Talk:Autobiography of Red
Add topic| This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| This article was edited to contain a total or partial translation of Autobiografía de Rojo from the Spanish Wikipedia. Consult the history of the original page to see a list of its authors. |
Assessment comment
[edit]The comment(s) below were originally left at Talk:Autobiography of Red/Comments, and are posted here for posterity. Following several discussions in past years, these subpages are now deprecated. The comments may be irrelevant or outdated; if so, please feel free to remove this section.
| It never says that Geryon lives in Canada. This is an assumption made by whomever wrote that detail in this article. I think it should be removed.
Juliebee 21:46, 31 May 2007 (UTC)juliebee Also, Geryon's wings are mentioned towards the end by one of the characters. It seems uneccessary to include a part about whether Geryon's wings are literal or not anyway, so I'm taking it out -anon — Preceding unsigned comment added by 129.59.115.1 (talk) 04:32, 23 February 2012 (UTC) Linking Ancash to the WP article on the Peruvian region appears to be in error and should probably either be explained or changed. Jkw0010 (talk) 18:03, 22 June 2012 (UTC) |
Last edited at 18:03, 22 June 2012 (UTC). Substituted at 08:40, 29 April 2016 (UTC)
"most complex characterizations of an LGBT character" vs "… a gay character"
[edit]Recently, @Twiceborncat changed "LGBT character" to "gay character", noting that the character is "only" gay and that the source doesn't mention "LGBT." I disagree with this change and have reinstated the wording of "LGBT character" once previously. I want to discuss that specific wording here before saving further changes to prevent the possibility of an edit war.
I reason that the character might be "just" gay, but is still "regarded as one of the most complex characterizations of an LGBT character." The implication for the statement in question isn't "this character is all of lesbian, gay, bi and trans," but "of all LGBT characters, this character is one of the most complex characterizations." Additionally, there's a noteworthy difference in the meaning of "most complex characterizations of an LGBT character" (i.e. referring to all LGBT characters) vs. "most complex characterizations of a gay character" (i.e. referring to only a subset of LGBT characters, namely gay characters).
The source states (quote) "It remains to this day one of the most complex and loving portraits in contemporary queer fiction." As "queer" is a popular umbrella term similar to the LGBT initialism, I think including "LGBT" (or, even better, "queer") instead better reflects the statement of the source. EverfreeFaerie 🧚♀️ (she/her) talk 11:45, 2 March 2026 (UTC)
- The article is from 2021, if they wanted to say LGBT, they would have said it. It is improper synthesis to use another article to argue for that label. Here is the full quote from the source: "Carson is an oracular figure especially among gay readers thanks to her 1998 “novel in verse” Autobiography of Red, which reimagines Geryon, the monster that Hercules slays in his tenth labor, as an awkward, vulnerable gay teenager in love with his hunky boyfriend Herakles. It remains to this day one of the most complex and loving portraits in contemporary queer fiction." It doesn't say portrait of a LGBT or queer person. It says portrait of a *gay* man. Twiceborncat (talk) 20:45, 3 March 2026 (UTC)
- You quoted the same sentence as me and it literally uses the word "queer" in this context: "[…] loving portraits in contemporary queer fiction." (emphasis mine) Queer fiction doesn't have just gay characters, but all sorts of queer identities.
- No one is arguing against the character being gay. It is not improper synthesis to read the source and represent its statements. However, abstracting away the word "queer" for "gay" is improper synthesis, as it misrepresents the statement which refers to queer identities (not "just" gay ones) as a whole.
- Again, there's a noteworthy difference in the meaning of "most complex characterizations of a queer character," referring to all queer characters (as the source does) and "most complex characterizations of a gay character," referring to only a subset of queer characters. As stated in my initial comment, after considering the context in which the statement appears in the source, I'd prefer the word "queer" over "LGBT." EverfreeFaerie 🧚♀️ (she/her) talk 21:18, 3 March 2026 (UTC)
