Jump to content

Talk:Bruce Pascoe

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 10 days ago by Aemilius Adolphin in topic BLP and Aboriginal identity


Dark Emu debunked

[edit]

See , and . Doug Weller talk 10:58, 14 June 2021 (UTC)Reply

Also "Bruce Pascoe has welcomed the Dark Emu debate – and so should Australia" a Guardian article.. Doug Weller talk 18:19, 26 June 2021 (UTC)Reply
"Debunked" is an emotive, confrontational verb that is NOT used by the people who have written critiques of the book. One can only wonder about the motives of those who use it here and at the article on the book. It does not lead to sensible conversations on the matter. HiLo48 (talk) 23:46, 26 June 2021 (UTC)Reply
Surely there should be some content talking about the criticism of the publication, if not using the word debunked, use some other language. Jdaly81 (talk)
"Debunked" is a factual statement, and an accurate one. It is only emotive to supporters of Pascoe's fraud. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 106.70.99.252 (talk) 02:28, 28 July 2023 (UTC)Reply
This article is about Bruce Pascoe, the person, not just one of many books he has written. HiLo48 (talk) 03:20, 28 July 2023 (UTC)Reply

Dark Emu

[edit]

Hello all

I have made a few edits. I have expanded the short description of Dark Emu to make it more accurate reflection of the work. I have used more neutral language with citations for controversial elements of the book. I have added a sentence on the recent detailed critique of the book by Sutton and Walshe. I have also reduced overlinking of common words. Happy to discuss.

Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 04:25, 8 August 2022 (UTC)Reply

There's far too much in this article about Dark Emu, which has an article of its own. This article certainly shouldn't contain criticism of a book he wrote. The content about that book probably needs to be shrunk to around one, short paragraph. I'd think about having a go at it myself, but I'm not sure if I'm ready for the battles with the racists, haters and bigots who haven't even read the book. HiLo48 (talk) 06:26, 8 August 2022 (UTC)Reply
I disagree. Dark Emu is easily his most successful book and the main reason for his public renown. The section on the book is only 246 words in an article of 1620 words (not counting lists and references). The book has inspired a full-length book response from two respected academics published by one of Australia's most reputable publishers, so a couple of short sentences on this response is both balanced and appropriate. True, there are separate articles on both books, but some repetition of key information is acceptable under policy. If you want to cut anything, I would say the overlong section of Pascoe's Aboriginal identity is ripe for a good prune. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 08:07, 8 August 2022 (UTC)Reply
I perceive a non-neutral, anti-Pascoe tone in your words. I see no point in continuing this conversation. HiLo48 (talk) 11:53, 8 August 2022 (UTC)Reply
Dark Emu and Pascoe himself have all been debunked by genetic experts and historians. Kargrid (talk) 10:40, 8 January 2024 (UTC)Reply
A person cannot be debunked. HiLo48 (talk) 00:09, 9 January 2024 (UTC)Reply
The fact an article exists on the book is irrelevant to this article. The more notable an author's book is, the more likely it is to have its own article *and* the more coverage it likely warrant's in the author's biography. If a book is entirely non-notable and trivial, it wouldn't warrant it's own article, and wouldn't deserve mention in the author's biography. If you go to any famous author's (or other artist's) biography, you'll find the greatest coverage of the most famous works, which tend ot have their own articles. Pascoe's work, and it's impact, is what's notable about him, more so than his identity, or his farm, or his volunteer fire service, or his family. Do you think the book wasn't significant to his career? A good article stands on its own, and doesn't assume readers will read related articles. What rule says we can't include criticism of a book in the author's bio? Now, maybe in this case the book's critics aren't worthy of mention if they're a insignificant minority position, or are from non-credible sources that we don't want to overweight. But, you seem to be under the weird idea that we can't include critiques of a book in the author's biography ever. --Rob (talk) 04:53, 9 January 2024 (UTC)Reply

Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 4 September 2023

[edit]

Addition to "Aboriginal Australian" to include "of English Decent" Mr Pascoes Great-Grandparents on both his Maternal and Paternal side were born in England and emigrated to Australia in the late 1800's evidence exists in proof that Mr Pascoe has no Indigenous blood and only identifies as such. Whitewings 1933 (talk) 08:48, 4 September 2023 (UTC)Reply

Wikipedia content must be supported by reliable sources. Do you have any for your claim? HiLo48 (talk) 22:18, 4 September 2023 (UTC)Reply
Geoffrey Blainey stated that Pacoe's "four grandparents were of English descent", and Warren Mundine wrote "that all Pascoe's ancestry can be traced to England". Pascoe himself wrote, "My little bit of black blood struggling in its chamber of Cornish muscle." (Gone Bush, "Middens", 1990, Roger McDonald ed.) and Pascoe has said this in several interviews. Josephine Cashman and Michael Mansell have expressed doubts about Pascoe's aboriginality. Most of this is already in the article, so readers can make up their own minds. However, as a matter of policy, the phrase "is an Aboriginal Australian writer" ought to be made compliant with MOS:BIOFIRSTSENTENCE, MOS:FIRSTBIO and MOS:ETHNICITY by only mentioning Australian citizenship. -- Michael Bednarek (talk) 02:38, 5 September 2023 (UTC)Reply
Blainey is at the far right extreme of attitudes to Aboriginal people. The rest is a cherry picked tiny list. HiLo48 (talk) 02:49, 5 September 2023 (UTC)Reply
Calling Blainey far right is ridiculous. He is one of Australia's most respected historians and has written extensively and with great sympathy on Aboriginal history. Triumph of the Nomads is a classic of Australian historiography. The article cites reliable sources that question Pascoe's claims of Aboriginal identity. Many of those who question his Aboriginal identity are elders of the very people he claims identity with. The lead is supposed to be an accurate summary of the contents of the article. I therefore propose a more neutral form of wording for the lead stating that Pascoe is an Australian writer who identifies as Aboriginal. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 03:22, 5 September 2023 (UTC)Reply
You misrepresented what I wrote about Blainey. As for Pascoe, since self identification is a primary element defining Aboriginality, why not simply say he is Aboriginal? I really don't understand the obsession over his ancestry displayed by a lot of people, especially those who don't like what he wrote. It seems that some think that if they can prove he's not Aboriginal, it somehow negates what he wrote. That makes no sense at all. And it's rather poor form on your part to make the change you proposed without any discussion on them. HiLo48 (talk) 04:28, 5 September 2023 (UTC)Reply
The definition of Aboriginal in Australia has three elements: 1) Aboriginal ancestry; 2) Identification as Aboriginal; 3) Acceptance by the Aboriginal community. As far as I can see from the article, Pascoe has only established 2). 1) and 3) are disputed. Therefore the most neutral thing would be to state that Pascoe identifies as Aboriginal, which is both true and uncontested. My changes are in accordance with policy BRD and lead. As for your personal observation, I don't care whether Pascoe is Aboriginal or not. My nly interest is that the lead accurately summarises the reliably sourced information in the article. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 05:11, 5 September 2023 (UTC)Reply
(ec)You misrepresented what I wrote about Blainey. You wrote, Blainey is at the far right extreme of attitudes to Aboriginal people. How is Aemilius Adolphin's response a misrepresentation? self identification is a primary element defining Aboriginality, but the accepted standard is the tri-partite test as formulated by Brennan in Mabo v Queensland (No 2) all of which is disputed. Consequently, the recent change, "Pascoe identifies as Aboriginal." seems appropriate. -- Michael Bednarek (talk) 05:17, 5 September 2023 (UTC)Reply

BLP and Aboriginal identity

[edit]

@Poketama, care to show me what part of WP:BLP you are citing? Removal of this content is not supported IMHO, it's simply people's statements that are attributed to them. Theevu (talk) 00:36, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Looking closer, your assertion of 'hearsay' seems to be unfounded. It's cited to Nyunggai Warren Mundine, who has ancestry from the group he's claiming, the Yuin. I don't think it's valid to say he is unrelated to the matter. The article also labels him as an expert in analyzing Australian Aboriginal genealogical claims. You would need sources saying otherwise. Theevu (talk) 00:46, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
While it's fair I missed that Mundine is Yuin, he is also a conservative politician writing an opinion piece for a conservative paper aimed at discrediting the author and their views. Its not a reasonable source to use, these are political commentary articles. Here is the first paragraph of Mundine's article: "In its rush to be part of the Kingdom of Wokeness, Australian academia and media have discovered, like the Hans Christian Andersen folktale, their King Bruce has no clothes."
Blainey and Mundine are not genealogists. The articles state Mundine and Blainey were referencing unnamed and uncited genealogists.
Please see WP:BLPSOURCES and WP:BALANCE, sourcing for controversial issues especially on a BLP is strict. For now I've marked the section with a 'too long' tag, because it takes up way too much space relative to the article. Poketama (talk) 01:40, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'd also throw in WP:RSOPINION. Poketama (talk) 01:42, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Mundine's article says: I used to head NTSCorp, the peak body representing NSW native title claimants, whose anthropologists, historians and gen­eal­ogists conducted research and evidence-gathering supporting nat­ive title claims and claimant group membership..
Blainey's article says: Warren Mundine...an expert in assessing a person’s claim to be Indigenous, has recently denounced Pascoe as a pretender. It wouldn't be accurate to say he has no experience or merit in judging Aboriginal genealogy.
He may very well be a conservative, but he doesn't seem to be some kind of extremist, his party affiliations (Labor, Liberal) don't indicate he is biased in such a way his genealogical analysis would be incorrect. He says colonials would have starved without Aboriginals in this article. Please cite the exact part of WP:BLPSOURCES, WP:BALANCE you are referring to. I would note that Blainey's article isn't labelled a commentary or opinion piece.
While I understand why you alluded to WP:RSOPINION, this content follows that just fine as both statements are attributed to the people who wrote them, such that When using them, it is best to clearly attribute the opinions in the text to the author. (i.e. using says, states). Theevu (talk) 02:02, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Theevu: Managing organisations is essentially what Mundine does, he's not a genealogist he's a bureaucrat. At present he's the chairman of CPAC Australia - I feel like this should say enough about why he's not an unbiased source. The Blainey article is clearly an opinion piece and is in The Inquirer section, their essays and opinions column. The Mundine article is also an opinion piece in the Commentary section. Blainey calling Mundine an expert does not make him an expert under Wikipedia's guidelines - I'm happy to change my mind on that if there's any actual evidence of him doing genealogical research himself or what primary sources they are citing. As this is a contentious issue it falls under WP:BLPREMOVE.
You asked for exact policy. WP:BLPBALANCE: "Do not give disproportionate space to particular viewpoints." This dispute dominates the page and needs to be summarised and trimmed. WP:BLPSOURCES says "Be very firm about the use of high-quality, reliable sources. All quotations and any material challenged or likely to be challenged must be supported by an inline citation to a reliable, published source." A political essay by a historian quoting a politician who is alluding to unnamed researchers is not a high-quality source for establishing very contentious genealogical facts under BLP.
Yes opinions can be included if attributed. However, attribution does not bypass WP:UNDUE. Just because an opinion is attributed does not mean it we can have lengthy quotations and a sizable chunk of a BLP article. + The idea that we are allowed to attribute opinions does not mean we can put uncited opinions into a BLP for contentious specialist issues.
I am not arguing that the controversy should be deleted entirely. I am arguing that under WP:BLPBALANCE and WP:BLPREMOVE, it needs to be summarised concisely and fairly. Poketama (talk) 04:56, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
What I would say is, it may be fair if Mundine said that he personally doesn't think Pascoe has Indigenous ancestry. Although this should probably be condensed to a couple sentences of cited disagreements rather than a paragraph of every person who disagrees. As he is a notable Yuin man this is fair, although it should be noted in text that he is a conservative politician. The same for Blainey and how he should be attributed. However, saying that they have evidence and 'it is known' without providing it is too far for Wikipedia to mirror. I would say the same for his supporters. Poketama (talk) 04:59, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I can't see any problem with sources or any significant problem with the balance. By my count there are 399 words devoted to Pascoe and others defending his Aboriginal identity and 90 words devoted to those questioning it. If anything, there is disproportionate space given to repetitive and vaguely worded quotes from Bruce Pascoe. Nor does it matter that some of the articles are opinion pieces: Pascoe is a public figure who has written extensively about his Aboriginal identity. His opinions about Aboriginal identity are extensively quoted in this article. Other prominent Indigenous and non-Indigenous commentators have different opinions and these are also quoted or summarised. As far as I can see the quotations and summaries are accurate and written in dispassionate, encyclopaedic language. Nor should we be selectively labelling people according to what we imagine to be their political affiliations or biases, nor making judgements on which ones are entitled to have a particular opinion. As long as these people are considered prominent enough to have their views published in a reliable source that's all that matters. There are wikilinks to the articles on the prominent people who are quoted, so readers can read these articles and make up their own minds about their possible biases and political leanings. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 13:36, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
The Blainey article is clearly an opinion piece and is in The Inquirer section, their essays and opinions column.
Thanks! This is helpful. It's good that it's attributed then. I think if you have concerns about weight of attribution, you can split up the Aboriginal identity section into an analysis and commentary section (i.e. non-opinion vs opinion sources)
Managing organisations is essentially what Mundine does, he's not a genealogist he's a bureaucrat...Blainey calling Mundine an expert does not make him an expert under Wikipedia's guidelines
NTSCorp specifically handles native title claims, including genealogical research for those claims. It's not unreasonable for him to discuss the topic and communicate findings from genealogists, that would have been a core part of his work. To be clear I wasn't using Blainey as proof he was a genealogist, but I should have worded that more carefully.
At present he's the chairman of CPAC Australia - I feel like this should say enough about why he's not an unbiased source.
I'm not opposed to attribution of this if reliable sources discuss it in context with his comments (I'm sure these exist. However, if we do this, we should probably also attribute that he is Yuin/of Yuin descent)
WRT WP:BLPREMOVE, I don't see any issues. The sources are attributed, not self published, and aren't synthesizing anything.
You asked for exact policy. WP:BLPBALANCE: "Do not give disproportionate space to particular viewpoints." This dispute dominates the page and needs to be summarised and trimmed.
It's only disproportionate if it doesn't reflect coverage. His identity is very much a topic of discussion given the amount of citations about it. Summarization and lessening of excessive quoting however, is something IMO that will help the article a lot. I agree with that completely. I think a general issue with this section is it might be lacking sourcing, as I can see them both discussing other people's statements in the articles as well, who aren't cited themselves. Generally with contentious topics, the more sourcing the better.
Thank you for entertaining this discussion + your indepth replies Theevu (talk) 13:52, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks for your considered input and help on this, I'll have a go at condensing things a bit and you can pop in and give it an edit when you have time. Best, Poketama (talk) 14:56, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I've made some edits. Something I think was important was noting Mansell is Palawa, which is a group Pascoe identifies with. From what I recall Mansell's descent is very much documented from the Bass Strait community. His criticism of Australian journalists in general is also important for the article - this conversation itself is an important case study on how settler-Aboriginal relations in Australia are playing out.Theevu (talk) 16:21, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Oh yeah Mansell is very important thanks for that. Poketama (talk) 02:49, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I have made a number of edits to this section so that it better reflects a NPOV and the content accurately reflects the cited sources. Specifically:
1) I have deleted the sentence: "Pascoe has said that his and many Aboriginal peoples ancestry had been intentionally buried due to trauma, discrimination, and cultural erasure.[1][2]"
I can't find Pascoe saying anything of the sort in the cited sources. The nearest I can find is in the Guilliatt article: "Today Pascoe can identify moments in his childhood when the hidden history of his family was briefly illuminated: the taunt of “nigger lips” at primary school; an indigenous woman remarking that “we know who your family are”. His mother’s brother sometimes alluded to their Aboriginal ancestry..."
2) I have moved the comments by Michael Mansell to the paragraph discussing those who do not accept Pascoe's Aboriginal identity. Mansell is a prominent critic of Pascoe's claims of indigenous identity. Putting him in the paragraph discussing those who support Pascoe's indigenous identity is a misrepresentation of his views as stated in the cited sources. The cited sources make it clear that Mansell and the Aboriginal Land Council of Tasmania do not support Pascoe's claim.
3) I have removed the sentence: " Aboriginal Land Council of Tasmania chairman Michael Mansell, a Palawa, writes that Langton's support is due to his acceptance from the community, but that she has not seen his documentation of ancestry."
This is misleading. Mansell is not acknowledging that Pascoe is accepted by the relevant Aboriginal communities, he is saying that Langton has accepted Pascoe's word over that of the Bunerong and Tasmanian Land Councils. This is what Mansell says in the cited source: "Marcia Langton ruled Pascoe is Aboriginal. Langton admits she does not know exactly what the circumstances are, but because Pascoe says he has papers (she hasn’t seen them) and Pascoe says he has a community acknowledgment, the whole matter, she adds, is settled. ... By necessary implication, Langton disagrees with both the Bunerong and Tasmanian Land Council’s denials of Pascoe’s claim. How Langton, from Queensland, operating from the bowels of Melbourne University all these years could know more than local Aboriginal groups is hard to understand."
4) I have removed the sentence: "He [Mansell] criticized Australian journalists, saying they did not communicate with Aboriginal groups when reporting on Pascoe's identity.[3]" This is misleading. Mansell is specifically saying that those journalists who accept Pascoe's claims of Tasmanian Aboriginal heritage did not check with the local Indigenous community. This is what the source says:
"ABC in Hobart has on record that Tasmanian Aborigines knew for years that Pascoe is a white man. But no one cared to listen. Not one of the journalists contacted me or any other relevant Aboriginal group to check the facts. The complete ignoring of communal knowledge on identity is at odds with the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples that we have the right to determine our own identity or membership in accordance with our customs and traditions."
5) I have added the following to the section on prominent critics: The Aboriginal Land Council of Tasmania does not accept Pascoe's claims of Aboriginal Tasmanian heritage. Its chairman Michael Mansell, a Palawa, writes that Pascoe provides "no names, no direct statement about from whom he gets Aboriginal heritage".
6) I have changed the description of Warren Mundine from "conservative political figure" to "Indigenous affairs advocate". Warren Mundine should not be given an unsourced political label if we don't pin similar political labels on every other person quoted or mentioned. This is editorialising. His wikipedia page identifies him as an advocate for Indigenous affairs, which seems the most appropriate description given the subject matter. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 08:01, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks Aemilius great additions, I've just added the Pascoe statement about lost ancestry in with the proper citation, added a Yuin Elder for balance per WP:NPOV, and removed the attribution to Mundine and Blainey per WP:BLPSOURCES. Poketama (talk) 08:44, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
removed the attribution to Mundine and Blainey per WP:BLPSOURCES.
Not sure why you keep doing this. You haven't explained what about WP:BLPSOURCES applies here. The sources are reliable and attributed to them directly. Theevu (talk) 12:27, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
2) I have moved the comments by Michael Mansell to the paragraph discussing those who do not accept Pascoe's Aboriginal identity. Mansell is a prominent critic of Pascoe's claims of indigenous identity. Putting him in the paragraph discussing those who support Pascoe's indigenous identity is a misrepresentation of his views as stated in the cited sources. The cited sources make it clear that Mansell and the Aboriginal Land Council of Tasmania do not support Pascoe's claim.
So this part is tricky. I put him later on because he directly addresses Langton's statement. I wasn't meaning to imply Mansell was pro-Pascoe, but I think I summarized his statement so much it could have accidentally been read that way. Part of why I ordered it as such was because it felt misleading to imply Langton's support was unchallenged/unanalyzed by others when Mansell had addressed it very directly. In this light, I think my agreement with Poketama about summarization maybe holds less merit than I thought. The coverage on his identity is actually much more prominent than I expected reading more, and I no longer believe a longer section is WP:UNDUE.
The aspect I feel should be communicated is that Mansell directly responds to Langton, and his broader commentary on Australian journalists (in his view) failing to contact Aboriginal organizations WRT Pascoe's identity. Given that his organization denies Pascoe's Tasmanian heritage, I think this is relevant to the broader context of the conversation.
4) I have removed the sentence: "He [Mansell] criticized Australian journalists, saying they did not communicate with Aboriginal groups when reporting on Pascoe's identity.[3]" This is misleading. Mansell is specifically saying that those journalists who accept Pascoe's claims of Tasmanian Aboriginal heritage did not check with the local Indigenous community
Indeed, this is what I wanted to communicate. This mixup has led me to think that an overshortened section on Pascoe's identity isn't sufficient. Theevu (talk) 12:34, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I have restored the following sentence because it is reliably sourced: "Mundine and Blainey say that genealogical research indicates Pascoe's ancestors are from England."[4][5]
I think it would be best to avoid inter se disputes between Langton and Mansell. I also think, for the sake of balance, that we should mention that many institutions such as universities etc, accept Pascoe's identification as Aboriginal. However, I could not find a source that lists such institutions succinctly.
As far as I can see, the public debate about Pascoe's identification as Aboriginal has died down since 2021. At least, nothing new has been said. So I think the section as it now stands is just about right, subject to my above comment on institutional acceptance. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 23:45, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'll add a sentence about the institutions thank you for your input. Poketama (talk) 00:25, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Alright, sure. I've shifted Mansell's quote to a summarization and added a bit more context. Theevu (talk) 03:44, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think your latest additions give too much weight to Mansell's position. We have already established that he and the Tasmanian Land Council dispute Pascoe's claims to Tasmanian Aboriginal heritage and we have concisely stated why. I think the article was fine as it stood with Poketama's last addition. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 13:19, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm not really satisfied with just a quote from Mansell, as it takes up more wordcount to convey less of what he was saying. He's the only progressive Aboriginal person quoted in the section, so I think his views are more relevant. He seems to be the only one who actually discusses the background behind the entire discussion in general as well, which is useful for an encyclopedia. Given that Australian Aboriginal identity is a pretty detailed article with several factors to it, I don't think his commentary on how that concept plays out and is determined in 2026 Australia is is undue. Theevu (talk) 13:23, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
It's fine if you dislike the changes, but the quote by Mansell is very vague as well and isn't really conveying what he was saying. He basically directly says Pascoe is not Aboriginal. Theevu (talk) 13:18, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
But we already state that the Tasmanian Land council does not accept Pascoe's claims of Tasmanian Aboriginal heritage and that Mansell goes further and does not accept his claims of Aboriginal heritage. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 13:23, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sorry we seem to be crossing each other's comments. How about you write a proposed rewording here and we can discuss it. Then add it to the article when we get agreed wording. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 13:25, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Apologies. My main concern is that the entire background of the conversation is only addressed by Pascoe in the paragraphs, when Mansell goes out of his way to discuss it as well. IMO we should include both or neither in this case. I'll try rewording it. Theevu (talk) 13:28, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Here's a draft with some changes, here's my rationale:
  • The sources cited inline do not support the content about Dulumunmun Harrison, all it says is he was his mentor. If there's a source for that it can be added, but it shouldn't have been atm. There's a quote by Pascoe saying Harrison supported him in the smh.au source, which isn't suitable for saying that in wikivoice.
  • There were a few grammatical errors in the version you reverted to, which I've corrected in this draft
  • Mansell's commentary is added with Pascoe's into a discussion section, and the identity section has been slimmed to just discussions of yes/no and context about that.
  • Added opinions of more Yuin than just Mundine, which should help satisfy the other editor who was concerned about Mundine's political leanings. It's important to include statements from all three groups he claims, given the partially community-based nature of Australian Aboriginal identity
  • Mansell comments conversation in general (like pascoe). So I'm including his commentary as we add Pascoe's multiple times. This is pertinent since Mansell doesn't even comment on Dark Emu in the sources, so leaving Pascoe's statement about that on it's own is strange.
  • Blainey, Cashman (who I presume isn't present on this article due to being less reliable?), and Mundine don't have their commentary included, but I presume that's because they were more focused on Dark Emu. If those merit inclusion i'm not opposed though.
-------------------------------------
Dispute over identity
Pascoe's identity has been publicly disputed. The Boonwurrung Land and Sea Council says he has no connection to the Bunurong. He responded, saying his connection was through the Tasmanian family, not a Central Victorian one.[6] The Aboriginal Land Council of Tasmania does not accept this claim. Its chairman Michael Mansell, a Palawa, writes that Pascoe has provided no evidence of a connection.[3]
Some Yuin dispute Pascoe's claim of Aboriginal identity, including Indigenous affairs advocate Warren Mundine.[7][8] It is also disputed by historian Geoffrey Blainey.[9] Mundine and Blainey say that genealogical research indicates Pascoe's ancestors are from England.[4][5]
Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders, based largely on his cultural contributions. Among these are scholar and former Minister for Indigenous Australians Marcia Langton, and Ken Wyatt.[7][10][11] His identity is also recognised institutionally; he was awarded the 2016 NSW Premier's Indigenous Writers' Prize,[12] and holds professorial appointments in Indigenous studies at the University of Melbourne and UTS.[13][14]
Discussion
Pascoe attributes attacks on his identity to political attempts to discredit Dark Emu, and says his heritage is distant.[6] Yuin elder Pastor Ossie Cruse defended Pascoe, stating he had done much for Yuin culture.[7] Mansell said Australian journalists ran counter to UNDRIP when validating Pascoe's identity without consulting Aboriginal groups.[3] Langton said it was difficult for some Aboriginals to prove their ancestry, saying it was due to a lack of records.[7]
-------------------------------------
An additional thing that should be confirmed - Is he, or has he consistently been claiming Tasmanian identity?
If he hasn't, we shouldn't be saying that - a cursory search shows me some places he's only attributed to the Yuin and Bunurong, especially recently. If he dropped it briefly, that's pertinent to his identity regardless. All depends on reliable sourcing ofc. Theevu (talk) 14:55, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Well, we provide context from Pascoe on the background behind the discussion, but nothing from anyone else. This would be fine if nobody else really discussed the matter in general (for example, Mundine and Blainey are more focused on Dark Emu), but Mansell does discuss the wider conversation. So if we are making the conversation just about the brass tacks of whether Pascoe is Indigenous, then Pascoe's commentary on the background shouldn't be included either. Otherwise I think Mansell's is highly beneficial for understanding the conversation. Theevu (talk) 13:26, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sorry, I am not sure who this last comment is directed to. There is a lot of information about Pascoe's views on his Aboriginal identity and that's fine because the article is about him. I don't think we need to provide equal space to the dispute about his identity. Background issues also don't need to be included unless they are directly relevant to Pascoe's Indigenous identity.
I much refer the current version because it is more concise and covers the key points. I especially don't like the idea of a sub-section called "Discussion" because this makes the section appear like an essay into Pascoe's identity rather than a simple summary of the cited sources.(I would prefer no sub-sections at all.)
The to and froing between Mansell and Langton is best avoided. I would support changing the quote from Mansell to "chairman Michael Mansell, a Palawa, writes that Pascoe has provided no evidence of Aboriginal Tasmanian heritage." But if you are concerned that too much space is given to Mansell, I would not object to dropping the reference to him altogether. It's probably sufficient to say that the Tasmanian Aboriginal land Council does not believe Mansell has Palawa heritage.
I wouldn't add Mansell's claims about the Australian media, which is a separate issue. No matter what the media say or who they contact, the fact is that some Indigenous people and groups endorse Pascoe's Aboriginal identity and some don't. Some other individuals and groups are also divided on the issue. We discuss some of the more prominent ones named in the cited sources.
The statement that "Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders, based largely on his cultural contributions" doesn't seem to be supported by the sources and I would drop it. The article in The Saturday Paper quotes Wyatt saying "If Bruce tells me he’s Indigenous, then I know that he’s Indigenous". So Wyatt's recognition is based on Pascoe's self identification. The article in the Sydney Morning Herald, dated 19 Jan 2020 quotes Pastor Ossie Cruse as saying that Pascoe has Aboriginal ancestry and is accepted by the local (presumably Yuin) community. This is more than simply a cultural contribution. As for Langton, the article in The Australian, "Pascoe should stop claiming Indigenous heritage" says that her support of Pascoe is based on his say so regarding his heritage and community recognition.
I think it would be more accurate to say, "Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders, based largely on his self-identification and acceptance by some in the Yuin community."
Also see the following article in the Mandarin: https://www.themandarin.com.au/163175-the-kinship-question-bruce-pascoe-and-the-long-search-for-his-mob/
I am not sure whether this counts as a reliable source though.
As for whether Pascoe still identifies as Aboriginal Tasmanian, this source, dated this month, describes him as Yuin, Bunnerong and Aboriginal Tasmanian. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2026/sep/26/author-bruce-pascoe-interview-new-book-the-european-mind-ntwnfb Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 07:45, 24 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't think we need to provide equal space to the dispute about his identity.
I would say the issue is that the context behind the conversation is discussed by several people, not just him, and it's a reasonable if not majority share of the conversation. If we prioritize his statement we aren't actually reflecting what RSes say neutrally. However I think just reducing it down to brass tacks is fine too.
The statement that "Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders, based largely on his cultural contributions" doesn't seem to be supported by the sources and I would drop it.
This one isn't by me, actually, if it's unsupported by sources I have no issue with its removal.
The to and froing between Mansell and Langton is best avoided.
I think this is reasonable thinking about it, as originally we weren't providing Langton's rationale, just her support.
The article in The Saturday Paper quotes Wyatt saying "If Bruce tells me he’s Indigenous, then I know that he’s Indigenous". [...] I think it would be more accurate to say, "Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders, based largely on his self-identification and acceptance by some in the Yuin community."
This is mostly reasonable, I agree. The only nitpick is I wouldn't specify Yuin community here, as no Yuin organization recognizes him. I added content showing very much the opposite, actually. His identity is rejected by several Yuin, which is shown in this source: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/indigenous/bruce-pascoe-should-stop-claiming-indigenous-ancestry/news-story/adb15f395a58d58cc54c20c1efc4bfd9 - I think we can say that some members (or Elders) of the Yuin community accept him, reflecting both this source and the Mandarin one you posted.
As for whether Pascoe still identifies as Aboriginal Tasmanian, this source [...] describes him as [...] Aboriginal Tasmanian.
Thank you. Doing a bit of cursory searching it seems he identifies with this again, so that front is settled imo.
I wouldn't add Mansell's claims about the Australian media, which is a separate issue. No matter what the media say or who they contact, the fact is that some Indigenous people and groups endorse Pascoe's Aboriginal identity and some don't. Some other individuals and groups are also divided on the issue. We discuss some of the more prominent ones named in the cited sources.
I think Mansell's claims about the media are more meritous of inclusion compared to his statements about Pascoe himself, as he contextualizes the core of the discussion well. He points out that the specific Aboriginal entities have stated denials of Pascoe, which isn't centred by reporters.
Through all the RSes, individuals validate Pascoe. This is absolutely fine to include as Wikipedia content, but he correctly points out it runs contrary to UNDRIP to discuss indigenity via this avenue, rather than via groups. This lines up with the Mandarin source you've posted (https://www.themandarin.com.au/163175-the-kinship-question-bruce-pascoe-and-the-long-search-for-his-mob/) which distinctly states that "There is a three-part definition usually applied to claims of Indigenous identity: self-identification, recognition within community, and documents that confirm descent." The article says documentation is not always possible, but doesn't negate acceptance by a group.
The same article (as well as this 2025 article from the quadrant) go on to say that the Yuin chairman of the local organization in Yuin Country did not recognize him: "Ultimately Bruce Pascoe’s claim to Aboriginality has been accepted by some members of the Yuin community, based on the NSW south coast. [...] a key community organisation, the Aboriginal Land Council of Eden, does not accept Pascoe’s claim. Yuin man BJ Cruse, who has chaired the land council for most of the last 40 years, told Crikey that he couldn’t back Pascoe’s claim. “As chairman of the ALC I definitely can’t and won’t say that he is an Aboriginal person. I can’t say that he is not, but I can’t say that he is,” he said." So atm all three aboriginal entities associated with his three claims do not accept him.
While BLP is important, we risk the encyclopedia diverging from institutional/academic/official/aboriginal foundations/consensus on Aboriginal identity if we intentionally do not include content (from RSes discussing it directly) WRT Pascoe. I would say I'm pretty happy with the 'the 1 sentence' added being Mansell's commentary on the journalistic methodology around his identity and how it relates to UNDRIP. It's a clean way of tying up the conversation and making it so we don't have to do a back and forth. Theevu (talk) 18:27, 26 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Just a note that Quadrant is a non-reliable source. Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources/all/Quadrant Poketama (talk) 10:42, 30 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm not citing quadrant. The information is present in other sources, so it's unnecessary to do so.Theevu (talk) 11:52, 30 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Theevu. As far as I can see:
1) We agree that the support of Pascoe's Aboriginal identity isn't just based on his cultural contribution. So we can say: ""Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders."
2) Or we could say: "Pascoe has been supported in his Aboriginal identity claim by some Aboriginal leaders, based largely on his self-identification and acceptance by some [elders/senior figures] in relevant Aboriginal communities." According to The Australian (22/1/2020), Rodney Dillon https://aiatsis.gov.au/about/who-we-are/governance-and-structure/council, a Palawa elder, supports Pascoe's Palawa heritage.
3) I am still unconvinced that we should include Mansell's criticism of the media. As far as I can see, most of the sources we cite give extensive space to Mansell and go out of their way to give the views of relevant Indigenous groups. Almost all point out that the relevant Tasmanian and Bunerong groups do not support Pascoe's claims. Pascoe only aims his specific allegations at some media, specifically ABC Tasmania and "left wing" media. This seems undue to me: giving too much weight to Mansell's claim about the media and UNDRIP. There is an alternative view. The Mandarin article quotes Prof Bronwyn Carlson as saying that there isn't a clear legal definition of Indigenous community acceptance. Local land Councils are not necessarily the ultimate authority for determining whether an individual has acceptance by the local community. (My understanding is that local land councils are set up for a different purpose, mainly for land right claims under various state and federal legislation).
4) I'm not sure whether Crikey/The Mandarin is a reliable source. But, the specific article looks fine to me; in fact, it looks like a solid piece of investigative journalism with good, named sources.
I'm not sure where this leaves us. Providing that the Mandarin article is considered reliable, I would not object to us adding that the Eden Land Council does not support Pascoe's claim to Yuin identity, at least as far as the Eden Yuin go. (However, my understanding is that Pascoe is claiming Yuin identity through its central Victorian branch.) But I think we will need to balance that with Prof Carlson's statement that it isn't clear who speaks on behalf on local Indigenous communities. If we add Mansell's comments about the media and UNDRIP, we will need to also balance it with Prof Carlson's statement.
@Poketama I would be interested in your views on this. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 22:51, 30 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree with 1)/2), as this is true and seems to be what is brought up most often. One note I'd add is 'based on...figures' may be a bit circular, except in cases where we have cites showing acceptance based on acceptance by others
WRT 3), I think this is somewhat fair. I'm not opposed to being more specific about what he says, or focusing less on what he says about journalism given what you've pointed out, but I still think the contextualization is important - a single mention of UNDRIP probably isn't going to be undue weight per se IMO. Mentioning Dillon as an individual works fine, but Mansell's org is the only relevant Palawa org that exists, as they basically descend from a few families.
Local land Councils are not necessarily the ultimate authority for determining whether an individual has acceptance by the local community.
Well, I don't want to say that they are on the article, but just say that Mansell says xyz (which roughly aligns with this idea, yes) - but you've offered a great way to moderate this:
If we add Mansell's comments about the media and UNDRIP, we will need to also balance it with Prof Carlson's statement.
This is very reasonable IMO. I actually think it benefits the article a lot to include that it isn't clear - as this helps give context to why the issue is even happening. Contrasting the UNDRIP precedent with Carlson's view that there is a "lack of a clear definition of an authority" as per Carlson is a pretty ideal explanation of the situation. Theevu (talk) 06:24, 31 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Not sure if Poketama is interested, as he's replying to you somewhere else a week later. Someone's marked their contributions on this page as AI-generated as well, so. Theevu (talk) 20:29, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sorry, I have been distracted on other matters. Unless the person who placed the tag can specify exactly which passages were AI generated I think the tag should be removed. I have rewritten one sentence which did not accurately reflect the cited quotation. the rest looks fine to me. But if you want to edit based on our agreed position above, please go ahead and I will review it when I get the chance. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 21:16, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sure, I'll ping you when I get to it. Just for context, the tag is about Poketama, not you Theevu (talk) 21:19, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks for the background. I hate AI writing and have expunged AI as far as possible from all my devices. Aemilius Adolphin (talk) 21:41, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

References

  1. ↑ Pascoe, Bruce (Winter 2012). "Andrew Bolt's disappointment". Griffith Review (36): 164–169. ISSN 1839-2954. Archived from the original on 23 October 2015.
  2. ↑ Guilliatt, Richard (25 May 2019). "Turning history on its head". Weekend Australian Magazine. Retrieved 20 December 2019.
  3. 1 2 3 Mansell, Michael (23 January 2020). "Bruce Pascoe Is Not Tasmanian Aboriginal". Tasmanian Times. Archived from the original on 24 January 2020. Retrieved 24 January 2020.
  4. 1 2 Cite error: The named reference Blainey2 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
  5. 1 2 Cite error: The named reference mundine2 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
  6. 1 2 Topsfield, Jewel (18 January 2020). "Bruce Pascoe says Aboriginality queries an attempt to discredit Dark Emu". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 23 January 2020.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Denholm, Matthew (23 January 2020). "Bruce Pascoe 'should stop claiming indigenous ancestry'". The Australian. Retrieved 23 January 2020.
  8. ↑ Nyunggai Warren Mundine (25 June 2021). "Where was scrutiny of Bruce Pascoe's claims in Dark Emu?". The Australian. Retrieved 14 March 2023.
  9. ↑ Geoffrey Blainey (17 July 2021). "Revisionism buries Australia's true past". The Australian. Retrieved 26 July 2021.
  10. ↑ Morton, Rick (30 November 2019). "Bolt, Pascoe and the culture wars". The Saturday Paper. No. 281. Retrieved 10 January 2020.
  11. ↑ Cite error: The named reference Website-1 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
  12. ↑ Allam, Lorena (2019-05-23). "Dark Emu's infinite potential: 'Our kids have grown up in a fog about the history of the land'". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2026-10-22.
  13. ↑ Sydney, University of Technology. "Reconciliation Week: Bruce Pascoe in Conversation". www.uts.edu.au. Retrieved 2026-10-22.
  14. ↑ Dorey, Nathan (2026-07-24). "Bruce Pascoe appointed Enterprise Professor in Indigenous Agriculture". Faculty of Science. Retrieved 2026-10-22.