Jump to content

Talk:Canadian electoral system

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Who on Earth...

[edit]

...copied this from EC's website? It refers to Elections Canada in the first person! 76.117.247.55 (talk) 23:13, 22 March 2011 (UTC)Reply

== Candidate selection process


Being an American I'm not familiar enough with the process to start it up but this article needs some discussion of how parties go about selecting their candidates for office. AP (talk) 19:32, 10 January 2012 (UTC)Reply

Including proportionality in the turnout section

[edit]

First, it's confusing to jump from turnout to proportionality.

Second, I'm not sure this really fits in this section. Of course disproportional could be one of the reasons turnout is lower, but that should be established before quoting statistics about it.

What do you think?

[edit]

It would be great to have a section explaining how, for example, in 2019 the liberals lost the popular vote but still came out ahead.I still don't quite get this. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Sara.koopman (talk • contribs) 21:48, 23 October 2019 (UTC)Reply

Conservatives had alot of votes in some provinces and not enough in others. 1 vote in Alberta is worth less than 1 vote in Quebec as an example. Certain provinces are over represented in the government. It's not based on geographic size of area, it's not based on population, it just is what it is. Kav2001c (talk) 05:14, 5 March 2021 (UTC)kav2001cReply
Irrespective of provinces, Liberals won its seats with fewer votes than the conservatives and wasted fewer votes in districts where they lost than Conservatives did.
The electoral system is based on separate districts where only person wins in each district and all other votes are wasted. and there is no overlying fairness even at the province level.
but yes, the districts where the Conservative won were to a large part in Alberta and Saskatchewan.
Certainly almost all of AB and SK seats went to Conservatives, and that was irrespective of the provincial vote shares each party took.
other than PEI's four seats (and the three Territorial seats), each province gets its fair share of seats based on population.
Alberta with 4M residents is about 1/10th of Canada population and gets 34 seats almost exactly 1/10th of seats in the House of Commons. However turnout varies from district to district so if AB has higher turnout than another province, then its votes are watered down a bit. But there is no way to predict voter turnout ahead of time.
More variation is caused by the percentage of votes that the winning candidate receives in each district. That can range from 18 percent to 82 percent. That also cannot be predicted ahead of time.
But a more-fair election system would encourage a high turnout and also that a large portion of the votes cast are actually used to elect someone. List PR and STV are such systems.
under today's FPTP -- about 65 percent vote and about half of the votes cast are used to elect someone,
under list PR or STV -- about 80 percent would vote and about 80 percent of votes cast would be used to actually elect someone. (See Switzerland, Norway, Denmark, South Africa, Turkey, Ireland and Sweden for examples) 68.148.137.191 (talk) 20:34, 4 July 2025 (UTC)Reply

this article is about Canada government and politics, not just its electoral system

[edit]

that Canada is bichambered is not really part of its election system.

To be technical, the Senate is not elected so has no place in an article about Canada's election system.

even nomination of party candidates is not really part of its election system.

election system = FPTP in single-member districts election reform could fit, saying how attempts made in past to change the election system 68.148.137.191 (talk) 20:39, 4 July 2025 (UTC)Reply