presentable would be an understatement. But I am not happy with the hook. I think there is more potential in Loades's review, specifically the part where he describes the priest as "an unamiable busybody". I can see a very vivid hook involving a nosey priest, a small Tudor village, and an appraised book. What do you think, Pbritti? Surtsicna (talk) 15:42, 22 January 2025 (UTC)Reply
    Thanks for your kind words and good suggestions, Surtsicna! I've written a couple articles on scholarly texts and plan on at least two more this year. Let's see if I can make a good ALT1:
    Best, ~ Pbritti (talk) 17:11, 22 January 2025 (UTC)Reply
Yes, Pbritti, that looks much more interesting! A "disastrous rebellion" would be attention-grabbing in any other hook, but can we try something lighter in this instance? Something like a busybody's running commentary of other people's affairs providing a glimpse into everyday life in a Tudor village. I think it would have an even greater impact. Surtsicna (talk) 19:59, 22 January 2025 (UTC)Reply
How about something more like ALT2:
@Surtsicna: Thanks for your interest in this review—I'm glad you want this hook to be as good as it can be! ~ Pbritti (talk) 23:29, 22 January 2025 (UTC)Reply
Yes, that is it! I love that one and I hope that you do too. Surtsicna (talk) 00:35, 23 January 2025 (UTC)Reply

Dates in infobox

[edit]

Pbritti: I have removed the dates from the infobox. A major point Eamon Duffy makes in the book, as you no doubt know, is that late medieval catholic practice had a significant half-life, and that popular belief in the early period of the Reformation was often ambiguous/equivocal, reflected in the fact that Trychay welcomed the accession of Mary and her reforms to the Church. It is not accurate to say that he became a member of 'the Church of England' in 1534 with the Act of Supremacy, and persisted as one until his death, even through the reign of Mary. This is not supported or implied by the sources. Another user, User:AddMore-III, tried to make a similar point last year. Endymion.12 (talk) 09:43, 14 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I concur. Trichay did not magically became "Anglican" (a term that became a marker of a separate denominational identity much, much later) in 1534. He was always a priest of the CoE, which became legally separated from papal jurisdiction (though was still far away from being Protestant). "Revisionists" like Duffy are the leading historians on the subject and their views are widely accepted in academia; Wikipedia should stick to their terminology, and prefer "traditional religion"/"reformed" (with a small r) to the misleading and superficial "Catholic"/"Protestant" dichotomy. AddMore-III (talk) 22:25, 14 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Endymion.12: Personal/communal religious practice is not the same as denominational identity. Duffy's research has always been primarily concerned with the former (which is absolutely far more fascinating and still poorly understood). However, there are sources that explicitly describe this change from being members of the worldwide Catholic Church to the newly independent Protestant national church, the Church of England (see, for example, this). That's placed as occurring in 1534. It is definitely not a commentary on what you rightly point out was an entrenched medieval Catholic religion, but it is a change in legal and nominal status (one that Trychay assented to). @AddMore-III: you just made my point: the Church of England legally separated from the Catholic Church in 1534. Trychay went from being a member of the Catholic Church in to being a member of the Church of England that year (which was founded as a distinct entity at that point and no earlier). Best, ~ Pbritti (talk) 01:14, 15 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I am not sure that a distinct denominational identity emerged in 1534 either. It is a feature of much older scholarship to suggest this, but more recent scholarship avoids the idea that, from 1534, people understood themselves to be a part of a distinct denomination or confession called 'the Church of England', separate from the rest of the universal Church. (Rather, at least under the Henrician Reformation, it was understood as being part of that universal Church, though not under the jurisdiction of the Pope. This is certainly how Henry understood the position.) Our contemporary denominational distinctions emerge much later. For example, as you probably know, the term 'Anglican' in English is first attested in 1598 by the OED, and is only used in something approaching the sense in which we use it today in 1613, by which time the Church of England had already been a distinct Protestant 'church' in something like the modern sense for about a generation. I work in part on 16th and 17th century religious policy and can present a number of sources at a later date if you like. Endymion.12 (talk) 07:41, 15 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Pn the ground, things were absolutely a bit squishy. However, we have sources that say Trychay became part of a new Protestant church in 1534. I am aware that there is more than a little going on behind the scenes, just as when new countries declare their independence or businesses come under new ownership. But a huge part of Duffy's thesis (and something supported by the sources) is that he became a member of this new Church of England. Best, ~ Pbritti (talk) 15:24, 15 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yes indeed he did become part of this new church, but not on 3rd November 1534 precisely. That is not warranted by any source. It is therefore better, in my view, to leave the infobox without precise dates. Endymion.12 (talk) 15:29, 15 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
But we do have sources that it was in 1534, including the aforementioned review in the Guardian and Paul Lewis's review in The New York Times (here, let me know if you can't access ProQuest on the Wikipedia Library to read this). Best, ~ Pbritti (talk) 21:32, 15 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
These are non-academic reviews written by journalists. There is plenty of recent historical literature that complicates this popular view (Peter Marshall, Reformation England; Christopher Haigh, English Reformations; Richard Rex, Henry VIII and the English Reformation; and, of course, Duffy's Stripping of the Altars).
Consider: would Christopher Trychay have understood himself to be a member of a new 'Protestant' Church of England in the evening of 3rd November 1534? No. Not even the King thought that, as you know.
If you really want the article to say he converted to a new 'denomination' in 1534, and remained a member of this denomination even during the brief restoration of Papal jurisdiction in England under Mary, I will not fight you over it. You wrote the article, and it does not matter that much. But I think it perpetuates an outdated view of this period to which few or no academic historians are now committed. (Do not worry, I have ProQuest access through my institution, but thank you.) Endymion.12 (talk) 09:29, 16 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Besides the point, but Haigh is pretty good and I still feel blessed for getting my copy of The Stripping of the Altars for free–great stuff, the lot of it. My point is that the somewhat simplistic "denominations started on a certain date" thing serves a purpose and is supported by sources. Because this is an encyclopedia where summarizing complex topics happens, there will be times where it feels a bit reductive. That said, it seems like you have some expertise in this area. Have you had a chance to look over some of my other articles on Elizabethan religion? I'd love to see your thoughts. Best, ~ Pbritti (talk) 13:02, 16 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Yes of course, happily, though it may take a while for me to get round to it. Best wishes, Endymion.12 (talk) 12:48, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply