Jump to content

Talk:Astrology

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 1 month ago by Wound theology in topic PP
Good articleAstrology has been listed as one of the Social sciences and society good articles under the good article criteria. If you can improve it further, please do so. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it.
Article milestones
DateProcessResult
July 11, 2006Peer reviewReviewed
December 13, 2006Featured article candidateNot promoted
January 2, 2014Good article nomineeListed
April 23, 2025Good article reassessmentKept
Current status: Good article

GA Reassessment

[edit]

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result: Kept. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 15:36, 23 April 2025 (UTC)Reply

Procedure

[edit]

Comments

[edit]

Much has been changed and argued about since this page was promoted a decade ago. In general it is unbalanced and skewed -- not in the WP:FRINGE sense but in that it tends to ignore how widespread astrology was in ancient and medieval times, and seems to misrepresent the work of ancient philosophical skeptics (who rejected all philosophical and scientific inquiry.) The "Theological viewpoints" section, likewise, implies that astrology was historically rejected in both Islam and Christianity, despite the fact that the exact opposite is true. wound theology◈ 08:03, 2 April 2025 (UTC)Reply

I see this as a comment about content; reviewing the six GA criteria, the only one near it is Neutrality, but the page is studiously neutral, despite much added-and-reverted partisan editing. Instead, your remarks about "ancient philosophical skeptics (who rejected all philosophical and scientific inquiry.)" and "Theological viewpoints" (Islam and Christianity) are both matters of historical detail, which can be fixed simply by adding a bit more detail in both cases. I suspect you have historical texts to hand which could fix both matters quite easily? I'll be happy to support you in getting such materials into the article, but I see that as normal development, nothing to do with neutrality (basically, just fine adjustment).
As for your remark about "how widespread astrology was in ancient and medieval times", I'd say (looking at the article after a long interval), that it does quite a good job of indicating the topic's importance in those eras, giving substantial weight in a detailed 'History' chapter to this aspect. That does not mean we can't add more detail, and I suggest we do, to satisfy your concerns. Chiswick Chap (talk) 09:57, 2 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
I do not think it is either Neutral nor sufficiently Broad in its coverage. The single largest section in this page is dedicated to the reception of astrology in the hard sciences, which dwarfs the comparatively tiny section on the principles and practice of astrology -- which covers three entire civilizations in less space than it takes to debunk the particular claims of modern horoscopic astrology. Elsewhere, significant weight is given to skeptical opinions in historical contexts, and even those viewpoints are presented in a very skewed manner -- the description of Plotinus as a critic of astrology without discussion of his very complex astrological views is heinous, in my view (see Adamson, "Plotinus on Astrology" in Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 35 for context on that issue.) Giving even broad coverage to the Theological viewpoints section is, to put it simply, a Herculean task -- it is a massively complex topic spanning centuries and dozens of particular schools and opinions, practically none of which can be given a single "pro" or "contra" summary; exactly why I find the lack of interest in expanding that section particularly telling. wound theology◈ 10:43, 2 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
Please don't find anything "particularly telling": my view is that our job on Wikipedia in a top-level overview-of-a-major-topic article is to give a very brief summary of many large and complex issues in a small space. I'm happy to help you extend the history, as long as it doesn't overwhelm the article; any further detail would go into subsidiary articles on Babylonian astrology, Hellenistic astrology (substantial articles, which we certainly can't and shouldn't try to duplicate here), etc.
With respect, we are very far from falling foul of either GACR Neutrality or Breadth criteria here: the article gives what many readers will find a surprising amount of detail on ancient matters. However, I'm very happy to accept your steer towards additional materials (possibly by asking you to email me a photocopy). Chiswick Chap (talk) 10:47, 2 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
I have added a brief statement about the ancient skeptics challenging everything: it's a bit of an iffy thing to do in an article as philosophers and others leap gleefully on anything with a "forall" in it, and it's close to being off-topic too, but it may help to answer your first concern (which I really don't see as misrepresentation at all: the article just says "A says x", which does not imply "A does not say y", specially as "y" is outside the article's scope). Chiswick Chap (talk) 10:47, 2 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
I have added a sentence on Plotinus from Adamson, mentioning his interest and two key concerns identified by Adamson. If there are further points on other ancient figures you'd like added, please identify them and I'll add them to the article (unless you feel like doing so yourself). Chiswick Chap (talk) 11:52, 2 April 2025 (UTC)Reply

Reasons for keeping

[edit]
  • Keep: 1) the article is studiously neutral, covering multiple points of view and giving equal weight to history, principles and practice, theology, science, and culture, and has been edited and debated by many editors; and 2) the article offers detailed and balanced coverage of a very large subject in the space of a single overview article (in "summary style" with "main" links to subsidiary articles). In particular, this one article cannot and must not attempt to cover every detail of everything that the more than 60 astrology articles on Wikipedia cover already: as sketched in the tree diagram below, this article is at the top of a substantial hierarchy of articles, and its job is to give new readers a compact overview of the field: which it does. Accordingly, it is a valid Good Article and should be kept as such. Chiswick Chap (talk) 14:24, 4 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
Astrology
over 60 subtopics
covered in subsidiary articles
and 3) the sources have been tidied up (moved inline) for simplicity and ease of maintenance, given the many new editors who visit here. Chiswick Chap (talk) 07:17, 21 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
@Chiswick Chap: how shall I retract the reassessment? I don't think my original critique holds anymore. wound theology◈ 08:15, 21 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
Just say so boldly here. Many thanks. Chiswick Chap (talk) 08:16, 21 April 2025 (UTC)Reply
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 28 August 2025

[edit]

I would like to request changes to all mentions of the Sun to be capitalized. As of now there are a mix in the article of lowercase and capitals, and I believe that capitals should be used. Thank you. 🫀 Crash // Organhaver (talk to me, maybe?) 01:14, 28 August 2025 (UTC)Reply

Care to give some examples of this "contradiction"? Slatersteven (talk) 09:44, 28 August 2025 (UTC)Reply

Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 7 January 2026

[edit]
Hamzaamirr (talk) 13:20, 7 January 2026 (UTC)Reply

I would like to seek guidance before making any changes, in accordance with Wikipedia’s editing policies. I manage an independent astrology education and consultation website, Theastrohealer.com, which focuses on astrology-related learning resources and public-facing explanatory content.

Before proposing any edit, I want to ensure full compliance with Wikipedia’s standards regarding neutral point of view, verifiability, notability, and conflict of interest. I understand that Wikipedia is not a platform for promotion, and any reference must be encyclopedic, reliably sourced, and useful for readers.

My intention is not to add promotional material, but rather to understand whether content from such an educational website could ever be cited appropriately (for example, as a general explanatory source), or whether it would be considered unsuitable under current guidelines.

I would appreciate feedback from experienced editors on:

Whether a privately operated astrology education website can ever qualify as a reliable external reference

If not, what type of independent third-party sources are generally preferred for astrology-related topics

Whether submitting a draft via Articles for Creation would be more appropriate instead of direct editing

I will not make any edits without consensus. Thank you for your time and for maintaining Wikipedia’s quality standards.

Try wp:villagepump (or wp:rsn), as this is not really an edit request. Slatersteven (talk) 13:23, 7 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
Your website is totally unsuitable for any citation use on Wikipedia. Do not even try, you would be wasting your time with that true-believer nonsense. Good luck. - Walter Ego 14:34, 7 January 2026 (UTC)Reply
Also an LLM-generated request. Yue🌙 (talk) 20:11, 17 June 2026 (UTC)Reply

Freeknowledgecreator copyvio

[edit]

Does that mean you've looked at the sources and compared them to the text to check for copyvio? theleekycauldron (talk • she/her) 17:40, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

Have you? Slatersteven (talk) 17:44, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
When someone is blocked for persistent, pervasive copyright infringement, their unreviewed contributions are presumed to be copyright infringement and "may be removed indiscriminately". When someone restores text removed in this way, they take responsibility for it, and have the burden of proving that it is not a copyright violation. theleekycauldron (talk • she/her) 17:46, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Now then place for, this discussion is the article talk page. And I do not agree it is onvioius. Slatersteven (talk) 17:48, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Slatersteven: I've moved the discussion to the article talk. As for the content, the content does not need to be obvious copyvio. Like I said, it is presumed under policy to be a copyright violation by virtue of the author being a serial plagiarist. Are you able to review the text? theleekycauldron (talk • she/her) 17:55, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
But at least some of what you removed were, in fact, sourced to two different sources, and thus it's hard to see how they can be copivios; others seem to be wholly attributed statements. Slatersteven (talk) 17:57, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Slatersteven: Having two different sources doesn't rule out plagiarism from one or both; attribution is also not always a panacea against copyright infringement. Some sentences were definitely fine (in fact, one or two weren't written by fnc), but they would not have made sense without the statements deleted, so I had to remove them as well. theleekycauldron (talk • she/her) 18:02, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
No need to keep pinging me, I see no issue with the content. I do not agree it is an obvious copyvio. So it may be time for others to chip in. Slatersteven (talk) 18:05, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm not sure where we're talking past each other; the standard is not "is it an obvious copyvio". The standard is "is it obviously not copyvio", and so far I don't see how you've shown that. theleekycauldron (talk • she/her) 18:08, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
You yourself said "fact, one or two weren't written by fnc), but they would not have made sense without the statements deleted", So I will wait for others to chip in who have access to the sources. Slatersteven (talk) 18:21, 21 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Seems most of the first paragraph after the first two sentences is unsourced. First sentence also seems to be not supported by the cited sources. Second sentence is supported by Rochberg source (and not copyvio). In the second paragraph, was able to verify (no copyvio) last sentence cited using Pingree (Britannica source).
I think concern is more about unsourced content, which may also be WP:OR after reading Britannica source, which seems to cover e.g. Chinese astrology. Asteramellus (talk) 01:16, 22 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

PP

[edit]

We we have to protect then talk page? Slatersteven (talk) 15:39, 1 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Nowhere near enough disruption to protect the talk page. ScottishFinnishRadish (talk) 15:45, 1 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Disagree. It's literally not going to stop until it is autoconfirmed-protected. It is a constant onslaught otherwise. wound theology◈ 16:01, 1 October 2026 (UTC)Reply